If Liu Bei didn t conduct the Battle of Yiling, would Shu Han have a chance to unify the Three Kingd

I think Shu Han has a very good chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, because in the Battle of Yiling that year, they lost a lot of warriors, which had a great impact on their strength.

In my opinion, if Liu Bei doesn't do this, then the Shu Kingdom will become stronger, and it will retain a lot of talents, and even get part of the territory of Jingzhou.

Yes, without the Battle of Yiling, the elite of Shu Han will not be lost, and Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition will be likely to succeed later.

There was no chance, because at that time, Liu Bei's general trend was gone, and he was already powerless to compete with Cao Cao.

No. It will only postpone the destruction of Shu.

It is possible for Liu Bei to unify the world, because there are still more talents under Liu Bei, including Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu, all of whom are very talented people.

There is no possibility. Because Liu Bei's side is not the strongest, it is impossible to unify the world.

Even if the Battle of Yiling did not occur, Liu Bei would never have the possibility of unifying the Three Kingdoms. In terms of comprehensive strength, the population and area of Shu. The military power was the weakest among the three countries.

Basically, there is not much chance, in fact, if Guan Yu wins the battle of Fancheng, Liu Bei has a relatively high chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, and the battle of Yiling is very difficult even if it does not fight with the strength of Shu Han.

First of all, the basis of the Battle of Yiling was that Liu Bei attacked Eastern Wu on the grounds of revenge, and it was difficult to avoid it under Liu Guanzhang's peach love in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Aside from this setting, before the Battle of Yiling, Shu had lost Jingzhou and its affiliated territories, when Liu Feng Mengda and others betrayed, the road to Wei could only be as difficult as seven out of Qishan, although there were 700,000 troops and not all (the so-called thousands of miles of grain, not one out of ten), may not be able to take advantage of Wei. At this time, the Shu-Wu alliance had a gap in Jingzhou, which also limited the strength of Shu.

On the other hand, Cao Wei lost the city and regained it, only a small number of soldiers and horses such as Fancheng before were lost (they had been supplied) and re-armed. If you really go all out to defeat Wei, there is a high probability that you will be weak in the follow-up, and you may face the crisis of annihilation again, which may be more dangerous than the situation after the defeat of Yiling (the front is surrounded and cannot be saved, which can be described as a dilemma).

The fiasco greatly damaged the vitality of Shu Han.

In the first year of Zhang Wu (221), Liu Bei sent troops to attack Eastern Wu in the name of avenging Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei was killed by his subordinates. Sun sent an envoy to ask for peace, Liu Bei was furious, and Wu general Lu Xun and other troops returned, and were defeated by the Shu general Wu Ban. Liu Beijun occupied Zigui and sent Ma Lianglian to meet and dismantle the Wuling Wuxi barbarians.

In the spring of the second year of Zhang Wu (222), Liu Bei sent Huang Quan to supervise the Jiangbei Chaduan Naval Army and led the army to march. In the autumn and July, he was defeated by Wu general Lu Xun in the Battle of Yiling, and the generals Feng Xi, Zhang Nan, Fu Wei, and Cheng Ji were killed.

The defeat of Yiling dealt a heavy blow to the newly established Shu Han regime, which not only lost a large number of soldiers and supplies, but also killed many generals. The following year, the death of the monarch Liu Bei crumbled the country built on his fame, and domestic rebellions broke out.

It took Prime Minister Zhuge Liang about five years to rebuild the army and quell these rebellions, and to raise the country's strength to the point where it could send troops against foreign troops.

It is impossible that even if he wins, Liu Bei will be greatly injured, the outstanding generals will be exhausted, and the Northern Expedition will face a two-front battle between Wei and Wu, and there will be no excellent generals to lead the army.

Only the Shu Han in Yizhou and Jingzhou, the maximum number of troops was 150,000 according to the proportion of the domestic population at that time, and the Wei State adopted the advanced Jiupin Zhongzheng system, which eased the class contradictions, stabilized and developed production, and the population increased greatly, especially in the Central Plains, there was originally a large population state, and the maximum number of troops mobilized by Wei was 25-300,000 according to historical records.

Compared with the Great Wei, Shu Han is still lacking in strength.

The establishment of the Three Kingdoms is a stage that history must go through.

No one can perish anyone.

It was to be maintained until the 60s of the 3rd century AD.

After that, the class contradictions in the Shu Han and Eastern Wu intensified, the palace struggle was fierce, and the political situation was unstable, while although the Wei State was ruled by the Sima clan, the Jiupin Zhongzheng system greatly stabilized the political situation.

The unification of China by Wei (Jin) is historically inevitable.

The superiority of the political system has played a huge role.

Please adopt it!!

If Liu Bei wins the Battle of Yiling, will Eastern Wu perish? Sima Yi pointed out.

That will have the strength to confront Cao Cao head-on, (the strength of Shu and Wu has always been weaker than Cao Cao), but it is difficult to predict what will happen later, when Liu Bei will die, what Zhuge Liang will do, etc.

In the Battle of Yiling, the Shu army dispatched a total of about 60,000 people, about 50,000 people directly participated in the attack, and Lu Xun's troops were more than 50,000. The reason why he failed was precisely because he did not have the right time, place and people and these three taboos: when the time came, he chose the scorching heat to attack Wu, Wu was nothing as a defensive country, and Shu, as an attacking country, marched every day under the scorching sun, and the period and body of the soldiers were slowly weakened.

If it was just the time of day, the Shu army could still rely on the number of soldiers to win. But without geographical advantages, it created a good opportunity for Lu Xun to sneak attack. The Shu army was stationed in a densely wooded area, and although it was close to the river, there was no way to resist the attack of the Wu army.

The most fatal thing is that Liu Bei had no one to make peace, and he did not listen to the advice of Zhuge Liang and others before setting out on the expedition, and almost none of the good generals participated in this battle. In addition, Lu Xun's tactics are appropriate, and his troops are not inferior, so Liu Bei's defeat is inevitable.

After Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, Liu Bei, in order to avenge Guan Yu, launched the Battle of Yiling a year later, but it ended in failure.

Eager to win, casually underestimate the enemy At that time, the death of the two brothers had already dealt a great blow to their minds, and it was also emotional.

It can be said that the reason for the failure is very simple, Liu Bei was in a hurry. Under the guise of revenge, he won the battle every year before, thinking that he would win this time, and he didn't pay attention to the method of using soldiers.

He didn't know how to use soldiers, he went deep into the Wu realm, Sun Quan originally planned to ask for peace, but he didn't listen, and was defeated by Wu General Lu Xun!

No, it's Zhuge who wants to rebel (Zhuge said in the thatched house that he wanted Qinchuan and Jingzhou to attack the Wei State together, why did you say that after sealing the Five Tiger Generals, Zhuge Liang only let Guan Yu fight Xiangyang alone, and Zhuge stayed and enjoyed himself by Liu Bei's side?) It was he who wanted to borrow the hand of Wei and Eastern Wu to kill Guan Yu, and then kill Zhang Fei, Liu Bei, Liu Feng and others.