In history, Shi Da had great achievements in the war, why didn t he replace Hong Xiuquan at that tim

Because Shi Dakai's prestige is not as big as Hong Xiuquan. Hong Xiuquan is the leader that everyone agrees on, and no matter how powerful Shi Dakai is, he is also his subordinate, and he cannot replace Hong Xiuquan's position.

Because Hong Xiuquan could be said to be the spiritual leader of the Tianping Heavenly Kingdom at that time, even if Shi Da had great military achievements, it would be difficult to replace the other party, and at that time, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom was facing the encirclement and suppression of the Qing army in all directions, and the situation was very critical, and it could not lead to riots because of internal strife.

1. Hong Xiuquan started with the so-called religion at that time, and this characteristic of the regime means that the people look to the religious leader as the leader, and the religious leader is everything, and can give any order to the people under his rule. Therefore, Hong Xiuquan had supreme power at that time, and Shi Dakai had no way to mobilize any troops and generals.

Second, with the successive killings of Yang Xiuqing and Wei Changhui, Hong Xiuquan also became suspicious of Shi Dakai. At that time, Hong Xiuquan was fully prepared for a possible rebellion, and Shi Dakai had no chance of winning at all.

Hong XiuquanHearShi DakaiThe response to the news of death was one of extreme remorse. Shi Dakai can be said to be a peaceful world.

One of the most legendary figures, just as "the history of the barnyard has been feathered, and a case of unevenness in the autumn is heard", this sentence is Shi Dakai. At the same time, he can also be said to be the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom.

One of the saddest generals, his life was full of ups and downs, and in the end he was defeated and executed.

Character evaluation

Shi Dakai was both a famous military strategist and an excellent statesman, and his literary and martial arts were outstanding, so people who did not know enough about his experience often mistakenly thought that he had once won the imperial examination (even Emperor Xianfeng.

They all mistakenly thought that he was a Hunan Gongsheng) and imagined him as He Zeng Guofan.

is of a similar age, and has passed the age of confusion during the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom period, and in traditional opera, he plays Shi Dakai as an old student.

In the CCTV TV series "Taiping Heavenly Kingdom", Shi Dakai was also played as a middle-aged man who was four or five filial piety and touched a ten-year-old man, which caused a great misinformation to the audience. In fact, Shi Dakai was only 16 years old when he was "invited out of the mountain" by Hong Xiuquan, 19 years old when he was in the Jintian Uprising, and he was 23 years old when he defeated Zeng Guofan's troops in Hukou and Jiujiang and threw himself into the water (Zeng Guofan was 46 years old at the time), and he was only 32 years old when he bravely took up righteousness in Chengdu, and he was an out-and-out young hero.

Shi Dakai stayed in Tianjing, and the ending was the same as that of Li Xiucheng later, even if there was no bloody conflict, because of unwarranted suspicion, the original effective advice would not be accepted (Li Xiucheng's original words in the TV series).

Because Shi Dakai had heavy troops in his hands at that time, he was very dangerous to Hong Xiuquan, Hong Xiuquan was very jealous of him, and in order to preserve the vitality of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, Shi Dakai left Hong Xiuquan.

Because Shi Dakai was too good, he was jealous and suspicious of Hong Xiuquan, and he couldn't tolerate Shi Dakai, and often targeted Shi Dakai everywhere, and his unfair treatment Shi Dakai really couldn't stand it, so he left.

Hong Xiuquan's suspicion is the fundamental reason for Shi Dakai's departure, if he doesn't leave, Shi Dakai will also let Hong Xiuquan die, although it may be better to die than a thousand cuts. But it's better to die vigorously than to let others die.

Because Shi Dakai is not superstitious and does not believe in God's religion, his personal views are not accepted.

Because Shi Dakai saw that Hong Xiuquan had killed several other kings with his own hands, he felt that he would die in the hands of Hong Xiuquan sooner or later, and he was extremely disappointed in Hong Xiuquan, so he led his troops to leave, and the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom has since declined.

There are two reasons: the first reason is that Hong Xiuquan can't tolerate Shi Dakai and wants to get rid of Shi Dakai and the second reason is that after the Tianjing Incident, Hong Xiuquan reused the clansmen surnamed Hong and suppressed Shi Dakai in everything.

01, the first reason is that Hong Xiuquan can't tolerate Shi Dakai and wants to get rid of Shi Dakai

When the Tianping Taiguo was not yet established, Hong Xiuquan was still working very seriously, thinking about the Tianping Heavenly Kingdom in everything, and the relationship with Shi Dakai was also very iron. Even if Hong Xiuquan established the leader of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom in the future, there is still a place for Shi Dakai.

And at the beginning, Hong Xiuquan was still sober-minded, knowing that he still had to rely on Shi Dakai, so Shi Dakai's position in the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom was also very stable. But as Shi Dakai's record is getting better and better, the people have supported Shi Dakai, and many people have volunteered to follow Shi Dakai.

But Hong Xiuquan ignored anything and lived a corrupt life every day, and at this time, someone told Hong Xiuquan that Shi Dakai's reputation overshadowed him. Hong Xiuquan was worried that his position would not be guaranteed, so he designed to frame Shi Dakai, so he wanted to get rid of Shi Dakai, but fortunately, Shi Dakai was clever and dodged, and the brotherhood between the two was gone.

02, the second reason is that after the Tianjing Incident, Hong Xiuquan reused the clansmen surnamed Hong and suppressed Shi Dakai in everything

After the Tianjing Incident, Shi Dakai also forgave Hong Xiuquan a lot, after all, the other two Heavenly Kings Yang Xiuqing and Wei Changhui all went to see Lord Yan, and the only remaining Heavenly King was Shi Dakai, so Shi Dakai's status suddenly became very high. Moreover, Shi Dakai is also really capable, and he quickly stabilized the situation, and the crisis of the Tianjing Incident was successfully passed.

It's a pity that after Hong Xiuquan experienced the Tianjing Incident, he no longer trusted anyone, and felt that Shi Dakai also wanted to seize power, so he vigorously promoted the clansmen surnamed Hong and suppressed Shi Dakai in everything. In the end, Shi Dakai couldn't do anything, and he was worried about when Hong Xiuquan would attack him, so he chose to leave.

Because Hong Xiuquan had scruples about Shi Dakai in the end, he was worried that Shi Dakai would seek to seize his position.

After Hong Xiuquan killed Wei Changhui. Hong Xiuquan is almost completely depraved and doesn't trust anyone. Shi Dakai was suspicious everywhere, and in the end, Shi Dakai couldn't stand it and left Nanjing with his troops and fought alone.

Men turn against each other, either persuasion or women. And Hong Xiuquan and Shi Dakai were because of the struggle for power, and with the death of Feng Yunshan in the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, their kings began to fight for power and profit.

The main reason is the uneven distribution of power and some related interests, and there are also other people who are responsible for it.