Why do you want to write Chao Gai to death, is it to highlight Song Jiang s Zhao an thought?

Yes, if Chao Gai does not die, Song Jiang will never have a bright day, so there is no need to write "Water Margin" anymore. Chao Gai and Song Jiang are not simply two people, but represent two kinds of thoughts, one is the hypocritical idea of wanting to join the imperial court based on Song Jiang's thoughts; The other is the heroic thought of the real wandering rivers and lakes represented by Chao Gai. These two ideas, at the beginning, Chao Gai was the boss, that is, at this time, Liangshan was a group of real rivers and lakes, and later Song Jiang became the boss, which meant that it changed immediately.

Some people say that if Chao Gai is not written to death, Song Jiang can also seize Chao Gai's throne by attracting personnel, after all, with Song Jiang's scheming, it is more than enough to deal with two Chao Gai.

However, Song Jiang wants to deal with Chao Gai, even if ten Chao Gai are added together, they are not Song Jiang's opponents, but there is a problem between them. If Chao Gai was played to death by Song Jiang Zheng'er's Eight Classics, or Song Jiang stood on the bright side and came out against Chao Gai, then there is still no need to write "Water Margin", or the main idea of "Water Margin" has changed, and the things written have also changed.

Because Song Jiang's character is a pedantic hypocrite, "pedantic" and "hypocrite" are Song Jiang's characters in his bones, which cannot be changed at all, once changed, it is equivalent to changing the style of this group of people dominated by Song Jiang.

First of all, it is assumed that Song Jiang used a stratagem to kill Chao Gai and seized his position as the king of the mountain. If this is the case, then Song Jiang's hypocritical side will inevitably be no longer hidden, and it will inevitably be exposed to everyone's eyes. For example, Song Jiang's reputation in the rivers and lakes must no longer be "timely rain", and it is no longer "righteousness" praised by everyone.

So in this case, even if Song Jiang can still pull up Liangshan's team, then the style of the team must be mainly insidious, not "heroic".

Secondly, it is assumed that Song Jiang rebelled against Chao Gai, did not kill Chao Gai, and set up his own mountain. Then at this time, the content of "Water Margin" must be the heroes of the rivers and lakes dominated by Chao Gai, and the people who want to take refuge in the imperial court mainly by Song Jiang. Pay attention to this group of heroes dominated by Chao Gai, who all look down on the imperial court, so they must have irreconcilable contradictions with Song Jiang's team, so "Water Margin" is not a war between the people and the court, but a war between two groups of civil forces.

In the Water Margin**, the reason why Chao Gai is written to death is to promote the development of the storyline of the entire **. paved the way for the later ups and downs of the storyline, and also played a role in throwing bricks and stones.

This is on the one hand, in addition to this reason, or because of Chao Gai's own character, his character itself cannot completely lead Liangshan, so he has this ending.

In fact, yes, because if Chao Gai does not die, Song Jiang will never have a bright day, then there is no need to write "Water Margin" anymore.

Eight heroes led by Chao Gai outwitted Yang Zhi's escort in Huangnigang. Due to the importance of the matter, the government went around arresting Chao Gai and others, and because of the betrayal of Bai Sheng, Chao Gai and others fell into an extremely dangerous situation. At that time, Song Jiang, who served as the director of Yuncheng County, ran non-stop to Chaogai Village to ventilate the news after receiving the official document issued by the Jeju government, and Chao Gai and other eight heroes were able to escape in time.

Chao Gai also responded positively in order to repay Song Jiang for saving his life. He specially wrote a letter to Song Jiang, plus ten gold bars, and arranged for the red-haired ghost Liu Tang to sneak into Yuncheng County to find Song Jiang. The main content of Chao Gai's letter is to express his gratitude and longing for Song Jiang, and second, he hopes that Song Jiang can join the Liangshan brothers to gather together to do the right thing for heaven.

Song Jiang was still deeply surprised and worried about Liu Tang's sudden visit, he didn't expect Chao Gai and the others to be so bold and dare to send Liu Tang to find him when the government was arresting them everywhere. Of course, Song Jiang was also worried that he would be implicated by Liang Shan, after all, he was a court official in the official palace. Therefore, Song Jiang politely refused Chao Gai's invitation to join the gang, and he asked Liu Tang to convey his greetings to Chao Gai, and only left one gold bar given by Chao Gai, which was put into the poster bag together with the letter.

Song Jiang was afraid of the risk and hurriedly sent Liu Tang away, because the secret letter written by Chao Gai and the gold bar really involved Song Jiang. Chao Gai also did a bad thing with good intentions, because Song Jiang forgot the poster bag in his outer room, Yan Poxi's residence. At that time, the relationship between Yan Poxi and Song Jiang was very stiff, because Yan Poxi fornicated with Zhang Wenyuan, and the two regarded Song Jiang as a stumbling block.

Song Jiang hurried to Yan Poxi's residence to ask for a poster bag, Yan Poxi had already read the secret letter and gold bars, Yan Poxi thought that Song Jiang's handle was in her hands, so she threatened him in every way, and even threatened to go to the government to denounce Song Jiang. Song Jiang killed Yan Poxi when he snatched the bag with Yan Poxi. For this reason, Song Jiang also ended up in exile.

Of course, Chao Gai later repaid Song Jiang for saving his life, that is, Jiangzhou robbed the law field to save Song Jiang, and the two of them each saved each other's lives.

His reaction was very surprised, because he didn't expect Song Jiang to save himself, but later he also repaid Song Jiang for saving his life, and he was a person who knew how to repay his kindness.

Thank you very much Song Jiang. He has always been thinking about Song Jiang's kindness, and finally responded positively.

Song Jiang. The contradiction with Chao Gai is not the contradiction between recruiting and not recruiting, but the question of who is the boss. The two have known each other for a long time. The buddies are righteous and have friendships. Chao Gai outwitted the Birth Gang.

When the incident was revealed, Song Jiang took the risk of ventilating and reporting the news, so that Chao Gai could save the day; Song Jiang was escorted to Jiangzhou for writing anti-poems.

The execution ground, Chao Gai and others robbed the law field to rescue Song Jiang back to the cottage, it can be said that the two of them shared weal and woe at this time, and there was no contradiction

The contradiction arose after Song Jiang arrived at the cottage. The root cause is that the two have different ways, and what Song Jiang is thinking about is to find an official through what means, glorify the ancestors, and make the Song family shine. And Chao Gai doesn't want to be an official, he is a mountain king in the cottage, and this soil emperor is also very happy.

When Song Jiang arrived at the cottage, Chao Gai wanted to give him the position, but how dare Song Jiang, first, his brothers had little strength, and second, this cottage was Chao Gai and Lin Chong.

The foundation created by Liu Tang, San Ruan and others, if they take this position, whoever obeys him will not have a good time.

Song Tangerine socks blind Jiang is scheming, he is heavy on the surface, but he hides very deeply, the surface makes it difficult for people to see, when he led the troops to win the battle, his wings gradually plumped, and his attitude was different, Chao Gai saw that his brother also listened to Song Jiang's orders. Chao Gai was psychologically uncomfortable, he felt that this position was going to be snatched by Song Jiang sooner or later, so Chao Gai also wanted to establish prestige in front of his brothers, and personally led troops to attack Zengtou City.

Unexpectedly, it was Shi Wengong.

He was wounded by a poisoned arrow and died. Before Chao Gai died, he didn't want to give this position to Song Jiang, and he was worried that his brother and Song Jiang would not have a good ending, so he said in his last words that the one who killed Shi Wengong would be the king of the cottage. It can be seen that the words and laughter were superficial in the past, but now it really exposes the ambivalence of the two competing for the boss.

As for the contradiction in Zhao'an, there was no sign at that time. Chao Gai is by no means an idle person, unlike Song Jiang's Dao, he can see it, but with Chao Gai, Song Jiang does not dare to mention the matter of taking his brothers to Zhao'an. After Chao Gai's death, Song Jiang exposed his true colors, changed his banner, changed the Juyi Hall to Zhongyi Hall, and continued to expand his influence and buy Li Shishi.

Many parties seek opportunities to recruit security, and finally realize recruitment. But he didn't expect that he was a thief in the eyes of the court, how could the court let the thief go? Liangshan heroes.

The ending is heartbreaking!

The contradiction is the question of who is the boss. Before he died, Chao Gai said that the person who killed Shi Wengong was the king of the cottage. exposes the contradictions between the two.

I think it's a contradiction between recruiting or not recruiting An, they don't care who is the boss, but there are differences on the issue of recruiting or not recruiting An.

The question is who is the boss. The final contradiction between Song Jiang and Chao Gai lies in who is the boss on both sides, not whether they can recruit or not.

No, it won't. Chao Gai's personality characteristics are very distinct, which can basically be summarized in a few words: he is bold and likes to make friends; Dare to act, dare to come forward in case of injustice; Speak of righteousness and be honest to friends; Impatient in case of trouble, not good at uniting people.

Personally, I think that if he hadn't died, he would definitely have chosen Zhao'an, after all, it was a general trend at that time, and it had to be so.

No, because Chao Gai has no feelings for the imperial court. And he knew that the court would not let them go.

Because Song Jiang was very ambitious, and soon after Chao Gai's death, Song Jiang became the boss of Liangshan.

How unusual it is for the city lord to ask for credit from his subordinates! It can be seen that Chao Gai has been forced to be helpless, and he has to make up his mind to lay down the former head city Liwei. And Sun Xu and Chao Gai's move is right in Song Jiang.

From recognizing the broken flag, to pointing the deer as a horse, and letting Shi Wengong be the substitute for the dead ghost, Song Jiang carefully arranged. But Shi Nai'an flickered, and his words were full of flaws. It is not difficult to see that the person who killed Chao Gai was Song Jiang!

Because Chao Gai has always been the absolute commander of Liangshan, but Song Renye accompanied Jiang and wanted to be the commander, so some people will speculate that Song Jiang buried and killed Chao Gai, so that he could become the commander.