In Red Tile , why didn t Ma Shuiqing hand over Lin Bing s letter to Tao Hui?

I like red tiles, I have seen it many times, and every time I see it, I will always be immersed in the poignant scene and emotions and can't extricate myself.

Regarding why Lin Bing's letter was in Ma Shuiqing's pocket, I think Ma Shuiqing definitely gave it to Tao Hui and Tao Hui confiscated it, and Ma Shuiqing didn't want to return it directly to his best friend Lin Bing, so he was too shocked.

I think Tao Hui is right to Du Gaoyang Judging from the conversation between Tao Hui and her father (Lin Bing overheard), Tao Hui didn't dislike Lin Bing, and was joked with Lin Bing by her classmates for three years, it is impossible not to feel it, if you really need to refuse Lin Bing, I am afraid that many opportunities will be rejected before. There were two reasons for not receiving the letter at that time

1. Lin Bing is good everywhere, but he also has a fatal flaw - shyness. Maybe Tao Hui didn't accept Ma Shuiqing's love letter because she liked Lin Bing, hoping that Lin Bing would show his sincerity and gradually get rid of his shyness. Ma Shuiqing misunderstood that Tao Hui didn't like Lin Bing for fear of hurting him, so he didn't send the letter back to Lin Bing.

Later in the article, it was said that after Lin Bing handed over the letter to Ma Shuiqing, Lin Bing always felt that Tao Hui had been giving him some inexplicable hints and even looking at him directly. Of course, it is understandable that they are all big children, and they don't think about things very well, and there are some misunderstandings that are wrong.

2, Tao Hui herself is also in a contradiction, Du Gaoyang, who was chosen by the family, and Lin Bing, who was chosen by herself, with the situation at that time, most of them were not as free to marry as they are now, and the choice of parents is still very important, with Lin Bing's personal situation at that time, Tao Hui knew that the family would definitely not accept it, but she believed that Lin Bing was a person who had the ability to create the future and hope, so she gave Lin Bing a lot of hints and opportunities. It's just that Ma Shuiqing missed the opportunity because he didn't return the letter for the sake of his friends. But at that time, they were not big, and it is estimated that Tao Hui can still afford to wait for three or four years, I'm afraid that we don't want people after Teacher Cao Peking University, hehe, digression.

I have always thought that Lin Bing is based on Mr. Cao, including people of our era, whose personalities are similar to Lin Bing, Ma Shuiqing, Yao Sanchuan, Xie Baisan, Ma Hanlin, and Zhao Yiliang described by Mr. Cao. What a dragon and other members of society who cut hair. There are also Tao Hui, Xia Lianxiang, Ding Mei, Shu Min、、、 these people, basically I can find prototypes from real life.

It was Ma Shuiqing who gave it to Tao Hui, but Tao Hui didn't look at it, and gave it to Ma Shuiqing, Ma Shuiqing didn't want to make Lin Bing sad, so when he left, he quietly put the letter in the pocket of the freshman.

It was Tao Hui who returned the letter to Ma Shuiqing as soon as she saw it, but she didn't read it, Ma Shuiqing was afraid that Lin Bing's confidence would be frustrated, so he ......Later, Ma Shuiqing was leaving, and he felt that Lin Bing should be let know this fact, so he deliberately put it in his pocket of his clothes to let Lin Bing know. Since then, Lin Bing has bid farewell to his ignorant and sensitive youth. (To be honest, Ma Shuiqing is a real friend!) ）

This can be varied. From the perspective of Ma Shuiqing's cleverness and ****, I think this matter is unlikely, Tao Hui's family will strongly oppose it, and both of them are not very decisive people, so they simply broke it from the beginning, and they didn't believe it, otherwise the two of them would be even more sad in the future. Second, from Ma Shuiqing's personal point of view, Lin Bing was left alone with his friends, his grandfather passed away, his father was uncoordinated, Shu Min was forced to leave, and he was also very depressed during that time, if Lin Bing was with Tao Hui again, he would really be alone.

Taken together, there is an ending of not giving a letter and joining the army after graduation. I would like to see Ma Shuiqing's future development.

It's not necessarily that Tao Hui returned the letter to Ma Shuiqing without reading it, Ma Shuiqing, as a brother, didn't want Lin Bing to be sad, so he put it in his pocket, this is just an idea, I feel that this is completely filling the reader's mind.

This is the imagination left by the author to the reader, so that the book is good. Look