After the death of Shu, why did Zhang Fei s family and Guan Yu s family have completely different fa

Updated on history 2024-06-13
20 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    First, Guan Yu killed Pang Hui's father Pang De before, and Pang Hui came to Guan Yu's family for revenge; The second is that Zhang Fei's family has a relationship with Liu Chan, and Liu Chan is safe.

    01, Guan Yu killed Pang De and laid the root of the curse. All these grievances have to start with the battle of Xiangfan launched by Guan Yu. After Liu Bei captured Hanzhong, Guan Yu, who was stationed in Jingzhou, also wanted to open up territory for Shu Han, so he privately engaged in a battle of Xiangfan.

    In the early stage of the battle of Xiangfan, because Cao Wei did not expect Guan Yu to attack, he was caught off guard by Guan Yu, and the result was that Guan Yu won several cities in a row. Let's think about what to do. <>

    Everyone agreed that someone should be sent to support, and at this time Pang De took it out and said that he was willing to go, but everyone disagreed, because Pang De's brother Pang Fu and good brother Ma Chao were in Shuhan. Pang De had to marry, and he also made a military order, so Cao Cao let Yu Ban and Pang De go. When the two came to the front line, the two sides were at a stalemate, and at this time it was raining heavily.

    Guan Yu thought of a way in his heart to let the soldiers block the drain according to the terrain advantage. In the end, through the flooding, the Seventh Army captured the forbidden Pang Dewei and shocked China. <>

    02, Pang will avenge his father. In fact, Guan Yu gave Pang De a chance, Guan Yu was quite optimistic about Pang De and wanted Pang De to surrender, but Pang De refused to scold Guan Yu, so Pang De died. After Pang De's death, his son Pang Hui stepped into the official career and became a member of Cao Wei's generals.

    Pang Hui's ability is okay, and his father's land in Cao Wei is still relatively high, so he mixes well in Cao Wei. But Pang Hui has always wanted to avenge his father, as long as he fights with Shu Han, he will definitely go. <>

    Hou Zhonghui and Deng Ai were ordered to destroy Shu, and Pang Hui also followed. Deng Ai smuggled into Yinping, and the later lord Liu Chan surrendered, and Pang Hui found Guan Yu's descendants at this timeHe killed all the descendants of Guan Yu and the three tribes. Zhang Fei's descendants are fine, first, Zhang Fei's descendants have no enmity with Cao Wei's big shots, and second, Zhang Fei's two daughters are married to Liu Chan, and Liu Chan will definitely protect Zhang Fei's descendants.

    Although Liu Chan is the king of the dead country, he still has a little right to speak.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    This is because Zhang Yide is Liu Chan's father-in-law. After the big and small Zhang is Liu Chan's wife, the person next to the pillow. Therefore, the Zhang family is still a serious relative of the emperor, while the Guan family can only be a descendant of the family and live a dull life.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Because Guan Yu is a hero who belongs to the world, and Zhang Fei is a hero of a family.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because Zhang Fei has relatives with the Xiahou family, the Xiahou family, as a famous family of Cao Wei, naturally few people dare to touch Zhang Fei's family; When Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, he killed Pang De, made a feud with Pang De's descendants, and was almost wiped out by Pang Hui.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because their backgrounds are different, Guan Yu has no background except for his own fame, and Zhang Fei is not only Liu Chan's father-in-law, but also has a relationship with the Xiahou family.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    I think the difference between the fates of the two is that one died more decently, the other died more miserably, one lived longer and one lived longer, one died for the country, one died accidentally, one died without any ties, and one died with a lot of ties because Guan Yu committed suicide Cong Town, and Zhang Fei was shot and killed.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Zhang Fei and Guan Yu are both dead, but the fate of the descendants of these two people is very different, Guan Yu and his family were exterminated by Pang De's son after Liu Chan surrendered in the state, and Zhang Fei's descendants were also sealed as princes by Wei Zhiji and got a good death.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Liu Bei's life was full of twists and turns and suffered countless failures, but he never thought of giving up, but tried to keep strengthening himself. Fortunately, he has two brothers who are willing to follow him all the time, no matter how bad the situation is, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei will never abandon life and death. Although they had a desire to live and die together at the time of their marriage, their fates were very different.

    Liu Bei died of depression due to the defeat of Yiling, Guan Yu was defeated and killed, and Zhang Fei died the most aggrieved, neither in battle nor from illness, but was assassinated by his subordinates.

    It can be said that the ending of all three of them is not very good, and the fate of their descendants is completely different. Although Liu Chan became the king of the dead country, he was not killed by the Wei State, but became an Anle Gong and spent the second half of his life comfortably. And Guan Yu's descendants were very miserable, when Deng Aivashu broke the city, the whole clan was killed, and none of them were spared.

    However, Zhang Fei's descendants are very lucky, and they are all safe. Why did Guan Yu's descendants end so miserably, but Zhang Fei's descendants were safe and sound?

    In fact, this is related to what Guan Yu and Zhang Fei did before their deaths. Guan Yu was infinitely beautiful during his lifetime, the number of famous generals who died under him was unparalleled, and any glorious record was enough to be famous all over the world. Therefore, this has caused him to be arrogant in the world, and few heroes in the world can enter his eyes.

    When Pang De carried the coffin against Guan Yu, Guan Yu didn't care about him at all and killed him within a few rounds.

    When Pang Hui entered Shu with Deng Ai, Pang Hui killed all the Guan family and killed none of them, so as to avenge Guan Yu's father's murder. Guan Yu would never have thought that one of the enemy generals he killed on the battlefield would cause his family to die many years later. If he knew, I believe that Guan Yu would not have killed the killer.

    However, it is also disgraceful for Pang Hui's behavior, he has no ability to find Guan Yu's descendants on the battlefield to fight a decisive battle to take revenge, but he picks Guan Yu's family who has no ability to resist, which really makes people look at him a little.

    As for Zhang Fei, he didn't have any big enemies during his lifetime, and the only ones he offended were Fan Qiang and Zhang Da, but the two of them had already killed Zhang Fei. His eldest son, Zhang Bao, was also unlucky, not killed on the battlefield, but died of traumatic brain injury, fell into the valley and died. Zhang Bao's son Zhang Zun has the shadow of Zhang Fei, when he defended Mianzhu Pass with Zhuge Zhan, Zhang Zun fought bravely to kill the enemy, led the army all the way into the enemy camp, but unfortunately died in the end, although Zhang Zun died early, but he died for the country and died a glorious death.

    And Zhang Fei's second son Zhang Shao is much luckier, after inheriting his father's title, he has been serving the Shu State, and his status in the imperial court is also very high. When the Shu Kingdom fell, their families were safe, and no one felt sorry for them. Moreover, Zhang Shao also followed Liu Chan to Wei to receive the title of marquis, and it can be said that he, like Liu Chan, spent the second half of his life in Wei without worrying about food and clothing.

    And more importantly, he also retained the bloodline of the Zhang family, and he did not break off like the Guan Yu family.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because Guan Yu has strong martial arts, he has many enemies, and he died earlier than Zhang Fei, and his descendants continued to serve Shu and died on the battlefield, and Zhang Fei's descendants lived in seclusion in the mountains and forests after the fall of Shu.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Because Guan Yu killed Pang De after the Battle of Xiangyang, he incurred the revenge of Pang De's descendants. Zhang Fei's family was treated favorably because of their marriage relationship with the Xiahou family.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    In the past China, those giants really existed. At that time, foreigners were very interested in Chinese giants, and they were invited to participate in various performances.

    Take a giant who once existed as an example, in 1894, this giant named "Chang Yanming" was meters tall and grew up in Yunnan; Also in Jiangsu, an American photographer, James Lycarton, was photographed with an unknown giant.

    And the very famous giant infiltrator "Zhan Shichai", nicknamed Wujiu, used to belong to Wuyuan County, Anhui Province, but now it belongs to the jurisdiction of Jiangxi, and the height of this giant is in meters. Because when Zhan Shichai was doing business, he met an Englishman who was very interested in him, so he went to the UK to participate in performances, and later traveled between major countries to participate in performances, and was called "Chinese giant". At that time, Zhan Shichai wore the official uniform of the Qing Dynasty to walk the catwalk for people to watch, with a monthly salary of 500 US dollars.

    But later, the height of Chinese people is getting shorter and shorter than that of foreigners, and the reason for this may be inextricably linked to a tradition of Chinese, that is, "kneeling".

    I'm afraid that for every Chinese, this action is known. To reproduce the society of today's branches, kneeling is nothing more than several situations:

    1. Worship ghosts and gods.

    In Buddhist halls, temples, or in front of the tombstones of ancestors, a large number of Chinese will kneel, kneeling to worship the gods and Buddhas to bless themselves and ask for peace or peace of mind.

    2. Kneel elders.

    This kind of kneeling is to worship heaven and earth, parents, husband and wife to worship each other during the New Year's festival, or when getting married, but now it has gradually changed.

    3. The weak kneel to the strong.

    Since ancient times, such a situation has arisen when encountering the question of asking for something from others, or begging for forgiveness from others.

    Kneel" this posture, starting from the Zhou Dynasty, how to kneel? How to kneel, at that time there was a specific set of clear prescribed procedures, so why do Chinese like to kneel so much? That's what most people say now.

    Before the Han Dynasty, there were no tables and stools, and at that time, whether people were eating, talking, or talking about things, they would directly spread a mat on the ground.

    For those who have money and status, the mats used to kneel will be different, but most of them sit on the ground, but at that time the sitting was basically the same as kneeling in Japan.

    Later, from the Yuan Dynasty, in addition to the nobility of etiquette, such posture also has the meaning of submission and humiliation in other situations. For example, in the TV series, the common people want to kneel when they see the officials, and they will kneel down to Qingyan when they see the strong, as a way to show their obedience.

    So this posture has left a deep imprint on the Chinese, all saying that "soldiers can be killed, not humiliated", no one kneels except parents, but how many people have done it?

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    This is because Zhang Fei's wife is a woman of the Xiahou family, and the Songkuan Xiahou family has a very high power and status in the Wei State, so the Zhang Fei family can survive.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because their relationship in Cao Wei is different, Zhang Fei's family has the care of his in-laws Xiahou's family, while Guan Yu's family has nothing, so the ending is different.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Because Guan Yu and Zhang Fei have different personalities and different people they offend, the final ending is very different.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Guan Yu's descendants and Zhang Fei's descendants all died in the battle for the country, and there was no pleasant luck to survive the enemy.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Zhang Fei's descendants are protected by the Xiahou family. So there was no danger, but Guan Yu was beheaded all over the house.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    The descendants of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were mediocre in martial arts, and finally died in the battle.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Zhang Fei and Guan Yu's sons can actually be said to have "died young", Zhang Fei's son Zhang Bao, Guan Yu's sons Guan Ping and Guan Xing all died at a very young age. And Zhang Fei's two daughters are married to Liu Chan as wives, and both of them have become queens before and after, and their status is naturally very high, so from the perspective of the two queens, Zhang Fei's descendants will have a better fate than Guan Yu's descendants, and if Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's sons are still alive, their status will naturally be very high.

    Although Liu Bei, Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei had wonderful lives, none of them could die well in the end. Guan Yu was defeated by Sun Quan's subordinate Lu Xun in the Battle of Xiangfan, and finally defeated Maicheng and was brutally killed by the people of Eastern WuThe same ending as Guan Yu was also killed by the people of Eastern Wu, and Guan Ping's age at that time was only 32 years old。And Guan Yu's other son, Guan Xing, was favored by Zhuge Liang when he was twenty years old, but unfortunately he died young in the end.

    And Guan Yu's daughter Guan Yinping is actually not recorded in detail in the official history, but she has appeared in ** and folklore, which means that she is inWhen Guan Yu was killed, Guan Yu had no real descendants, and by the time Guan Yu's son's descendants grew up, Shu had already come to an end. In contrast, the fate of Zhang Fei's descendants is better than Guan Yu'sZhang Fei's only son, Zhang Bao, is rarely recorded in the official history, and only uses the words "little Zhang Fei" and "untimely death" to describe it.

    And Zhang Fei's two daughters are much better than his elder brother, both of whom are married to the queen Liu ChanThe elder sister became Liu Chan's first queen (nicknamed Empress Jingwai), and the younger sister became Liu Chan's second empress after Empress Jingwai died, so the fate of Zhang Fei's descendants is naturally better than Guan Yu's. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both Liu Bei's sworn brothers, if Guan Ping, Guan Xing and Zhang Bao can live, maybe the fate of Shu will be rewritten from now on.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Guan Yu made a lot of contributions to Liu Bei, and his descendants also continued to serve the Shu Kingdom, and the end was very miserable, Zhang Fei lived longer than Guan Yu and could protect the descendants, and his descendants also retired after the fall of the Shu Kingdom.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because Guan Yu is very likely not considered by his descendants, while Zhang Fei is different, Zhang Fei has done a lot of things for his descendants to live a good life, so it has led to a different fate for the last descendants.

Related questions
29 answers2024-06-13

Cao Cao went south to destroy Liu Bei, and by the way, he wanted to destroy Sun Quan as well, so he went out of the Battle of Chibi. It was Liu Bei's first battle after the alliance with Sun Quan. >>>More

18 answers2024-06-13

Zhang Fei robbed little Lori, why is no one pursuing it?

13 answers2024-06-13

The Hankrama family and the Huyan Jueluo family have been enemies for generations, so they fight when they meet. >>>More

8 answers2024-06-13

The ultimate family of little dragon girls: Ah, I can hear you.

17 answers2024-06-13

If you're a girl, I feel like the ultimate family is better, because the plot of the ultimate class is very compact, and it's too tortuous, I watched the ultimate class first, but I can't watch it anymore when I see the fifth episode, and the ultimate family has more emotional dramas, family, friendship, love, but the focus is still on the ability, and it feels like the summer feels very comfortable, and the ultimate family has more episodes, so the plot is naturally bigger, anyway, the ultimate family I have finished watching one episode at present