If Guan Yu recruited Cao Cao to Liu Bei as a military advisor, would Cao Cao agree?

I won't agree, Cao Cao is a generation of heroes, and his ideal is to be an emperor, not a military advisor under others, so he will definitely not be a military advisor to Liu Bei.

Of course, Cao Cao would not agree, he himself has great talents and lofty ambitions, and he wants to be the lord of a country, and it is impossible for others to be a small military advisor.

Guan Yu was defeated and persuaded by Cao Cao to surrender, and Cao Cao treated Guan Yu very favorably, but Guan Yu did not forget the old feelings, so he defected to Liu Bei again.

In the fifth year of Jian'an, Cao Cao personally conscripted Liu Bei, Liu Bei was shocked to learn that Cao Cao's army was coming, and personally led dozens of horsemen out of the city to observe, and sure enough, he saw Cao's army banner, so he had to rush to the battle, and was defeated by Cao's army, and Liu Bei's wife was captured.

Cao Cao then captured Xiapi, and Guan Yu was trapped on the earth mountain for escorting Liu Bei's family. Liu Bei's family is still in the city, Cao Cao sent Zhang Liao to persuade him to surrender, Zhang Liao and Guan Yu Tucheng about three things, and one of them will not surrender.

Cao Cao wanted to win Luo Guanyu wholeheartedly, and the rewards continued. Kung Fu has been done for almost two years, but it has no effect at all, Guan Yu believes that Zhongyuan finally escaped to Liu Bei. It was only in the Battle of Guandu that Guan Yu killed Yan Liang (Wen Chou) among the ten thousand troops, and reported Cao Cao's favor to Zhipei, so he decided to leave Cao's army.

Cao Cao. Don't kill Guan Yu.

There are several reasons for this:

1, Cao Cao wanted to influence Guan Yu. Guan Yu is a tiger general, Wen Jiu beheaded Huaxiong and killed Yan Liang.

Wen Chou, among the ten thousand armies, is like a tiger entering the flock, bravely covering the world. Cao Cao has always attached importance to talents, hoping to influence Guan Yu by treating him well, and finally let him defect to his command. 2. Cao Cao wanted to take the initiative morally.

Guan Yu is a loyal and righteous person, who is righteous and righteous, and will repay his kindness. Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, feeling that Cao Cao treated him well, and left him only after making great contributions for Cao Cao. For Liu Bei.

Guan Yu never forgot it. Cao Cao gave Guan Yu a new robe, but Guan Yu wore it inside the old robe, because the old robe was given by Liu Bei, Guan Yu said that the old robe was worn outside, and seeing it was like seeing Liu Bei himself. Cao Cao gave Guan Yu a thousand miles of red rabbit horses.

Guan Yu thanked him again and again, saying that if he knew Liu Bei's whereabouts and rode a thousand-mile horse, he would be able to see Liu Bei within a day. Cao Cao said with deep feelings: "The owner does not forget his roots, and he is a righteous man in the world!"

In addition, when Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, there were "three covenants", one of which was that if he knew Liu Bei's whereabouts, Guan Yu would go after him, and Cao Cao agreed.

3, Cao Cao wanted to educate the soldiers around him. To educate the soldiers around him, Guan Yu is a living textbook. I heard that Guan Yu hung the seal and sealed the gold, and walked out of the city gate, Cai Yang, the general under Cao Cao.

I want to lead the troops to capture Guan Yu back. Cao Cao stopped him and said to the soldiers who followed him: "Guan Yu does not forget his old master, he understands when he comes, and understands when he goes, what a big husband!"

Learn from him." Cao Cao was a good person to the end, and simply brought dozens of people to see off Guan Yu. Cao.

Guan Yu arrived in Liu Bei's arms, and Cao Cao did not kill him because Cao Cao was a person who cherished heroes very much, and he felt that Guan Yu was very appreciated by him, so he couldn't bear it. For this reason, the measure of killing Guan Yu and Cao Cao is not so small.

Liu Bei once defected to Cao Cao, Cao Cao's adviser Cheng Yu once persuaded Cao Cao to kill Liu Bei, Cao Cao's other adviser Guo Jia thought that Liu Bei was a popular hero, and took the initiative to defect to Cao Cao, killing Liu Bei would hinder the world's heroes from obeying Cao Cao's heart, Cao Cao and Guo Jia had the same opinion, so they did not kill Liu Bei.

In 198 AD, Lu Bu sent troops to attack Liu Bei, Liu Bei defected to Cao Cao after the defeat, since ancient heroes know heroes, Cao Cao has long seen that Liu Bei is a rare hero, knowing that he will not live under the people for a long time, on the issue of whether to kill Liu Bei, Cao Cao's advisers have different views, Cheng Yu believes that Liu Bei is an ambitious person, will never sincerely return to Cao Cao, leave Liu Bei by his side, sooner or later will cause trouble, it is better to kill to avoid future troubles. However, Guo Jia believes that Cao Cao's great cause has not been accomplished, and there is still the strongest opponent in the north, Yuan Shao, who needs to win the hearts of heroes in the world, and Liu Bei has a high prestige among the people and princes. Because before that, Cao Cao learned a lesson and thought that Guo Jia was right, so he kept Liu Bei by his side and treated him generously, neither reusing him nor killing him. Hope!

It's useless to kill him, and letting him go will also show his bearing and love for talent. And Liu Bei's power was very small at that time, and he was attached to Yuan Shao, so Cao Cao didn't take Liu Bei seriously, and even if he let Guan Yu go back, it couldn't affect his own interests.

Because Cao Cao cherishes talents very much, and Guan Yu is such a talent, Cao Cao cherishes talents, and also hopes that his policy of recruiting talents can make Guan Yu heartfelt to himself, he is indeed very good to Guan Yu, but in the end Guan Yu still chose Liu Bei.

Because Cao Cao cherishes talents, Guan Yu is a big hero, and Cao Cao is reluctant to kill.

Cao Cao respects him as a man, and the feeling that heroes cherish heroes.

Because he is both civil and military, Cao Cao still wants to use him as a talent.

Because he and Cao Cao's early encounter with each other, he was forced to surrender to Cao Cao when he was Sun Que, and he did not really surrender to Cao Cao, so he rebelled against Cao Cao in the later period.

Mainly driven by interests, he can be reused by Liu Bang's side and can have more power.

Even if Guan Yu took refuge in Cao Cao, Liu Bei would still be able to establish Shu Han.

1. Guan Yu is important to Liu Bei, but it is not irreplaceable for Shuhan Group.

Second, the key to the establishment of Shu Han. Liu Bei later entered Sichuan with Pang Tong, so Pang Tong can also be said to be the key person in the establishment of Shu Han, and Pang Tong helped Liu Bei capture Yizhou and other places. Later, in the Han Dynasty, Liu Bei brought Fazheng, so Fazheng can also be said to be the key to the establishment of Shu Han.

These three times are the key to the establishment of Shu Han, and the key person in these three things is not Guan Yu, although Guan Yu has merit, but he is not Mr. Key. So even if Guan Yu turned to Cao Cao at that time, it would not have much impact on the entire situation in Shu Han.

It can be established, Liu Bei will lose a lot without Guan Yu, but it will not affect Liu Bei's establishment of the Shu Han Group, because in addition to Guan Yu, Shu Han has many excellent commanders and generals.

I think Liu Bei should be able to establish Shu Han, but Shu Han was not so smoothly established.

Yes, because Zhuge Liang is the core figure of Liu Bei's group, it doesn't matter if there is one less Guan Yu.

At that time, Liu Bei was thinking about the overall situation, and did not dare to risk killing Cao Cao.

He definitely still wanted to use Cao Cao, and he didn't want to get rid of Cao Cao too early, but he didn't expect to leave a disaster for himself in the future.

At that time, Cao Cao's strength was already very strong, and rash action would make Liu Bei Guan Yu very passive, and he might not succeed.

How could Cao Cao be so easy, he could kill him if he said he could kill him, and Liu Bei also thought that Cao Cao had a certain usefulness.

Cao Cao was so resourceful, he was definitely not so easy to kill.

Liu Bei should have felt that the time was not yet ripe to kill Cao Cao.

Because Liu Bei wants to create a very benevolent image for the world, if he kills Cao Cao, it will violate benevolence and morality.

It should be that Liu Bei knew that Cao Cao was not so easy to kill.

Because Liu Bei wants to maintain his image of benevolence and righteousness, if he kills Cao Cao, his image will be ruined.