Before the Hongmen banquet, why didn t Xiang Bo directly let Xiang Yu spare Zhang Liang?

Updated on culture 2024-08-04
8 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-15

    Although Xiang Bo is Xiang Yu's uncle, Xiang Yu is also Xiang Bo's leader after all, and what Liu Bang did at that time was too much, if he directly persuaded Xiang Yu at this time, Xiang Yu would definitely not listen.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-14

    Because Zhang Liang is his savior. Xiang Bo was fortunate to meet Zhang Liang after killing people and was exempted from the death penalty, Zhang Liang was like a grace of reinvention to him, although Xiang Bo should have full authority to think about Xiang Yu, but he could not kill his benefactor.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    Because he still knows Xiang Yu's character better, although Xiang Yu is a person with a more direct personality, but the decisions he makes will not be easily changed because of others.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Historical Records. Xiang Yu Benji".

    ..Xiang Wangnai and Fan Zeng rushed to encircle Xingyang. The king of Han suffered, and he used Chen Ping to plan the king of the middle.

    King Xiang's envoy came, because he was too strong, and he wanted to enter it. When he saw the envoy, he was shocked and said, "I thought that the messenger of the father was the messenger of the king of the opposite item."

    Hold on even more, and eat the king's messenger with evil food. The messenger returned to the king of Xiang. King Xiang suspected that Fan Zeng had a personal relationship with Han and seized the power slightly.

    Fan was furious and said: "The major events in the world are decided, and the king does it himself." May the bones be returned to the army.

    Xiang Wang Xu Zhi. Before he reached Pengcheng, he died of gangrene.

    The specific thing is that when the two sides confronted each other in Xingyang, Xiang Yu sent an envoy to Liu Bang**, Liu Bang first was "too fast" (with cattle, sheep and pigs and three animals to prepare food, the highest number of courtesies to entertain guests), when the envoy was about to eat, he went in and saw the messenger, and said in surprise: "I thought it was the messenger of Yafu (Fan Zeng), but I didn't expect it to be the messenger of King Xiang (Xiang Yu)." So he took everything away and replaced it with very shoddy food.

    After the envoy returned, he told Xiang Yu. So Xiang Yu suspected that Fan Zeng had colluded with the Han army, and weakened Fan Zeng's military power. Fan Zeng was very angry and said:

    The overall situation of the world has almost been decided, the king (Xiang Yu) you can do it yourself, I want to return to my hometown. Xiang Yu agreed. As a result, before Fan Zeng could go to Pengcheng, he died of an attack on his back because of anger.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Xiang Yu's personality is excessive, and he can't know people well, this is a taboo for the monarch, Fan Zeng can't use it, let alone others...

    After Xiang Liang's death, he began to assist Xiang Yu. With his help, Xiang Yu entered Xianyang all the way, and suppressed Liu Bang, who entered the customs first, and became the overlord of the world. However, Xiang Yu's woman's benevolence ignored Fan Zeng's advice at the Hongmen banquet and let Liu Bang go.

    After that, Liu Bang raised troops from Hanzhong, occupied the Guanzhong Plain, and went out of the pass to attack Wei and Korea, which opened the prelude to the dispute between Chu and Han. They went back and forth, fought for a long time, and finally stalemate in Xingyang. Liu Bang's grain and grass transportation channel was cut off by Xiang Yu, so he could only sit in the lonely city and have nothing to do.

    Fan Zeng persuaded Xiang Yu to seize the opportunity and kill Liu Bang. The situation was urgent, and Liu Bang adopted Chen Ping's strategy to sow discord between Xiang Yu and Fan Zeng. The specific method was that when Xiang Yu sent the envoy to come, he asked people to deliberately set up a table with good wine and food, and the envoy hurriedly withdrew when he was about to eat, and explained that this was prepared for the envoy sent by Fan Zeng, and the envoy of King Xiang did not have such a high standard of food.

    The envoy was really furious, and as soon as he went back to tell Xiang Yu with oil and vinegar, Xiang Yu began to feel unhappy in his heart. He didn't say anything, but he cut Fan Zeng's military power. Lao Fan's white beard shook and trembled, and in a fit of anger, he made a gesture and said that he wanted to tell the old man to return to his hometown, but he didn't expect Xiang Yu to approve it immediately.

    Now he had no choice but to make a small bag and go out. It is estimated that he still counted on Xiang Yu to keep him, and he didn't even want a car. However, he walked for a long time before he realized that Xiang Yu was playing for real, so he was angry and anxious, and died halfway before he reached the base camp Pengcheng.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    It is not Zhang Liang who separates Xiang Yu and Fan Zeng, it is Chen Ping, Chen Ping's ability is not very strong, but he is a first-class master who plays this method. There is a difference between the Hongmen banquet in the movie and the historical facts.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    First, there may be artistic exaggerations of his behavior in film and television works, and the actual performance may not be so obvious or explicit. The second is that he is Xiang Yu's youngest uncle, the age is relatively close, and he should have had a good relationship since childhood.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because of Xiang Yu's personality, he is more affectionate, not to mention that Uncle Xiang is his uncle.

Related questions
23 answers2024-08-04

I think it's because of Zhang Liang, because Zhang Liang saved Xiang Bo's life before. In addition, Xiang Bo felt that the Hongmen banquet was not a good time to kill Liu Bang, so he did not help Xiang Yu at the Hongmen banquet.

25 answers2024-08-04

At the time of the Hongmen Banquet, Xiang Yu had not yet established himself as the overlord of Western Chu, and at this time, the general way of writing history by Sima Qian, the author of historical records, was called by the later positions of the characters, such as when writing about Liu Bang's rebellion, they were all "lonely".

4 answers2024-08-04

Unless Xiang Yu can see the future and see that his future self was driven to the edge of the Wujiang River by Liu Bang and Han Xin and had to kill himself, otherwise, Xiang Yu had no reason to kill Liu Bang at the Hongmen banquet. >>>More

5 answers2024-08-04

In order to kill Pei Gong Fan in the following ambush.

10 answers2024-08-04

For the world. At the end of Qin, it is just the background.