In the Sino French war, why did China lose money?

The French army is strong, and only some shrimp soldiers and crab generals who came across the ocean, and the strength and international status of this map are still very high, if it is like Japan in Vietnam, or if it uses this as an excuse to start a war, the Qing ** will suffer even greater losses. Instead of one more enemy, one more friend or neutral. This is to curry favor with France, but it is also afraid that it will beat itself to the death.

Because the war was not lost, but the treaty signed after the war gave France a lot of benefits, so some people say that "China was defeated in the Sino-French War".

In the ninth year of Guangxu of the Qing Dynasty (1828), a war broke out between the Qing Dynasty and France in northern Vietnam.

Although the Qing army suffered a crushing defeat on land and sea in the early stage, the defense of Taiwan and Hangzhou Bay was successful in the later period, and Feng Zicai led all the troops to the battle of Zhennanguan to bring a heavier ** to the French army, and the French commander Nigri was also seriously injured, and the defeat of the war directly led to the collective collapse of the cabinet of French Prime Minister Jouferi.

On May 13, 1885, the Qing Dynasty appointed Li Hongzhang as a negotiator to begin negotiations on a formal Sino-French treaty with the French representative and Minister to China, Badeno, in Tianjin.

In the 11th year of Guangxu (1885), Li Hongzhang and the French minister Badeno signed the "Ten Articles of the Sino-French Treaty of Vietnam" in Tianjin, and from then on, China recognized France's annexation of Annam, and the door to southwest China was opened.

Because of this, the world lost power and humiliated the country, and signed when the Qing army won the battle, so the result of the Sino-French war was called "France won without victory, and our country was defeated without defeat". And for a century to come, this statement was heard endlessly and generally accepted.

There appears to be no compensation.

It just won a local war, and it is still at a disadvantage on the whole.

It seems that in order to explain the loss of power and humiliation of the Qing Dynasty, the evaluation is a bit biased.

It is mainly the cowardice and compromise of the Qing ** rulers that the fruits of victory will be buried.

France replaced the Manchus as protectorates of Indochina such as Annam.

The Mawei Division was annihilated.

Some of the achievements of the Westernization Movement can be sustained for a while compared to 30 years ago.

China was undefeated and defeated, in fact China won, but the Chinese rulers, cowardly and fearing retaliation from France, took the initiative to sue for peace.

The outcome of the Sino-French war: China was defeated undefeated; France won't win.

Qing ** is weak, not allowed to fight back, undefeated and defeated.

1. The difference between the preparation of the Qing army and the French army is not very large;

2. Learned the lessons of the Battle of Mawei and was fully prepared;

3. Take advantage of the favorable terrain of Zhennanguan;

4. The soldiers participating in the war were excited by the national righteousness and their morale was high.

The Sino-French War, which resulted in a decisive military victory for China, forced the French cabinet to fall, was undefeated. However, Li Hongzhang will.

As a capital for compromise and peace, he advocated that "when a peace treaty is concluded with Langshan by virtue of the power of Langshan's victory, the legal person will no longer seek it in vain." 1885

On June 9 of that year, Li Hongzhang and the French Minister to China, Baderno, formally signed the "Sino-French New Treaty" in Tianjin, which China basically accepted.

France's aggressive demands, so China is defeated without defeat. France, as the loser of the war, basically succeeded in launching this time.

The main purpose of the war of aggression. France not only seized all of Vietnam, but also opened the gateway to southwestern China, and for the first time, it achieved.

The privilege of building railways in China, so France was victorious.

The Sino-French War was militarily defeated by the Qing Dynasty!