Why did Ning Yuan only behead more than 200 people, what level of combat effectiveness is this?

Updated on international 2024-02-21
31 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The Ningyuan victory was part of the Ming and Qing wars, and the Ningyuan victory was not a major battle, but it had a great impact on the Ming Dynasty. Because it is not a major battle in terms of the number of deaths, but it is a very important battle in terms of its impact on the government. The Great Victory of Ningyuan was a battle between the Ming Dynasty and the Later Jin Dynasty in the first month of the sixth year of the Apocalypse (1626), the Ming army was victorious, and the Later Jin army was defeated, which was also the first time that the Ming army defeated the Later Jin army.

    In the Battle of Ningyuan, the Ming army won in the main battlefield - Ningyuan City, and lost in the sub-battlefield - Juehua Island, but in general the victory was the main one, so the Ming Dynasty called this victory "Ningyuan Great Victory". After Ningyuan's victory, Jin lost 17,000 troops.

    The Battle of Ningyuan took place in the sixth year of the Apocalypse, the last second emperor of the Ming Dynasty. At that time, the Later Jin (later known as the Manchu Qing) forces rose in Liaodong, unified the Jurchen people, and began to attack the Ming Dynasty, successively winning the great battles of Fushun, Qingshuibao, Liaoshen, Guangning, etc., singing triumphant songs all the way. The Ming Dynasty sent Sun Chengzong, the teacher of the Emperor of the Apocalypse, to supervise Ji Liao, which was also quite effective, so that Hou Jin did not dare to commit it again.

    However, Sun Chengzong was attacked by the eunuchs of the imperial court and was removed from his post. In place of Sun Chengzong was Wei Zhongxian's henchman Gao Di.

    The Ming and Qing wars were a brutal war of the replacement of dynasties, so the battle was very fierce in this war, but the Ming army occupied the home advantage, was very brave in the battlefield, and the battle situation was very clearHe only lost more than 200 people, which is not only the reason for the home field advantage, it can be regarded as a level gap in the war, but also a very different difference in soldiers, gradually showing the difference between countries.

    The history of the Ming Dynasty is very complicated, especially in the late Ming Dynasty, when the party struggle in the imperial court was fierce, and the battles at the border pass seemed to be inextricably linked with the government and government. Commanded by Yuan Chonghuan, the historical background of the Ming army's first victory over the Houjin army is also the historical background of Ningyuan's victory.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    This kind of combat effectiveness is average, but the Ming Dynasty won a relatively good situation, so it was just an internal fight.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The victory and significance of the battle cannot be determined by how many people are killed, but more should be the meaning and impact of this war on people, because Yuan Chonghuan was more benevolent at that time, so many enemy troops surrendered.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Combat effectiveness cannot be determined according to the number of people killed, although Ning Yuan's victory was victorious, but the leader Yuan Chonghuan's personality is more benevolent, so he does not like to kill innocents indiscriminately, and most of the soldiers surrendered.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    The leader Yuan Chonghuan has a more benevolent personality, so he doesn't like to kill innocents indiscriminately, and only beheaded more than 200 people, also to stabilize the people's hearts.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Poof, just 200 people died and the stall was collected, it seems that the Houjin Army is really in vain.

    The death of 200 is fake, and the 500 written in history is also fake, but if you have a brain, you will not reply to the letter, and if you don't die a few thousand people, Nurhachi can easily withdraw from the army.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    We should pay more attention to the significance of Ning Yuan's victory, rather than how many people were killed, such combat effectiveness was also good in the Ming Dynasty, because their enemies were also very strong and terrifying.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    The team in the era of cold weapons was basically hand-to-hand combat, although the sickness was connected, but in fact, not many people died, and this number was also very large.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Ning Yuan beheaded 200 in a great victory, but because of his own mistakes, nearly 10,000 people on Juehua Island in the nearby defense area were wiped out.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    This beheading level 269 is not about the number of people who lost the Houjin, the number officially recognized by the Ming Dynasty is more than 17,000, and most of the wild histories record tens of thousands. The battle of Ningyuan was able to obtain the first rank, mainly because there was a breach in the city wall, and at the moment of crisis, Yuan Chonghuan took the lead in eliminating the enemy army and filling the gap; and the first rank obtained by Yuan Chonghuan when he sent a death squad to raid the position of Houjin Engineering Equipment at night; The Houjin offensive was extremely fierce and urgent, including two days of non-stop onslaught, but it was difficult for them to storm the city wall, and there were not many heads in this regard.

    There is also a very important point, because the Ming Dynasty army had a lot of bad habits of harming the country and the people during that period, Yuan Chonghuan really did not like the first-level meritorious service, so the later Ningjin victory and the defense of the capital (known as the Beijing Division victory after the Qing Dynasty) were agreed with the soldiers before the war that as long as they were victorious, they would be beheaded and captured. As for the historical subversion hype content about Yuan Chonghuan on the Internet, it actually has nothing to do with history, but is suspected of malicious rumors and slander.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Although Ning Yuan's victory was a big battle, Yuan Chonghuan only killed more than 200 people, which was also related to his own character, he was more benevolent and did not like to kill innocent people indiscriminately.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    It has to do with his own character, his own character will not kill innocents indiscriminately, and the beheading of more than 200 people may only be to preserve his victory in the war, and whether the war is won or not has nothing to do with how many people are killed.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Ningyuan's great victory refers to the combat intention of Jin's attack on Ningyuan after being defeated. Ming defended the golden attack and did not take Ningyuan City, which was a great victory with the situation at that time.

    But when Houjin retreated, he also came and went freely. It is impossible for the besieging side to just lose two hundred people, the problem is that people can retreat with the corpses, and the Ming army does not dare to pursue, otherwise it will become a field battle between the two armies.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Ning Yuan's victory is a story made up by Yuan Chenghuan himself! So then he was killed! More than 200 people are also called great victories.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    In the defense of the city, can you run out and grab the corpse of the enemy and cut off the head? Only 200 people died, and Nurhachi will retreat? It would be nice to be able to grab 200 heads. Hei Yuan's are all descendants of Mao Wenlong.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Ningyuan's victory was a big battle, but Yuan Chonghuan only beheaded more than 200 people because he was a kind commander and did not kill innocents indiscriminately.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Ning Yuan's victory does not need to be measured by the number of beheadings, and Yuan Chonghuan is also a Confucian general, he is not a person who is addicted to killing, it doesn't matter how many people are beheaded, the important thing is that the Ming Dynasty won.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    The number of beheadings is not equal to the actual number of enemy troops, and the number of enemies killed by the Ming Dynasty against Ning Yuan's victory is 17,000; In the wild history, it is tens of thousands or more than 10,000. The Battle of Ningyuan was mainly a defensive battle to defend the city, and only the people who attacked the city wall and left the whole body could let the Ming army get the head, which was one of them; the second is that a large number of Houjin's corpses were snatched back outside the city; The third is that Yuan Chonghuan has always been pragmatic, and he has always hated the drawbacks of cutting ranks during and after the war, so in several famous battles, there were many pre-war appointments, as long as the victory was won, the prisoners were not counted. These are clear in history!

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    How many people can be killed by a big iron egg with one shot? Two hundred people is good.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Two hundred enemies were killed, and hundreds of thousands of compatriots became alien slaves.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    As far as I know, the calculation method of beheading in the Ming Dynasty is different, looking at the head not the number of people killed, and if you can't bring it back, you won't be rewarded for killing 10,000 imperial courts.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    This is mainly because Yuan Chonghuan is more benevolent, after all, no one wants their hands to be covered with blood.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    This is because it has a lot to do with his character, how can a Confucian general kill on a large scale.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Yuan Chonghuan, the former soldier of Ning, according to the Guan Jin right grain tuntong sentenced Jin Qiliang to Zhaojin, right, and Dalinghe The three cities are all forwards, if the troops are collected and retreated, the people who are safe will be reinstated, and the restored frontier will be recaptured, and the Yuguan and other areas can retreat several times. Present the details to the Tao, and according to this. The art of war has advanced but not retreated, and the Jin and Right areas have set up troops to hide and unload grain, and the deployment of the official security has not guarded and withdrawn, which is absolutely unreasonable, and the enemy is weak when he moves, not only the east slave, that is, the west captives, but also the light of China.

    Then the 300,000 stone grains in Youtun "advanced but not retreated" and sent back gold in vain. Jin Qiliang, who was in charge of grain at the head of Ningyuan City, was shocked to death by his own cannon. Why didn't I get food, and there was no proof of death.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    The beheading of more than 200 people may also be just to protect their own victory in the war, and in order to appease the people, they cannot be killed indiscriminately.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Make a mistake, behead more than 2,000 people.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Because Yuan Dudu is Mr. Dongguo,

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Most of the corpses of the Tartars were recovered, after all, it was a defensive battle!

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    The so-called Ningyuan victory was actually just a political show, and the pragmatists defended by Wei Zhongxian believed that the Ningjin defense line was just a waste of the imperial court's food and salary, and the corrupt group dominated by the Donglin Party died in protecting the Ningjin defense line for the needs of corruption. When Gao Di issued the order to retreat, Yuan Chonghuan accepted the order of the Donglin Party and refused to retreat, but he was a straw bale and had no military ability at all, so he colluded with his old customer Houjin to resell military rations. It was to seize the grain and grass from Juehua Island in Youtun, which was supposed to be transported back to Guannai, and let Houjin rob it, and after Houjin, who spent two days gathering troops near Ningyuan, went south to Juehua Island to grab grain and grass and returned to the army, Ningyuan's great victory was brewed.

    The Donglin Party used this as a political bargaining chip to win the Ningjin strategy, and laid the foundation for hollowing out the treasury and corrupting grain and salary in the future.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    The real situation of Ning Yuan's victory is that Huang Taiji used all his troops to barely capture Ning Yuan, and it was at a heavy price.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    Yuan Chonghuan relied on the powerful firepower of the red-clothed cannon to carry out the bombardment condescendingly, which made Ning Yuan's great victory.

Related questions