Cao Cao has the grace of knowing Guan Yu, why does he still let Guan Yu guard Huarong Dao?

This was done by Zhuge Liang on purpose, taking advantage of Guan Yu's emphasis on love and righteousness, he knew that Guan Yu was likely to let Cao Cao go, but Cao Cao really couldn't die at that time.

The purpose of arranging Guan Yu to guard Huarong Dao was to deliberately let Cao Cao go, and it was precisely because Cao Cao had the grace of knowing Guan Yu that Cao Cao's suspicion and defensive spirit were reduced.

The purpose of letting Guan Yu guard Huarong Dao is to let Cao Cao go, although the camps are different, but for the sake of the overall situation, it is not suitable to kill Cao Cao at this time, and letting Guan Yu release Cao Cao can also reduce Cao Cao's vigilance.

This is deliberate by Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu attaches great importance to love and righteousness, and Cao Cao has the grace of knowing him, so he will definitely let Cao Cao go if he can't do it.

Because Zhuge Liang knew that Cao Cao had the grace of knowing Guan Yu, Guan Yu would let Cao Cao go, Liu Bei's forces were still quite weak during the Battle of Chibi, if Cao Cao died, the court would be in chaos, and Liu Bei would not be able to control it.

Because Cao Cao's soldiers were already seriously damaged, there were not many soldiers to follow him, such an important place, so it was handed over to Guan Yu.

Because Zhuge Liang's meaning is to let Guan Yu secretly let Cao Cao go after guarding Huarong Dao, instead of strictly guarding it, with the grace of knowing the encounter, he just let Cao Cao go and protect the peace of the world.

Before Guan Yu went to Huarong Dao, he made a military order, and the original text is as follows: Cao Cao Guo treated a certain person seriously, and a certain person had beheaded Yan Liang, punished Wen Chou, relieved the siege of the White Horse, and reported to him. If you bump into it today, you won't let it go!

Kong Ming said: "If you let it go, what will happen? Yun Chang said:

May it be according to military law! ”！

Zhuge Liang's purpose in arranging Guan Yu to guard Huarong Dao was to deliberately let Cao Cao go. Zhuge Liang believed that if Cao Cao was killed, it would definitely lead to chaos in the Northern Wei Dynasty.

After Guan Yu let go of Cao Cao, Zhuge Liang wanted to kill Guan Yu, Liu Bei begged hard (including the element of show), Zhuge Liang let Guan Yu go, no matter what, Zhuge Liang's resourcefulness is amazing, and the whole person is a set!

<> Guan Yu released Cao Cao in Huarong Dao, is this really to repay his kindness? Or is there another reason? After Guan Yu lost in Xuzhou, Liu Bei did not know where to go, Guan Yu took two sisters-in-law to be surrounded by Cao Cao, during this time Cao Cao's courtesy to him he did not have in Liu Bei, out of Cao Cao's camp through five passes and six generals Cao Cao sacrificed his generals to protect Guan Yu, to a certain extent, Cao Cao to Guan Yu is appreciation, has exceeded the interests of the two armies, expressing personal feelings, is a hero to another hero's sympathy.

People are not plants and trees, who can be ruthless. Cao Cao's heart for Guan Yu, how could Guan Yu forget. Even if he is in Liu Bei's place, there should be a piece of warmth in his heart.

This is a normal reaction of human nature. Therefore, Guan Yu released Cao Cao on Huarong Road, even if he made a military order, in the face of Cao Cao's human nature recovery, he let him go.

After his defeat and death, his soul drifted to Yuquan Mountain to call himself the Marquis of Hanting instead of calling himself the Five Tiger Generals of Shuzhong. It is spiritually belonging to Cao Cao, and Cao Cao thinks that Cao Cao has a good eye for heroes. This title was won by Cao Cao when he was at Cao Cao's place.

In Xishu, he was only named the Five Tiger Generals, and he was dissatisfied with this title from the psychology and would not mention it, that is, when Jing Fan was in Jingfan, he was already dissatisfied with Shu. His inner destination is Cao Wei. And he was named the General of the Five Tigers, and Shu was dissatisfied with him and dissatisfied with his Huarong Dao for letting Cao Cao go.

Zhuge Liang arranged for him to guard Huarong Dao, which was also a test of his heart and loyalty to Shu. From this, it can be seen that he was left in Jingzhou when Liu Bei Zhuge Liang entered Xichuan, and there was a dispensable place, which was abandoned because of his lack of loyalty, and he would still let Cao Cao go in the future in the battle with Cao Cao. His subordinates also felt that he was not used by Xishu and treated him lazily.

Guan Yu's loyalty is beyond doubt. There is Bole, and then there is Maxima. If Guan Yu is a maxima, then Liu Bei and Cao Cao are Guan Yu's Bole.

For Liu Bei to withdraw Guan Yu's loyalty, then for Cao Cao, Guan Yu's righteousness is reflected. Guan Yu is also a person who is both civil and military. In the face of major rights and wrongs, Guan Yu chose to focus on the overall situation.

Huarong Dao let Cao Cao go, in order to repay Cao Cao's kindness. For the sake of the overall situation, the Three Kingdoms are the masters. Zhuge Liang's arrangement allowed Guan Yu to kill two birds with one stone.

But the biggest beneficiary is Zhuge Liang. A military order made Guan Yu swear to obey Zhuge Liang from now on. I owe Zhuge Liang a great favor.

Since then, Guan Yu's wisdom has been achieved!

It's not entirely to repay the favor, there are other reasons, because if Cao Cao is killed at that time, it may cause the north to become unstable, so Cao Cao must be left to maintain the stability of the north and Liu Bei's status.

Yes, I think it's just to repay the favor, and there is no other reason to see that this person is also a particularly affectionate person in history.

Guan Yu is a person who values love and righteousness, Cao Cao once had a favor to Guan Yu, Guan Yu couldn't bear to kill Cao Cao, so letting him go was simply to repay his kindness.

Because he remembered Cao Cao's lenient treatment of him, and Cao Cao also admired his talent very much, he was indeed to repay the favor, because this kindness was very important to him.

Answer: Not only to repay the gratitude, but also Guan Yu's heart is still influenced by the idea of loyalty, so he made such a move.

Let Guan Yu guard the first layer of Huarong Road, which means to let Guan Yu let Cao Cao live in order to repay the kindness of the previous support. There is also a layer of waiting for Guan Yu to come back and give Guan Yu a dismount. Guan Yu had always been dissatisfied with Zhuge Liang before. It's three birds with one stone, maybe there is a deeper meaning later, so let's study it slowly.

It was because Zhuge Liang wanted Liu Guanzhang and the others to owe him a great favor, so he sent Guan Yu to guard Huarong Dao, and Zhuge Liang's plan was very successful.

This is because Zhuge Liang didn't want to kill Cao Cao at that time, and he also knew that Guan Yu was very affectionate and righteous, and he would definitely let Cao Cao go, so he sent him.

Because Zhuge Liang thought that Cao Cao could not die at that time, and Zhuge Liang knew Guan Yu's temperament, he would let him guard Huarong Dao.

It was Zhuge Liang who wanted to send a favor to Guan Yu to buy Guan Yu, because Guan Yu was always a little unconvinced by Zhuge Liang, so Zhuge Liang used this trick to convince Guan Yu from then on.

Because Zhuge Liang knew that Cao Cao was still in a state of flux at this time, and his strength was very strong, he could not be killed at this time, and if he was killed, his soldiers would inevitably retaliate.

Because Zhuge Liang wanted Guan Yu to return Cao Cao's favor, which would be beneficial to the future conquest of the world, Zhuge Liang also asked Cao Cao to guard Huarong Dao.

Zhuge Liang knew that Guan Yu would let Cao Cao go, because he felt that Cao Cao should not die at this time, and if he died, it would definitely cause his son's revenge.

The main reason is that Cao Cao cannot die. If he died, he would have no power to restrain Sun Quan. Cao Cao's defeat and remaining forces were bound to plunge the north into chaos.

Cao Cao's soldiers were defeated. Although he lost his army and generals, the foundations of the north remained, and his power was definitely the strongest among the governors. Cao Cao already had four states in the north and half a country.

The north is rich in products and has a large number of people. He went through all the dynasties. There are also unknowns.

Wu Dong's Sun Quan is not the same. Be it cities, armies, money, food, population, taxes, etc. Cao Wei is the most powerful, several times, or even dozens of times stronger than Sun Liu.

If Cao Cao is killed, the north will fall into chaos, and there will even be another scuffle between the princes. Liu Bei's power was also the weakest of all the princes. When the north fell into chaos, Liu Bei would naturally be helpless, so Cao Cao could not die for the stability of the world.

The north may have stabilized, so Cao Cao retained his powerStop Sun Quan from using the Northern Expedition to control the world. Thus eliminating the possibility of being annexed by Soochow. Later, he adhered to the strategy of resisting Wei and Wu, and waited for the Northern Expedition in the later period.

Since it is impossible to kill Cao Cao, why not let Guan Yu garrison Huarong Dao, so that Guan Yu's reputation for integrity can be achieved, and he can be good to Cao Cao? In this way, Cao Cao could concentrate on attacking Eastern Wu, and Liu Bei's development would be smoother.

Cao Cao was an important force in defending the rebellion in the north and containing Sun Quan. Liu Bei was weak, and Cao Cao was dead。Sun Quan's first killer must be Liu Bei.

The Sun-Liu Alliance will cease to exist. It would be beneficial to release Cao Cao's restraining power. The second is that Guan Yu has never seen Zhuge Liang.

The previous used car was occupied by Zhuge Liang. The proud Guan Yu didn't look at Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang took this opportunity to make Guan Yu confess.

Because the reason for this was to let Guan Yu and Cao Cao sever their relations, which would also be conducive to the struggle and development of the two sides in the future.

Because Cao Cao can't die, if he dies, he won't have the strength to restrain Sun Quan. Cao Cao's army was defeated, but his strength still existed, and the killing of Cao Cao would inevitably plunge the north into chaos.

Because Zhuge Liang did this because Guan Yu owed him a favor, and also to not kill Cao Cao directly.

At this time, Cao Cao couldn't die, and Sun Quan couldn't see that he intended to let Cao Cao go. In this situation, Guan Yu, who is benevolent, righteous and emotional, has become the best choice to take the blame.

knew that Guan Yu would let Cao Cao go, and let him Shouhua Rongdao explain that Zhuge Liang allowed Guan Yu to let Cao Cao go.

1, caused by the Mandate of Heaven, 2, Grace and righteousness.

3. Game advantage.

So I chose to let him guard Huarong Dao.