How should we evaluate the merits and demerits of Qin Shi Huang s residence and construction of the

Historians are particular about looking at history with a third eye. We cannot measure the people and events of the past by today's standards. When Qin destroyed the Six Kingdoms, the Six Kingdoms rose up to resist, and many heroes emerged, and we still sing the praises of these patriots today.

At the same time, Qin Shi Huang unified China, and we are also singing the praises of his great achievements. Why? Because we are descendants of the Six Kingdoms, and we are also descendants of Qin.

The ancestors fought among themselves, and the younger generations did not intervene.

Back to your question. Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall to defend against the invasion of the Central Plains by the Xiongnu from the north. Under the conditions of the time, the people could only be forced to serve in forced labor.

It seems cruel today, but at the time, it was a must. If according to the current standard, His Majesty the Emperor first issued a Zhaoshu, asking the ** of all counties in the world to mobilize the people, participate in voting, elect parliamentarians, and then rush to Chang'an to form the first Great Qin Imperial Council to discuss the feasibility of building the Great Wall and appropriation. At the same time, the people of the whole country will also have a referendum on whether to agree to the construction of the Great Wall, and before that, they will have to explain the reasons for building the Great Wall.

It is also necessary to assess the impact of the construction of the Great Wall on the situation in East Asia and report back to the Parliament and the Head of State. All of this still has a lot of work to do. Is it possible?

History is very interesting. Even the Xiongnu, their genes have long been integrated into the body of the Chinese nation. When we are the descendants, how can we make irresponsible remarks about our ancestors?

History is history, and it is important to be true.

I think it's good. Without the Great Wall, the Xiongnu would not have come over. is necessary. But it's not good to repair the palace and so on. It is necessary to develop production first and build construction on a large scale. However, the Great Wall should still be repaired.

Qin Shi Huang was also a good emperor.

At that time, the merit was in the future.

Building the Great Wall to prevent the invasion of the Xiongnu can also be considered a good thing.

Grasp the good, taste the bad, merit is not so important.

People all over the world go to Beijing to see the Great Wall when they have a holiday.

Anyone who says is secondary, the key is to look at yourself and your contribution

Find information, draw down the key points, and put them together. Copy it down again. This is the best way to learn. Hee-hee.

First, to protect the Central Plains from the harassment of nomadic peoples, resist the invasion of external ethnic minorities, and protect the Central Plains agricultural civilization;

Second, it has promoted the integration of the Central Plains civilization of the Chinese nation, left incomparable spiritual wealth for future generations of the world, and made the Great Wall a totem and symbol of China's image;

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall:

First, it wastes a lot of money and resources of the country;

Second, it brought suffering and a heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people, which inspired the rebellion of the lack of people, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

First, to protect the Central Plains from the harassment of nomads, resist the invasion of external ethnic minorities, and protect the agricultural civilization of the Central Plains;

Second, it has promoted the integration of the Central Plains civilization of the Chinese nation, leaving an incomparable elite and incomparable wealth for future generations in the world, making the Great Wall a totem and symbol of China's image;

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall:

First, it wastes a lot of money and resources of the country;

Second, it brought suffering and a heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people, stimulated the people's revolt, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

For more than 2,000 years, Qin Shi Huang was regarded as a tyrant by most people, and people criticized him for burning books and pit Confucianism, building the Great Wall, building palaces, and building a large number of buildings, and putting all the burdens on the working people, which caused dissatisfaction among the people; However, some people praised him as "the first emperor of the ages" and affirmed his contribution to opening up a unified situation, unifying weights and measures, and laying the map of China. So, was Qin Shi Huang a tyrant or an emperor of the ages? This is actually how you evaluate him.

The evaluation is naturally different from different angles. In fact, when we evaluate a person, we should affirm that the character of "person" is three-dimensional, that is, the character is multifaceted, and we cannot make one-sided conclusions, and the same is true for evaluating Qin Shi Huang. We often say that the Qin Emperor built the Great Wall and built the palace, which cost the people and money, but in the era of the Qin Dynasty, the construction technology was not developed, and it was necessary to build a military defense line like the Great Wall, without using a lot of people's power, okay?

Although it brought suffering to the people, it built a strong defense line for the Qin Dynasty to resist the invasion of the Xiongnu, and also provided the foundation for subsequent dynasties. The Great Wall of Eastern Gansu in the Qin Dynasty was the largest construction activity in Gansu since its history at that time, and it was also the largest expenditure of human, material and financial resources of the people of Gansu during the Qin Dynasty. The completion of the western section of the Great Wall of Qin has played a positive role in protecting the social and economic stability and development of eastern Gansu.

After Qin victoriously defeated the invasion of the Xiongnu nobles, in order to consolidate the achievements made on the battlefield, the first emperor ordered Meng Tian to preside over the construction of the Great Wall, the largest military defense project in the history of our country. The construction of the Great Wall began during the Warring States period. At that time, Wei, Zhao, Chu, Qi, Yan, Qin and other countries all built the Great Wall.

Some of them are built in the interior, but mainly in the northern areas bordering some ethnic minorities. For example, King Wuling of Zhao "broke the forest and Hu in the north, built the Great Wall, and went down the Yin Mountain from the generations, and the highest que was the stopper". In order to defend Donghu, Yan "also built the Great Wall and made Yang to Xiangping".

As early as the seventh year of the reign of the Emperor of Jian (408 B.C.), Qin had "entrenched Luo", that is, built a city along the Luo River to prevent Wei. In the first year of Queen Qin Huiwen (324 B.C.), she once "built a county fortress" to imperial Zhao. When Qin Zhaoxiang was king, he was still in Longxi, Beidi, and Shangjun to "build the Great Wall to reject Hu".

Based on the actual effectiveness of these Great Wall constructions, Qin Shi Huang felt that it was necessary to defend the Xiongnu nobles from moving south again and continue to build a larger Great Wall.

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall to persecute many people, making them suffer inhuman abuse.

Preventing enemy aggression is, in a sense, also a great contribution to the protection of the people, and the merit of the construction of the Great Wall should belong to the people, because some of them sacrificed their lives to build this magnificent Great Wall!

Qin Shi Huang! Although Meng Tian stared at the construction, but Qin Shi Huang didn't say anything and told him to build, did he dare to do it?

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall is far greater than the merit, to protect the country against foreign invasion, has increased the country's military capacity, a country wants to long-term stability without the conditions for stability and unification is not feasible, and the Han Dynasty is strong to a certain extent thanks to the hardware construction of the former Qin Dynasty.

The merit was to effectively prevent the invasion of the northern nomads in the Central Plains, but without the power of the people, the peasants of the Qin Dynasty were tired of building the Great Wall, and their production declined and their living standards dropped significantly.

Function: 1. Protect the Central Plains from the harassment of nomads, resist the invasion of external ethnic minorities, and protect the agricultural civilization of the Central Plains;

2. It has promoted the integration of the Central Plains civilization of the Chinese nation, left incomparable spiritual wealth for future generations in the world, and made the Great Wall a totem and symbol of China's image;

1. A lot of money and resources of the country have been wasted;

2. Bringing suffering and heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people; It inspired the people to revolt, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

Pro: Qin Shi Huang ordered the construction of the Great Wall to defend against foreign attacks, and sent Meng Tian to attack with troops. After eliminating the threat of the Xiongnu, Qin Shi Huang immediately reversed the spearhead and decided to surrender and vigorously develop the Yue area, relocating nearly 500,000 people to the Yue area to live with the Yue people, and promoting the integration of ethnic groups.

Disadvantages: Tens of thousands of prisoners are used every year, in fact, the vast majority of them are innocent victims, who work for many years under the scorching sun, in the bitter cold, and the criminal law is extremely harsh, resulting in the death of many workers and the formation of corpses.