Guan Yunchang has been invincible all his life, why did he fail in Maicheng?

There were many heroes in the Three Kingdoms period, Guan Yu is one of the more popular among everyone, Guan Yu's martial arts are superb, and he is a famous general of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period. Known as the "Martial Saint" by the world, why Guan Yu, who could pass five levels and kill six generals, was defeated in Maicheng, I think the main reason is the huge disparity in military strength, Guan Yu's own personality problems, and Liu Bei's talent reserve at that time was not enough.

First, there is a huge disparity in military strength. At that time, Guan Yu was the governor of Jingzhou, and his troops were about 30,000 to 50,000 people, who were Guan Yu's main force, and Cao Cao's army of about 100,000 people went to attack Guan Yu one after another.

The second is Liu Bei's cronyism, when Liu Bei had just seized Yizhou, the territory became larger, and there were many generals who needed to be guarded, because Jingzhou was an important place, so the generals who were guarding Jingzhou at that time were Mi Fang (Liu Bei's eldest brother), Liu Feng (Liu Bei's righteous son) and Meng Da, Liu Bei arranged for his relatives to guard Jingzhou, but did not consider that these people and Guan Yu's personality was incompatible, and finally Dr. Ren and Mi Fang rebelled, and Guan Yujun's relatives were captured, which led to the gathering of morale, and finally Guan Yu's army was defeated in Maicheng.

The third is that Guan Yu is too arrogant and stubborn. Guan Yu himself has an arrogant personality, he looks down on a few people sent by Liu Bei to guard Jingzhou, he doesn't know how to restrain himself, he feels very good, too proud, at that time Sun Quan wanted to marry his son to Guan Yu's daughter, but Guan Yu looked down on him, and said, "How can my daughter marry your son", of course, Sun Quan, as a generation of monarchs, must be angry, and Guan Yu is so humiliated by him, it must be unbearable, so he decided to attack Jingzhou.

There are many reasons, such as the disparity in strength of this battle, but I think arrogance is the main reason, because pride underestimates the enemy and does not make more proper arrangements.

Martial saint Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, and defeated Maicheng because of the disparity in military strength between the enemy and us, as well as Liu Bei's nepotism, and then Guan Yu's arrogant personality and too arrogant.

There are many reasons for Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng, there is a gap in military strength, and there are also personal reasons for Guan Yu, and the success or failure of every battle is not the reason of one person.

Because Guan Yu was outnumbered and isolated, there was no help from reinforcements. And the enemy is menacing, and there are many generals in charge, and morale is high.

I think it's mainly because Guan Yu is too confident, thinking that his decisions are all right, and he doesn't listen to other people's advice.

It is said that it was because Liu Bei did not send troops to support Guan Yu at that time, and Guan Yu had no choice but to go into Maicheng alone to fight to the death, how could it be because of arrogance, no matter how arrogant a person is, he will not die.

Because Sun Quan sent many generals to encircle and suppress Guan Yu, and arranged to lure him in, Guan Yu really couldn't fight, and no one helped him when he asked for support.

Guan Yunchang lost in Maicheng, mainly because their military conditions were quite different, and Liu Bei was also proud of himself.

The defeat of Maicheng was not only because of Guan Yu's arrogance, but also because of the huge disparity in strength between the enemy and Guan Yu, and the lack of capable generals in Guan Yu's army was also one of the reasons.

First, there are not many enemies for heroes, second, there is no one to support, and third, it may really be the end of the hero, after all, there are too many changes on the battlefield.

Guan Gong started to attack Cao in Jingzhou, but he did not resist. Wu Lumeng took advantage of the situation and attacked Jingzhou (actually Jiangling). Guan Gong returned to rescue Jingzhou, the troops were insufficient, and the reinforcements of the Cao army had arrived, Guan Gong not only did not recapture Jingzhou, but fell into the front and back attacks of the Cao and Sun families, and suffered from the enemy's back, so he led the remnants of the army to retreat to Maicheng.

The nearest reinforcements were in Shangyong, and the guard Liu Feng Mengda chose not to save (in fact, Shangyong's troops were insufficient, so if you save it, you are likely to get in), so Guan Gong's entire army was wiped out.

From the seventy-sixth episode of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Xu Gongming fought against the water, and Guan Yunchang was defeated and took Maicheng. Maicheng is in Lianghe Township, Dangyang City, more than 20 kilometers away from Pingyang Town. It was an important city of Chu in the Eastern Zhou Dynasty, and the seat of Zhaoqiu County in the eighteenth year of Emperor Kaihuang of Sui (593 AD).

Tongzhi of the Qing Dynasty recorded in the "Dangyang County Chronicles": "Maicheng is fifty miles southeast of the county, between the two rivers of Fuzhang, and is built by King Zhao of Chu. During the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu was attacked by Sun Quan, and Xibaomai City was here."

This is what I just cut out (36 words): Guan Yu started to replace Cao Jun with Jingzhou soldiers, and he didn't give up. Lü Meng took advantage of the situation and attacked Jingzhou. The nearest reinforcements were in Shangyong, so Guan Yu's entire army was wiped out.

Guan Yugong couldn't get into the city, and he was attacked by Lu Meng on the back road. had to return to Jingzhou. Lü Meng appeased the people in Jingzhou, and Guan Yu's corporals heard that their families were fine, and they fled one after another.

Guan Yu asked Liu Feng, Mi Fang and others for help. However, because Guan Yu was usually arrogant, he treated 2 people slowly. There was no rescue for the two.

As a result, when Guan Yu arrived in Maicheng, the soldiers were centrifuged, and the grain and grass were insufficient. When Guan Yu broke through, he tripped over a tripping horse. Captured and killed by Soochow.

The easiest rock game.

Shu Guan Yu was too arrogant, and Lu Xun of Eastern Wu took advantage of this to pretend to praise Guan Yu's merits and let him relax his vigilance. Sure enough, Guan Yu planned to leave Jingzhou north to fight Cao, but Lü Meng took the opportunity to cross the river in white clothes and quickly seize Jingzhou, only to end up with Guan Yunchang finally defeated Maicheng.

Slightly more detailed.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, and was flooded in the forbidden Seventh Army, and the military power was greatly boosted, and Cao Cao had proposed to move the capital to avoid its edge. In October of the 14th year of the Second Jian'an Rebellion (219), Jiangdong general Lü Meng took advantage of the confrontation between Guan Yu and Fancheng defender Cao Ren to attack Jingzhou and captured Guan Yu's base camp Jiangyu Zao Tomb. Guan Yu was attacked on both sides, and hurriedly withdrew his troops from Fancheng to the west and stationed in Maicheng.

Lü Meng adopted a strategy of division and disintegration, so that Guan Yu's soldiers had no intention of fighting and gradually dispersed. Guan Yu was isolated and helpless, and held on to Maicheng. Sun Quan sent someone to lure Guan Yu to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, set up a banner at the head of the city, pretending to be a sergeant, but he fled, only more than ten horsemen followed.

Sun Quan sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang to cut off Guan Yu's various ways, captured Guan Yu and his son Guan Ping in Linfu, and immediately executed them.

The explanation in Mandarin is: two fists are hard to beat four hands, and a good man can't stand up to many people。From God's point of view, Guan Yu's defeat is actually a reasonable thing, and his defeat is due to his own arrogance.

Guan Yu, the word cloud is long, a native of Xie County, Hedong County in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, because he has a three-foot long hair, he is also called "beautiful bearded man" by the worldGuan Yu's martial arts are superb, the Qinglong Yanyue knife in his hand weighs eighty-two pounds, sits down a thousand chasing the wind and red rabbit horses, travels thousands of miles a day, and goes up the mountain and down the water like walking on the ground。At the same time, Guan Yu is loyal and unparalleled, was captured by Cao Cao, Cao Cao in order to receive Guan Yu's heart, on the horse a mention of gold, off the horse a mention of gold, three days of a small banquet and five days of a big banquet, Baoyu beauty does not want money to give Guan Yu, and in the name of the imperial court Guan Yu as the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. Even so, it still failed to impress Guan Yu's heart, and after learning the news of Liu Bei, Guan Yu resolutely left Cao CaoThousands of miles to ride alone, pass five passes and kill six generals, but also return to Liu Bei's side, Guan Yu's behavior was praised by later generations as "righteousness".

After Liu Bei's power expanded with the assistance of Zhuge Liang, he handed over the responsibility of Jingzhou's defense to Guan Yu. Before Zhuge Liang left Jingzhou, he had told Guan Yuqian thousands of instructionsTell Guan Yu to keep in mind the eight-character policy of guarding Jingzhou: Sun Quan in the east and Cao Cao in the north

Although Guan Yu verbally agreed, it can be seen from what he did afterwards that he did not take Zhuge Liang's established policy seriously at all. Because Guan Yu was too arrogant, he felt that his thoughts were the most correct

In order to deal with Liu Bei, who was far away in Xichuan, Guan Yu mobilized his troops in Jingzhou and went north to attack Cao, aiming at Fancheng, which was guarded by Cao Ren, the general of Cao Wei. The early part of the campaign went well, Guan Yu besieged Fancheng, and with the help of Tianshi, flooded the Seventh Army, captured the forbidden Pang De, shocked Huaxia, and reached the pinnacle of life. However, the extremes of things must be reversedCao Cao saw that it was difficult to defeat Guan Yu, so he secretly contacted Sun Quan, hoping that Sun Quan could sneak attack Jingzhou, so that Sun Quan could get the coveted territory of Jingzhou, and Cao Wei could relieve the siege of Fancheng.

After Sun Quan received Cao Cao's request, he did not send troops immediatelyInstead, he thought about the relationship between the Sun-Liu Alliance, and first sent someone to negotiate with Guan Yu, hoping to marry Guan Yu and marry Guan Yu's daughter to Sun Quan's son, so that the Sun-Liu Alliance could be more reliable and reject Cao Cao. If anyone else, they may not refuse this olive branch that they took the initiative to send, but Guan Yu is not someone else, in Guan Yu's arrogant mind, except for Zhang Fei, who can afford Liu Bei, everyone else is not in Guan Yu's sight, including Sun Quan. Originally, refusal is rejection, and it is not difficult to find a more euphemistic reasonBut Guan Yu didn't do this, but scolded directly, saying that how could his tiger girl marry Sun Quan's dog, and also drove away Sun Quan's messenger.

Guan Yu, with his own strength, smashed the Sun-Liu alliance that Zhuge Liang had worked so hard to maintain。After Sun Quan was humiliated by Guan Yu, he directly sent Lü Meng to cross the river in white clothes and attacked Jingzhou.

Guan Yu's defeat is no wonder to others, and the cause he planted himself has such a result.

The main reason is that Guan Yu was too arrogant and looked down on the heroes and heroes of all walks of life at that time, so that Sun Quan and Cao Cao joined forces and finally had no choice but to defeat Maicheng.

Guan Yu himself was more conceited, did not handle the relationship with Soochow well, and did not follow the advice of his subordinates at the critical moment, so it led to failure.

Personal heroism swelled, and contrary to the diplomatic line of "rejecting Cao Cao in the north and Sun Quan in the south" formulated by Zhuge Liang, he acted arbitrarily and arbitrarily, rejecting the friendship of the envoys of Eastern Wu, and undermining the united front.

Because Guan Yunchang at that time was too proud and fell for the tricks of Wu State, he lost Jingzhou and defeated Maicheng

First of all, his enemy Cao Cao is also very powerful, and he is a famous military strategist in history, and secondly, his pig teammates do not cooperate with him.

All his life, he regarded himself as Qinggao and felt that his martial arts were also invincible in the world, so he swelled up very much and despised his opponents.

Guan Yu's "arrogance" looks down on Sun Quan the most. Whether Sun Quan fights Jingzhou or not, it was originally between the two. Zhuge Jin's idea for him was exactly what Sun Quan wanted.

Sort of, after all, in the late Three Kingdoms, as soon as Lu Bu died, there were few people who could fight, so he was careless.

I believe that his failure was not just the result of carelessness, but of his behaviour and personality over the years, because he was so extreme that he could not be criticized.

It's because of cornering. Guan Yu lost Maicheng because he chose Maicheng because he was desperate, so he was not careless.