In the Three Kingdoms, why does Guo Jia not go out of the mountain if Zhuge Liang does not die?

Updated on history 2024-07-11
18 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Because of the death of Xi Zhicai, Guo Jia dared to go out of the mountain. The most complete statement is "Zhicai does not die, Guo Jia does not come out, Guo Jia does not die and Wolong does not come out".

    In fact, such a statement is wrong, Xi Zhicai, Guo Jia, and Zhuge Liang were all relatively good strategists during the Three Kingdoms period, and the three of them have never had any intersection, and their order of going out of the mountain is not because of a certain person, they are all looking for opportunities to go out of the mountain.

    Introduction

    Xi Zhi was a strategist in the early days of Cao Cao's business, and Cao Cao was very important. In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is not too much introduction to Xi Zhicai, but a brush-by-pass. In fact, in the early days of Cao Cao's business, Xi Zhicai's contribution was not small, but unfortunately Xi Zhicai died young.

    Xi Zhicai died, and Cao Cao lacked a more capable strategist around him, Xun Yu found Cao Cao's difficulties, so he took the initiative to recommend Guo Jia. Guo Jia was unhappy with Yuan Shao, and when he saw a letter of recommendation from a friend, he came to Cao Cao's side, so Guo Jia replaced the position of Xi Zhicai with his super ability and became one of the most important strategists around Cao Cao.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Guo Jia died in 207 AD, and Zhuge Liang went out of the mountain to assist Liu Bei in 208 AD; Therefore, there is a saying that has been handed down - Guo Jia is not dead, Zhuge is not out. Is this a coincidence? Or is it a deliberate choice?

    Guo Jia, Guo Jia was born in Yingchuan, had a vision when he was a teenager, saw that the world would be in chaos at the end of the Han Dynasty, and lived in seclusion after the age of twenty, secretly befriending Yingjie and not interacting with the world; Guo Jia first went to Yuan Shao, but he was not allowed to reuse it and was idle for six years.

    Later, one of Cao Cao's most important strategists, Xi Zhicai, died, and Cao Cao asked Xun to ? Shounder, flounder, desolate Changfen Jingnuo, which stroke? Follower?

    Chyme pressure? Urn gingivals? Instantaneous, Tong Yiyi?

    Dangerous? Guess what? To Ben Yan Crab?

    Yi Wei bears the wreckage of Ao Xin? Page deletion painful file Na play? Fade the pry?

    Tricky? Orime? Cryptos?

    Bo Sheng supplement? He said, "This is my true master!"

    From then on, Guo Jia became Cao Cao's staff and military officer-the military advisor sacrificial wine, and offered advice and loyalty to Cao Cao's Quartet campaign. What Guo Jia is best at is accurately judging the psychological state of each opponent, which often becomes the key to Cao Cao's victory (which is also the reason why Guo Jia is the spy leader under Cao Cao in "The Alliance of Military Divisions").

    For Liu Bei, Cao Cao's strategists have their own opinions, such as Cheng Yu, who feels that Liu Bei is a heroic who is unwilling to lie in wait, and suggests that Cao Cao should strangle all dangers in the cradle; But Guo Jia felt that Liu Bei was a threatening person, but he couldn't kill him, and from the overall situation, he suggested that Cao Cao put Liu Bei under house arrest for life.

    But later he was escaped by Liu Bei; However, Cao Cao has been suppressing Liu Bei's development, at least when Guo Jia was still alive, Liu Bei was at most cowering in Xinye City, being "protected" by Liu Biao, the assassin of Jingzhou; It was not until after Guo Jia's death that Liu Bei "looked at the thatched house" to find Zhuge Liang out of the mountain.

    After Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain, he planned for Liu Bei to seize Jingzhou first and then take Yizhou, and fully assisted Liu Bei; Liu Bei, who was assisted by Zhuge Liang, quickly embarked on the road of foreign expansion like a fish in water, and finally became a hegemon.

    But I didn't expect that after Guo Jia's death, Cao Wei actually appeared a Sima Yi, which was also due to fate.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Because Guo Jia's month far exceeded Wolong.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Where does this statement come from? Zhuge Liang's departure from the mountain after Guo Jia's death was just a coincidence, if Guo Jia was long-lived, would Zhuge Liang waste his talent and not want to go out of the mountain? Certainly not.

    Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong are called "Wolong" and "Phoenix Chick", in fact, they are only limited to the nicknames in the circle of celebrities and scholars in Nanyang and Xiangyang (Pang Degong, Sima Hui, Huang Chengyan, Xu Shu and others). Liu Bei lived in Jingzhou, and went to Nanyang to visit the thatched house, perhaps by the way.

    Zhuge is the Langya Wang clan, but Zhuge Liang's parents died early, and when he was young, he and his younger brother went to Jingzhou Liu Biao with his uncle Zhuge Xuan, and then Zhuge Xuan passed away, lost his support, and lived in seclusion in Longzhong, which was already a declining Shi clan.

    Although Cao Cao is "eclectic" in selecting talents, he still relies on cooperation with the family. Heroes such as Guo Jia (although Guo Jia is deeply trusted by Cao Cao, in fact, his position is not high, but later generations instinctively think that he must be in a high position to be trusted by the monarch, but in fact, it is not), and it is difficult to hope to get the same political status as Xun Yu and Sima Yi.

    At that time, Cao Cao had unified the north, and in the Cao camp, there was little room for the political rise of the declining scholars, even though Zhuge had the talent of the heavens and latitudes, but if he wanted to have a broader political stage to display his talents, it would be a better choice for an emerging warlord like Liu Bei, not to mention that Liu Bei did have a heroic posture.

    In addition, don't say that Zhuge Liang can't compare to Guo Jia or anything, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms distorts history and says that Zhuge Liang is very strategic, in fact, Zhuge Liang's talent lies in political strategy, and Guo Jia is military strategy. Zhuge Liang is equivalent to Xiao He in the early Han Dynasty, and Guo Jia is equivalent to Zhang Liang in the early Han Dynasty, so how can it be said that who is inferior to whom?

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Guo Jia is Cao Wei's first strategist, so there shouldn't be much objection. Zhuge and Zhou Yu were the first strategists of Shu Han and Eastern Wu respectively, and among the Three Kingdoms, the most powerful was undoubtedly Cao Wei. And Guo Jia assisted Cao Cao, in the most critical process from "a small prince" to "unifying the north", which is the same as Zhuge Zhoulang, but the country Cao Wei established in the end was the most powerful.

    Although there are many other factors in it, it is not inappropriate to be the reason for recommending Guo Jia as the first strategist of the Three Kingdoms.

    In addition, among these people, Guo Jia is also the purest strategist. Zhuge , Sima and Zhou Yu are not only giving advice, but most of the time they are actual executors, prime ministers and generals, rather than pure strategists. Pang Tong didn't mention the goods, he led the troops to go out and was ambushed and hung up.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Without historical evidence, it is all in vain.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Zhuge Liang went out of the mountain when Guo Jia was there, and Sima Yi was because after Guo Jia's death, there were no talents in the Wei Kingdom, and at this time the mountain would be reused!

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    There is an old saying in the history of the Three Kingdoms: "Guo Jia does not die, and Wolong does not come out". In the year when Guo Jia died of illness, Liu Bei invited Zhuge Liang out of the thatched house.

    This will make future generations think, is Zhuge Liang not going out of the mountain because he is afraid of losing to Guo Jia? Who is this Guo Jia, who can make Mr. Zhuge Kongming so jealous? Is Guo Jia really so powerful?

    Before Guo Jia defected to Cao Cao, he worked for a short time with Yuan Shao, and later his friend Xun Yu recommended Guo Jia to Cao Cao. The interviewer is Cao Cao himself, and the two of them can be said to have met late and admired each other. So Guo Jia began a legendary and short life, making suggestions for Cao Cao's Quartet campaign and serving loyally.

    How awesome is this Guo Jia? He successively helped Cao Cao eliminate Lu Bu, defeat Liu Bei, conquer Yuan Shao, and successfully pacify Hebei. It can be said that it was with Guo Jia's great help that Cao Cao was able to smoothly unify the north.

    Among Cao Cao's many strategists, only Guo Jia knows Cao Cao best, and the two have a close relationship, like friends. According to the car, the two people are in the same car, and they sit in the same seat. In Cao's tent, which is strict with the army, Guo Jia has a lot of unconventional behavior, but in the eyes of Cao Cao, who prefers him, "This is an extraordinary person, and it is not appropriate to detain him with common sense."

    In his long career, Cao Cao always took Guo Jia with him, so that he could learn from each other at any time and act when the opportunity was right. Whenever there is a major military event, Guo Jia's strategy has never miscalculated. Cao Cao placed infinite hopes on the young Guo Jia, and planned to entrust Guo Jia with the important affairs of governing the country behind him after pacifying the world.

    It is a pity that Guo Jia died of illness during Cao Cao's expedition to Karasuma at the age of thirty-eight, which can be described as an untimely death. Cao Cao was defeated in the Battle of Chibi, and his nose and face were swollen and he cried: If Feng Xiao is here, he will not be lonely!

    And then I often miss him, such as "Sorry for filial piety!" Painful and filial piety! It's a pity!

    It can be seen that Guo Jia is important to Cao Cao.

    Objectively speaking, Guo Jia is good at military strategy, and Zhuge Liang is good at internal affairs and military training, and the two are actually not comparable. Guo Jia's death is undoubtedly Cao Cao's biggest loss, but Zhuge Liang is by no means an idle person, and he is not afraid of Guo Jia and does not go out of the mountain.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhuge wants to go out of the mountain and scare Xiao Guo Jia to death.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    It is true that Guo Jia came out of the mountain after his death. The two did not go head-to-head, and it was impossible to determine who was better. However, the importance of the two to their respective fathers is the same.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Zhuge Liang was only taken care of by Liu Bei after Guo Jia's death, Zhuge Liang did come out of the mountain after Guo Jia's death, but it does not mean that Zhuge Liang is not as good as Guo Jia, Guo Jia is very powerful, known as a last resort, if Guo Jia does not die early, he should become an opponent with Zhuge Liang.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Not really, because Guo Jia is much older than him. Zhuge Liang was only a teenager when Guo Jia died, they are not people of the same era at all, it should be Zhuge Liang who is more powerful.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Guo Jia is a very capable person, and there is also a saying among the people called "Guo Jia does not die, Zhuge Liang does not come out", it seems that Guo Jia's talent is above Zhuge Liang, and Guo Jia can only come out when Zhuge Liang dies, but in fact it is not the case. Guo Jia is indeed a very capable person, but Zhuge Liang's talent is not below Guo Jia at all, but after Guo Jia's death, Liu Bei invited Zhuge Liang to go out of the mountain, and this time node formed a sequence, Guo Jia just died, Zhuge Liang went out of the mountain, so there is such a saying, but Zhuge Liang's talent is not under Guo Jia.

    1. Guo Jia lived in seclusion when he was young. Guo Jia is a very powerful person, with remarkable talents, and very visionary. At the end of the Han Dynasty, Guo Jia was about to be in chaos in the world, so Guo Jia began to live in seclusion.

    The so-called real hermit is not completely indifferent to the world's major affairs, but the world's major affairs are in his own heart, and Guo Jia is also such a person. Although Guo Jia is living in seclusion on the surface, in fact, he has made a lot of friends and controls the overall situation of the world, which also provides preparation for his departure from the mountain.

    Second, Guo Jia defected to Yuan Shao. When he was 21 years old, Guo Jia saw that Yuan Shao had already grasped power, and Yuan Shao was recruiting, so Guo Jia was ready to go out of the mountain and defect to Yuan Shao to display his ambitions. But this defection did not bring the results he wanted.

    Yuan Shao is a more arbitrary person, although he likes to plan, but he is not decisive, which conflicts with Guo Jia's thoughts, so Guo Jia went back to live a reclusive life.

    3. Guo Jia defected to Cao Cao. Cao Cao is a person who loves talents, Guo Jia met Cao Cao through Xun Yu's introduction, and Cao Cao also recognized Guo Jia's talent very much, so he was reused by Cao Cao. He successively helped Cao Cao eliminate Lü Bu and Liu Bei, and conquered Yuan Shao, making a lot of contributions, but 11 years later, Guo Jia died of illness.

    Later, Liu Bei visited the thatched house three times and asked Zhuge Liang to come out of the mountain.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because Guo Jia's intelligence is particularly high. It was Guo Jia who helped Cao Cao unify the north, without Guo Jia, there would be no success for Cao Cao, I think Guo Jia is stronger than Zhuge Liang, if Guo Jia does not die, there is no room for Zhuge Liang to develop at all.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Because Zhuge Liang only came out of the mountain after Guo Jia's death, Zhuge Liang disappeared before. And Guo Jia does have this strength, Cao Cao was not defeated when Guo Jia was there.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because people think that Guo Jia's talent is above Zhuge Liang, if Guo Jia does not die, then Zhuge Liang will not have the face to go out of the mountain.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because Zhuge Liang is not Guo Jia's opponent, he has the ability to judge life and death when he speaks, and he is almost in the state of an unpredictable prophet.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    This is actually a conspiracy, "Guo Jia is not dead, Wolong is not out" The sentence is actually true, Zhuge Liang deeply knew that he was not the opponent of the genius Guo Fengxiao, so he used the method of praying for the Beidou to suck away Guo Jia's star, so that Guo Jia died young, and he was willing to rest assured that he would go out of the mountain.

    Guo Jiazi Fengxiao, is the Eastern Han Dynasty in the late years of Cao Cao's account strategists, and Xi Zhicai, Xun Yu, Xun Yu and Cheng Yu and others together to assist Cao Cao, many times for Cao Cao to give advice, in Xuzhou to capture Lu Bu, Guandu defeated Yuan Shao, after the battle of Chibi, Cao Cao sighed that if Guo Fengxiao is here, it will not be such a fiasco.

    Soon after the victory of the battle of Guandu, Liu Bei planned to attack Cao Cao in Runan, but in the end he was defeated by Cao Cao because of the number of soldiers, and then Liu Bei had to lead the remnants of the defeated army to go south to take refuge in Liu Biao in Jingzhou, where he met many reclusive gentlemen in Jingzhou, including the famous "Mr. Shuijing" Sima Hui.

    When Sima Hui was talking to Liu Bei about the world's talents, he took the opportunity to mention Wolong and Fengxiao, and said: "What are the best talents in the world, only Wolong and Fengxiao are the real sages and talents today, and the two of them can stabilize the world if they have one!" ”

    But he completely forgot about another genius in the world, that is, Guo Jia, "Guo Fengxiao", this Guo Jia is a natural talent, a descendant of the Warring States gods and Guiguzi, so he is also known as a "ghost talent", not only resourceful, but also has the talent of an unpredictable prophet.

    Long after the envoy sent to Jiangdong returned to Xuchang to report the news of Sun Ce, Guo Jia predicted that Sun Ce was unprepared, impatient and unscrupulous, and would be killed by the assassins sooner or later, and later Sun Ce would indeed die at the hands of the assassins; Lu Bu occupied Xuzhou, and after sending Chen Deng to Xuchang, he failed to get Xuzhou Mu for himself, but was deceived by Chen Deng's rhetoric, Guo Jia said that Lu Bu would definitely be destroyed within half a year, so it was fulfilled; In his later years, Guo Jia suggested that Cao Cao run thousands of miles to attack Wuhuan and win a complete victory, which shows that his use of troops was so unexpected.

    So after Zhuge Liang, who lived in seclusion in Nanyang, heard about it, he had to refuse to go out of the mountain, so he used the technique of Qimen Dunjia and used the method of the Beidou to suck away Guo Jia's star, which made Guo Jia die young, and he dared to go out of the mountain after three visits to the thatched house.

Related questions
5 answers2024-07-11

Zhuge Liang was born in the fourth year of Emperor Guanghe of the Han Dynasty (181) in a family of officials in Langxiyangdu (now Yinan County, Shandong). Zhuge is the Lang evil family, the ancestor Zhuge Feng once served as a lieutenant of the Sili School (the commander of the garrison Beijing Division) when the Yuan Emperor of the Western Han Dynasty. Zhuge Liang's father, Zhuge Gui, the word Jungong, was a Taishan county in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. >>>More

8 answers2024-07-11

The reason for the difference is because:Wei Yan is rebellious and ruthless; And Meng Da is much more mediocre in comparison >>>More

14 answers2024-07-11

Because the public is often influenced by the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, they ignore Lu Su's unique shining point in history, and only remember Zhuge Liang's "highlight performance". We all know that Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of Shu, can be said to be a well-known generation of heroes in Chinese history, and he has made countless literati compete for his outstanding wisdom and outstanding integrity. >>>More

19 answers2024-07-11

Li Yan's selfishness and Adou's mediocrity.

19 answers2024-07-11

Guo Jia is not dead and Wolong does not come out, it is a coincidence. Liang's political achievements were so sharp that they overshadowed his military achievements, so Liang entered the Ten Philosophers of Wumiao, but Jia did not have "Ten Victories and Ten Defeats", "Prophecy of Sun Ce's Assassination", "Soldiers' Speed", and "Legacy Determination of Liaodong". Liang took one state to ten states, and the Wei State was also considered to be a rolling climb, and a large number of talents were excavated, so that Shu Han lasted for decades, Liang is a person who can be in charge alone, a Jia who has not even brought soldiers, slightly inferior to Liang.