In the battle of Guandu, why didn t Liu Biao listen to the opinions of his subordinates and attack C

If he goes to attack Cao Cao, Sun Ce will sneak attack Jingzhou, and Sun Ce, the enemy of killing his father, has been staring at it with a tiger's eye.

Moreover, Liu Biao's prestige in the Jingzhou army is not high, his power is insufficient, his military strength depends to a large extent on the Cai family in Jingzhou, and the discord between the three armies is a taboo for sending troops.

You can't deduce the previous decision from the results of history, if you are Liu Biao, if you don't know who won and who lost in the battle of Guandu, do you dare to risk attacking Cao Cao?

I am used to living a leisurely life all my life, and when I get older, I naturally have no enterprising spirit. For him, spending his old age in peace, guarding the territory of Jingzhou, and not causing trouble is the greatest contribution to his ancestors and the people.

Liu Biao is as timid as a mouse. Sit and eat the empty garbage. He didn't think he had come to hit him.

It is enough to enjoy yourself here. Rat-eyed. He saw that Cao Cao was very fierce.

What a broken yellow scarf. Levy Wuheng. That writes merit.

I was scared. Dare to hit someone?

If he had this courage and courage, he would not have sat on the nine counties of Jingxiang and did nothing.

The outside is wide and the inside is taboo, the scheming is indecisive, the talent cannot be used, and the good cannot be accepted.

Who said that there was Liu Biao in the battle of Guandu, the battle of Guandu was the war between Yuan Shao and Cao Cao, the famous battle of Cao Cao won more with less, and you said that it was Liu Biao...

The commanders of the warring sides Yuan Shao and Cao Cao.

Generals Zhang He, Gao Lan (later defected to Cao Cao), Chun Yuqiong, Yuan Shang, Yuan Tan, Xu You (later defected to Cao Cao), Guo Tu, Tian Feng (was imprisoned by Yuan before going to Guandu), Cao Cao, Cao Hong, Cao Zhang, Xiahou Dun, Wang Zhong, Xiahou Yuan.

Strength Approx. 110,000 30,000 to 40,000** Approx. 80,000 Unknown.

Taking advantage of the stalemate between Cao Cao and Yuan Shao in Guandu, Liu Biao attacked Cao Cao from behind, can Cao Cao be destroyed? This question is actually very similar to a question in World War II - if Japan and Germany flanked the Soviet Union, could they destroy the Soviet Union? Cao Cao's position is very bad, and none of the people around him are good stubble.

If these people attack Cao Cao together, I'm afraid Cao Cao will be destroyed several times. Cao Cao certainly knows this better than anyone else. Judging from Cao Cao's previous expeditions, Cao Cao is also trying his best to avoid multi-front battles.

Before the full-scale war with Yuan Shao, Cao Cao had already destroyed Lü Bu, Yuan Shu, Zhang Yang's old subordinates, and others. When Zhang Xiu returned to Cao Cao at Jia Xu's suggestion, Liu Biao directly lost Nanyang County, and the threat to Cao Cao was greatly reduced. When Cao Cao and Yuan Shao were at a stalemate in Guandu, Yuan Shao sent someone to ask Liu Biao to send troops to help; Before that, Zhang Xian, the Taishou of Changsha, under the persuasion of Huanjie, together with Lingling and Guiyang, rebelled.

War is not only fought on the surface, but also outside the battlefield. Zhang Xian and other Jingzhou local judgments, was there any involvement of Cao Cao? Just pacifying the local chaos in Jingzhou involved a lot of Liu Biao's energy.

In addition, Cao Cao also supported Jiaozhi Taishou Shixie, and his intention was self-evident, that is, to let Shixie put pressure on Liu Biao from the south. Whether the strategy is placed in Jiaozhou in the south or Cao Cao in the north is really a problem. At this time, Liu Biao also began to face the choice between going south and going north.

In the end, Liu Biao could only be false to Yuan Shao, because many people at that time were mostly optimistic about Cao Cao. In such an environment, Liu Biao chose and could only choose to give up attacking Cao Cao. It turns out that Liu Biao's choice was correct.

Liu Biao took advantage of the fact that the north was not happy to fight, and greatly consolidated his power, and Jingzhou changed hands after Liu Biao's death.

Looking at Guo Jia, he said that Liu Biao was a "talker", but he made Jingzhou a paradise. At that time, many people went to Jingzhou to escape the war. Returning to this question again, Liu Biao chose to fight with Yuan Shao at that time, can Cao Cao still win the battle of Guandu?

Although Cao Cao can avoid multi-front battles as much as possible, it does not mean that Cao Cao does not have the ability to fight on multiple fronts. Cao Cao was also stabbed in the back and was forced to fight on multiple fronts. Liu Bei and Guan Yu both belong to a power group, and they can't cooperate with each other.

Liu Biao and Yuan Shao, as two forces, are both suspicious masters at critical moments, so it is not difficult to be defeated by Cao Cao.

Even if Liu Biao just wants to stab a knife in the back to get a vote, it is not a simple matter. Lü Meng took advantage of Guan Yu's attack on Cao Cao to capture Jingzhou, which was also done with sufficient preparations in advance. Before Cao Cao attacked Yuan Shao, he also made full preparations in advance, and the defense was to send troops behind Liu Biao.

If Liu Biao starts a war with Cao Cao, he must fight quickly, otherwise once the war falls into a stalemate, Liu Biao himself will be anxious, and he will have to withdraw his troops. Cao Cao's was only a little more difficult, but it was not so much that it would be destroyed by Liu Biao and Yuan Shao.

During the Battle of Guandu, if Qiao Pei Liu Biao attacked Cao Cao from behind, he would definitely succeed. In the battle of Guandu, Cao Cao originally used a small number of filial piety to fight against Yuan Shao's infiltration army. The difference in strength made Cao Cao dare not act rashly for a while, and there were even signs of defeat.

It is impossible, because Cao Cao's ears are very good, and he can hear any wind and grass.

I think it's possible, because Cao Cao is patronizing against Shu and Sun Wu in front, and he won't have a way behind at all.

During the Battle of Guandu, if Liu Biao attacked Cao Cao from behind, he would definitely succeed. In the battle of Guandu, Cao Cao originally fought against Yuan Shao's army with a small number of troops. The difference in strength made Cao Cao dare not act rashly for a while, and there were even signs of rout.

At this time, Liu Biao sneaked up on Cao Cao from behind, and Cao Cao would definitely be defeated, after all, he was attacked by the enemy on his back, and he lost the other. If Cao Cao turned his head to deal with Liu Biao, Yuan Shao could directly take Cao Cao, so Cao Cao did not dare to turn around and deal with Liu Biao, and Liu Biao could deal with Cao Cao without fear.

In the battle of Guandu, Cao Cao's troops were far inferior to Yuan Shao. Yuan Shao had 100,000 elite soldiers and 10,000 horses. And Cao Cao only had 20,000 elite soldiers.

In the era of cold weapons, this disparity in numbers was fatal, which is why battles with fewer victories and more omen are regarded as classics. Yuan Shao lost the first battle, lost Yan Liang and Wen Chou, two generals, but the troops, grain and grass, and armament still occupied a clear advantage, and the war entered a tug-of-war, and finally the war lasted for more than a year, and finally ended because Xu You defected to Cao Cao and offered a plan to attack Wuchao.

In ancient wars, soldiers and horses went first before grain and grass were moved. In addition to soldiers and horses, grain and grass play a decisive role in the victory or defeat of a war. In the days of the stalemate between Cao Cao and Yuan Shao, the people were already tired, and there were not a few who defected.

Cao Jun was short of grain and grass, and Yuan Shao was rich in grain and grass. If Liu Biao attacked Cao Cao at this time, Cao's army would be defeated, but Liu Biao had previously said that he would not help Cao Cao or Yuan Shao, but just watched from the sidelines, which made Cao Cao have a turnaround.

Xu You was originally Yuan Shao's advisor, but Yuan Shao rarely listened to him, so Xu You defected to Cao Cao and gave Cao Cao information about Yuan Shao. After Wuchao was attacked, Yuan Shao's generals also defected to Cao Cao. If Liu Biao came to attack Cao Cao at this time, he would definitely be defeated by Cao Cao.

No, because Sun Ce was also a huge threat at that time, and if he did, he might be killed by Cao Cao instead.

It is possible to succeed, depending on the operational skills and strategic deployment, and Cao Cao has a lot of combat experience in this regard.

Of course not. Because Cao Cao protected himself very tightly, he also ambushed the army behind him.

I think it should be theoretically or absolutely impossible, because at that time, Cao Cao's main force was fighting against Yuan Shao with all his might, so it was already fighting very hard, and many people were also exhausted.

The first thing he did at that time was that Cao Cao had taken precautions and taken measures, and the second point was that when Cao Cao was in the rear, Liu Bei had already taken the corresponding method to stop it.