Before Cao Cao died, why did he kill Yang Xiu but not Sima Yi?

Updated on history 2024-06-17
23 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Cao Cao killed Yang Xiu because Yang Xiu followed Cao Cao's son Cao Zhi, Cao Zhi wanted to seek power, but Cao Cao couldn't bear to kill his own son and could only kill Yang Xiu to relieve his anger. And he didn't kill Sima Yi because of Sima Yi's assistance Cao Pi, Cao Pi is relatively low-key, Sima Yi is loyal to the Cao family, and he is a famous strategist in the army, which can help Cao Pi make contributions, so Cao Cao will bypass Sima Yi's life.

    First of all, let's take a look at the personality traits of Sima Yi and Yang Xiu. Yang Xiu is the grandson of Yuan Shu, and he is also a big family, his father is Yang Biao, a famous military general, and it is precisely because of his background that Yang Biao is so ambitious and high-profile. If it's just a high-profile thing, it's fine.

    However, this person's emotional intelligence is not high, and he has repeatedly contradicted Cao Cao in the army, and regarded Cao Cao's words as a deaf ear, which laid hidden dangers for him to be killed. As for Sima Yi, he acted very low-key, knowing that Cao Cao had doubts about himself, so he pretended to be sick at home to dispel all Cao Cao's concerns about himself, and gradually won Cao Cao's trust.

    Secondly, we can also look at the political orientation of the two people. Yang Xiu assisted Cao Cao's youngest son Cao Zhi, and Sima Yi assisted Cao Cao's eldest son Cao Pi. Cao Zhi has been a smart and clever child since he was a child, Cao Cao wanted to pass on his position to Cao Pi at first, and Yang Xiu saw Cao Cao's plan, so he tried his best to assist Cao Zhi.

    But being smart was mistaken by being smart, and it was precisely because Cao Zhi firmly believed that his father's position would eventually be passed on to him, so he became high and invincible. Cao Cao gradually changed his opinion of Cao Zhi, but Yang Xiu did not react, and continued to come up with some bad ideas for Cao Zhi to fight for power and profit. In the end, Cao Cao decided to remove Cao Zhi from his position, but Cao Zhi was his own son after all, so Cao Cao only chose to execute Yang Xiu.

    On the other hand, Sima Yi followed the low-key Cao Pi. Cao Pi knew that his father loved Cao Zhi more, so he didn't fight or grab. Sima Yi also reminded himself to keep a low profile, and it was this cautious style that won Cao Cao's trust.

    Therefore, Sima Yi was able to protect himself and became a famous soldier in the Wei capital.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Sima Yi is a talent, Cao Cao is a person who loves talents, he wants Sima Yi to serve Wei again, but he didn't expect Cao Ren to die earlier than Sima Yi, so there was a betrayal later.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    When Yang Xiu was alive, he thought he understood Boss Cao's meaning very well, but he didn't know that he was clumsy, and staying in it would expose Boss Cao's ambitions, while Sima Yi knew how to be wise and foolish, and he was very good at grasping Boss Cao's careful thinking.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Because of Yang Xiu's existence, there is a great threat to Cao Cao's son Cao Pi as the emperor, Cao Cao must kill him, but unlike Sima Yi, the Cao family can also use him to do many things.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he only behead Yang Xiu and not kill Sima Yi?

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he let Sima Yi go and kill Yang Xiu instead?

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Before Cao Cao died, why didn't he kill the ambitious Sima Yi, but killed Yang.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Cao Cao could feel Sima Yi's threat to Cao Wei, but Cao Cao was also very talented, and Sima Yi was also Cao Wei's pillar at that time, so Cao Cao didn't kill him. As for Yang Xiu's indulgence, he violated Cao Cao's taboo several times, and Cao Cao killed him when he was angry.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Cao Cao felt that Cao Pi could suppress Sima Yi, so he did not kill him. Killed Yang Xiu because Yang Xiu was blind and arrogant and did not attach himself to Cao Pi.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because he didn't want Cao Zhi to become a puppet, Yang Xiu was good at figuring out people's hearts, and Cao Zhi was not his opponent, so he removed him.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Cao Cao replied before he died, and why not kill the ambitious Sima Yi in order to clear the way, but killed Yang.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Before Cao Cao was dying, why did he only behead Yang Xiu, and didn't let Trembling kill Sima Yi?

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he let Sima Yi go, and killed Yang Chao and stupid Xiu?

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Yang Xiu and Sima Yi are both high-IQ talents in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and they were once appreciated by Cao Cao, but Yang Xiu and Sima Yi have different personalities, Yang Xiu is too flamboyant and shows his cleverness everywhere, while Sima Yi is introverted and knows how to hide his edge. is also because of such a personality, which leads to different endings for the two. Let's talk about why Cao Cao killed Yang Xiu instead of Sima Yi before he died?

    1.Yang Xiu is too flamboyant

    Yang Xiu is the son of Taiwei Yang Biao, who has received a good education since he was a child, and is not only knowledgeable, but also extremely intelligent. Maybe it's because his IQ is too high, so he is more flamboyant in terms of being a person, his emotional intelligence is very low, and he is also very straightforward in speaking. At that time, Cao Cao said that he had the habit of killing people in his dreams, and everyone knew that this was just Cao Cao's excuse for being suspicious, and there was no need to say it, after all, he was the boss, and whatever you said was what he said.

    However, Yang Xiu, this guy, just told Cao Cao's lies, and told his son Cao Zhi, do you think he is stupid, and he is too arrogant. Moreover, his political ideas are also contrary to Cao Cao, but they are the same as Cao Cao's least favorite Kong Rong faction, which makes Cao Cao hate it very much. <>

    2.Sima Yi is low-key

    Sima Yi was born in a Sima family, his father was Sima Fang, and he often taught Sima Yi and his brothers. Sima Yi has been very smart since he was a child, likes to read all kinds of books, especially likes to study military books, so Sima Yi has a very high military talent. In terms of being a person, Sima Yi has always kept in mind Sima Fang's teachings, and everything should be low-key and not strong.

    Therefore, Sima Yi later came to work under Cao Cao, and was once humble and respectful, inconspicuous, and knew how to hide his edge, so that Cao Cao could not grasp the handle and punish him. <>

    Therefore, the biggest reason why Cao Cao wanted to kill Yang Xiu instead of Sima Yi before he died was that Yang Xiu was too clever and flamboyant, and Cao Cao couldn't leave such a person to bewitch his son and let them fight each other. And Sima Yi has always been low-key and well hidden, Cao Cao couldn't find his fault, there was no excuse, so he didn't kill him.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he only behead Yang Xiu and not kill Sima Yi?

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because Cao Cao was deceived by Sima Yi's behavior, Cao Cao felt that Sima Yi was not a big threat to him, but felt that Yang Xiu was too smart and was likely to pose a very big threat to his power.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because Yang Xiu was too flamboyant, he repeatedly guessed Cao Cao's thoughts, and the key was to guess correctly, Cao Cao was afraid of him, Sima Yi was more obedient, and he kept hiding his strength, so that Cao Cao felt that he could control him.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he let Sima Yi go and kill Yang Xiu instead?

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Before Cao Cao died, why did he only behead Yang Xiu and not kill Sima Yi?

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Before Cao Cao died, why didn't he kill the ambitious Sima Yi, but killed Yang.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because he thought that Sima Yi could help Cao Wei to be strong, and he could also leave Cao Pi to kill the prestige, but leaving Yang Xiuding would make Cao Zhi a puppet.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Because Sima Yi was better disguised, Cao Cao did not see his ambitions. Yang Xiu, on the other hand, is too flamboyant and does not have a high emotional intelligence.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Although Sima Yi was talented and Cao Cao felt that he might not be able to control him, Sima Yi did not show his flaws so that Cao Cao had a reason to kill him, and Yang Xiu's sharp edge made Cao Cao feel a greater threat.

Related questions
41 answers2024-06-17

Yang Xiu and Sima Yi are both high-IQ talents in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and they were once appreciated by Cao Cao, but Yang Xiu and Sima Yi have different personalities, Yang Xiu is too flamboyant and shows his cleverness everywhere, while Sima Yi is introverted and knows how to hide his edge. is also because of such a personality, which leads to different endings for the two. Let's talk about why Cao Cao killed Yang Xiu instead of Sima Yi before he died? >>>More

41 answers2024-06-17

I think it's because Sima Yi's background and strength are very strong, and at the same time, Sima Yi's strength should not be underestimated, it would be a pity to kill him like this, so he couldn't kill Sima Yi, so he could only kill Yang Xiu to make an example of the monkey.

14 answers2024-06-17

Before Cao Cao died, why did he only behead Yang Xiu and not kill Sima Yi?

5 answers2024-06-17

Yang Xiu intervened in the struggle for the throne between Cao Pi and Cao Zhi and supported Cao Zhi.

21 answers2024-06-17

Emperor Guangxu was imprisoned in Yingtai after the failure of the Wuxu reform, once Longyu went to visit by Yi's order, and originally wanted to persuade, but Guangxu even said "Kneel down, kneel down" and urged her to leave quickly, but Longyu didn't move, so he went up and pushed her, and the strength was greater, and the queen was pushed down, and Longyu cried and left, and never saw each other again.