Liu Bang children. The villain Xiang Yu is the real big hero and hero

Updated on history 2024-04-21
21 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    I don't really recognize Xiang Yu as a hero. He did things exactly according to his own likes and dislikes, and he went to Xianyang to burn and plunder, and heard that the fire burned for more than a month, which greatly disappointed the people. Compared with Liu Bang, he can listen to the advice of his subordinates, and he does not commit any offense with Minqiu.

    Although his heart was also itching, looking at the gold and silver treasures. But he still endured it, one was that he was afraid of Xiang Yu, and the other was to buy people's hearts. Kill two birds with one stone!

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    As the saying goes: the big husband can bend and stretch. Xiang Yu lacks this, so Liu Bang has the world in mind, dares to do but does not dare to be, can endure what Xiang Yu can't bear, these "qualities" became Han Gaozu, so everyone's values are different, maybe Xiang Yu's biggest wish is to be able to be with his Yu Ji forever happy.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Xiang Yu is a bit like Yuan Shao, but he doesn't listen to any beneficial opinions, so the Hongmen banquet let Liu Bang escape. But his own ability is very strong, so he defeated the Qin army of 200,000. But Liu Bang's generals and military advisors are smarter than Xiang Yu, not comparable to the Qin army.

    Hence the loss. It was mainly the problem of talent and treatment of talent that made Xiang Yu lose.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    But soldiers don't get tired of cheating. Although I also hate Liu Bang, I have to admit that Xiang Yu was defeated by his benevolence.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Yes; Liu Bang Xiao'er can be the emperor because he is a villain; Because he can pretend to be righteous and righteous, and the most powerful is to deceive people.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    You horses, don't understand history, you are yelling and screaming here, and you have nothing to look at the historical records.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Why is Liu Bang treated the people well as a villain, and Xiang Yu is a murderer, but he is regarded as a hero?

    Because Xiang Yu is a person who values love and righteousness, and Liu Bang pushed his daughter out of the car in order to achieve his goal, and also hurt the personal behavior of the daughter who sheltered his family, there is nothing to say, there is no impeccable treacherous villain. Xiang Yu is a person who values love and righteousnessAlthough Xiang Yu was unsuccessful at the end, he is really a person who values love and righteousness, he has been fighting all his life, and there are many victories, he can say that he wants power and power, and there are some people who want people, but he only loves one woman in his life, that is, Sun Shangxiang, according to today's point of view, he is a peerless good man. When he surrounded Liu Bang, he didn't cry, but when he saw Sun Shangxiang and was worried about Sun Shangxiang's future life, he immediately cried.

    Let's take a look at Liu Bang, although his army management is quite good, he will not bother the people, and he thinks about the people in everything, but Liu Bang's mentality towards his parents and children is very bad, and he really feels like an orphan, and his family is not important, especially in ancient times, the most important thing was loyalty, filial piety, benevolence and righteousness. Probably told it to future generations. Liu Bang is a villainSo how can a king with a human heart come to everyone and say that he is a treacherous villain, and that he is a rogue king?

    I think everyone will say this, and there is a reason, Liu Bang's own personal behavior will be inappropriate, he can't win the other side in the battle of Pengcheng, so he can only escape.

    On the way to escape, he met a warm-hearted person to take in his family, all of them were in the Qi family, I think everyone didn't expect it, Liu Bang took a fancy to the daughter of the Qi family, and he didn't care whether other girls wanted it or not, and directly forced him to have sex with the daughter of the Qi family, which was too scummy. There is also a more excessive thing, when she fled west, the car he was sitting in was too heavy because there were too many people, so he couldn't run fast, and directly pushed his daughter out of the carA person doesn't even have the most basic filial piety, it's all for himself, his family doesn't want it, and the world will definitely say that he is a villain.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    It has a certain relationship with dealing with people, and it also has a certain relationship with some historical records, Xiang Yu is more righteous in the rivers and lakes, so he has been sought after by many people Yu Chunzi.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The former is a very selfish person who has a lot of hooliganism and a lot of bad treatment for his family, while the latter is a very dedicated person.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    This is because of some behaviors, in the dynasty of the time, there were many nobles, and ordinary people were not important to some people.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Many people have the impression in their minds that Xiang Yu is a hero and Liu Bang is a villain, so they are puzzled by the ending of the Chu-Han rivalry in which Xiang lost Liu Sheng. In fact, this impression is wrong, and the reason for Xiang Liu's victory is obvious.

    First of all, Xiang Yu is the villain, and Liu Bang is the hero.

    I believe that many people have seen the fragment of "Historical Records: Xiang Yu Benji", thinking that Xiang Yu can carry the tripod and pull out the mountains and cover the world, and is a big hero, but in fact, Xiang Yu is just a reckless man, and he is a reckless man with a strong villain habit, Xiang Yu's start was started by killing Xiang's benefactor will be Yin Tong, Xiang Yu's second rise in Chu was by killing his boss Song Yi, Xiang Yu obtained the power to slaughter the world, and it was by coercing Pei Gong Liu Bang, Xiang Yu broke his promise and sealed Liu Bang in Bashu, As for Xiang Yu taking Liu Bang's father hostage when the two armies were facing each other, and shooting Liu Bang with a hidden arrow when he was reasonable, they were all villains familiar to the majority of readers, and these behaviors put together can only prove that Xiang Yu is a villain.

    And Liu Bang is different, Liu Bang has always been regarded as a "lenient elder", "benevolent and loving", "often generous", Liu Bang since Pei County, whether it is to destroy Qin or Chu, and even the later princes and kings, they are all hands-on, what is this not a hero?

    Secondly, Xiang Yu can not use people, but he can't use people.

    As we all know, Han Xin and Chen Ping were originally all in Chuying, and they were all under Xiang Yu's command, but Xiang Yu never really reused them, and they had to go to the Han camp in the end, and when they went to the Han camp, Liu Bang, the king of Han, let them shine. Missing a few talents, this is not a serious matter, the serious thing is that Xiang Yu uses people is very problematic, and Long He should be Xiang Yu's first great Sima, with 200,000 Chu troops to rescue Qi State, and was wiped out by Xiang Yu in the first battle. Cao Zhi should be Xiang Yu's second great Sima, when Xiang Yu fought with Peng Yue, Cao Zhi was responsible for defending Chenggao, but after a day or two of kung fu, Liu Bang recaptured Chenggao, and the incompetent Cao Zhi was chased and killed by the Han army and could only commit suicide.

    Zhou Yin should be Xiang Yu's last great Sima, guarding Jiujiang for Xiang Yu, but was successfully lured by Liu Jia to surrender, leading the Chu army stationed in Jiujiang to go to Xiaxia, wanting to put Xiang Yu to death. All kinds of facts show that Xiang Yu is capable of not using people, but he can't use people, in this case, can Xiang Yuyan be undefeated?

    All in all, Xiang Yu is not a hero, and Xiang Yu is also very problematic in employing people, so Xiang Yu's failure is inevitable.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because Xiang Yu's army at that time was brave and good at fighting, and it was well-equipped, he didn't take Liu Bang in his eyes at all, but Liu Bang seized this point and united other countries to collectively crusade against Xiang Yu, so he defeated Xiang Yu.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because although Xiang Yu is very powerful in martial arts, he is inferior to Liu Bang in terms of wisdom, and he can't judge some things very rationally, Xiang Yu's character determines his failure.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Xiang Yu will be limited to a secular framework when making any decisions, but Liu Bang can break these mundane and pursue a higher cost performance.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    "Historical Records: Xiang Yu Benji" He is a stubborn person with a strong villain habit. Xiang Yu started by killing Xiang's benefactor and guarding Yin Tong. Liu Bang is considered to be "a benevolent and loving person, a generous elder and a generous person".

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Xiang Yu is indeed a hero, this is understandable, but no one stipulates that a hero must win, and a villain does not necessarily have to lose.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Liu Bang was able to take care of the overall situation and make the best use of the people, so that this group of luxury strategists, who can be called the top in the ages, and the lineup of generals can give full play to their talents perfectly under his command, which is obviously beyond Xiang Yu's reach. Secondly, Liu Bang took the four words "thick face and black heart" to the extreme, and he didn't want to be embarrassed, which was not comparable to Xiang Yu.

    We all know that in the Han Dynasty, there was a famous "Gaozu", who once led Han Xin, Zhang Liang and other top talents to defeat the invincible Western Chu overlord Xiang Yu in the four-year Chu-Han War, and won the great cause of the world; Eventually, the Han Dynasty lasted for four hundred years, and the Chinese, to this day, are still known as "Han Chinese" by the public.

    That's right, this legendary figure is, of course, the famous Han Gaozu Liu Bang. Compared with Liu Bang's legendary experience, the public often relish his old enemy Xiang Yu. After all, Xiang Yu is a legendary genius who was born out of thin air and has the template of "Long Aotian" in all aspects.

    With 50,000 troops, he defeated Zhang Han, who had 400,000 elites;

    not only shattered the myth of the invincibility of "Yabaiqi" Zhang Han, but also wiped out the rule of the Qin Dynasty in one fell swoop. Later, famous classic battles such as the Battle of Pengcheng did not illustrate Xiang Yu's military talent and extraordinary determination. However, Rao is so, he is still not Liu Bang's opponent.

    The biggest reason why Liu Bang can succeed is, of course, because he can take care of the overall situation and give full play to the ability of every talent under his command. For example, Han Xin, who is known as the "Soldier Immortal", Xiao He, who firmly occupies a place in history, Zhang Liang, who "seeks saints", and Chen Ping, who is rampant in the world with intrigue and trickery, etc.

    Their success, of course, has their own ability, but it is also closely related to Liu Bang's reassuring and bold appointment. second, it is Liu Bang's "thick face and black heart", and he has no aristocratic bottom line;

    Just imagine, a person who dares to kick his son out of the car at a critical moment, a person who can talk and laugh and watch his old father jump into the fire pit, how can he not succeed?

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    I think Xiang Yu is indeed inferior to Liu Bang in terms of using troops and strategy, although Xiang Yu is a generation of heroes, but he is definitely not as good as Liu Bang in terms of fighting with soldiers, otherwise he will not be defeated by Liu Bang.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    He is not as good as Liu Bang in terms of knowing and employing people, buying people's hearts, etc., because Liu Bang has a good vision and accepts many talents that Xiang Yu does not look down on for his own use.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    In the eyes of some readers who don't read the official history, Liu Bang, the ancestor of the Han Dynasty, is a villain, and Xiang Yu, the overlord of Western Chu, is a big hero, and is puzzled that the villain finally defeated the big hero. But in fact, all this confusion and incomprehension is because these readers who don't read the official history misunderstood Liu Xiang and the others.

    First of all, Liu Bang is not a villain, and Xiang Yu is not a big hero.

    As early as Xiang Liang's death and the consolidation of the power of the Chu State, the Chu State decided to divide the troops into two routes, one to attack Qin in the west, and all the way north to rescue Zhao. The road to the west is the most dangerous, no one dares to go, only Xiang Yu and Liu Bang are willing to go west, but the whole state of Chu agrees that Xiang Yu is a fierce thief and is not a suitable person to go west, Liu Bang is a lenient elder and can help righteousness and go west.

    The meaning of being a fierce and cunning thief is that Xiang Yu is very brave and slippery, as fierce and cunning as a thief. Look at this adjective, it's definitely not describing a big hero, right? How can you describe a great hero as a cunning thief?

    The meaning of the lenient elder is that Liu Bang is a decent person, benevolent and righteous, and has the style of an elder, looking at this adjective, this is by no means describing a villain, right? How can a villain be said to be a lenient elder?

    Secondly, Liu Bang is a real hero, and Xiang Yu is a real villain.

    In the eyes of many people, Liu Bang is a figure who has been defeated repeatedly, and his military skills are not worth mentioning at all. But in the record of "Historical Records", from the beginning of Peixian's incident, Liu Bang has always risked the arrows and stones, destroyed Qin, cut Chu, and punished the princes and kings, Liu Bang has always been at the forefront of the war, never flinching, even if he was injured by Xiang Yu's secret arrow, Liu Bang still got up after a simple bandaging to work the army, this determination is definitely made by heroes and heroes, and Qiao Feng in Jin Yong** is nothing more than that. So I think Liu Bang is a real hero.

    Besides, Xiang Yu, the two armies faced each other, and he wanted to coerce Liu Bang before tying Liu Bang's father into battle, but Liu Bang couldn't be reasonable, so he shot Liu Bang with a crossbow, this is a villain's behavior, as for Xiang Yu's assassination of Yin Tong, the killing of the general Song Yi, and the killing of the righteous emperor Xiong Xin in Jiangnan, they are all villains, such a Xiang Yu is not worthy of the word big hero at all.

    In short, the reason why Xiang Yu lost to Liu Bang is because Xiang Yu is a real villain and Liu Bang is a big hero.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Because Xiang Yu didn't have the ability to gather people, he was reluctant to reward his subordinates, and there weren't many capable people to help him, so he couldn't win the world.

Related questions
9 answers2024-04-21

Xiang Yu, of course. Xiang Yu is enough for a man no matter what, he is a big hero. >>>More

16 answers2024-04-21

In fact, love is very hazy, but the only thing I know is that love is the pillar of a person's spirit, because everyone longs for true love, true love is two people's care for each other, each other's thoughts, no matter when put their hearts in each other's hearts, this is true love, if you love her, learn to love her silently, care about her, and prove it with action, love is not to be said, to be attentive, to understand, to give, to feel, to bear How can true love be so easy to get, If you really want to use your life to protect her, then use your life to prove that if you don't love, leaving is the best choice!!

6 answers2024-04-21

Xiao He, Han Xin, Zhang Liang, Chen Ping, Cao Shen, Wang Ling, Zhou Bo, Peng Yue, Fan Xu.

16 answers2024-04-21

Many people who pay attention to health preservation, they will be particularly concerned about some health knowledge in their daily life, and they will also have a high concern about their usual eating habits and what they eat and drink, and they hope to be able to eat healthy. Not only do they pay attention to some nutritional combinations on some ingredients, but they will also try to choose some healthier water quality when drinking water. For example, for some people who are proficient in health preservation, they will also subdivide water to a certain extent. >>>More

24 answers2024-04-21

Slippery, deep-minded, will use people, can bend and stretch. >>>More