Xiang Yu was defeated by Liu Bang, why did the descendants blow Han Xin?

Because Liu Bang himself did not have any military talent. Han Xin's military talents were outstanding, and he helped Liu Bang conquer the territory of the Han Dynasty.

Because it was Han Xin who led the troops to defeat Xiang Yu, not Liu Bang, Xiang Yu was indeed defeated by Liu Bang, but in fact, this battle was planned by Han Xin.

Because these are basically Han Xin's methods, Liu Bang just gave orders, and it was Han Xin who mainly gave advice, so people blew Han Xin.

Xiang Yu attaches great importance to affection and righteousness, and ignores money and beauties, so he treats his friends and subordinates with sincerity, but he does not know how to reward beautiful women and officials, Liu Bang is marketable, ruthless and righteous, and less humane, but he specializes in winning people with beautiful gold silks. There is no eternal righteousness in the world, only eternal profit, and this is where it comes from. For Han Xin, there is no way to verify it, and he can't simply look at him from Xiang and Liu, he may have switched to Liu to find a sense of identity and need a platform to show himself.

But Sima Qian is such a rigorous figure, and he only records Xiang Yu, who is not an emperor, as this record, which shows that he absolutely recognizes Xiang Yu's personality, and it stands to reason that he should actually be listed in the family.

Personally, I don't think there is such a possibility, I think even if Han Xin establishes himself as the king, he will not be able to share the world with Liu Bang and Xiang Yu.

No way, at that time, two-thirds of the world was in the hands of Liu Bang, and Han Xin only controlled a Qi country. Behind Liu Bang is the big granary of Hanzhong, which is run by Xiao He, and it consumes all the energy to kill Han Xin.

No, although he is really a brave and resourceful person, it's just a pity that he doesn't have the same ambition as Liu Bang and Xiang Yu.

I think it's difficult, although Han Xin has high personal ability and is good at fighting, he doesn't have the same ambition as Liu Bang, and it is difficult to become big.

I think it's difficult, first of all, his soldiers can be said to be loyal to Liu Bang, he himself does not have enough strength, and if he sets himself up as a king, he will not be able to be very strong if others imitate him.

The possibility is almost zero! Hanshin does not have its own team. No successful regime can be conquered by an emperor or a leader alone.

No, Liu Bang has Zhang Liang and Xiao He, and Wu has Fan Hao and Zhou Yafu. Zhang Liang is planning the general trend of the future, even though Han Xin relied on wisdom to fight Liu Bang and retreated, but Han Xin could only see the victory in front of him, but he didn't know that Zhang Liang used the defeat to lead Han Xin into the terrain that was unfavorable to him, and Han Xin could defeat Xiang Yu but could not beat Zhang Liang. The battle of wisdom and strategy is the most exciting battle, and the slightest mistake can turn the tide of battle.

No, in terms of political image, Liu Bang has the grace of knowing Han Xin, if Han Xin establishes himself as a king, it will be ungrateful and seriously lose points in political image. Moreover, Han Xin has no fixed forces and bases, and the generals of Han Xin's army are all Liu Bang's people, and there is nowhere to prepare for food, grass, and military salaries.

I think Han Xin can compete with Liu Bang and Xiang Yu, because after pacifying the Qi State, Han Xin's strength has formed a three-legged trend with Liu Bang and Xiang Yu. Militarily speaking, no one can match Han Shin.

I don't think so, Han Xin can't compare to Xiang Yu and Liu Bang in terms of timing and fate. Han Xin is not decisive enough and has no means compared to Xiang Yu and Liu Bang.

No one could have predicted the outcome! Xiang Yu had strong military strength at that time, but he was alone and did not have strong logistics support and long-term strategic planning, and he would definitely not be the one who won in the end. Han Xin was also a hegemonic party in military strength at that time, and the battle was even more invincible, but there was no group formation and no strategic planning, and it was difficult to predict the outcome in the future.

Liu Bang's military strength was the weakest at that time, but he had already formed a political bloc and had a solid logistics base, and in the long run, Liu Bang should still win. It's a pity that Liu Bang has an Achilles heel and it is difficult to guarantee Liu Bang's victory: that is, Liu Bang is old, and Xiang Yu and Han Xin are in their prime of life, Liu Bang was close to 60 years old at the time, and he was already old at that time, and it was difficult to support him for a few years.

So the ending is really unpredictable.