In the battle of Dingjun Mountain, if Xiahou Yuan concentrated his forces against Liu Bei, would he

A good general uses soldiers, and if a good doctor treats a disease, the disease will change and the medicine will also change. ”

The descriptions of the Battle of Dingjun Mountain, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" are different. According to your description, it should be a quote from the battle examples of the "Three Kingdoms".

In the era of cold weapons, the death of the main general was very accidental, so we can't ** Xiahou Yuan's fate. But I personally think that the battle of Dingjun Mountain was defeated by Xiahou Yuan, and Dingjun Mountain could not be defended.

At that time, the most likely strategy should be to withdraw from Dingjun Mountain, get closer to Zhang He, Xu Huang, Guo Huai and other troops, rely on each other, and choose key terrain to hold on to wait for reinforcements.

In the battle of Hanzhong, Cao Wei guarded very tenaciously and had completed the task excellently.

Cao Wei did not receive assistance from the rear in the defensive battle of Hanzhong, and held out for more than a year with a lone army against the troops of the whole country of Western Shu. Moreover, he has achieved many results, and has successively annihilated the troops of Wu Lan, Lei Tong, and Chen Shi of the Shu Army.

Under Zhuge Liang's planning, Xishu sent a steady stream of reinforcements and supplies to the front line. It effectively guaranteed the soldiers and morale. Cao Wei's army became a tired soldier, and the soldiers could not be replenished.

In the battle of Dingjun Mountain, when the Shu army opened a gap in the defense line of Zhanghe, the stalemate was broken. At this time, Cao Wei's defeat was decided, no matter whether Xiahou Yuan divided his troops to aid Zhang He or not, I personally thought it was no longer important.

Cao Cao's strategy towards Hanzhong was too conservative.

After Cao Cao occupied Hanzhong, everyone persuaded Cao Cao to attack Yizhou while Liu Bei's foothold in Western Shu was not stable. For this reason, Cao Cao sighed with emotion: "People are bitter and worthless, and they have Long, and they look back at Shuye? "Leaving Xiahou Yuan to guard Hanzhong, he led the troops back to the court.

I can't do anything about why Cao Cao didn't attack Shu, he should have his own reasons. But leaving a lone army to defend Hanzhong, without reinforcements for more than a year, is too much to say. Maybe he overestimated Xiahou Yuan's ability, or maybe he underestimated Xishu's determination, I don't think it should be.

You must know that Hanzhong is the gateway to Xishu, and it is foreseeable that if you block the door of people's homes and sharpen their knives, they will fight hard with you. And no matter how strong Xiahou Yuan's ability is, if he favors the enemy country, it should only be a matter of time before he fails.

Xiahou Yuan may not die in battle, but he will inevitably suffer heavy losses in his troops. In the Battle of Dingjun Mountain, Xiahou Yuan will fight all his troops against Liu Bei, so Zhang He's troops sent by Xiahou Yuan will inevitably be defeated by Liu Bei. Zhang He and Xiahou Yuan are fighting each other, one side loses, and the other side will be difficult to retreat.

Then he should not have died in battle, because his concentration of troops at that time was also very powerful.

It shouldn't be, because if you fight Liu Bei, you will have a chance to break out of the encirclement, and you won't die in battle.

The death of the folk Xiahou Yuan must be said separately, in history, Xiahou Yuan was the person in charge of Cao Cao's subordinates, and he can basically be said to be the leader of the Western Front. When he died, he was a general of Zhengxi. At that time, Cao Ren, the general of Zhengnan, was in charge of the southern front.

The Eastern Front was the governor of the army as Xiahoudun. Xiahou Yuan said that he was one of the commanders of Wei's three major armies, and there was no problem. There were indeed many generals who died on the battlefield during the Three Kingdoms period.

Yan Liangwenchou, Zhang He, Guo Yuan, etc. But what about the commander-in-chief of the army who died at the forefront?

In the history of the Three Kingdoms, he died directly at the front line, and Xiahou Yuan was definitely the biggest card and one of the biggest cases involved. Cao Cao went to Chang'an to operate remotely. Xiahou Yuan and Liu Bei dated for a year.

Liu Bei passed the water of the resolution and set up a village in the army. Xiahou Yuan and Zhang fought together. The two sides will be close.

Liu Bei burned Cao Jun's antlers at night. Zhang Shoudong, Xiahou Yuan Shounan. Liu Bei attacked Zhang He, but Zhang He couldn't do it.

Xiahou Yuan gave half of his troops to Zhang He. Fa Zheng concluded that he could attack at the right time, and Liu Bei let Huang Zhong attack and kill Xiahou Yuan in formation.

After the battle of Hanzhong, after a long time, the initiative belonged to Liu Bei, not a son-in-law. Historically, Huang Zhong was promoted to the rank of general in this battle, alongside Guan, Zhang, and Ma. The credit was so great that Guan Yu complained.

Such a terrible feat. There is a saying that Zhuge Liang's "Later Teacher's Table" is a forgery. Xiahou Yuan was killed, deeply shocked Cao Cao, made it public, and made Cao Cao very sad, Hou Yuan was Cao Cao's general of Zhengxi, and the general of Zhengxi was in the Han Dynasty in the Han Dynasty in the Han State of Wu (Shu) Although there was no big problem.

But in the Wei State, he was a general like a cow, and his rank and authority were similar to those of the commander of the theater. Cao Cao's "Three Expeditions" general is permanent, high and powerful, not a good friend's henchman, a capable general, can not be appointed, Cao Cao and the Xiahou family are one, Cao Cao's surname is Xiahou, Xiahou Yuan's brother Xiahou is very important to Cao Cao, it is said that the former general who was appointed as the former general is the former general of the Quartet Generals. The relationship between Cao Cao and Xiahou Yuan is like the relationship between Liu Bang and Fan Xu, not only a brother-in-law but also a good brother, the two grew up with urine when they were young.

In the battle of Dingjun Mountain, Liu Bei led more than 10,000 elite troops, because Zhang He was not Liu Bei's opponent, so he divided half of the army to rescue, in this case, if he did not divide the troops to rescue Zhang He, Zhang He's army would be defeated, his own combat strength was damaged, and he lost the possibility of destroying You Pei to win the victory. In addition, Huang Zhongzhi's ability to kill Xiahou Yuan was also because he was too careless, that is, even if he dispersed his forces, he was not afraid of the other party at all.

Some people say that if Xiahou Yuan does not rescue Zhang He and concentrates his forces to attack Liu Bei, he may be victorious, but there is a certain risk in this, if Zhang He is destroyed, he will not be able to defeat Liu Bei, and when Liu Bei combines the two forces in one place, it will be his end, on the surface it is a way to injure the enemy by one thousand and lose eight hundred, but because Liu Bei preemptively, Xiahou Yuan has fallen into passivity, and in this case, it is the best policy to use troops safely.

The reason why Huang Mo was able to kill Xiahou Yuan was because of his geographical and psychological advantages, in terms of force, Xiahou Yuan was not weaker than Huang Zhong at all, or Fa Zheng gave Liu Bei advice to take advantage of his antlers to lure Xiahou Yuan out, because he knew that it was the veteran Huang Zhong who was fighting against him, and he didn't expect him to rush over directly, so when the other party never responded, Xiahou Yuan began to relax and slack, and it was at this time that Huang Zhong suddenly hit him by surprise, In this case, even Xiahou Yuan's troops began to disperse, and he did not dare to fight directly, both psychologically and physically, he fell into a disadvantage, and this strategy was also used to deal with Ma Chao, at that time Liu Bei knew that Zhang Fei was not Ma Chao's opponent, so he let Ma Chao fight for half a day.

From a strategic point of view, Xiahou Yuan did not make a mistake, but he fell into a disadvantage in some details, because he was too confident in his own strength, he fell into the trap of the enemy step by step, so if he did not send troops to rescue Zhang He, he would definitely not die, but this war also lost the hope of victory.

There is no chance, because his troops are not as good as Liu Bei, and the fierce generals and military divisions on Liu Bei's side are stronger than him, even if he concentrates his troops, he will lose.

I don't think there's a chance. Mainly because Liu Bei has Zhuge Liang by his side, Zhuge Liang will give him advice. Let the former have no chance.

I think if she had concentrated on preparing for Liu Bei at that time, he would still have a chance to win, after all, the difference between them is not particularly big.

Liu Bei's army defeated Cao Cao's army in the battle of Dingjun Mountain in Hanzhong, and Huang Zhong beheaded Cao Cao's brother Xiahou Yuan, which should have been a great joy, but Liu Bei was not happy. Liu Ranran had basically not won the battle against Cao Cao before. This time, Huang Zhong killed Xiahou Yuan in Dingjun Mountain, which can be said to have helped him out of a bad breath, so Liu Bei was overjoyed at first, but soon Liu Bei lost his face, and he asked why it was not Zhang He who was killed, but only Xiahou Yuan, you must know that Xiahou Yuan is the main general of the Cao Wei group guarding Hanzhong, and Zhang He is only the deputy general of the reinforcements.

Liu Bei has the ability to recognize people, even above Zhuge Liang. Compared with Xiahou Yuan and Zhang He, although the force value is about the same, if you want to talk about wisdom, Xiahou Yuan is too far behind. Liu Bei sighed that he killed Xiahou Yuan this time, but Zhang He, who was more powerful than him, became a frightened bird, how easy is it to kill Zhang He?

Just like Liu Bei's **, after Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Liang's first 4 northern expeditions to Qishan, his main opponent was Zhang He, Zhang He was like a mountain of Cao Wei's group in front of Zhuge Liang, causing Zhuge Liang's army to be defeated repeatedly.

This time in the battle of Dingjun Mountain, it was not expected that Huang Zhong could kill Xiahou Yuan. Huang Zhong just lit a fire on the periphery of Xiahou Yuan's army and burned down the military facilities on its periphery, Xiahou Yuan made a mistake in decision-making, and led hundreds of people away from the camp to run over to fight the fire, Fa Zheng urged Huang Zhong to attack decisively, who would have thought that there was Xiahou Yuan this marshal among these hundreds of people. Xiahou Yuan was directly wrapped in dumplings, and his head fell to the ground.

And Zhang He, who posed the greatest threat to the Shu Han regime in Hanzhong, was not harmed in the slightest.

Xiahou Yuan is Cao Cao's close relative, and Shu Han has now formed a bond with Cao Cao by killing Xiahou Yuan. After Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, Cao Cao deigned to curry favor with Sun Quan, whom he despised, and jointly dealt with the Shu Han regime, for this reason, Liu Bei suffered a lot for this. Zhang He is very clever in fighting, he will eat you if he fights, and he will run away if he can't fight.

Liu Bei said that there was another meaning, and warned his soldiers that Xiahou Yuan was just a weak chicken, and the tough battle was still to come, and Zhang He was the main target.