The man pretended to commit suicide, and his girlfriend rescued him and drowned, is this an accident

The legal aspect has been taken to the point ofIntentional homicideThe verdict was handed down against the man, indicating that the legal side believed that the man had committed a criminal case, and the man was finally sentencedHe was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison and deprived of political rights for three years.

I will briefly tell you about the specific situation of the incident here. The love between a man and a woman is a sister and brother who are more than ten years apart, one night after the two accompanied the customer to drink, they met to drink chicken soup in a hotel, and then when the two arrived at the store where the chicken soup was drunk, the woman inadvertently found that the man had it on his mobile phoneGamblingSo the two quarreled in the store.

After the man left, when he was walking by the river, suddenlyI came up with the idea of pretending to drown to scare my girlfriend,

And when his girlfriend came, he pretended to be motionless and ignored his girlfriend. Seeing this, his girlfriend jumped into the river and tried to save the man, but the woman couldn't swim. After the woman jumped into the river, the man turned to the womanPerformed a drag behaviorThe woman was pulled to deep water, and the woman was swept away by the rushing river, and the body was found 6 days later.

And that night the man was rescued by a passing resident.

Different judges expressed different opinions on the verdict in this case.

Some people think that this can be defined as an accident, while others think that it is a negligent event, and of course some people think that it is a criminal offence. The contradiction lies in the fact that the man dragged the woman under the influence of alcohol and pulled her into deep water, and if this is considered alone, the man is guilty of indirect homicide.

No matter what kind of crime it is, the man finally lost a girlfriend who loved him very much, and after seeing the man jump into the river, the woman also jumped into the river without hesitation, and shouted: If you want to die, you will die together, and the reason why the woman quarrels with the man is also to hope that the man will not be contaminated with gambling addiction again.

Then analyze this caseDrinking alcohol is also a key point. Alcohol can poison people's minds and make people lose their normal logical thinking ability, and the man actually came up with the idea of pretending to drown to scare his girlfriend under the influence of alcohol, and dragged his girlfriend to the deep water under the influence of alcohol.

If the man was awake at the moment, I don't think he would have such childish thoughts and such actions that are not responsible for the lives of others.

Therefore, here is also a warning to everyone, drinking must master a degreeYou can't drink to the point where you get drunkBecause when you go crazy, you won't be able to control your thoughts and actions, and you're likely to do things you'll regret for the rest of your life.

This is a criminal case, because the man first committed suicide intentionally, he may have had a conflict with his girlfriend, and then his girlfriend must have been his fault for saving him to death.

Personally, I think it's a criminal case. There is a causal link between the death of the girlfriend and the man's conduct in the sense of criminal law. The fact that the man had a clear understanding of the depth of the water and other conditions when he entered the deep water area for the first time, and that he was drunk and caused trouble and forcibly dragged the victim to the deep water area and then let go, indicating that he subjectively had a laissez-faire indirect intention, which constituted the crime of intentional homicide.

This matter should be regarded as a criminal case, because the man's actions have been suspected of intentional harm to others, and the man's behavior has violated the law, so it will be recognized as a criminal case.

It is a criminal case, the man pretended to commit suicide, and when his girlfriend rescued him, he dragged her underwater and drowned, which is the crime of intentional homicide and therefore a criminal case.

Criminal cases. The woman died in order to save the man, although the man did not intentionally kill people, it is also an outdated homicide, and it needs to be imprisoned, so it is a criminal case.

This should be an accident, this man should just want to create such a scene, but he didn't specifically want to design his girlfriend's death.

I think this may be a criminal case, because the boyfriend pretended to commit suicide, then it shows that the boyfriend has the ability to keep himself out of danger, but he cheated on his girlfriend and made his girlfriend lose his life, which has already constituted a criminal case.

This is a criminal case because the man planned the incident and deliberately harmed his girlfriend.

This was an accident, because the man probably didn't know that his girlfriend couldn't swim, let alone that his girlfriend would go into the water to save him, and that he couldn't swim.

Although it was not intentional, it is still a criminal case.

This should be an indirect act and a criminal case.

Water is a very important thing for people, but it is also a very dangerous thing. As we all know, most of the human body is water, and water is an important part of people. People can go days without food, but if they don't drink water for more than three days, they will lose their precious lives due to severe lack of water.

In the same way, there are many places in people's lives that cannot do without water, and when we wake up in the morning, we need water to wash; By eveningWe need water to bathe; When there are dirty clothes, we need water to wash them.

Although water is important and indispensable, it is still very harmful, and floods are a big example. Whenever there is a flood in one place, many people lose their homes, and Henan is a well-known example some time ago. This is a natural disaster, and in our lives, there are many hidden dangers of water, and drowning is a serious hidden danger.

For drowning, children are a major group to pay attention to, but according to statistics, people who lose their lives due to drowning are generally swimmers.

As for drowning, there was a recent incident of a bad nature in Huai'an, Jiangsu Province, where a man in Huai'an pretended to commit suicide by the river, and his girlfriend immediately went down to the river to save the man. This eventually led to the drowning of the man's girlfriend. After this incident, many people will ask, is this man's behavior a crime?

In my opinion, the man's actions were criminal and that he indirectly caused his girlfriend's loss of life. If it weren't for this behavior of his, her girlfriend would not have entered the water, thus happening with such a thing as losing her life. In any case, the man is responsible for the incident.

I think there are a few things we need to pay attention to about about this happening. First of all, the lives of others cannot be harmed in any way, and in our behavior, there is a little bit of life-threatening behavior that needs attention. Secondly, when encountering someone falling overboard, it is necessary to face the situation calmly to avoid unnecessary accidents.

In this case, what we have to do is to call the police first and wait for professional personnel to come to the rescue. If we go into the water to rescue ourselves, when we don't know the method, there may be incidents that not only do not save people but take their own lives, and the Huai'an incident is a clear example.

The criminal case, because there was a deliberate letting the deceased fall into the water, also shows that the man probably wanted to kill his girlfriend in the hope that the police could find out the truth.

Criminal incident, because the man is suspected of inducing his girlfriend to commit suicide, and eventually caused the woman's death, so it is a criminal incident.

It belongs to the ** thing, he pretended to commit suicide, his girlfriend persuaded him, but he didn't expect him to pull his girlfriend into the water and let his girlfriend die.

In fact, this should be an accident, but this accident is also very tragic.

In the end, the man was sentenced to 12 years and six months in prison by the Huai'an Intermediate People's Court, and was also deprived of political rights for three years. <>

The man involved in the case was born in 1999 and worked in a local bar in Huai'an, where he met his girlfriend, who was 11 years older than the man involved, but in the end the two parties confirmed their relationship. Although the age difference between the two is 11 years, they generally get along relatively well. But in February 2019, after the two got off work, there was a quarrel due to some trivial matters in life, and then the man left angrily.

In the days that followed, the more the man thought about it, the more angry he became, and he felt that he was so shameless that he had the idea of scaring his girlfriend by threatening to jump into a river while passing by a river. <>

Then the man directly called ** to his girlfriend, and told the other party that he wanted to jump into the river, and also recorded his ** about to jump into the river and sent it to his girlfriend. After receiving the information, the man's girlfriend Li came to the place of the crime as soon as possible, in fact, the man didn't really want to jump into the river at this time, but just wanted to scare his girlfriend. When the man reached the deep water, he did not continue to move forward, but when he heard the noise, his girlfriend thought that the other party was really going to jump into the river, and then he didn't care that he couldn't swim, so he jumped into the river to save people.

After jumping into the river, the woman was dragged to the deep water by her boyfriend, and soon two more people became entangled in the cause, so they all lost their balance. The man was not swept away by the water because he tightly held on to the reinforced concrete in the river, but his girlfriend was not so lucky to be swept away directly by the current, and it was finally confirmed that the woman drowned. In this case, the man must have been suspected of intentional homicide, so there was no problem with being sentenced to 12 and a half years in prison.

The man was convicted of intentional homicide and was held legally responsible, and the court has sentenced him to 12 years and six months in prison.

The legal responsibility that a man needs to bear is that he needs to compensate his girlfriend, he needs to be responsible for his girlfriend, he needs to bear the corresponding legal provisions for his girlfriend's death, and he also needs to apologize to his girlfriend's parents.

The man has been sentenced to 12 years and 6 months in prison for the crime of intentional homicide.

I don't agree with this approach.

Now everyone yearns to fall in love, thinking that falling in love is a beautiful thing, but in fact, some boys are not as good as their girlfriends. Falling in love itself is a very sweet thing, but if you meet an irresponsible boy, it is better to be single, and it is better to be happy than to live in pain, at best, there is no boyfriend, and there are still no less. <>

1. What happened.

One night, a small couple had a conflict, the man wanted the woman to coax him, so he came up with the phenomenon of pretending to jump into the river and pretending to be drowning, at this time the man's hand grabbed a steel bar on the bridge pier to pretend that he was drowning, the girlfriend was very anxious when he saw this situation, the man was very anxious because of his physique, and he dragged his girlfriend who wanted to save him into the water, and the woman was washed away by the water because she did not stand firm, and finally died. <>

2. What to do after this happens.

After this happened, the man also sent **,** said to save Su Su, from my personal point of view, the man doesn't really want to save the woman, because the man himself is strong, you can try to find it, instead of saying in a very low voice on the side to save Su Su. In court, the indictment charged the man with intentional homicide, and the man had an opinion on this matter, he said that subjectively I did not want to harm her, I was guilty, and I admitted, at best, it was negligence causing death, and as soon as this sentence came out, it was clear that the man did not deeply realize his behavior, and did not have a trace of remorse, and the final result was that the procuratorate believed that the man's behavior was indirect intent in the crime of intentional homicide, and was sentenced to 12 years and 6 months. <>

3. My opinion on this matter.

I think this is an extremely irresponsible boy, it can be seen from the ** that both parties are adults, adults should know how to respect and understand rather than blindly noisy, using his girlfriend's preference for himself as a capital to show off, which leads to a sad final result.

I think this man's approach is very naïve, treating life as a child's play, and even affecting his girlfriend.

I think the man's behavior is very bad, so I think he will definitely be punished as he deserves.

I think the man's actions have broken the law because there is a suspicion of leading others to commit suicide, and it has also caused serious consequences.

In the end, it should be because of manslaughter**, and prison is inevitable, and the final punishment is very severe.

will be punished by the law, this person has done some bad things, so he will let his girlfriend drown. There is something that two people can say well, and they should not scare each other in such a way.

When two people are in love, it is inevitable that they will quarrel because of trivial matters in life. When I am in love, how should two people get along, and how should they ease the relationship after a quarrel. It is a truth that two people who are in love must understand.

A man in Jiangsu pretended to commit suicide because he was angry with his girlfriend, but unfortunately died when his girlfriend went to rescue him. Was it intentional or accidental by the boyfriend?

His girlfriend was worried about the man's safety and jumped into the water and persuaded him. The man did not listen to the woman's advice and pulled the girl into deep water, which eventually caused his girlfriend to drown. And the refusal to understand that neither the man nor his girlfriend knows water, in this case, the man has to wonder what his motives are?

In court, the man also tried his best to defend himself, saying that he subjectively did not mean to kill his girlfriend. Just trying to scare him, manslaughter at best. But I think it doesn't make sense to jump into the water when you know that you can't water, and you have to pull your girlfriend into deep water when you go into the water to persuade you, if this is manslaughter.

If a woman knows how to water, and a man who knows that she knows how to water, throws her into deep water, thinking that his girlfriend will not drown, then it may be considered manslaughter, but this is not the case. I think men are subjectively trying to kill their girlfriends.

Any act of scare must be based on the premise that it will not harm the personal safety of the other party. And as two adults, doing such a dangerous thing. If the conviction was based solely on manslaughter, I think the punishment for this man would be too light.

Such a man is not only irresponsible, but also extremely terrible in life. Gambling itself is a wrong thing to do, and he met a girlfriend who didn't even care about his own life to save him. Not only did he not cherish it, but he was so ruthless that it eventually led to the drowning of his girlfriend, which made people resentful.

An originally beautiful marriage, due to his own irresponsibility and recklessness, caused an irreparable tragedy. Hopefully, such an accident will not happen again. I also hope that everyone will cherish their lives and not joke with life.