Is the failure of Longzhong Pair to be realized by Zhuge Liang s miscalculation or another reason?

The steps that are not implemented in Longzhong Pair are the third step. Its strategic policy is: when the time comes, diplomatically ally ally with Sun Quan, and militarily, on the one hand, the Jingzhou soldiers will attack the Wanluo direction, and on the other hand, the Western Shu troops will attack the Qinchuan direction on the flank, so as to achieve the goal of seizing the world.

There are many reasons why it has not been realized, after all, Sun Quan is not a fool, the Three Kingdoms are fighting for hegemony, and Shu Han and Eastern Wu are also confrontational. Zhuge Liang looked down on Dongwu too much.

Longzhong's strategic thinking is not wrong, and the reason why Longzhong's right was not realized in the end was because Guan Yu lost Jingzhou, and Liu Bei led the army to attack Wu and lost a large amount of national strength and soldiers, resulting in the failure to realize.

In fact, there was another reason, Zhuge Liang did not expect that Liu Bei would insist on going his own way, and did not listen to the dissuasion to defeat the Eastern Wu in the end.

Longzhong seems to be wrong for itself?

Zhuge Liang said that it was very beautiful, but Zhuge Liang did not explain two points. 1 Zhuge Liang said that the world has changed, so he will send an admiral. So the question is, has the world not changed? What to do? Cao Cao was politically correct, militarily strong, and had a high tolerance for error.

One meaning is that the situation is miscalculated. In Zhuge 's mind, Liu Bei occupies most of Gyeongju, Liu Bei's lord Sun Quan is a guest, and Liu Bei can only rely on Sun Quan, and there is no capital to oppose. But it backfired, and the actual Sun Quan was Zhu Youfei was a guest.

His prediction didn't work at all. Longzhong only succeeded in the Yizhou part, and right and wrong are unusual.

According to Zhuge Liang's design, he occupied Gyeongju Yiju and stayed there. Waiting for the world to change. Unchanged, 2 back, won the game. For Sun Quan, the biggest threat is not Liu Bei, but Liu Bei.

If you want to cooperate with Sun Quan, you must at least take a knife from Sun Quan's neck and give in. According to the wisdom of Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei, these two points cannot be thought of, but there is no record in the history books, which is really incomprehensible.

Some people think that Longzhong is a wrong national policy for itself, you see? One meaning is that the situation is miscalculated. In Zhuge 's mind, Liu Bei occupies most of Gyeongju, Liu Bei's lord Sun Quan is a guest, and Liu Bei can only rely on Sun Quan, and there is no capital to oppose.

But it backfired, and the actual Sun Quan was Zhu Youfei was a guest. His prediction didn't work at all. Longzhong only succeeded in the Yizhou part, and right and wrong are unusual.

First, Zhuge Liang went to Liu Bei's company for an interview at that time, and he didn't have much experience when he worked in a different place before. In addition, Zhuge left room for himself, and did not say that the hegemony would definitely be realized, nor did Han Shi say that he would definitely prosper.

In addition, the changes in the world are not said to have been seen before Liu Bei's death. With Sun Quan as a rubber ball, he forgot that Sun Quan also had the capital to surrender if he surrendered. The Southern Expedition is Jiangdong, and the importance of the Southern Expedition is very important to the three families, which does not take Sun Wukong seriously.

Another meaning is that the situation is miscalculated. In Zhuge 's mind, Liu Bei occupies most of Gyeongju, Liu Bei's lord Sun Quan is a guest, and Liu Bei can only rely on Sun Quan, and there is no capital to oppose. But it backfired, and the actual Sun Quan was Zhu Youfei was a guest.

His prediction didn't work at all. Longzhong only succeeded in the Yizhou part, and right and wrong are unusual.

No. Longzhong is Zhuge Liang's half-life hard work, which is reasonable, but Liu Bei lost Jingzhou because of carelessness, which finally led to the failure of the strategy.

Of course not, Zhuge Liang is a very smart person, so Liu Bei valued him so much, and he decided to go out of the mountain after three visits to the thatched house, so I think it was well thought out.

The prospect of Longzhong is not perfect, and it cannot be said that it is wrong. Liu Bei went from having no people to send people under the fence to dominating Bashu and Sun Quan and Cao Cao, all in the analysis and planning of Zhuge Liang in "Longzhong Pair", and Liu Bei, the main person who failed to recover the Han Dynasty, died too early, and his son Liu Chan did not have the ability and desire to recover the Han Dynasty, even if Zhuge Liang died of exhaustion, it was useless.

There is a mistake in this, but it is not true, there are many places where the understanding and translation of ancient and modern texts are different, but in fact, it is correct to understand according to the ancient meaning before.

I think there is indeed a certain mistake, Zhuge Liang is too beautifying the situation outside. He didn't personally experience the real difficulties outside, so he boasted about Haikou.

It's fake. Longzhong is Zhuge Liang's contribution to the future development of the world, and Liu Bei did what Zhuge Liang said, so he had three points of the world's capital. The person who said that there was something wrong, I don't think he was smarter than Zhuge Liang.

No, the correct ideas of "Longzhong Pair" accounted for half, and the wrong strategy also accounted for half, so that the Shu Han regime succeeded half.

It's not a strategic mistake, Longzhong is an absolute for the ages, when Zhuge Liang has not yet come out of the mountain, he can gain insight into the situation in the world, and in a word, it can be seen that he is very wise.

It is not a strategic mistake, Longzhong is correct in his thinking, because he has already taken into account the strength comparison of the three forces, and analyzed what the future trend of Liu Bei's soldiers and horses will be.

Longzhong was not only strategic, but also the only feasible strategic policy of Liu Bei Group at that time, which could be said to be tailor-made for Liu Bei at that time. If Longzhong can be well executed, Uncle Liu Huang has the pattern and strength of his grandfather Liu Bang, and Guan Yu does not take the enemy lightly, Liu Bei Group has a chance to win, although to a large extent, it is necessary to wait for the trick and wait for the Cao Wei Group to make a mistake.

Longzhong's strategy of occupying Jingyi against China was not wrong, although occupying Jingyi did not guarantee that Liu Bei's group would gain the world. At that time, in terms of Liu Bei's fundamentals, Cao Cao in the north could not be provoked, and there was no possibility of grabbing territory from Cao Cao, and the princes were basically cleaned up by Cao Cao, and the Sun family in the east was not easy to provoke, and there was no land to occupy if Jingyi was not occupied.

The problem is the timing of the attack. Longzhong's words are clearly written"Externally knot Sun Quan, internal political management; If there is a change in the world, he ordered a general to lead the army of Jingzhou to Xiang Wan, Luo, and the general to lead the people of Yizhou out of Qinchuan. "said that it was until there was a change in the world (that is, there were internal problems in Cao Wei), and now Cao Wei is fine, Cao Cao is not dead, although he was defeated in Hanzhong, but the overall strength still has a great advantage, and it is not time for a strategic offensive at all.

There are also those who have been bumping in the relationship with Sun Quan's group since the Battle of Da Chibi, and if Sun Quan is not stable, he will attack a behemoth like Cao Wei and die. After the Battle of Yiling, it was basically doomed.

It can be seen from the above that Longzhong's pair is completely deformed after half of the execution. Of course, Longzhong has many problems, such as Liu Bei can't control Guan Yu, Jingzhou and Yizhou are too far apart, and the two attacks can't cooperate with each other. It is impossible for Sun Quan to give up Jingzhou and so on.

But you can't say that Zhuge Liang was talking on paper, because this was the only viable option for Liu Bei at that time. Some places may be modified, such as forming a good alliance with Sun Quan as much as possible, giving Sun Quan the four counties of Jingnan and some places with no strategic value, promising to give the entire part of Jingzhou to Sun Quan after attacking the Central Plains, or simply forming a coalition with Sun Quan's side to attack all the way. Those who achieve great things must have extraordinary tools, and Liu Bei's tools are far inferior to Liu Bang's.

Of course, these measures still cannot guarantee that Sun Quan will not turn against water. <>

Then you can only guard your own territory first, rest and wait for changes. Make sure you don't make mistakes on your side first, and wait for the other party to make mistakes. For example, Cao Pi made a stupid move to lead the army to collapse the river and attack both sides of Sun Quan's side, and Liu Bei's side hurriedly mobilized.

On the one hand, Jingzhou desperately showed favor to Sun Quan, sent money and grain, and even promised to cede part of Jingzhou's land after the war, just to support Sun Quan not to make peace with Cao Wei, on the other hand, to find a way to eat Liangzhou in the Han Dynasty, Jingzhou invaded Nanyang to find a way to occupy Jingbei, but to avoid a strategic decisive battle with Cao Wei, and narrow the gap with Cao Wei little by little. Anyway, it is necessary to cooperate with Sun Quan to consume Cao Wei as much as possible, and not give Cao Wei time to recuperate.

First of all, everyone knows that Zhuge Liang belongs to a very wise person, so his cage is very worthy of everyone's reference, after all, he has experienced more things and read more books, so he is very knowledgeable.

In Zhuge Liang's Longzhong pair, it can be seen that Zhuge Liang is not at ease with Adou, gives him advice, and also helps him analyze the environment at that time.

"Longzhong Pair" analyzed the situation in the world for Liu Bei and formulated the general strategy of the Shu Han camp, and then Zhuge Liang went out of the mountain to become Liu Bei's military advisor, taking Jingzhou and Yizhou into a peak trend.

I think this is Zhuge Liang's view of the world, because he also had certain resources in the court at that time.

Personally, I think Zhuge Liang's Longzhong pair has actually shown his ambitions and ambitions. Since ancient times, smart people have liked to express their ambitions implicitly, but they also want to use their talents.

It is a very clever strategic plan, but it does not consider everything comprehensively and ignores Soochow.