Is the real Zhuge Liang as powerful as in Romance of the Three Kingdoms ?

Updated on culture 2024-02-09
9 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is said that after Zhuge Liang followed Liu Bei out of the mountain, Liu Bei treated Zhuge Liang with the courtesy of a teacher, and also appointed him as a military advisor. Later, Cao Cao's army went south to conquer Jingzhou, and Zhuge Liang commanded Liu Bei's army for the first time to achieve the victory of "burning Bowangpo", and then won the victory of "burning Xinye". Unfortunately, this is not the case at all in history.

    After Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain, there is no record in the history books that Liu Bei appointed him as a military advisor. In fact, there were no such positions in the army at that time. Liu Bei is stationed in Xinye, and he is still sending people under the fence, how can he give Zhuge Liang what kind of official position?

    Zhuge Liang really began to have a position, it was after the Red Cliff War, Liu Bei gradually seized some territory in Jingzhou, and after he became the pastor of Jingzhou, he appointed Zhuge Liang as a "military general". Before that, he had no position at all, and it was impossible for him to command Liu Bei's army, let alone "burn Bowangpo" and "burn Xinye".

    According to historical records, even for 10 years after the Battle of Chibi, Zhuge Liang never commanded a single battle or led any army. The reason why Zhuge Liang is great is not that he was entrusted with a heavy task at the beginning, and then it was smooth sailing and good news was spread. On the contrary, for more than ten years after that, he has been engaged in some inconspicuous grassroots work, and has done it well, using his excellent work to win the respect of Liu Bei and everyone, and finally assumed the important position of prime minister of Shu.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    No, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms just deified the tasks and made the characters reach the level of perfection.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhuge Liang is indeed deified, and the real Zhuge is not what people say in legends. For specific "deeds", you can refer to Mr. Han Qing's article "Zhuge Liang of the Power of the Government and the Opposition" (not selling advertisements, just providing you with a famous opinion).

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    No, Luo Guanzhong deified him. What kind of empty city plan, the straw boat borrowed arrows, and the three qi Zhou Yu, all of which are fictional.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    No, it's just a myth of history.

    He's just a politician.

    And it is said that Cao Cao used the empty city plan, but Zhuge Liang did not use it.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a long story written according to historical documents (such as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, etc.),**Focus on the shaping of characters, people's thinking may be very peculiar, it is always necessary to reflect a superman, like many fantasy today**, the protagonist is always invincible.

    Many of Zhuge Liang's storylines were not completed by him personally in history, but focused the advantages of many characters on him alone, so as to highlight the character image even more.

    The author may have his own deeper meaning and ideals in **, how can future generations know?

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    No, Luo, he deified.

    But in "Lost Street", Kong Ming shed tears, which also shows that Kong Ming is a person, not a god.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    There are a lot of this kind of stuff on the Internet, and I don't have time to find it for you slowly, anyway, Zhuge Liang is deified, and if you have time, you can read "Three Kingdoms", and if you don't have time, you can search on the Internet, and there will be a lot of articles scolding him.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    No, people deified him.

Related questions
6 answers2024-02-09

Liu Bei borrowed Jingzhou--- but did not repay it.

24 answers2024-02-09

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there are several characters who have been specifically described, saying that they are handsome, white-robed generals, Zhao Yun. >>>More

27 answers2024-02-09

Hehe, in fact, the landlord just wants to see how these people are scrambling to get the reward points, they all look like they understand very well, it's really ridiculous, how can the landlord not know such a simple question? Look at these people in a hurry.,Someone actually gave a long lesson to the landlord.,I really want to ask that buddy: You,How much is a pound?

3 answers2024-02-09

Romance of the Three Kingdoms author Luo Guanzhong How did he complete this book.

9 answers2024-02-09

For us as descendants, the history of the Three Kingdoms mainly comes from historical records such as the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", although there are personal opinions of historians, but they are generally viewed from an objective perspective. And "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written by Luo Guanzhong, a native of the Ming Dynasty. If you look at "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", you will find that it is completely praising Liu and degrading Cao, although Wei was the strongest during the Three Kingdoms period, but in traditional Chinese feudal thought, it supports Liu Han orthodoxy, so Liu Bei, as the royal family of Liu Han, has been portrayed very positively in the book. >>>More