Which is the most powerful compared to Zhuge Liang or Sima Yi?

In the official history, who is more powerful Sima Yi or Zhuge Liang? In fact, for this problem, whether it is from the "Three Kingdoms" or other historical books, Sima Yi is far inferior to Zhuge Liang, Sima Yi and Chen Qun's small alliance in the early stage was crushed by Xun Yu and Xun You, and they died before these two jumped on the stage**.

Let's talk about "Three Kingdoms" first, in the Three Kingdoms, Sima Yi asked for war for thousands of miles, endured all kinds of humiliation, and faced Zhuge Liang, such a scumbag commander, I believe Sima Yi didn't want to do this, after all, when he destroyed Meng Da, he was majestic. The loss of the famous general Zhang Jaw, which is also recorded in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, Cao Cao's five sons and generals were killed by Sima Yi in this way, whether it is true or false, Zhang Jaw was killed by your Sima Yi, and Wei lost another general. Judging from this alone, Sima Yi is not as good as Zhuge Liang, at least he suffered defeat.

Let's talk about the other two history books, "Book of Jin", "Spring and Autumn of Han Jin", and "Zizi Tongjian", which are also books of the Jin Dynasty, which record many deeds concealed by Chen Shou, such as the Battle of Lucheng, Shangfeng Cutting Wheat, Fear of Shu Like a Tiger, Sima Yi's Sneak Attack on Zhuge Liang and Returned in a Defeat, and Death Zhuge Scared away the 100,000 army of Huozhong. Chen Shou avoided these deeds related to Sima Yi, this is not to avoid the scandal of the Sima family, but why?

In the official history, it is impossible to find the deeds of Sima Yi who defeated Zhuge Liang, but there are many places where Sima Yi was defeated, so in terms of military talent alone in history, Sima Yi is far inferior to Zhuge Liang, and Zhuge Liang is an outstanding military strategist in China, Sima Yi is just an ordinary military strategist, and the gap between the two is not a little.

In modern times, many people return the Three Kingdoms to Jin, and then pull it to the duel between Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang, this is a matter of the bull's head and the horse's mouth, Sima Yi seized the Cao family's power, and it is not the Shu Han regime, how can Sima Yi be more powerful than Zhuge Liang? Secondly, even if Sima Yi's descendants destroyed Shu and Eastern Wu, how much does this have to do with you Sima Yi, you have been dead for decades, this is all the credit of your descendants, and it will be counted on you and Zhuge Liang? If according to this logic, Cao Cao is not as good as Sima Yi, because the world was usurped by Sima Yi, and Cao Cao has to fight with the living Sima Yi as a dead man.

There are really many phenomena in modern society, which are incomprehensible, and I don't know whether this social phenomenon is good or bad.

Sima Yi not only 'consumed' Zhuge Liang, but his own strength (strategy, courage) was also a few points stronger than Zhuge Liang.

In real history, the intelligence of two people is comparable, and they win and lose each other's battles, and they are not so mysterious as in **.

Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang was much more powerful than Sima Yi in the early stage, and even Sima Yi was very jealous of Zhuge Liang in the later stage.

Sima Yi is more powerful, because Sima Yi finally controlled the Cao Wei regime and laid the foundation for his descendants to unify the world.

Zhuge Liang is even more powerful, because Liu Bei invited him out of the mountain when he had nothing, and he could still help Liu Bei build the country.

Whether it's great or not, it depends on which aspect. In my opinion, Sima Yi is powerful, but Zhuge Liang is even more popular. The most respected thing in traditional Chinese culture is the "choice of righteousness and benefit".

In other words, when morality and interests conflict, the person who chooses morality will be remembered in history. Let's take a look at Zhuge Liang's life, in the past, he was Mr. Wolong, and Liu Bei, a down-and-out imperial prince who sold straw shoes, visited the thatched house and invited him out of the mountain. After coming out of the mountain, Mr. Liu Bei, who was a mercenary everywhere, actually won one-third of the world and became the emperor.

This shows Zhuge Liang's ability. And when Liu Bei died, he told Zhuge Liang, Liu Adou, this kid, you see that he can become a weapon, and if he doesn't succeed, you will directly become the emperor. Zhuge Liang immediately expressed his loyalty to Liu Chan, and then he was loyal, he died, and his son Zhuge Zhan committed suicide in defeat.

It can be said that making pants is not a hard work, and it is just death.

Let's take a look at Sima Yi, he was not taken seriously in the early days of Cao Agui's post-queen group. Later, after Cao Cao's strategists were repeatedly reduced, Cao Apu reluctantly used it, and was very suspicious of Sima Yi's character, thinking that he was not loyal enough to be honest and sincere, and was suspected of usurping the throne. Sima Yi is old and serious, the city is very deep, and in order to save his life, even pretending to be crazy and stupid seems so real, and he has deceived wave after wave of spy eyes.

It is estimated that Sima Yi thought in his heart, Cao Cao, Cao Cao, Lao Tzu followed you to the north and south, and there is no merit and hard work. I am not a usurper, so why do you force me to die? Rather than my whole family dying on trumped-up charges in the future, I should find an opportunity to take his place!

When Cao Cao didn't die, Sima Yi didn't make any moves. When Cao Pi was not dead, Sima Yi did not make any moves. The level of the later emperors was too poor, and Sima Yi got the opportunity to establish his own Jin Dynasty.

The ancients said: Those who steal the country are marquis, and those who steal hooks are punished. If it's deep, let's not say it.

Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang fought several times in their lives, Sima Yi was frightened back by the empty city plan, and was almost burned to death in Shanggu but finally escaped, and there should be no winner in the long-term confrontation. Sima Yi was defeated repeatedly, exchanging defeat for time and space, and finally dragged Zhuge Liang down. Purely in terms of who is more powerful, Zhuge Liang is undoubtedly higher than Sima Yi.

Sima Yi. In fact, in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the author wrote Zhuge Liang to God, and Zhuge Liang himself was an ordinary strategist. And Sima Yi is a hero.

It depends on what angle you look at, Zhuge Liang is indeed better than Sima Yi in terms of wisdom, but Sima Yi is both civil and military, can arrange troops to fight wit, and can also carry a gun on a horse to fight bravely, from this point of view, Sima Yi is better than Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang is really powerless.

Different people have different opinions, but it is certain that Zhuge Liang is definitely not as legendary as the legend!!

It's hard to say that war is good, the time and place are favorable, and sometimes luck is also the key to success or failure.

Personally, I think Liu Bei doesn't have Cao Cao's strategy and strategy. But it is also divided into three parts of the world with Cao Cao. This shows that competence is not the key to success or failure.

Of course it's Zhuge Liang, when he set up an empty city plan, Sima Yi was scared and didn't dare to enter!!

Sure Sima Yi, no doubt. sang the praises of Zhuge Liang in the history books, but only to promote the need for royal orthodoxy, Zhuge Liang was written more sharply. But in history, Zhuge Liang really didn't have anything.

After all, Sima Yi is directly a power center gamer, and in the end, there are some achievements in history!

It must be Zhuge Liang who is powerful, haven't you heard a sentence in the Three Kingdoms, Wolong Fengxiao has to be able to settle the world alone, in the Northern Expedition, Sima Yi was defeated by Zhuge Liang many times, and once he was almost captured alive, after Zhuge Liang retreated from the enemy, Sima Yi said that I am not as good as him, Zhuge Liang also scared Sima Yi after his death, if Shu was not supported by Zhuge Liang, there would be no Shu State at all, no matter from any point of view, Zhuge Liang must be better than Sima Yi.

Sima Yi: He has luck, but Zhuge Liang doesn't.

Of course, it was Zhuge Liang, when he set up an empty city plan, Sima Yi retreated.

Of course, it was Sima Yi, and his situation determined his wisdom.

In terms of prudence, Sima Yi was more cautious than Zhuge Liang, but it was because he was too cautious that he was deceived by Zhuge Liang's empty city plan. In terms of intelligence, the two are not comparable. But in terms of military talent, Sima Yi is much more powerful than Zhuge Liang in this regard.

At one point, the demise of Shu was actually caused by Liu Bei's willfulness and Liu Chan's incompetence. Originally, there was only one step away from unifying the whole country in Shu, and it was because Liu Chan listened to the villain's words that Shu was defeated and killed. On the contrary, Sima Yi was different, he taught his son well, and later unified the whole country and established the Jin Dynasty.

Zhuge Liang is smart, but Sima is hard

Some people say that "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has improved Zhuge Liang at every turn, and it seems that only he knows the official history. Actually, does he really understand the official history?

This question of the landlord was judged as early as the late Three Kingdoms. Zhang Yan, a third-party person from Eastern Wu other than Liu Shu and Cao Wei, once wrote the following article:

Wu Dahonglu Zhang Yan made a silent note, and his description of the book of Liang and Sima Xuan Wang said: . .Zhuge and Sima were the two phases, and they were given the honor of the master, or they were awarded to Shu Han, or they were named in Yi and LuoIn the past life, the advantages and disadvantages of the two phases can be obtained and detailed.

Kong Ming Qiba, the land of Shu, the land of a state, the big country of Fang, its warriors and people, cover one-ninth also, and to pay tribute to the Great Wu, resist the northern enemy, to make the ploughing and warfare have an army, the criminal law is neat, tens of thousands of foot soldiers, long drive Qishan, and have the ambition of drinking Mahe and Luo.

Zhongda is ten times the land of the world, and the people who have annexed it, and the prison city has the elite, and there is no intention of the enemy, so that he can protect himself, so that he can go freely. If this person does not die, and his will ends, he thinks about it year after year, and he plots day by day, then Liang and Yong will not dissolve the armor, China will not release the saddle, and the trend of victory and defeat has also been decided.

Today's Zhongda's talent is reduced to Kong Ming. The above quotations are all selected from the official history "Pei Songzhi's Note * Three Kingdoms * Zhuge Liang Biography").

If Kong Ming hadn't died halfway, the final victory would have been his. Therefore, Sima Yi's talent is not as good as Zhuge Liang's - this is the objective conclusion of the people who witnessed the incident at that time. It's better than either.

The so-called research of people in 1 or 2,000 years is convincing.

Although celebrities are dead, history does not repeat itself. But from the reading of historical materials and plays, it can be seen that Kong Ming's talent is far better than Zhongda.

1. Before the Battle of Jieting, Kong Ming set up a village in Jieting before Zhongda, and Sima Yi said after hearing the news: Kong Ming is really a god!

2. The Battle of Qishan? , Zhuge wept ghosts and gods, harvested Longxi wheat, Sima Yi said afterwards: Zhuge Liang is a god, he will make heaven and earth, and the generals don't have to chase it.

3, the Battle of Qishan 6, after Kong Ming's death, Sima Yi chased and was frightened away by the wax figure, and sighed afterwards: Dead Zhuge scared back the living Zhongda, and laughed. At this time, it was widely spread among the people.

4, the Battle of Qishan 6, Sima Yi watched the stars at night, the host and guest two stars were bright and dark, and said: I didn't believe in the stars before, but after fighting with Kong Ming, I have seen it so far, and I can't help but believe it.

5, the Battle of Qishan 5, Sima Yi's wooden ox and horse said: Kong Ming is really a talented man in the world.

6, Cao Cao's important strategist, Chen Yu: This person's talent is better than ours hundreds of times and thousands of times. Xu Shu also said this.

Looking at it again, Zhuge Liang is the first wise man in the Three Kingdoms. The mother is undoubted.

Zhuge Liang is more like a politician, his famous battles were fought for him by Mr. Luo Guanzhong, and Sima Yi was both civil and military - the Sima family established the Jin Dynasty, but the Shu Kingdom was destroyed, so I think Sima Yi is a little more powerful.

Zhuge Liang is slightly better, and with the same conditions, Sima Yi can't do as well as Zhuge Liang, of course, it's also for **. It's just that no matter how strong a person is, he can't change anything.

Dead Zhuge can live Zhongda, but after all, one dies or, whoever lives long wins.

In history, Zhuge Liang is not as divine as written in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and there are many schemes that Luo Guanzhong used to put on him. It is recommended to take a look at the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Although I personally like Zhuge Liang very much, six out of Qishan!

But objectively speaking, I think Sima Yi is more powerful. After all, in the end, it is still the world of the Sima family, ......

Sima Yi, although he is inferior to Zhuge Liang in intelligence, is far superior to Zhuge in endurance.

Sima Yi is far-sighted, able to bend and stretch, and wins steadily and better than Zhuge Liang.

There are only losers and winners in war, and there are no process sympathy awards.

If you want to say who is powerful, of course, the winner is king, and it is always the successful person who can tamper with history, so I think Sima Yi is still a little stronger.

But if you want to talk about dialectics, then I will still maintain the style of our party, half of each of them.

Both of them are garbage, Zhuge Liang is powerful, isn't it also unified, he died before he got out of the school, and the hero was full of tears. A tragedy.

Sima Yi is even more rubbish, he has been up and down all his life, like a dog, guarding against kings, villains, what is the use, and finally helped Sima Shi seize the world in his later years, all of which has nothing to do with him.

Zhuge Liang is powerful;

1. After Zhuge Liang's death, Sima Yi was frightened and retreated, so that the Shu Han army retreated safely;

2. The empty city plan shocked Sima's army, so that Sima Yi did not dare to attack;

3, Sima Yi is suspicious and cautious, and the political means are tough, Zhuge Liang is loyal to the country, dedicated, not as good as Sima Yi in the political game, Sima Yi is not as good as Zhuge Liang from a military point of view, from a political point of view, Sima Yi's ambition and conspiracy can swallow mountains and rivers, and Zhuge Liang is indeed a loyal person.

In terms of the overall situation, Zhuge Liang is not as good as Sima Yi.