What will happen if you change Zhao Yunshou Street Pavilion? If the street pavilion is Zhao Yunshou,

To ask Zhao Yunshou whether the street pavilion can be defended, it first depends on what is the reason for the failure of the street pavilion.

The defeat of Jieting in the First Northern Expedition in 228 had its objective reasons from a strategic point of view.

First of all, the Shu Han Command headed by Zhuge Liang underestimated the war mobilization ability and mobility of Cao Wei. Wei Yan predicted in "The Plan of the Meridian Valley" that it would take more than 20 days for the main force of Cao's army to assemble and reach Tongguan, but in fact, it took less than ten days for Cao Wei's Zhang He to reach the Jieting, which was 200 miles west of Tongguan.

Secondly, the troops participating in the war were also at a disadvantage in Shu Han. Zhuge Liang's main force was scattered, part of it was accepting the three counties, part was besieging Qishan, and part of it was fighting with the Wei army from Liangzhou, and the Ma Tan sent out to resist the Wei army was estimated to have only 10,000 to 20,000 troops. And it was Zhang He's army of 50,000 that attacked the street pavilion.

In terms of general ability, Ma Tan is only thirty-nine years old, and he usually mainly does staff work, which is evaluated by Liu Bei as an exaggeration. And Zhang He's years in the army are older than Ma Yan's age and have rich experience.

In this case, Ma Tan faced a strong enemy, lacked the determination to resist head-on, violated Zhuge Liang's pre-arrangement, and avoided going up the mountain, but was cut off from the water source by Zhang He and collapsed without a fight. If he could have been ruthless enough to hold the intersection, even if he was defeated in the end, he would not have been defeated so simply. After all, the equipment and military formation of the Shu army are still relatively deterrent in flat combat.

In this way, we can see the significance of changing Zhao Yun.

If it was Zhao Yunlai who led the battle of Jieting, he could not change the strategic estimate before the war, nor could he change the comparison of the forces of the two sides. But Zhao Yun, as a veteran who is about the same age as Zhang He, is the most daring to fight a tough battle. He will definitely be able to lead the Shu army, follow Zhuge Liang's instructions, and camp in front to block Zhang He's front.

Thinking of the battle of Nanwei four years later, in 231, Wang Ping led his troops to block Zhang He, and Zhao Yun could only do better.

Similarly, in the later stage of the Battle of Yijieting, Wang Ping with more than 1,000 people was able to make Zhang He afraid of three points through bluffing, while Zhao Yun had an empty plan in the Battle of Hanzhong. There will be no shortage of schemes in this area.

To sum up, if Zhao Yun leads troops to guard the street pavilion, most of the street pavilions will not be lost, at least not soon.

It's a pity that there are not so many talents in Shu Kingdom, Zhao Yun guards the Street Pavilion, so who are you going to send to Xiegu to lead the suspicious soldiers to seduce Cao Wei's main force? Except for Zhao Yun, I'm afraid that no one has this ability and qualification.

Zhuge Liang is too conservative! The key is that Liu Bei has turned his years of advantages into nothing!

If Zhao Yun guards the street pavilion, he will definitely hold it, because Zhao Yun is a person who obeys orders, and he will do what Zhuge Liang arranges.

Changing Zhao Yunshou Street Pavilion should not fail. Zhao Yun is both civil and military, delicate, and has a lot of practical experience, so he should not make a mistake like Ma Yan.

The kiosk will not be lost anytime soon. In fact, it is not difficult to defend the street pavilion, as long as it is an experienced general, let alone Zhao Yun, who has been in a hundred battles.

Not necessarily. Ma Tan lost the street pavilion because he lightly advanced the enemy, Zhao Yun is a veteran of a hundred battles, if he guards the street pavilion, he may be more cautious, and the street pavilion may not be lost.

The same will be lost. Maybe lose it slowly, and buy some time for the Shu Han Army Forest Search Team. However, it will not have a decisive impact on the outcome of the campaign.

Zhao Yun is brave and strategic, if he guards the street pavilion, he should not lose it.

Zhuge Liang also did not clearly state that he had to keep it for a few days, one day was death, and ten days was death. Therefore, the street pavilion is a dead land, and whoever comes will die.

Where is Zhao Yun at this time? He was leading the army to feint from Jigu to attack the Chang'an city of Yi County, and contain Cao Zhen's Guanzhong army. If it weren't for that, Zhuge Liangyou would not have had a chance to capture the five counties on the right side of Longnian at all.

I don't think Zhao Yun would have failed if he had guarded the Street Pavilion, because Zhao Yun was able to guard the Street Pavilion very well and was able to defeat the enemy.

I don't think so, because if it were Zhao Yun, he would definitely deploy a defense at the foot of the mountain, and then set up a force at the top of the mountain, so as to form a corner and not give the enemy a chance to take advantage of it.

Failure is inevitable, but it will last a few more days than Ma Tan, but it should not be more than five days.

No, Zhao Yun's ability is far superior to Ma Yan's, and he will not change Zhuge Liang's layout self-righteously.

If Zhao Yun will not fail in guarding the street pavilion, because Zhang He will run when he sees Zhao Yun.

No, because he will definitely obey Zhuge Liang's deployment, strictly abide by the order, and guard the street pavilion.

Don't be deceived by the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhao Yunyuan was in Ling County at that time, as a suspicious soldier involved Cao Zhen's army, how could he go to Shoujie Pavilion.

Zhang He's generals (and even soldiers) defeated Zhao Yun at Keigu. It should be one kind in a street kiosk.

First, Wei Yan led 10,000 soldiers and horses out of the Xiegu Road, feigned attacking the fortifications, and attracted the power of Cao Allah. Second, Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi led 10,000 soldiers and horses (Wudang Feijun) to garrison the street pavilion. Third, Chen Shi led five cadres to garrison Liucheng.

Third, Liao Hua led five cadres to garrison Nan'an. Fourth, Zhang Yi and Zhang Wei each led 10,000 soldiers and horses to attack Longxi.

Zhao Yun has more important things to do, good steel is used on the blade, otherwise wouldn't it be better for Zhuge Liang to guard it personally?

You've watched too much of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, right? What is Romance, a story based on the canonical history.

Yes, because neither of them will change Zhuge Liang's layout, and there is nothing wrong with Zhuge Liang's layout.

Wars are all risky, and it is impossible to be foolproof, if these two people are to defend it, it can only be said that it is very likely to hold it.

Yes, Zhao Yun and Wang Ping are familiar with the art of war, and they are flexible in their use of troops, so they will not march and deploy the formation like a horse, so the street pavilion can be guaranteed.

The geographical location of the street pavilion is very special, easy to defend and difficult to attack, if Zhao Yun and Wang Ping are allowed to guard, they will definitely hold it, and the street pavilion will be foolproof.

According to Pisen, it will be lost, the street pavilion is just a small dusty place, Zhuge Liang's original intention is not to hold Zen to delay the pace of Cao Jun's attack, as long as it can hold until Zhuge Liang unifies.

Yes, because there is nothing wrong with Zhuge Liang's layout, and the strength is sufficient as a defender.

It is said that Zhao Yun is a victorious general and has basically never lost a battle in his life, but people are afraid of Zhao Yun not because of his wisdom, but because of his martial arts and bravery. Zhao Yun is not Zhang Fei's kind of brave and unscrupulous person, but even if he is brave and strategic, he can't fight Sima Yi, and Sima Yi can't come out and fight Zhao Yun alone, unless it is Zhuge Liang himself, otherwise anyone will not be able to guard the street pavilion, but Zhao Yun's words will not be as arbitrary as Ma Yan, and he will not listen to the advice of his subordinates.

In fact, if Ma Tan is not too conceited, he can also defend for a long time, the street pavilion itself is a mountain road, it is an easy to defend and difficult to attack military fortress, Zhuge Liang was also because the grain and grass in the army could not keep up, had to withdraw the army, so he sent Ma Tan to guard the street pavilion. But after Ma Jian arrived at **, he could defend it for a long time, but Ma Jian had to get the army to the mountain, and Sima Yi didn't spend a single soldier after he arrived at **, and directly cut off his water source, and it didn't take a few days to break himself.

If Zhao Yun goes to guard the street pavilion, Zhao Yun will definitely be able to defend for a long time as long as he guards step by step according to Zhuge Liang's intentions, but in the end he will definitely be captured.

Change the Zhaoyun Street Pavilion, and the Street Pavilion will definitely not be lost.

01, Ma Tan lost the street pavilion, what about Zhao Yun. Ma Tan can be said to be a sinner of Shu Han to be honest, if it weren't for this troublesome operation, maybe Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition would have been successful. Since we talked about the battle of the street pavilion, let's talk about how this guy made a fuss.

At that time, Cao Pi died, and Emperor Cao Rong of Wei Ming had just succeeded to the throne not long afterZhuge Liang saw this as an opportunity, so he began his journey to the Northern Expedition.

Zhuge Liang has made a total of five northern expeditions in his life, and the only time he has a chance to succeed is the first time, but this time he was ruined by Ma Yan'er. Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition, because Cao Wei's defense was insufficient, so the Northern Expedition began very smoothly, until he came to Qishan, Qishan was easy to defend and difficult to attack, Zhuge Liang could not capture Qishan in a short time, and at this time Emperor Wei Ming had come to Chang'an to supervise the battle and sent Zhang He as the vanguard.

Zhuge Liang sent Ma Tan and Wang Ping to meet Zhang He and defend the street pavilion. After Ma Tan came to the street pavilion, he had a comical idea in his head, and wanted to divide the troops into two ways, let Wang Ping guard the street pavilion, and take a team of people to the mountains by himself, Wang Ping advised, but he did not listen。After Zhang He came to the street pavilion, he chose to besiege Ma Tan in the mountain first, cut off its water source, and was finally broken one by one, and the street pavilion was lost, which also caused Zhuge Liang to withdraw his troops.

If the person guarding the street pavilion is replaced by Zhao Yun, I personally feel that the street pavilion will not be lost. First of all, we need to know what the reason for the Ma Tan Dian Street Pavilion isMa Tandi Street Pavilion was mainly because of personal reasons, and it was he who gave Zhang He a chanceIf he doesn't make his own decisions, it is still unknown whether Zhang He can capture the street pavilion.

02, Zhao Yun will definitely be able to guard the street pavilion. If it was replaced by Zhao Yun, Zhao Yun decided not to make such a mistake, but it was not to say how Zhao Yun's ability went wrong. In fact, Zhao Yun has always been exaggerated, and even praised as a fairy-like figure.

But in the official history, Zhao Yun is not so fierce, counting Zhao Yun's achievements in his life, except for saving Liu Chan twice, he rarely wins in battles, and most of the time his performance is average.

Of course, I'm not belittling Zhao Yun, although Zhao Yun is not a top general, but he is also a top general in the second rate, I'm talking about the ability to fight. Zhao Yun is a relatively stable person, and his status in Shu Han was already very high during the Northern Expedition, so he didn't need to be in a hurry to make meritorious contributions like Ma Yan, so I personally speculate that Zhao Yun will not make a fuss, and he will still honestly accept the street pavilion.

At this time, let's look at the abilities of Zhao Yun and Zhang He, to be honest, I personally feel that Zhao Yun's ability to lead troops to fight is not as good as Zhang He. But Zhao Yun's guarding the street pavilion for a while is no problem, and Zhang He is just a vanguard, how many people can the vanguard team have? As long as Zhao Yun stabilizes the waves, Zhang He can't do anything about Zhao Yun in a short time.

And Zhao Yun also has a deputy general, that is, Wang Ping, who closed the street pavilion with Ma Tan. Wang Ping's ability to reason is still very strong, and Zhao Yun is not a person like Ma Yan, who does not listen to the advice of his subordinates, and there is no problem for the two of them to guard a street pavilion together。The important thing is that Zhuge Liang just needs them to drag Zhang He and let him have time to capture Qishan.

Therefore, I personally think that Zhao Yun can definitely defend the street pavilion.

No, because Zhao Yun is very brave in battle, and it must be foolproof to have him guarding the street pavilion.

Won't lose. Zhao Yun is brave and strategic, has rich combat experience, will not make low-level mistakes, and can steadily defend the street pavilion.

I don't think it will be, because Zhao Yun is very powerful, I admire him, and he will keep it.

No, because Zhao Yun is not only very capable, but also respectful of Zhuge Liang, and will not change his layout and strategy casually.

Yes, Zhao Yun has a lot of combat experience, and he is much more powerful than Ma Yan, so he will definitely be able to defend the street pavilion with both wisdom and bravery.

Knowing that it was Zhao Yun guarding the street pavilion, no one should dare to attack, so Zhao Yun could defend the street pavilion!

At that time, it was Zhao Yun who guarded the street pavilion, and Zhao Yun couldn't hold it, because Zhao Yun was brave by nature, stubborn and self-serving, brave and unscrupulous, so it was difficult to keep it.

Yes, Zhao Yun is resourceful and proficient in the art of war, and he will not make such a mistake when guarding the street pavilion.

can't hold it, because Zhao Yun has been following Liu Bei's side and doesn't have much actual combat experience, while Ma Jian has at least been studying by Zhuge Liang's side.

Definitely can't hold it, Zhao Yun followed Liu Bei, only swept the remnants of the defeated army, and did not command the army to fight. Being a minion with Huang Zhong shows that the combat assault is brave, but he can only be a starter. The Battle of Keigu was the only suspicious battle that Zhao Yun was assigned, and he was almost defeated because of his mistakes.

If you believe in the fictional Battle of Hanshui, then you have to believe that Zhao Yun was disabled when there were more soldiers than Cao Zhen, which shows that Zhao Yun is not of great use. ）

The geographical conditions of the street pavilion are very different from what Zhuge Liang said, if Zhao Yun or Wang Ping are asked to guard the street pavilion, they will be more conscientious, but the street pavilion may not be foolproof.

The street pavilion is a military choke point, and it is the kind of terrain that is more suitable for defense than attack. But at that time, when Zhuge Liang explained the topography of Ma Tan Street Pavilion before the Northern Expedition, the strategy had also been deployed, and later Ma Tan also defended the Street Pavilion according to Zhuge Liang's deployment and his own improvisation, that is to say, it was almost completely in accordance with Zhuge Liang's deployment. And if it is replaced by a general with combat experience like Zhao Yun or Wang Ping to defend it, maybe when he sees the difference between the geographical location of the street pavilion and the expectation, he can be more improvised, instead of blindly following Zhuge Liang's deployment, so that he may be able to hold it.

Ma Jian is still relatively talented, but his talent is more about talking about soldiers, and he doesn't have much actual combat experience at all, and Zhuge Liang actually sent Ma Jian to train him. However, Ma Tan did not take Zhuge Liang's order to guard the street pavilion seriously, and one would be foolproof with Zhuge Liang's deployment. When Ma Tan arrived at the street pavilion, he did not take the camp, but ran to the mountains to find out, if the danger came, he could protect himself.

If Zhao Yun or Wang Ping arrived at the street pavilion, they would first follow Zhuge Liang's deployment, and by the way, see if there was any discrepancy in the surrounding terrain, and be prepared to strictly guard the street pavilion. When the enemy arrives, he must fight to kill the enemy instead of thinking about self-preservation. Even if the street pavilion is lost in the end, it must have a clear conscience.

The loss of the street pavilion led to the failure of the first Northern Expedition of Shu Han, which can be said to be caused by Zhuge Liang's improper use of people, but the combat effectiveness of Cao Wei's army is also very strong. When something is wrong, there will be more ways to deal with it than advocating self-preservation.