Xu Shu, who didn t give Cao Cao advice, did the final ending be good?

Because Xu Shu was very dissatisfied with Cao Cao's blackmailing of himself, and felt very ashamed of Liu Bei in his heart, he refused to give Cao Cao advice, but Cao Cao didn't care about winning people's hearts.

The ending was that Xu Shu did nothing after arriving in Wei and lived a quiet life. He began to follow Liu Bei, but Cao Cao took his mother hostage and forced Xu Shu to join Cao, so Xu Shu was reluctant to give Cao advice.

At that time, Xu Shu was very talented, and he did not give Cao Cao a strategy against Liu Bei, but he was always reused by Cao Cao, and the ending was better.

It's good, he was not killed by Cao Cao in the end, but chose to go into hiding, away from the war, and lived a very ordinary life.

Mention "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Presumably everyone is familiar with it, and when it comes to Xu Shu.

Everyone may be confused, especially whether he will give advice after entering Cao Ying. So did he offer a plan at all? In fact, after he entered the Cao camp, he was Cao Cao.

He has offered two schemes. <>

We all know that Xu Shu is not only resourceful and familiar with the art of war in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", but also has a hand in the way of using soldiers. In fact, the lord that Xu Shu was loyal to at the beginning was actually Liu Bei.

He won many great achievements for Liu Bei when he was just starting out, and was later selected by Cao Cao because of his outstanding talent. <>

In order to make Xu Shu use it for himself, Cao Cao designed to kidnap his mother, that is, the Xu family, and later learned that his mother was kidnapped by Cao Cao, and Xu Shu had to choose to leave Liu Bei and enter Cao's camp for the safety of his mother. However, when Xu learned that Xu Shu entered Cao Ying alone for her own safety, she chose to hang herself because she didn't want to affect her son. Later, it was speculated that although Xu Shu still remained in Cao's camp, he did not offer a plan for Cao Cao because of his mother's death.

However, from the two historical events, it can be clearly found that in fact, Xu Shu still offered two schemes for Cao Cao. One of them is burning Chibi.

At that time, Xu Shu knew Pang Tong.

planned but did not demolish him, but took advantage of this opportunity to take the initiative to ask Cao Cao for help, wanting to go to the town to guard. Second, from "the first year of Yankang, Xu Shu took Xu Fu."

The name is included in Cao Pi.

We can also know that Xu Shu was very actively involved in the "persuasion" at that time, but Xu Shu had the right to choose not to participate in this decision-making at the beginning, but he still risked the controversy to carry out the "persuasion". <

After that, Xu Shu became disheartened by the death of Cao Chong, so he decided to propose to Cao Cao the idea of resigning and going into hiding. Although Cao Cao allowed Xu Shu to leave at first, he didn't want him to leave with his life, he wanted to eradicate Xu Shu, but due to Cao Pi's obstruction, Cao Cao had to let Xu Shu leave, and Xu Shu, who resigned like this, began to live in seclusion, and finally passed away peacefully.

He really didn't offer a strategy, and his final outcome was very bad, because he didn't make a contribution, so he was killed by Cao Cao, and his descendants were also killed.

It is recorded in the history books that he did not offer a plan, and he was finally executed tragically, although Xu Shu is a scheming person, but he is sometimes very friendly to people.

In fact, the story of Xu Shu is similar to the story of Guan Yu's temporary surrender to Cao Cao, which is used to interpret the saying "being in Cao Ying's heart is in Han".

The 14th chapter of "Xuanbao Half-Knowing and Explaining the Three Kingdoms" - Xu Shu entered Cao Ying.

There is a saying that it is difficult for a clean official to decide family affairs, who dares to guarantee that he will be able to do better than Xu Shu in this situation.

Again, under what circumstances did Xu Shu go to Cao Ying, he was forced to go after Cao Cao caught his mother, and he was unwilling. And Xu Shu's mother died because of this. In this case, you still expect Xu Shu to help you come up with ideas, you can dream about it, it would be good if you didn't hit you with a rake.

On the third floor, you are embarrassed to say that Xu Shu is a traitor, if your mother is killed by someone else, will you go to do something for your mother-killing enemy? What is a reputation for fame, that's nonsense.

In the end, Xu Shu himself said that his mother died because of himself, and if he returned to Liu Bei, he would inevitably lose his trust in the world and become an unfaithful and capricious person. Let me ask you, are you willing to be disloyal and untrustworthy?

Xu Shu was forced by Cao Cao to threaten his old mother to Cao Ying, and had to leave Liu Bei. But he never plotted for Cao Cao, Xu Shu spent decades in Cao Wei, but he never made a difference in politics and military. Therefore, in later generations, there are proverbs such as "Xu Shu enters Cao Ying - without saying a word" and "he is in Cao Ying, and his heart is in Han".

has come out, that is, he has given Cao Cao a series of schemes to harm Cao Cao.

No. He didn't come up with a plan in his life.

There are two plans, the first is when Zhao Zilong is seven in and seven out of Changbanpo, Cao Cao wants to get Zhao Zilong, Xu Shu said that if Zilong is captured alive, he can persuade him to surrender, and as a result, Cao Cao asked the military academy to catch Zhao Zilong alive so that Zhao Zilong can get out of trouble, although Xu Shu is to protect Zilong, but it is also a plan that Xu Shu offered for Cao Cao. The second time was before the Battle of Chibi, when Cao Cao's arrival reported that Ma Teng was going to fight Xuchang, Xu Shu heard Pang Tong tell Cao Cao that he would go home to guard Xuchang, but in fact, he ran away first. Both of these tactics were tricked by Cao Cao.