Is Li Ling a loyal minister or a traitor?

Li Ling is Li Guang's grandson, although he was captured in the war, he didn't do anything bad for the country, so he should be loyal.

Li Ling is the protagonist of a historical tragedy. And what created this tragedy was our criteria for evaluating historical figures.

From a modern point of view, he is not. As a commander-in-chief, he did his duty. Not in the past, he didn't die, so it wasn't right.

Li Ling, a famous general in ancient times, once fought on the battlefield for the Qin State and was highly appreciated for his success. However, in his later years, he was accused of being a traitor.

Li Ling's betrayal is said to have been caused by his surrender to the guerrilla leader Wu Qi. But is this the truth?In fact, Li Ling did not make this decision independently, but was abandoned during the military campaign of the Qin State.

When Li Ling was a general of the Qin state, he led a losing campaign of the Qin state. After the defeat, he was drawn into the internal struggle for the reputation of the Qin state. In the context of political struggle, he was forced to leave his ranks in exchange for a safe place to live.

Eventually, he was forced into surrender.

In the case of forced surrender, Li Ling's actions were not unilateral betrayal, but a reasonable choice to protect himself and his family in the face of political and organizational failures and disturbances. Later, Li Ling was not the director of intelligence in the guerrillas, but played the role of ensuring the unity of the team.

Therefore, we should not just regard Li Ling as a rebel, but should look at this matter from a deep political, social, and even human perspective. In fact, what Li Ling did was not a unilateral betrayal, but a reasonable choice to protect himself and his family in the face of political and organizational failures and disturbances.

Yes. Li Ling pretended to surrender to the Xiongnu at that time, and later Emperor Wu of Han ordered the killing of the Li Ling people, and Li Ling completely fell to the Xiongnu.

I don't think Li Ling surrendered. He was just forced by the situation to save the lives of his subordinates in order to serve the court in the future.

Li Ling betrayed the Han Dynasty, but this was also the responsibility of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, because Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty asked Li Ling to fight the Xiongnu with 5,000 infantry.

His actions were all betrayal. Regardless of whether his subjective emotions feel that he has not betrayed, his objective behavior is already counted.

I don't think so, because his approach is still relatively normal.

After Li Ling surrendered to the Xiongnu, Li Ling's descendants did not have a good time, because they were no longer useful, and they would be spurned.

In fact, Li Ling's matter now seems that the dramatic tension is very large. Originally, he did not surrender, but the court misunderstood his approach and executed people related to him. caused his family to die, and he ended up drifting outside.

Li Ling is not a traitor, and he does not have an avatar, but he will surrender because of his lack of ability and forced by the situation. But Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty could not understand it, so he and his descendants were driven out of the Central Plains, and they could only survive among the border herding minorities for the rest of their lives.

He did become a traitor, but I think his descendants were basically spurned by people, and then his life was not good, and their descendants were also vulnerable to bullying by others.

Li Ling did not really surrender to the Xiongnu and became a traitor, but Li Ling led 5,000 troops to fight against the 80,000 Xiongnu soldiers, and was forced to surrender when he was outnumbered, and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty listened to the rumors and drove Li Ling out of the Central Plains, and Li Ling's descendants also lived in the Xiongnu.

Li Ling was forced to surrender, but Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty listened to the rumors, blamed Li Ling's family, and killed them, and it was precisely because of this that Li Ling stayed in the Xiongnu and did not go back.

Li Ling did not completely surrender to the Xiongnu, but because he was outnumbered, he was forced by the situation at that time, and Sima Qian also defended Li Ling. Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty drove Li Ling out of the Central Plains, and Li Ling and his descendants could only live among the Xiongnu.

There should be no, this is the strategy of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, the bitter meat plan + the counter-plot, as for killing Li Ling's whole family, it was killed by the Huns Shan Yu, in order to be more realistic.

In the eyes of the emperor, Li Ling's surrender was a betrayal, but in fact, Li Ling chose to surrender because he was outnumbered, leaving Qingshan behind. Misunderstood and condemned as traitors, his descendants were also saddled with such statements and could not live in their own country.

Li Ling's descendants were all killed, and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty was furious and blamed Li Ling's family for his merits. This is also the reason why Li Ling did not come back in the end.

After Li Ling was recognized as a traitor by Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, he condemned the rest of his family and killed all his descendants.

Li Ling is a very loyal person. In order not to start a war with the Han Dynasty, he applied to guard the frontier. Far from the land of conquest.

Sima Qian exonerated Li Ling because he believed that Li Ling did not really surrender to the Xiongnu, but rather a roundabout policy. He believed that Li Ling had been framed, not really surrendered.

Li Ling is the protagonist of a historical tragedy. And what created this tragedy was our criteria for evaluating historical figures.

Everyone's opinion is different, some people say that Li Ling surrendered to the Xiongnu and was not ashamed of him, and some people think that he dared to run rampant with "5,000 foot soldiers", not because he was afraid of death.

It was determined by the identity and status of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty and the narrow and selfish position he formed. He complicated Sima Qian's exculpatory behavior, and did not think that Sima Qian exonerated Li Ling only out of the responsibility of an objective and honest historian, so Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty thought too much, of course, this is also caused by his identity, status, and environment, and he can't not think of complicated things, after all, it is in the officialdom, so the anger of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty and the misfortune of Sima Qian are, in a sense, a historical necessity. - The little girl is foolish, I hope to understand.