Whose fault is it for the Ma Tan Lost Street Pavilion ?

I think it was Ma Tan's responsibility to lose the street pavilion, because Ma Tan was very arrogant at that time and did not abide by Zhuge Liang's plan.

Of course, Ma Tan had to bear the greatest responsibility, did not listen to Wang Ping's advice, and insisted on setting up a village in the mountains. As a result, the army was besieged and the street pavilions were lost. The second is Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang tried to appoint Ma Jian against public opinion, which indirectly caused the loss of the street pavilion, and sending others may not be the result.

In the end, Ma Tan paid for his life, and Zhuge Liang did nothing in the later Northern Expedition.

It should be Ma Tan's fault, he did not follow the strategy given to him by Zhuge Liang and set up camp at the foot of the mountain.

In my personal opinion, the responsibility for losing the street kiosk is more in Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang, as the commander in the army, has an unshirkable responsibility for improper employment. knew the importance of the street pavilion, and also knew the shortcomings of Ma Tan, but Zhuge Liang still appointed Ma Jian to take on the important task of the first street pavilion.

The street pavilion has a very important geographical location for the Shu army. Zhuge Liang, as the commander of the three armies, used the wrong generals, and finally caused the loss of Jiechun Hu Pavilion. Then he slashed the horse with tears and left his responsibilities clean.

For the loss of the street pavilion alone, I think Ma Jian and Zhuge Liang should both bear the main responsibility. It's a pity that the only person who was punished in the end was Ma Yan.

As the old saying goes: "No one is perfect without gold", even if he is a genius like Zhuge Liang, there are times when he makes mistakes. When Cao Cao was defeated by Huarong Dao, he sent Guan Yu to intercept and kill, and finally Guan Yu remembered the old love and let Cao Cao go, which was the first mistake he made.

Of course, it can also be said that Zhuge Liang did it on purpose, just to let Guan Yu return this favor.

When guarding the street pavilion, there was a better choice than Ma Jian at that time, even if the deputy general Wang Ping was asked to guard the street pavilion, maybe Senbi would not let the street pavilion be lost, so that Zhuge Liang's "a big game of chess with celery" would be ruined.

From the perspective of selecting generals, Zhuge Liang must be responsible for this. In the end, he is responsible for the failure.

Ma Yan's talent is deeply appreciated by Zhuge Liang, but Zhuge Liang also has times when he doesn't know people. He has always been jealous of Wei Yan, and he has never faced up to Wei Yan's talent. On the contrary, Ma Yan, who talks on paper, has high expectations.

In order to show his determination to protect the street pavilion, Ma Tan also made a military order for Zhuge Liang. It was such a military order that finally cost him his life.

At that time, if the people guarding the street pavilion were replaced by Wei Yan, I think Wei Jun would not have succeeded. Of course, there is no if in history, otherwise history will be changed, and the fate of the Three Kingdoms will also be rewritten.

It was because there was some noisy social background at that time, and the main responsibility was related to many people, and the result was that he had to be cautious and filial piety, so it had nothing to do with him.

It was because Ma Tan was a self-righteous person, with no special practical experience, and then he was particularly panicked and vague in his heart, in this battle, he just blocked the passage of the Wei army of Shanyuchen, and the result of the later teasing Zen continued had nothing to do with him.

It was because of Zhuge Liang's misjudgment that he lost the street pavilion, and this matter is not only Ma Yan's responsibility, but also has a lot to do with Zhuge Liang.

This is because there are other responsible persons for this matter, and Zhuge Liang is also responsible, and Ma Jian cannot be blamed for everything.