If Song Jiang chooses to continue to fight, can he lead the heroes of Liangshan to win the Great Son

If Song Jiang continued to fight, he would not be able to lead the heroes of Liangshan to overthrow the Song Dynasty. Song Jiang is a smart person, he has experienced so many battles, he already knows what the ending is, he also understands the temperament of Liangshan heroes, and also understands that many of them can't achieve great things, he knows that he can't change the ending of the Great Song DynastyAfter all, the Song Dynasty was a serious dynasty even if it was corrupt, and it was not easy to overthrow it.

And the heroes of Liangshan were not of the same heart at that time. There are also a lot of differences among them, there are many internal contradictions, and there are more and more people, but everyone's purpose is not as simple as the original, and as time goes by, everyone's ideas are changing, and people are selfish and think about themselves. In the end, it was the Great Song Dynasty that suffered, because of internal and external troubles, there was the Dajin Dynasty outside, and Song Jiang rebelled inside, and Song Jiang also knew that this would not be beneficial, and he could not overthrow the Song Dynasty, and it would weaken the strength of Huaxia.

Song Jiang has a heart to love the country, protect the country and revitalize the country, but he is also intolerant。After all, it was just an uprising, and it was different from a regular country, it was nine deaths and one life, plus there was internal disunity in the later period, there were rebellions, some escaped, some sued for peace, and there were many injuries, which could not constitute too much combat power at all, and if they continued to fight, it was the Great Song Dynasty that suffered in the end. Not to mention overthrowing the Song Dynasty, self-preservation is a problem, so in the end there is only one ending, which is death, Song Jiang knew that this was not a wise decision, so in the end he did not choose to fight.

Song Jiang is a smart man. He has his own ideas, he also wants you to live by yourself, he knows that Liangshan has no future, he only has the opportunity to surrender, but the fight is only death, so it is better to surrender by himself, let the Great Song Dynasty fall lightly, at least he can save a life If Song Jiang continues to fight, he can't lead the heroes of Liangshan to overthrow the Song Dynasty, after all, the Song Dynasty is a serious dynasty even if it is corrupt, and it is not easy to overthrow it.

It shouldn't be, there are many people in Liangshan who charge into battle, but there are very few people who have scheming and strategy, and there is a lack of governance managers.

I don't think so, how can the 108 heroes of Liangshan alone want to fight against such a big empire. The thousands of troops and horses of others are not kept to watch.

It shouldn't be good, after all, there are still too few people, and a country as big as the Great Song Dynasty shouldn't be so easy to be defeated.

Although Song Jiang has wisdom, he led the heroes of Liangshan to fight the Great Song Dynasty. It may not be possible to fight, after all, not everyone is a special soldier.

It's hard to say. It depends on whether those Water Margin soldiers are united and listen to Song Jiang's command, otherwise they will not be able to unite if they have their own little Jiujiu and scattered sand.

Song Jiang is a very wise person, he can guess people's hearts and improve morale, and I think if he insists on fighting, he will also have good results.

This is not certain, after all, although the Song Dynasty was corrupt at that time, it still had such a big foundation, so it is really hard to say.

There will be a gathering of heroes on the beam, and they are also gathered together for various reasons that cannot be reused, but there are many people and opinions, so this result is uncertain.

There are four classic masterpieces in Chinese history, namely "Water Margin", "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", "Dream of Red Mansions" and "Journey to the West". And among them, "Water Margin" tells the stories of heroes from all walks of life, and the characteristics of the 108 heroes in the Water Margin also left a deep impression on readers. What impresses us the most is the fact that Song Jiang was recruited in the Water Margin, so if Song Jiang was not recruited, would he probably lead all the heroes of Liangshan to the right path?

Then the answer is definitely impossible.

In "Water Margin", the only official position Song Jiang has held is the secretary, but he is also in some extremely small matters, and he can't get in touch with a higher level of ** at all. However, in Song Jiang's heart, he has always wanted to enter the imperial court and a certain official position. If Song Jiang hadn't been recruited, he would have been doing nothing, working hard all his life in this small position of the secretary, and finally slowly aging down.

Moreover, in the book, Song Jiang's power is very small, if he does not accept the court's recruitment, he will not only confront the court, but also fight against Fang La. In terms of historical records, it was a relatively prosperous era, so it was almost impossible for Song Jiang to overthrow the Northern Song Dynasty.

Although there are 108 heroes on Liangshan, and they have always taken it as their duty to do the way for the sky. But this is also the belief of a small group of people, and some of the rest use this name as a cover to satisfy their own selfish interests. It can be said that Liangshan at that time was a more righteous bandit gang.

After they disdained to rob some ordinary people's property, under the leadership of Song Jiang, although Liangshan seemed to be united, its internal structure was very complicated.

If Song Jiang did not accept Zhao'an, they would rely on the big mountain of Liangshan, rely on the mountain to eat the mountain, and in the end they would only gradually scatter around because of the lack of material life. Then a small number of these people will eventually end up heroic. Therefore, looking at Song Jiang's strategy in this way, it is still very deep, and Song Jiang accepted Zhao'an, so he left a good reputation for the heroes of Liangshan.

If Song Jiang had not been recruited, he would not have been able to lead the heroes of Liangshan to get the right path, first of all, the heroes of Liangshan later acted as bandits under the banner of doing the right thing. Secondly, the heroes of Liangshan basically did not marry wives and have children, so there was no new force. In addition, Yangsan's high-level leaders have different personalities and do not have a common goal.

Everyone is very familiar with "Water Margin", and the final ending makes people sigh, Song Jiang, as the leader of Liangshan, finally chose to accept the recruitment of the imperial court. Many people believe that if the heroes of Liangshan were not given good morning, Song Jiang might have made a difference in leading the heroes of Liangshan. Personally, I don't think there is such an assumption, and what awaits them will not be the right one.

First of all, the heroes of Liangshan later acted as bandits under the banner of doing the right thing for the sky. At the beginning, Liangshan's income channel was mainly through robbing homes and houses, robbing passing vendors, and maintaining the daily life of the Liangshan brothers through the money obtained. Later, there were more and more people in Liangshan, and this kind of petty fight could no longer meet everyone's daily life and expenses, so they started the idea of the Daimyo's Mansion, and later even attacked Dongping Mansion and Dongchang Mansion.

Although Song Jiang was under the banner of doing things for the heavens, what they did was some burning, killing and looting. Therefore, in the end, Yangsan will most likely turn into a real bandit.

Secondly, the heroes of Liangshan basically did not marry wives and have children, so there was no new force. If we take a long-term view, we will find that the future of Yangshan is bleak, or it can be said that there is no future, because many people have not married wives and children, and their pension is a problem, and no offspring is equal to no new force to replenish, which is also a problem. When this generation is old and dead, there will be no successors, so there will be no reason to break out.

In addition, Yangsan's high-level leaders have different personalities and do not have a common goal. Liangshan 108 will be called brothers and sisters on the surface, but in fact they are not the same enemy. Although some of them are in the grass, they were once officials of the imperial court, and some of them are heroes in the green forest and people in the rivers and lakes.

As a result, they have fallen apart internally and will inevitably go their separate ways in the future, and there will be no lasting unity.

That's my take on this.

I don't think so, this is determined by Song Jiang's personality, because his essence is still a person who covets wealth and nobility.

It is more difficult, it is very likely that you will be a bandit for the rest of your life, and it is very difficult to get back on the right path.

As follows:

1. Song Jiang's neighbor and friend Chao Gai and a group of 7 people robbed Liang Zhongshu of the birthday gift given to his father-in-law, and after the East Window incident, Song Jiang released 7 of them privately. Liu Tang gave Song Jiang a letter of thanks and 100 taels of garlic gold, but was discovered by his adopted woman Yan Poxi, and threatened Song Jiang with this, Song Jiang was angry and killed Yan Poxi.

2, then Song Jiang fled to Chai Jin Mansion and lived for more than half a year, and then went to his apprentice Kong Ming Kong Liang Mansion for a period of time. Later, Xiao Li Guanghuarong wrote to Song Jiang and asked him to go to Qingfeng Village to play for a few days, and in the process of going to Qingfeng Village, he got acquainted with Wang Ying, Yan Shun, Zheng Tianshou and others, and then because Qingfeng Village was provoked by Liu Gao's wife, Song Jiang and his gang killed him and prepared to go to Liangshan.

3. Later, the imperial court granted amnesty to the world, due to Song Jiang's little follower Zhang Wenyuan's provocation, the imperial court did not release Song Jiang. Later, Huang Wenbing was instigated by Huang Wenbing, and Cai Jiu, the ninth son of Cai Jing, escorted Song Jiang and Dai Zong to the execution ground for questioning and beheading, and later Liangshan and his gang robbed the Jiangzhou law field with Li Kui, Li Jun, Mu Hong, Zhang Shun and others, and saved Song Jiang, Song Jiang had no way out, so he went to Liangshan.

When the birthday gang was ordained, Song Jiang got acquainted with Chao Gai, the leader of Liangshan Shuibo, and later had a lot of contact. After Song Jiang angrily killed his concubine Yan Poxi, he was desperate, and he didn't want to affect the old husband and brother in the family, so he went to Liangshan to become a leader.

<> "Why was Song Jiang not very willing to go to Liangshan at the beginning?

"Water Margin" is the first chapter in the history of our country with the theme of peasant uprising**. The author is Shi Nai'an in the late Yuan Dynasty and early Ming Dynasty. Its prototype was a peasant uprising led by Song Jiang, a native of Shandong, in the late Northern Song Dynasty. Before going to Liangshan, Song Jiangdang's charge was a big official.

Song Jiang was not very willing to go to Liangshan at the beginning, there are two reasons, the first reason is the above, Song Jiang wants to serve the imperial court, wants to display his ambitions, if he embarks on the road of "rebellion", it may not be a legitimate means, the second reason is that he is a local priest, he is also a high-ranking official, and has a lot of income, so Song Jiang does not want to give up his job and family.

Song Jiang's family is also a well-known wealthy businessman, Song Jiang has a talent, so he went to the government to become an official, and was appointed as the secretary, the secretary is a scribe in the yamen, the main job content is to write documents, and provide advice for the county order, which is similar to the "master" in the TV series, but he is about the same level as the county order, so his status is much higher than that of the "master", and there are many things under his jurisdiction.

Song Jiang, as a priest, often communicates with the people on behalf of the government, and Song Jiang is a capable person, often seeking benefits for the people, and is loved by many people, and is very popular, almost no one in a town does not know the famous Song Priest, although there are seven or eight priests in a county, but Song Jiang stands out from the crowd and is the most talented and prestigious one in the priesthood, so Song Jiang's social status is very high.

Song Jiang's official position is very high, his family conditions are also very rich, and the people also praise him, but later Song Jiang was demoted for murder, and later because of the poetry for himself, he was forced to be helpless, after he was rescued by Chao Gai and others, he went to Liangshan with them, and then there was the next thing, if there was no demotion to the official, Song Jiang would not give up such a high position and take risks.

1, Song Jiang privately released Chao Tianwang, after Chao Gai robbed the birth gang, the government went around to arrest the suspect, Bai Sheng confessed to Chao Gai and others because he was tortured, the government was ready to arrest Chao Gai immediately, Song Jiang learned about it, and reported it to Chao Gai in time, Chao Gai was able to prepare and escape the arrest of the government, Song Jiang was still a little righteous.

2, Song Jiang killed Yan Po in anger, after Chao Gai fled to Liangshan, in order to repay Song Jiang, the red-haired ghost Liu Tang took a few hundred taels of silver to see Song Jiang at night, and left a letter from Chao Gai, but Chao Gai's letter was unfortunately learned by Yan Poxi, and he wanted to threaten Song Jiang to fornicate with robbers, Song Jiang was helpless, and killed Yan Poxi angrily, Song Jiang was also a ruthless person.

3, Song Jiang subdued the thunderbolt: Song Jiang fled to Huarong's Qingfeng Village after killing Yan Poxi, because Liu Gao's wife framed Song Jiang, which led to Huarong's rebellion, Qin Ming knew about it, and led 500 soldiers to arrest Song Jiang Huarong.

was tricked into the trap pit by Song Jiang and captured alive, Song Jiang asked the soldiers to take Qin Ming's armor to make trouble with the prefect, the prefect thought it was really Qin Ming, so he killed Qin Ming's family, Qin Ming had no choice but to join Song Jiang, and Song Jiang married Hua Rong's sister Xu to Qin Ming. Song Jiang is a scheming person!

4, timely rain will be Shenxing Taibao: In Jiangzhou prison city Song Jiang got acquainted with Shenxing Taibao Dai Zong and later Water Margin Bishop Black Whirlwind Li Kui, Li Kui and Song Jiang hit it off at first sight and worshiped Song Jiang as brothers. Song Jiang is a righteous man and is very good at winning people's hearts.

5, Song Gongming three dozen Zhujiazhuang: Shi Xiu Yang Xiong and Shi Qian went to Liangshan together, passing by Zhujiazhuang, because Shi Qian stole a Xiaoxiao chicken in Zhujiazhuang, and attracted the war between Liangshan and Zhujiazhuang, Lin Chong, Hua Rong, Qin Ming, Li Kui, Hu Sanniang, Wang Ying, Shi Xiu, Ou Peng, Deng Fei, as well as Xie Zhen and Jiebao, Sun Xin Sun Li, all invested in this war.

In the end, under the command of Song Jiang and Wu Yong, Liangshan broke through Zhujiazhuang, returned triumphantly, and married Hu Sanniang to Wang Ying.