If Xiang Yu obeys Fan Zengyan, can he defeat Liu Bang?

If Xiang Yu obeyed Fan Zengyan, it was possible to defeat Liu Bang. Because at that time, in terms of the military strength of the Chu army and the Han army, the Han army and the Chu army were far from being at the same level.

He can't defeat Liu Bang, because, Xiang Yu is indecisive, hesitant, and has no grand strategy, even if he obeys Fan Zengyan, he can't defeat Liu Bang.

No, because Xiang Yu is the commander of the first army, and Fan Zeng is only Xiang Yu's military advisor, if Xiang Yu obeys Fan Zeng's words, it will cause instability in the army's morale, which will greatly damage morale.

He will be the last to sit on the throne. Because Xiang Yu is brave and resourceful, and is also loved by everyone, Xiang Yu can sit on the throne.

Because Xiang Yu and 2 Yu Ji gave birth to a girl, even if they win, the position of the emperor will still be passed on to Liu Bangdu's son in the future, and Xiang Yu wants to only let his daughter marry the son of Liu Bang and Lu Pheasant, so he still doesn't want to compete with Liu Bang for the position of emperor.

It is possible, because there were only Xiang Yu and Liu Bang at that time, and the two of them wanted to win the throne, and the strength of the two of them was relatively strong, Liu Bang could not be the emperor, so he could only Xiang Yu.

Probably, because he is a very stubborn person, and he doesn't believe many people when they speak, so it will lead to his own death.

It was King Chu Huai who should be the emperor.

Xiang Yu actually didn't want to be the emperor, he just wanted to be the overlord of Western Chu quietly, if he wanted to be the emperor, he could be the emperor after the battle of Julu, but unfortunately his retro ideas were too deep-rooted, but at that time, since the unification of Qin, the feudal system was destined to be replaced by feudal centralism, which was an unstoppable trend in history.

Xiang Yu is a veritable war maniac, and the feudal system also wants to maintain his desire to fight, so Xiang Yu's demise is historical, and Liu Bang can't destroy him in time, and there will be "Ma Bang" in the future, which is an unstoppable trend in history.

If Xiang Yu listened to the advice of the strategist Fan Zeng, with Xiang Yu's influence and military strength in the society at that time, it was very likely that he would defeat Liu Bang and unify the world, and the specific reasons were as follows.

1, Xiang Yu was completely defeated by the "human factor", if he followed Fan Zeng's advice, he could defeat Liu Bang.

The reason why Xiang Yu was defeated was completely defeated by "human factors" and "decision-making factors", Xiang Yu had a first-class strategist "Fan Zeng" around him, and after the destruction of Qin, Xiang Yu began to swell, and Fan Zeng "did not listen to his words and did not obey", resulting in several delays in the fighter, causing Liu Bang to "defeat the strong with the weak" and defeat Xiang Yu, if Xiang Yu listened to Fan Zeng's strategy, he could easily defeat Liu Bang in the early stage.

2. If Xiang Yuhongmen Banquet implements Fan Zeng's plan, there will be no "Chu and Han hegemony" in history.

The historical background of the Hongmen banquet incident is that Xiang Yu is strong, Liu Bang is weak, and Fan Zeng, who has a forward-looking vision, saw that leaving Liu Bang Group is to raise tigers for trouble, and will compete with Xiang Yu for the world in the future, so Fan Zeng designed the Hongmen Banquet and got rid of Liu Bang is very important for Xiang Yu.

Xiang Yu is called the "God of War" in history, the ancients evaluated Xiang Yu as "Xiang Yu's bravery, unique through the ages", Xiang Yu's military thought is also quite influential in the history of ancient Chinese warfare, so Xiang Yu's personal military talent can completely crush Liu Bang, with a hundred possibilities to defeat Liu Bang.

In addition, Xiang Yu was strong at that time, before Liu Bang got Han Xin, Xiang Yu's military strength was significantly higher than Liu Bang, under Chen Ping's divisive strategy, but Xiang Yu gradually lost trust in Fan Zeng, and even suspicious, disagreed with Fan Zeng's suggestions, and insisted on going his own way, which led to Xiang Yu, who was obviously stronger, and finally gave Liu Bang, who was obviously weaker.

4. Liu Bang commented on the reason for Xiang Yu's failure, "Xiang Yu has to increase and cannot be used".

After Liu Bang defeated Xiang Yu, he summed up the reason for defeating Xiang Yu and said, "Xiang Yu got Fan Zeng and couldn't use it, so he was captured by me", so it can be seen that the main reason for Xiang Yu's failure was that Xiang Yu did not listen to the advice of the strategist Fan Zeng.

Jiang Ji once commented on Xiang Yu: "If Xiang Yu obeys Fan Zeng's strategy, he will take the world in peace", which shows that the main reason for Xiang Yu's failure is still "not listening to Fan Zeng's strategy", if he listens, he can unify the world.

will dominate the world. Xiang Yu has made huge mistakes in many decisions, and if he listens to his father Fan Zeng, he is likely to unify the world.

No. Because in fact, Xiang Yu is not without strength, but not as good as Liu Bang to win the hearts of the people, the so-called winner of the hearts of the people wins the world, Xiang Yu can't get the most people's hearts, then he can't get the world.

No. Xiang Yu's own personality is problematic, even if he has been listening to Fan Zeng's words, it is impossible to unify the world.

If this is really the case, then Xiang Yu will have a lot of fewer competitors, and there will be fewer obstacles for him to unify the world, but he didn't listen.