If Liu Bei wins the Battle of Yiling, will he be able to unify the Three Kingdoms?

Updated on history 2024-03-06
16 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    No. This is not necessarily. The battle of Yiling destroyed the Eastern Wu, and Shu Han was also greatly injured, so he could only let Cao Wei sit and reap the benefits of the fisherman!

    Let's talk about the Battle of Yiling! The three males at the end of the Han Dynasty have their own origins. Sun Zhong seeks the foundation of his father and brother, and the family industry is needless to say.

    Although Cao Mengde was ugly, the eunuch was ordered at that time, and in addition to the attachment, he couldn't help but be proud of the spring breeze and make steady progress. Only Liu Xuande Kongtuo Emperor, Zhao Mu is difficult to understand, weaving mats and selling shoes, enlisting in the army, neither ancestors start a business, but also lack tens of thousands of dollars to buy the home of the captain. Starting from scratch, he fought for three points of the world with his head, and he died nine times for a lifetime, and he will achieve positive results, but "his prosperity is also vigorous, and his death is also sudden".

    When "Longzhong Pair" came to an abrupt end and the dust settled, Liu Xuande was stunned to find that "the rules of saving the Han Dynasty will stop here", and his role has quietly changed from Han Guangwu to "White Emperor" Gongsun Shu. The hatred of the country and the family, naturally" refers to the banner of righteousness, and it is appropriate to be in the Sun family. ”<

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Liu Bei mixed Sun Quan with him, so he could only speed up Sun Quan to join forces with Cao Wei. The reason why the Three Kingdoms can last for so many years is because the triangular structure is the most stable. One horn is strong, and the other two horns are bound to unite to suppress him.

    When Cao Cao was strong, it was Sun and Liu who allied forces against Cao. Liu Bei's strength was replaced by Wei and Wu uniting to pit Liu Bei. There is only one possibility for the unification of the three countries, and that is that the strength of one country can crush the union of the other two countries.

    The Wei and Jin dynasties occupied the hinterland of the Central Plains, as long as they held on to the basic market and restored economic agriculture, it was a natural result to rely on population advantages to drag Sun Liu to death. Therefore, Zhuge Liang repeatedly went on northern expeditions, and Sun Quan attacked Hefei several times, all of which sought change and survival and wanted to break the inherent pattern.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The most mysterious thing about the Three Kingdoms is the balance, if one is strong, the other two will inevitably unite. Even if Liu Bei was able to win the Battle of Yiling, it would be impossible to eliminate Sun Quan in a short period of time. This bought time for Wei to rescue Wu.

    At the same time, Liu Bei's two commander-level generals were tragically killed one after another, which was a fatal blow to Shu Han! Coupled with objective factors such as supplies and troop sources, it is impossible for Liu Bei to unify the Three Kingdoms. Liu Bei's best chance to unify the Three Kingdoms lies in the immortality of Pang Tong and Fa Zheng, but unfortunately both died young, if these two people do not die, Liu Bei's unification is still possible.

    Guan Yu and Zhuge are very strong in military talent, while Zhuge is cautious, Pang Tong is not dead, Zhuge is not in Shu, and it is impossible for Wu to sneak attack Jingzhou. On the contrary, Zhuge trains his troops, and his troops will be stronger. As for Pang Tong, he is also a genius in military affairs, and he is better at scheming than Zhuge , and there are few rivals in the entire Three Kingdoms.

    plus Zhang Fei and Wei Yan are the world's fierce generals, and it is another super combination. It's a pity that history has no assumptions, and the fall of Pang Tong, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Fa Zheng and others doomed Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang to be difficult to achieve the great cause of reunification.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    No. The Yangtze River out of Yiling, although the river surface suddenly relaxed, there is still the Jingmen, the tiger's tooth of the force, the mountains on both sides of the river, but the narrow road of the river is connected, the army is difficult, there is a risk of cutting off for the enemy, and the river is turbulent, its advance is easy to retreat is difficult to know. Considering this, the Han general Huang Quan first planned and then sought war, and proposed to lead a light army to test, and Liu Bei led the main force to respond to it.

    If according to Huang Quan's strategy, first for the invincible, and then wait for the enemy to win, the Han army has no risk of defeat, but the main force refuses, and Lu Xun is stationed on the main road, Huang Quan is partial to the division to attack it, it is bound to be insufficient troops, it is difficult to achieve great success, the Han army will be trapped at the mouth of the gorge, helpless. This plan is not accepted by Liu Bei, it can be imagined. <>

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    I'm afraid not, Soochow has capable people and an army. Even if Liu Bei is lucky to win, he will only occupy half of Jingzhou at most and stop, and it is possible to lose it in the end.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    If Liu Bei wins, it means that Liu Bei is no longer Liu Bei, but a mercenary god.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Support. It's good to think, but Liu Bei didn't have the strength to win the battle of Yiling at that time, if Guan Yu didn't carelessly lose Jingzhou, Zhang Feima Chaofa Zheng was alive, Liu Bei crossed Jingyi Erzhou, Wen had Kong Ming Fazheng Liu Ba, Wu Guan Yu Zhang Feima Chao, maybe Shu Han's achievements would be more brilliant. At that time, Liu Bei married Sun Quan, respected Sun Quan as the king of Wu, made Eastern Wu attack Hefei, Guan Yu led the Jingzhou army to attack the Central Plains in the north, pinned down the main force of Cao Wei in the Central Plains, and then united with Gongsun Yuan in Liaodong in the north, so that the Liaodong army attacked the counties of Youzhou, ordered Ma Chao to contact the Qiang people in the northwest, and made the Qiang people attack the counties of Liangzhou, so that Zhang Fei led the partial division out of the Jigu Valley to feint and attack Yicheng to contain the main force of Cao Wei Guanzhong, Liu Bei led the main force of the Shu army such as Fazheng Ma Chao, Zhao Yun, Feng Xi, Zhang Nan and other Shu troops to go out of Hanzhong to capture the counties of Longyou, so that Wei Yan sent surprise troops to march from the Meridian Valley, Taking advantage of the fact that the main force of Cao Wei Guanzhong attacked Chang'an in one fell swoop when the main force of Cao Wei Guanzhong fought fiercely with the Shu army in the area of Longyou in Yicheng and the emptiness of Chang'an City, and then took Tongguan by winning and blocking Cao Wei's reinforcements from the Central Plains, so that even if Cao Wei could not be destroyed, at least he could occupy Yongliang Erzhou west of Tongguan, Guan Yu did not expect him to be able to capture the counties of the Central Plains, because the Central Plains should be Cao Wei's trump card troops guarding the town, and Guan Yu's ultimate goal was to contain the main force of Cao Wei in the Central Plains, so that it could not aid Guanzhong in the west.

    At that time, Liu Bei will be able to occupy the land of Jingyi, Yongliang and the four states. If Sun Quan exerted all his strength to bring all the elite soldiers of Eastern Wu to attack, he might be able to defeat Zhang Liao and occupy the counties of Cao, Wei and Huainan. In this way, Cao Wei's strength will be greatly reduced, and the three countries should be equal in strength (perhaps Eastern Wu will be slightly weaker).

    At that time, it is difficult to say how the three countries will unite and how they will fight.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Yes, before the battle of Yiling, Sun Quan wanted to cede Jingzhou to sue for peace, because Liu Bei and Wu Guozhong did not agree, Sun Quan ordered Han Dang, Zhou Tai and other generals to lead tens of thousands of soldiers to meet the Shu army, and the Wu army was defeated. Sun Quan failed to make peace again, so he sued Cao Wei for peace, and sent Lu Xun to fight back to defeat Liu Bei.

    If Liu Bei agrees to sue for peace, capture Jingzhou and attack Shangyong first, make Hanzhong Jingzhou connect to the north, and force the Wu army to go north, at least it is not difficult to capture the Guanzhong region, plus the efforts of talents in the late Shu Han period, it is not difficult to destroy Wei and Wu. If after destroying Wu in one go, Liu Bei insisted on buying people's hearts in the area south of Hefei, ordered Zhuge Liang and Ma Chao's troops to enter Xiliang, and sent Jingzhou generals to fight hard in Xinfan, supporting the army of Cao Ren and others.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    If Liu Bei wins, then Cao Pi will send troops to Hanzhong, just as Lu Xun defeated Cao Pi and sent troops to Hefei.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    I think it is very possible, because capturing the entire territory of Eastern Wu, including Jingzhou, and then confronting Cao Wei in the north and south, and then dividing the army into two ways can make Cao Pi finish off.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Basically, there is not much chance, in fact, if Guan Yu wins the battle of Fancheng, Liu Bei has a relatively high chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, and the battle of Yiling is very difficult even if it does not fight with the strength of Shu Han.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    First of all, the basis of the Battle of Yiling was that Liu Bei attacked Eastern Wu on the grounds of revenge, and it was difficult to avoid it under Liu Guanzhang's peach love in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Aside from this setting, before the Battle of Yiling, Shu had lost Jingzhou and its affiliated territories, when Liu Feng Mengda and others betrayed, the road to Wei could only be as difficult as seven out of Qishan, although there were 700,000 troops and not all (the so-called thousands of miles of grain, not one out of ten), may not be able to take advantage of Wei. At this time, the Shu-Wu alliance had a gap in Jingzhou, which also limited the strength of Shu.

    On the other hand, Cao Wei lost the city and regained it, only a small number of soldiers and horses such as Fancheng before were lost (they had been supplied) and re-armed. If you really go all out to defeat Wei, there is a high probability that you will be weak in the follow-up, and you may face the crisis of annihilation again, which may be more dangerous than the situation after the defeat of Yiling (the front is surrounded and cannot be saved, which can be described as a dilemma).

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    No. Because the talents withered in the later period of the Shu Kingdom, and Cao Cao was not as unbearable as he imagined, he could not dominate the world.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    No, because the gap in strength between Shu Han and the other two countries is still too big, and this cannot be bridged.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    He couldn't unify the world, thinking that Cao Cao's strength in the north was still very strong, and Cao Cao had a lot of generals, and the north he ruled was also rich, and it was still difficult for Liu Bei to unify China.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    can't dominate the world, because Liu Bei's failure is the trend of the times, and there is no so-called if.

Related questions
20 answers2024-03-06

I think Shu Han has a very good chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, because in the Battle of Yiling that year, they lost a lot of warriors, which had a great impact on their strength.

16 answers2024-03-06

I think so, because Liu Bei was proud and complacent, so he insisted on avenging Guan Yu when his army was tired and the logistics were not enough, if there was more time to repair the army, he should not lose so badly.

14 answers2024-03-06

OneIt should be that Zhuge Liang was sick at that time, and he was seriously ill, so they didn't have anyone to give advice, so their morale would be greatly reduced。Therefore, after losing 50,000 soldiers and horses, it will be a slump, because if there is no morale, then it is really a particularly important loss for a team. So if Zhuge Liang hadn't been sick at that time, there might not have been such a problem, so Zhuge Liang was particularly important to Shu Han at that time. >>>More

5 answers2024-03-06

Campaign Introduction: Battle Name: Battle of Yiling, also known as the Battle of Yiling and the Battle of Yiting. >>>More

34 answers2024-03-06

Battle of Yiling,The Soochow Group has paid for almost three years, and the biggest loss in this battle is actuallyLiu BeiClique. >>>More