When Guan Yumaicheng asked for help, why didn t Liu Feng save him when he saw death?

The reason why Liu Feng didn't save Guan Yu when he asked for rescue in Maicheng was because Liu Feng had already had the heart to rebel, so he naturally didn't plan to save Guan Yu. Because after Guan Yu died in battle, Meng Da began to pull Liu Feng to surrender to Cao Wei.

In fact, Liu Feng did not have many soldiers and horses in his hands at that time, and he also had to defend against the enemy in the north.

Because he didn't get an order, he didn't dare to use troops without authorization, after all, he was the one who was suspected by Liu Bei.

First of all, the relationship between Liu Feng and Guan Yu is not good, Liu Feng and Guan Yu are both the same kind of strong temperament, once they meet, it is easy to spark, coupled with the instigation of people with intentions, the two are even more incompatible.

Moreover, Liu Feng and Meng Da had problems with the military arrangement, once they were tracked down by Liu Bei, there must always be a reason, Meng Da had an active brain, and first detained the basin to Liu Feng. In the end, Liu Feng was powerless, he had indeed just controlled Shangyong, and he had not yet stabilized his position, after receiving Guan Yu's rescue, he had no one to help, and when he was able to help in the end, he was cut off by Wei Wu.

The defeat of Maicheng is the story of the twenty-fourth year of Han Jian'an, when Shu Han general Guan Yu was intercepted by Wu General when he defeated Maicheng, and was beheaded in frustration. Later, he used the metaphor of "defeating the wheat city" to fall into a desperate situation, describing that people who can succeed in everything also have failures. Maicheng is in Lianghe Township, Dangyang City, Hubei Province, more than 20 kilometers away from Pingyang Town.

It was an important city of Chu in the Eastern Zhou Dynasty, and the seat of Zhaoqiu County in the eighteenth year of Emperor Kaihuang of Sui (593 AD). Qing Tongzhi's "Dangyang County Chronicles" recorded: "Maicheng is fifty miles southeast of the county, and it is said that it was built by King Zhao of Chu.

During the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu was attacked by Sun Quan, and he went west to Maicheng."

Maicheng is located in Lianghe Township, Dangyang City, Hubei Province, more than 20 kilometers away from Pingyang Town. It was an important city of Chu in the Eastern Zhou Dynasty, and the seat of Zhaoqiu County in the eighteenth year of Emperor Kaihuang of Sui (593 AD). Qing Tongzhi's "Dangyang County Chronicles" recorded:

Maicheng is fifty miles southeast of the county, between the two rivers of Fuzhang, and is built by King Zhao of Chu. During the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu was attacked by Sun Quan, and he was defeated and took Maicheng."

Resources.

The reason why Meng Da didn't save Guan Yu: Everyone knows that Meng Da was originally Liu Zhang's subordinate, and the reason why he surrendered to Liu Bei cannot be said to be his choice, but it was also at the instigation of Fa Zheng and Zhang Song that he would have this kind of move. Then, as the first batch of people to surrender to Liu Bei, Zhang Song was killed by Liu Zhang, and Fa Zheng was reused by Liu Bei.

Looking at Meng Da on the other hand, not only did he not get the same treatment as Fazheng, but because he was suspicious, he was sent to the remote Jingzhou by Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei.

As a result, Meng Da's heart began to be unbalanced. Meng Da thought that he had merit in surrendering to Liu Bei, but he was angry with Guan Yu here, and he already had thoughts of betrayal in his heart. And Meng Da's betrayal represents the psychology of the original Shuzhong personnel.

To put it simply, although Liu Bei occupied Shuzhong, the hearts of the people were not all towards Liu Bei, that is to say, from Meng Da's betrayal, it can be seen that Liu Bei's camp is unstable.

The reason why Liu Feng did not save Guan Yu. In fact, Liu Feng's betrayal was both reasonable and unexpected. Liu Feng is nominally Liu Bei's son, but in the final analysis, he is not Liu Bei's own son, but Liu Bei's adopted son.

When Liu Bei first adopted Liu Feng, he was opposed by Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu and others, which also laid the groundwork for Liu Feng not to rescue Guan Yu later.

And the fundamental reason why Liu Feng did not go to the rescue of Guan Yu was that Guan Yu had opposed Liu Bei's canonization of Liu Feng as the prince. In this regard, in the seventy-sixth chapter of the book, "Xu Gongming's War against the Water and Guan Yunchang's Defeat in the Wheat City", there is such a description:

Da smiled and said: "....When he heard about the general of Hanzhong Wang's first heir, Guan Gong was displeased. After the king of the Later Han Dynasty ascended the throne, he wanted to establish an heir ,......The king of Hanzhong then sent people to Jingzhou to ask Guan Gong, who thought that the general was the son of a moth and could not be arrogant, and persuaded the king of Hanzhong to leave the general in the land of Shangyong Mountain City to prevent future troubles.

Perhaps, it was Guan Yu's actions that completely caused Liu Feng to be reluctant to send troops to rescue Guan Yu. However, in fact, Liu Feng did not go to the rescue of Guan Yu, which reflected a microcosm of the power struggle in Liu Bei's camp. Guan Yu supported Liu Chan, not Liu Feng.

Since Liu Feng can't get Guan Yu's support, why should he save him now? Once Guan Yu is rescued, won't he still be reused?

Therefore, on the surface, Liu Feng and Meng Da did not go to rescue Guan Yu because the two of them were afraid that Guan Yu would punish them. In fact, one represents the instability of Liu Bei's camp in Shuzhong, and the other represents the political struggle of Liu Bei's heir. Therefore, the later Shu Han, on the surface, was a ball of harmony, but in fact it was an undercurrent.

Perhaps, this is also the fundamental reason why Shu Han did not dominate the world in the end!

First of all, it must be clear that Meng Da's statement that Liu Feng did not send troops to rescue Guan Yu comes from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", which is a family dialect, not a historical fact. The fact is that after Liu Feng and Meng Da received Guan Yu's letter for help, neither of them agreed to send troops, and it was not the result of Meng Da instigating Liu Feng. So, why didn't Liu Feng and Meng Da launch a rescue of Guan Yu?

According to the record of "Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Liu Feng": "Since Guan Yu surrounded Fancheng and Xiangyang, he even called for Feng and Da, and ordered the troops to help themselves. Sealed and resigned, it was attached to the mountain county at the beginning, and it could not be shaken, and it was not accepted by the feather.

Please note that when Guan Yu asked Liu Feng and Meng Da for help, it was when he besieged Fancheng and Xiangyang, not when he defeated Maicheng, and this difference is very big. We all know that Guan Yu won the battle when he sent troops to besiege Fan Xiang, and he asked Liu Feng and Meng Da to send troops just to ask them to help him expand the results of the battle, not to save his life. This can also be seen from the statement in the above account that "the troops were ordered to help themselves".

This is very clear, Liu Feng and Meng Da did not send troops because they thought that Guan Yu was victorious and there was no need to send troops. This can also answer your question, why Liu Feng and Meng Da did not send troops was because the two of them did not think it was necessary to send troops.

Guan Yu was defeated and took Maicheng, why didn't Liu Feng save him when he saw death? When Liu Feng was given death, he told the truth.

Guan Yu is arrogant (so written in the history books!) Will he go and let someone else save him? He must have thought that he was OK with his abilities to defeat the enemy

In fact, it was useless to save it, Jingzhou was lost. Guan Yu went back to be punished, Liu Bei cut or not?

Liu Feng was not loyal to Liu Bei, so he was the same to Guan Yu, and Liu Feng did not become the crown prince, so he still had a grudge against the Liu Group, maybe he was very happy to see Guan Yu die.

Because Liu Feng was Liu Bei's adopted son at that time, he was disloyal to Liu Bei, and Guan Yu looked down on him at that time, so when Guan Yu was defeated, it was impossible for him to rescue him.

What nonsense, the three counties of Jingzhou guarded by Guan Yu are estimated to have a total strength of no more than 30,000 in their heyday, and the territory of the three counties in the east of the Han Dynasty guarded by Liu Feng is much smaller, how can the total strength be 50,000, it is estimated that there are 20,000 horses!

The real situation is incomprehensible, now look at this problem to understand what the purpose of the rescue is, if Liu Feng sent troops to recapture Jingzhou, there is basically no possibility of this, but it will allow Dongwu to take the opportunity to seize Shangyong. If it is still necessary to send troops to rescue Guan Yu's personal life, Liao Hua can kill Shangyong, not to mention Guan Yu, who is known as the martial saint, the question is that Guan Yu did not go to Shangyong, can he still be killed if he really goes to Shangyong. Guan Yu's death stand objectively said that Liu Feng did nothing wrong, but there was a problem with Guan Yu's planning!

There must be a reason for the effect, because when Liu Bei accepted Liu Feng as a righteous son before, Guan Yu spoke out against it, Guan Yu felt that Liu Bei already had a son, and it was inappropriate to accept the righteous son. This is the main reason why Liu Feng did not come to the rescue.

Because no matter how close the personal relationship is, it is only a working relationship, and you can't meddle in other people's family affairs, how can Liu Bei's matter of establishing a prince be what his brother said, so he didn't go to the rescue when he was defeated.

Where did Liu Feng come from with 50,000 soldiers and horses? Liu Bei's battle against Yiling with the power of Shu was only about 100,000! I'm afraid it's not a brainstorm to ask this kind of question!

In the romance, Meng Da provoked Guan Yu to persuade Liu Bei not to establish Liu Feng as the prince, because Liu Feng was not born to Liu Bei, so Liu Feng held a grudge and refused to send troops to rescue him, resulting in Guan Yu being killed. In the end, Liu Bei also followed Zhuge Liang's suggestion to execute Liu Feng, which inevitably hindered Liu Chan's ascension to the throne in the future.

Isn't this just a grudge, Guan Yu's sentence of the son of a moth actually caused a murderous disaster, which is embarrassing.

I'm afraid there aren't 50,000 soldiers? Liu Bei's battle of Yiling was almost exhausted, and the strength of the whole country was only about 50,000! Also, Guan Yu is a person with high IQ and low emotional intelligence, and he basically has a bad relationship with the people around him.

This is obviously nonsense, Guan Yu in the entire Jingzhou region only has more than 50,000 horses, a mountain city, will Liu Bei give Liu Feng so many people? Where did the number come from?

Jingzhou is the land of the four wars, and it is also the place where the soldiers must fight, Guan Yu is only 30,000 or 40,000 horses as a fake Jieyue, Liu Feng, how can Meng Da say that he has 50,000 soldiers? It's all untrue!

Guan Yusu didn't like Liu Feng, and Liu Feng was of course dissatisfied with him, but he didn't know how serious the consequences of not saving Guan Gong were.

Guan Yu will not command more than 50,000 soldiers in Jingzhou, and Liu Feng will not exceed 10,000 troops in Shangyong plus Meng Da's 4,000 troops.

Liu Feng (?) —220), a native of Changsha (now Xiangyin, Hunan) in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, a general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, and the adopted son of Liu Bei, Emperor Zhaolie of the Shu Han Dynasty. He has martial arts, a strong personality, and extraordinary strength.

With Zhao Yun, Zhang Fei and others swept Xichuan, he had quite a lot of military achievements, and then led Meng Da to capture Shangyong, which was deeply trusted by Liu Bei. But later, Guan Yu went north to Cao Wei and asked Liu Feng many times to raise troops to help, but Liu Feng refused. Then he invaded Meng Da and forced him to surrender to Wei.

Meng Da and Wei Xu Huang attacked Liu Feng together and persuaded Liu Feng to surrender, but Liu Feng did not surrender, and was betrayed by his subordinates and returned to Chengdu. Liu Bei gave Liu Feng to death at the suggestion of Zhuge Liang, and Liu Feng cut himself, and Liu Bei deeply regretted it.

When Liu Bei wanted to establish a prince, he once asked Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu who Liu Feng and Liu Chan should set up, Zhuge Liang said that this was Liu Bei's family matter, and he couldn't ask. Later, Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, Liu Feng hated Guan Yu, so he did not send troops to save him, resulting in Liu Feng being beheaded by Liu Bei.

There are only more than 10,000 people in Zhang Feilang, and 50,000 people from Liu Feng**?

Why did Liu Feng have to send troops to rescue Guan Yu, he had every reason not to send troops and defend himself.

Secondly, Guan Yu launched the Xiangfan Campaign completely on his own initiative and was not instructed by the Yizhou base camp. At first, Guan Yu controlled the battle situation, and the wind and water were smooth, and the flooded Seventh Army shocked China. When he besieged Xiangyang and Fancheng, he successively "ordered" Liu Feng and Meng Da to "send troops to help themselves", instead of using "rescue".

Liu Feng and Meng Da had just succeeded in the mediocre area, and the situation was still unstable, so they refused to send troops. The so-called "generals are outside, and the king's orders are not subject to them", not to mention that Guan Yu is not a "king", his order Liu Feng can be decided according to the situation, sending troops is just a choice, and it is the duty to not move the troops.

Besides, Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son, he should realize that Guan Yu and Jingzhou are extremely important to Liu Bei in every way, and he risks being liquidated in the future and refuses to send troops, and there must be a deeper reason for him.

Finally, from Guan Yu's killing Liu Bei's attitude towards Liu Feng, it can be seen that the name is called. If Guan Yu's death was directly related to Liu Feng's failure to send troops to help, then Liu Bei would not forgive Liu Feng, but the fact is that Liu Bei did not treat Liu Feng well. After a long period of time, Liu Bei did kill Liu Feng, but out.

Because he didn't dare, he didn't dare to do anything that was not within his own responsibility without being ordered by Liu Bei or Zhuge Liang.

Because he didn't dare, he heard that the Wu army was besieging Maicheng, and he was afraid to fight, and at the same time heard Meng Da say that Guan Yu had opposed the establishment of Liu Feng as the prince.

Because Liu Feng and Guan Yu had personal grievances and conflicts of personal interests, these factors led to Liu Feng's deep resentment and dissatisfaction with Guan Yu at that time.

Liu Feng, who had 50,000 troops, was not far from Maicheng, but he did not go to rescue Guan Yu, because when Guan Yu was defeated, there were not many troops he led, and no one thought that he would be defeated so quickly, and he fled alone.

Because although Liu Feng is not far from Maicheng, he also has his own selfishness, and he wants to preserve the strength of his army, so this is the case.

The reason why Liu Feng didn't go to save Guan Yu was because he knew that his strength couldn't save him; And Liu Feng and Guan Yu have contradictions, and they don't want to save them in their hearts.

Maybe Liu Feng thinks that he can't beat Soochow, and Liu Feng and Guan Yu have contradictions. Therefore, there is no salvation when you see death.

First, because he was far away from Guan Yu at that time.

Second, he had relatively little power at the time, and no one listened to him.

Third, the politics at that time were not very stable.

This is because the relationship between the two of them was very stiff at that time, and he didn't want to cause trouble for himself, so he didn't save Guan Yu in the end.

Because he felt that doing so would not bring him any good, and that some of his subordinates would lose their lives.