What will be the outcome if Guan Yu successfully breaks through from Maicheng?

Assuming that Guan Yu breaks through from Maicheng, my opinion is that Guan Yu may not be able to return to Chengdu, because Guan Yu has been proud of his talents all his life, he is a high-minded and arrogant person, and ordinary people can't get into his eyes, and the entire Dongwu is not in Guan Yu's eyes, Guan Yu is even more known as the Jiangdong rat, even Sun Quan asked Guan Yu for his son to refuse in person, and he didn't give Dongwu any face, but Guan Yu was attacked by Dongwu and lost Jingzhou, at this time Guan Yu's Guan Yu can be said to be disgraced, and at the same time, Guan Yu will also feel sorry for the trust of his eldest brother Liu Bei and military advisor Zhuge Liang, and Guan Yu was already old at that time, and at the same time he was injured, so Guan Yu was likely to die of depression if he couldn't get to Chengdu.

Liu Bei will definitely not blame Guan Yu, so let him make meritorious contributions, and the battle of Yiling will still start, but not to avenge the killing of Guan Yu, but to recapture Jingzhou. Personally, Zhuge Liang still won't agree this time. Guan Yu has always been arrogant, and with Liu Bei, the result is estimated to be about ...... the Battle of Yiling in the official historyGuan Yu committed suicide because he could not recapture Jingzhou or became ill in annoyance and died.

Liu Bei may also die of illness due to failure......

If Guan Yu successfully broke through from Maicheng, would Liu Bei kill Guan Yu? The answer is no, because Guan Yu's status in Liu Bei's heart is different from that of other generals, Guan Yu is not perfect, and he has made many mistakes before, such as Guan Yu once made a military order, but then let Cao Cao go in Huarong Road, on this point, Liu Bei should have executed Guan Yu, but Liu Bei did not do this, and this time Liu Bei would not kill him either.

In fact, Liu Bei thought in his heart that Guan Yu's killing was not Guan Yu's responsibility, but someone else's, otherwise he would not have raised troops later to avenge Guan Yu, of course, not only revenge, Liu Bei also had his political intentions. In addition, there is another point, Liu Bei has not become a real monarch at this time, he and Guan Yu have a deep brotherhood, and they will never take Guan Yu's life because of this, at most they will give a heavier punishment.

Guan Yu led the remnants to retreat to Shangyong, because Shangyong was close, and Guan Yu once sent Liao Hua to ask for help in history. Since Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and failed Liu Bei's trust, Guan Yu may refuse to return to Chengdu to meet Liu Bei, but will instead take it upon himself to regroup (bring Yong's soldiers) to recapture Jingzhou. The result is certainly predictable......Defeated.

If Guan Yu is lucky enough not to commit suicide, he may return to Chengdu to plead guilty.

Guan Yu didn't die and returned to Chengdu, so what would Liu Bei do to him? Reading the feelings of the three knots in Taoyuan, Guan Yu will not be blamed, because the generals who lost the city and lost the land during the Three Kingdoms abounded, Zhang Fei lost Xuzhou drunk, Cao Ren did not listen to the advice and lost Fancheng, Xiahou Yuan lost Chang'an, and so on. The most important thing is that Liu Bei still had capital at that time, and if Guan Yu recovered from his injuries, it was possible that Liu Bei's three brothers would send troops to recapture Jingzhou again.

Liu Bei has always been a benevolent and generous image, which is also an important reliance for him to win people's hearts, many people think that Guan Yu's failure is not only his personal reason, coupled with the relationship between Guan Yu and Liu Bei, if Guan Yu is killed directly because of this incident, it may also affect people's evaluation of him, you must know that Guan Yu's prestige is not low.

It is well known that Meng Da and Liu Feng did not give a helping hand to Guan Yu at the critical moment, Liu Bei was very angry about this, and he also thought that if these two people were willing to save Guan Yu at the critical moment, then Guan Yu would not die like that. Meng Da surrendered to Wei in advance because of this, but Liu Feng thought that he had no second thoughts, and was killed by Liu directly after he returned.

If you can bring out one, twenty thousand. Guan Yu will join Liu Bei, Jingzhou soldiers are the main force, and they are very capable of fighting. The plot must be Guanzhang, Zhao's three-way army to take Jingzhou, and the plot of the Three Kingdoms has changed.

Judging from the situation at that time, it was difficult for Guan Yu to get to Xichuan even if he broke through the Linfu path, and it was a new city to continue north from Linfang, who was the guard? Liu Feng Mengda, you should know very well what these two have done, they refused to send troops to rescue Guan Yu, and now that Guan Yu is here, these two are likely to be afraid of Guan Yu's settlement after the autumn and refuse to open the city gate, and even block the other roads leading to Xichuan in the new city.

Not only does he not blame, but he comforts him, and the identity of the second master is not ordinary!

It was Lu Meng who was more precisely defeated by himself.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, and was flooded in the forbidden Seventh Army, and the military power was greatly boosted, and Cao Cao had proposed to move the capital to avoid its edge. In October of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219), Jiangdong general Lü Meng took advantage of the confrontation between Guan Yu and Cao Ren, the defender of Fancheng, to attack Jingzhou and capture Guan Yu's base camp Jiangling. Guan Yu was attacked on both sides, and hurriedly withdrew his troops from Fancheng to the west and stationed in Maicheng.

Lü Meng adopted a strategy of division and disintegration, so that Guan Yu's soldiers had no intention of fighting and gradually dispersed. Guan Yu was isolated and helpless, and held on to Maicheng. Sun Quan sent someone to lure Guan Yu to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, set up a banner at the head of the city, pretending to be a sergeant, but he fled, only more than ten horsemen followed.

Sun Quan sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang to cut off Guan Yu's various ways, captured Guan Yu and his son Guan Ping in Linfu, and immediately executed them.

Above is a historical allusion.

It is said that when he was arrogant, he looked at no one and despised the place, so he was defeated, so he was defeated by himself.

Well, it's Lu Meng. Actually, I think it was Guan Yu who lost to himself. He won the battle because he basically fought the battle, and was later appreciated by Cao Cao, after Liu Bei got the land of Sichuan and Shu, he became the commander of the generals, Liu Bei has repeatedly won military exploits abroad, and he himself has not been able to get the opportunity to make meritorious contributions, so that he has been guarding Jingzhou is inevitably a little boring, plus he is proud of the enemy, confident that Dongwu will not dare to sneak attack his Jingzhou, so the commander of the army went out, and finally caused the abdomen to suffer from the enemy.

And Lu Meng himself was single-handedly promoted by Zhou Yu, and he was later influenced by Lu Su, so he was very good in both fighting and strategy, and it was inevitable to kill Guan Yu in the end.

was defeated by Lu Meng's scheme, and was caught by Ma Zhong and Pan Zhang in Maicheng.

Guan Yun Changgui is the head of the five tiger generals of Shu Han, watching him behead Yan Liang and Wen Chou, and warm wine and Huaxiong, he is simply a superb sword and no one can beat him. Seeing him ride alone for thousands of miles, passing five levels and killing six generals, he never put people in his eyes. Later, when the Seventh Army was flooded and captured by the forbidden Pound, he was so high-spirited that even Cao Cao was so frightened that he wanted to move the capital to avoid his edge.

After the loss of Jingzhou, he was defeated and captured by many nobodies, and then let Sun Quan show his head to the public, which made people sigh.

Why did Guan Erye, who had been domineering all his life, end miserably when he was famous: this time, that time. When Guan Yu passed the five levels and killed the six generals, he was young and strong, and he was ambitious at that time and wanted to make contributions.

And when he was defeated and took Maicheng, he was a prince, guarding Jingzhou, his worth doubled, and he had a party of men and horses, so he naturally had to think about the overall situation, and it was impossible to break out of the encirclement by himself at this time, and meet Liu Bei, he was Guan Yu, and he couldn't help but be responsible for his face. was too arrogant, thinking that he could carry the girder of Jingzhou, mistakenly compared Sun Quan's son to a dog, refused Zhuge Jin's proposal, refused to marry, deceived people too much, and cut off the life of the Wushu Alliance, which also ran counter to the basic national policy of "uniting Sun Quan and resisting Cao Cao" analyzed by Zhuge Liang's "Longzhong Pair".

The decision-making was wrong, Guan Yu was stubborn, did not listen to his advice, misused people, and insisted on letting Premier Pan Rui Jingzhou. Pan Rui was embattled and surrendered to Sun Quan as a result. However, Guan Yu may have underestimated this person, this person who doesn't seem to be very shrewd is actually upright under Sun Quan, Sun Quan especially likes to go out to hunt, Pan Rui persuaded:

There is no stability in the world, hunting is not a priority, you do this, and your subordinates will easily follow suit. Sun Quan replied casually: "You have been outside for too long, I rarely go out now, and I don't play this anymore."

Pan Rui glared and said, "Really? Seeing that there were hunting bows and arrows hanging on the wall next to him, he rushed up and took them down and broke them, and then walked away, Sun Quan was dumbfounded.

Later, Sun Quanju asked his son to marry Pan Rui's daughter and became in-laws with Pan Rui. Sun Quan once said to his son: "Mrs. Pan is often a sincere gentleman, and her daughter must be a good girl."

It was a tactical mistake, and he didn't know the strategy of the arrogant soldiers, so he withdrew the troops of Jingzhou. Although Guan Yu is known as a famous general, he doesn't know the arrogant plan arranged by Lu Xun. Lu Xun once wrote a letter to Guan Erye, boasting that Guan Yu was today's Han Xin, even more powerful than them, Guan Yu was very useful, so he withdrew his defense, and finally fell into a big trap.

Arrogant by nature, knowing that there is an ambush on the path, he also said, "Although there is an ambush, why am I afraid!" "I threw myself into the net and lost my life. This Guan Erye thought that back then, he could anticipate things like a god, just like when he said that Yan Liang was like a native chicken and tile dog, but he was captured by life.

It can be seen that Guan Erye's defeat of Maicheng is not unrelated to his age, as the saying goes, the veteran does not mention the courage of the year, and a person has the ability to do it, in the twilight of his life, if he is not aggressive, he will be clear if he listens, and he may go to the opposite side of himself. Guan Yunchang had nothing when he was young, but in his later years, he had fame and profit, so he was naturally burdened by fame, and he no longer had the invincible spirit of the year.

In fact, Guan Yu's defeat in Jingzhou is certainly related to his carelessness, but it is by no means just the word carelessness that can summarize the reason for his defeat in Jingzhou, I think that behind the superficial phenomenon of his carelessness, there are more profound reasons hidden. Jingzhou is the throat of Sichuan and Shaanxi, during the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei crossed the two states of Jingyi and wanted the world, and Cao Cao Sun Quan also wanted to eat this piece of fat, therefore, Jingzhou became a place where the three must fight. It is precisely because Jingzhou is so important that Liu Bei will use Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou.

In 219, about leading the army to attack Cao, winning one by one, to Fancheng, and Cao Jiang stalemate, about the arrow in the field. But Guan Yu was unwilling to retreat to Jingzhou, so he gave Sun Quan an opportunity. So Wu Dadu Governor Lu Meng led 30,000 and 90 fast boats, and selected soldiers who were familiar with the water nature to pretend to be merchants on the ship, and the elite soldiers were all in the cabin, straight to the north bank of the Xunyang River, Jing Garrison said that he was a merchant when he interrogated, because of the wind in the river, he came to this wall, and distributed the finances to the defenders.

In the middle of the night, the elite soldiers who were in ambush in the ship came out empty, and captured the beacon tower guards to the cabin, so that they could not release the letter, so the commander of the Wu army drove straight in, rushed to Jingzhou, and asked the captured soldiers to open the city gate, and when the city gate was opened, the Wu army swarmed in and occupied Jiangling effortlessly. Cao Cao hurriedly sent the grand prize Xu Huang to fight Guan Gong urgently. Xu Huang spread the news of the loss of Jingzhou everywhere, and Guan Junjun was in turmoil, but Guan Yu didn't believe it.

His carelessness and conceit of refusal to admonish the enemy were the external reasons for the defeat, which can be easily seen from his conversations with Zhuge Liang and Sima Wangfu of the army. When Zhuge Liang handed over Jingzhou to Guan Yu to guard, he repeatedly instructed: 'Reject Cao Cao in the north, and Sun Quan in the east' is the fundamental plan to keep Jingzhou, although Guan Yu said on the spot that 'the words of the military advisor should be remembered from the bottom of his heart', but later it can be seen from what he did that he did not take Kong Ming's words to heart.

Sun Quan of Eastern Wu sent Zhuge Liang's brother Zhuge Jin to come to the matchmaker to take the initiative to marry Guan Yu, and wanted to marry Guan Yu's daughter as his daughter-in-law, Sun Quan was the emperor of Wu, and he didn't insult Guan Yu's daughter, but Guan Yu was furious: 'My tiger girl Anken marries a dog!? In doing so, Guan Yu completely violated Zhuge Liang's strategy of 'Donghe Sun Quan', and the Wu-Shu military alliance collapsed.

After Sun Quan heard Zhuge Jin's report, he was immediately furious, and he wanted to fight Guan Yu to the death. After Ma Chao surrendered to Liu Bei, Guan Yu knew that Ma Chao's martial arts were outstanding, so he wanted to enter Sichuan to compete with him. Zhuge Liang wrote a letter to praise him, and persuaded him with the importance of guarding Jingzhou, Guan Yu dispelled the heart of the competition.

When going to the meeting alone', many people advised Guan Yu not to go, but Guan Yu said: 'I am in the midst of thousands of spears and blades, when the arrows and stones are attacking, the horses are vertical and horizontal, as if entering the realm of no one, how can I worry about the Jiangdong group of rats!? This is contempt for the heroes of Soochow and overconfidence.

Later, although Lu Su was generous and escaped this catastrophe, the final result was still defeated by Soochow.

The story of Guan Yu's defeat of Maicheng occurred in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219 AD), in the summer of this year, Guan Yu led the army from Jingzhou to attack Fancheng in the north, flooded the Seventh Army, and captured Pang De alive, Megatron Huaxia, Cao Cao even planned to move the capital, in order to avoid its front, but the praying mantis preyed, the yellow finch was behind, Guan Yu Fancheng had not yet been taken, but because of the relaxation of vigilance and lax vigilance on the Eastern Wu, the vigilance was not strict, and the Eastern Wu took advantage of the loophole and seized Jingzhou. Guan Yu was on the front line of Fancheng and heard that Jingzhou was lost, so he had to return to the army. Cao Cao intended to let Guan Yu and Sun Quan fight each other, and did not send troops to chase after them.

On the way back to Jingzhou, Guan Yu knew that Sun Quan had personally led the army to Jingzhou, and Jiangling, Gong'an, Yidu, and Yiling had all fallen into the hands of the Wu people, and the situation was very critical. At this time, the soldiers of Guan Yu's department had no intention of fighting because their wives and children were already under the control of the Wu army, and they fled in large numbers. Guan Yu saw that he was exhausted, and it was hopeless to attack Jingzhou immediately, so he went to Maicheng from Dangyang, wanting to reorganize his troops and horses in Maicheng and wait for rescue.

In addition to Guan Yu's own conceit, and his refusal to listen to the advice of Sima Wangfu at a critical moment, there is also the unfathomable providence in the universe. Guan Yu's defeat and Jingzhou's loss contributed to the pattern of the Three Kingdoms, and also achieved the spirit of loyalty and righteousness about Guan Yu's righteousness and fame. Guan Yu's objective factors for defeating Maicheng, his carelessness and conceit in refusing to admonish are the external reasons for the defeat.