If Yang Xiu was in Liu Bei s hands, would he die?

may not die, although Yang Xiu is open-minded and likes to care about other people's private affairs, but he is still very talented, Liu Bei is a person who likes talents, Yang Xiu should not die.

It is difficult to determine the matter of history, but I personally think that with a person like Liu Bei, Yang Xiu should die.

More will die! Liu Bei was originally a hypocritical person, a thief in front of his subordinates. Nagasaka falls Adou; White Emperor City Tuogu, if Yang Xiu and Liu Bei all the things are said, it will not be dead.

Supporting Wolong and Phoenix Chicks This is determined by Yang Xiu's temperament It has nothing to do with others Oppose 05111 Starry Sky Doesn't Cao Cao love Cai Cao Cao let Guan Yu look for his brother Knowing that he will be his enemy in the future, he will also release it Can this Liu Bei do it? Zhao Yun's battle on the long slope is not Lao Cao has something to say I am afraid that Zhao Yun has already become a hedgehog I agree with Xun Na Service Liu Bei is the most treacherous It is not that Lu Bu scolded Liu Bei The big-eared thief Haha.

No matter who it is, it has to go through life and death, even if Yang Xiu is in Liu Bei's hands, but his nature is difficult to deserve, as the so-called:"The country is easy to change, but the nature is difficult to change. ''

Yes. Although Liu Bei was known for his tolerance, Yang Xiu was too arrogant, even interfering with the monarch's family and personal privacy, and ignoring his own monarch, no matter who he was under him, such a person would not end well. It is estimated that even if Liu Bei loves to kill him, he will alienate him, just like Ma Yan, he is exaggerated, and he will not be useful.

Yang Xiu is likely to make Liu Bei unbearable, but he shouldn't kill him.

It's a weak question.

Maybe Yang Xiu was so arrogant because of Cao Cao.

But there's no denying it.

Yang Xiu does have a flawed character.

If Liu Bei is also cautious.

That's what.

No, in the entrepreneurial stage, you will die when you keep it.

It will only be kept, not reused.

Probably not. At the very least, let him go home.

Liu Bei shouldn't kill such a talented person, but Zhuge Liang might not be able to say it.

When Cao Cao was building the garden, the craftsmen asked Cao Cao to review the design drawings of the garden project, and Cao Cao didn't say anything, only wrote a movable type on the garden door. The craftsmen were puzzled and hurriedly asked Yang Xiu. Yang Xiu said:

The prime minister thought that the design of the garden gate was too big, and the craftsmen revised the plan according to Yang Xiu's prompts. Cao Cao was very happy when he saw the renovated garden gate, and asked the craftsmen how they knew their minds, and the craftsmen said that it was thanks to the guidance of Master Yang. Cao Cao praised Yang Xiu in his mouth, but he hated Yang Xiu's talent in his heart.

Cao Cao and Yang Xiu rode together, when passing by Cao E's stele, they saw that the stele was engraved with yellow silk, young woman, grandson, and mortar, Cao Cao asked Yang Xiu if he understood the meaning of these eight words? Yang Xian wanted to answer, but Cao Cao said, "Don't tell it yet, let me think about it." It wasn't until after walking thirty miles that Cao Cao said:

I already understand the meaning of those eight words, and tell me what you understand to see if we see the same thing. Yang Xiu said: "Silk, Yang Xiu's color is also silky, and it is absolute; Young women, maidens also, and so on; The grandson is for the sake of his daughter's son; 齑臼 is a vessel that receives five xin, and the word "辤" is 辤 (辤 is the traditional Chinese character of the word). These eight words are the four characters of 'wonderful words', which are the praise of the inscription of Cao E's stele. Cao Cao exclaimed

Er's talent, Minwu thirty miles also. "

When Cao Cao leveled Hanzhong, he suffered defeats in a row. If you want to enter the army, you are afraid that Ma Chao will refuse. wanted to withdraw the troops, but he was afraid that the Shu soldiers would laugh in shame, and he hesitated in his heart.

coincided with the chicken soup and saw the chicken ribs in the bowl, so he felt nostalgic. At this time, Xiahoudun entered the account, asked for the night password, and replied casually, "Chicken ribs!" Yang Xiu saw that the order was passed on to the chicken, so he asked the accompanying sergeant to pack up and prepare for the return journey.

The soldiers asked why they knew that the King of Wei was going to return to the division, and Yang Xiu said: "From tonight's order, I know that the King of Wei has made up his mind to withdraw his troops. Chicken ribs, tasteless food, it is a pity to abandon it.

If you can't win today, you can't win now, and if you are afraid of people laughing, it is useless here, so it is better to return early. The teacher of King Wei was in these days, so he prepared to pack up early, so as not to panic before leaving. Cao Cao had long hated Yang Xiu for being higher than he was, but now seeing that Xiu had guessed his own thoughts, he was furious and convicted of disturbing the army's heart and killed Yang Xiu.

Yang Xiu was only thirty-four years old when he died.

Yang Xiu in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was killed by Cao Cao in the autumn of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, and was killed by Cao Cao for "leaking words and teachings before and after, and handing over to the princes", Yang Xiu sighed: "I think it will be too late to die." ”

Cao Cao's reason for killing Yang Xiu:

The crime of Yang Xiu's death is unknown, but the cause of his death is more complicated, and the main reason is because of two major political factors.

Yang Xiu committed a taboo in the struggle for power in the ancient royal family and participated in the battle for succession.

Yang Biao and Yang Xiu's own identities and political concepts conflicted with the interests of the Cao Wei regime, Mrs. Yang Biao was the daughter of Yuan Shu, and Yang Xiu was the grandson of Yuan Shu, and the political concept Yang Biao and Yang Xiu were both on the same path as Kong Rong and You Heng and other Qing scholars, so they were jealous.

Yang Xiu (175 A.D. 219), the word Dezu, a native of Huayin, Shaanxi, the son of Taiwei Yang Biao, and a writer in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. Yang Xiu is knowledgeable and extremely intelligent, and serves as the chief secretary of the Prime Minister's Mansion. In history, "At that time, the military country was eventful, and the cultivation always knew the outside and the inside, and everything was satisfactory."

Yang Xiu was able to let go of seven things.

The Kuomen Incident: Cao Cao once asked someone to build a garden, but he did not comment on it after reading it, but only wrote a movable character on the door of the garden.

A crisp incident: Cao Cao received a crisp, on the box wrote "a crisp", Yang Xiu saw it, so he asked someone to eat the whole box of crisp, Cao Cao asked him why he did this, he replied: The box says "one person has a mouthful of crisp", how dare the prime minister's order be violated? 」

Murder in a dream: Cao Cao was afraid that someone would assassinate him, so he pretended that he was good at killing people in his dream, and even killed a close attendant and pretended to cry bitterly, and buried the man so that he could make an example of him. Yang Xiu knew what Cao Cao was thinking, so he relied on his cleverness to expose Cao Cao.

Wu quality incident: Cao Pi secretly invited Wu Zhen into the inner mansion to discuss Cao Cao's desire to establish a prince, but he was afraid that someone would know, so he used a big curtain to hide Wu Qian. Yang Xiu knew, so he told Cao Cao, and it turned out that Cao Pi really used a big silk next time, and Cao Cao suspected that Yang Xiu wanted to frame Cao Cao.

Yemen Incident: In order to test the talents of his two sons, Cao Cao asked them to go out of the city gate, but asked the gatekeeper not to let people out, Yang Xiu taught Cao Zhi to kill him if anyone dared to stop him. Although Cao Zhi successfully went out, Cao Cao knew that he was taught by Yang Xiu and was very angry.

Answer: Yang Xiu once made more than a dozen answers for Cao Zhi, and every time Cao Cao asked Cao Zhi about military affairs, Cao Zhi answered them fluently, so Cao Cao was suspicious. Later, Cao Pi bribed Cao Zhi's left and right and stole those answers to inform Cao Cao.

When Cao Cao saw it, he already had the intention of killing Yang Xiu.

Chicken rib incident: Cao Cao only said that the slogan of the night was "chicken ribs", but Yang Xiu used his wisdom to figure out the true meaning of "chicken ribs", and told the soldiers to pack their luggage and prepare for the class division, which of course led to death in the end.

Not necessarily. Although Liu Bei would treat him well, Cao Cao might have been angry at Yang Xiu's defection to Liu Lun's armament and sent assassins to kill him. The assassins of Wei were very powerful, and one of Zhuge Liang's heirs was assassinated by the assassins of Wei.

Yes. Liu Bei is more tolerant, and Liu Bei deliberately created his appearance of being tolerant of the elderly, for the sake of his reputation, he will also tolerate Yang Xiu's arrogance.

No. Yang Xiu was anxious for quick success, and he would do whatever it took to achieve his goal, and if he was placed in Liu Bei's camp, Zhuge Liang would also kill him.

People can't be arrogant, but they can't be arrogant, Yang Xiu is stubborn and self-serving, no one in his eyes, this kind of character is destined not to be liked by those in power, so the final death is already destined.

Because if Cao Cao didn't kill him, he would most likely be killed by his other political enemies, and he would use even more vicious schemes.

Yes, Yang Xiu is good with Cao Cao, and he has a good relationship with Cao Zhi, although he is smart, but Cao Cao is very condensed, and he is afraid that Yang Xiu will leak the news.