If there were no immortals during the Shang Dynasty, would it have perished?

During the Shang Dynasty, whether there were immortals or not, the demise was certain, and it was the most useful to promote the development of the times, and the demise of one dynasty brought about the next dynasty.

Whether there are immortals or not, the Shang Dynasty will perish. The Shang Dynasty fell not because of the gods, but because of the war of Muye, and the slave army of the Shang Dynasty turned against the water.

If you're talking about TV**, there are no gods from all walks of life, and it is estimated that there is a halo of the protagonist to continue his life, if you are talking about reality, there must be no gods from all walks of life in real life.

Whether the demise of the Shang Dynasty in history must have been caused by disasters such as Daji and the people, it should be said that so far, there is still conclusive evidence to be found.

The Shang Dynasty will perish. The Shang Dynasty fell not because of the gods, but because of the war of Muye, and the slave army of the Shang Dynasty rebelled.

Even if there are no immortals from all walks of life, they will perish, and the survival and death of a dynasty are not determined by one or two people, but by a combination of factors.

There were no immortals in the Shang Dynasty, and the Romance of the Gods was made up by the Ming Dynasty. At that time, the fall of the Shang Dynasty was inevitable, firstly because of the brutality of the Emperor Xu, and secondly, the growth of Xiqi made it inevitable for them to overthrow the rule of the Shang Dynasty.

I don't think so, there is a protagonist aura to continue his life, if you are talking about reality, there must be no gods of all walks of life in real life.

Because after the Shang Dynasty was crowned a god, the gods all went to heaven. This statement is derived from my country's gods and demons ** "Romance of the Gods", in fact, in folk rumors, there has never been a shortage of so-called "immortals" in all dynasties. In the book "Romance of the Gods", it is about the immortals in the world at the end of the Shang Dynasty who were divided into two factions to fight each other, and in the end, most of them entered the list of gods and were controlled by the heavenly court, and then they all transferred from the human world to the heavenly world, so from then on, the immortals in the human world were no longer visible.

Before the Zhou Dynasty, that is, during the Shang Dynasty, at that time, the world's immortal cultivators were flying all over the sky, and even serving as officials in the world. Looking at the existence of Kong Xuan, the so-called first person under the so-called sage, you can see that his ability is so great that he was an official in the court of the Shang Dynasty and a general soldier. From this, we can imagine that in that era, although there were few immortals compared to mortals, they were not uncommon, at least for mortals, immortals were not rare pandas.

But because of this, it is easy for the world to be in chaos. Because the combat power and destructive power of the gods are too strong. Any immortal who has been cultivating for a few years can inflict death on mortals on a large scale, and a quasi-saint like Kong Xuan, if he wants to, can even destroy the entire human race.

Although for some reason, those immortals can't hurt human beings casually, but at this time, there are not many bad immortals in the world, so the world can be said to be in dire straits.

Therefore, these immortals need to be restrained. But everyone cultivates immortals for freedom, and it is naturally not a simple matter to restrain them, so there is the so-called battle of the gods. The battle of the gods, to put it bluntly, means that the losers will be controlled by the heavenly court, because their souls will be controlled by this magic weapon after entering the god list.

And after the battle of the gods, the immortals who were not controlled by the god list either joined the heavenly court, joined Buddhism, or lived in seclusion, and the general trend of the world was controlled by the heavenly court from then on, so it was difficult to see the immortals in the world again.

Because the social system has changed after the Shang Dynasty, it was impossible to cultivate immortals before, don't be deceived.

Of course, there are no immortals, but because the Shang Dynasty was a slave society before, the rulers needed to use these myths to enslave people's minds.

There is no doubt that many cultural relics unearthed in China can prove that China has at least 5,000 years of history, but there are many myths and few history books in the Shang and Zhou dynasties, so why are they myths and legends before last week, and there are clear historical records after the Zhou Dynasty, is there really a cultivator before the Zhou Dynasty, of course the immortal cultivator does not exist, at most it is a practitioner who knows how to maintain health, and why mythology only existed before the Zhou Dynasty, perhaps it has something to do with our writing and recording methods, Chinese mythology can be traced back to Pangu opening the world, Nuwa created people, and then the three emperors and five emperors appeared, Dayu ruled the water, etc., these seemingly exaggerated myths actually have a certain background, such as Nuwa created people to symbolize that China was a matriarchal society in ancient times, and women dominated the whole society.

Regarding your question, first of all, let me make a few clarifications, not that there are no myths after the Zhou Dynasty, on the contrary, there are still a lot of myths after the Zhou Dynasty, and the myths after the Zhou Dynasty are also extremely exciting. As long as you go to the historical materials quietly, you can find that in fact, after the Zhou Dynasty, people still did not give up the description of myths.

Secondly, I will answer you again why there were so many myths in the Zhou Dynasty, but there were fewer in later generations. The first reason is that the era of the Zhou Dynasty is so old that there are not even any records that can be verified, in order to be able to make a simple distinction between the historical figures and stories of the Zhou Dynasty. So in a mythological way, all the stories of the Zhou Dynasty were simplified, and this is also the reason why "Fengshen Bang" was born.

Because people began to write more and more about what was written. Slowly, the so-called biographies began to appear, and certain personal records were made. And the most important thing is the appearance of historians, it is precisely because of this that everyone has a certain understanding of the people of these dynasties, and there will be no more myths about them.

It is precisely because there are more and more means of recording that people will no longer be overly mythical about certain things. And the understanding of history is no longer simply recorded through stories and legends. Of course, there are still myths, such as Guan Erye, and Li Bing's father and son, all of which were mythologized later.

But this also tells us one thing, when civilization progresses, all this becomes another way of recording.

Because the Shang Dynasty was the first dynasty in China, neither the Xia Dynasty nor the previous history existed. The more obscure the history, the more myths there are, because there was no civilization before the Shang Dynasty, and the Chinese made it up themselves.

It's normal, just look at the antiques, the bronze tripod with the word in the Shang Dynasty is not allowed to be traded, and the transaction is a felony, so you can understand why other antiques don't have this provision.

The Shang Dynasty is too far away from the present, and a lot of real history has not been recorded, and a lot of history has been passed down by word of mouth, so it is inevitable that it will be deified.

Personally, I think that before the Shang Dynasty was crowned a god, it was an era when many people and gods were mixed, and people and gods had not been completely separated, so many characters were deified. After being canonized as a god, man is officially separated from God. Therefore, after the canonization of gods, dynasties and dynasties, few people have been deified, and even if there are, they are individual characters, or a few characters of individual dynasties.

Until the Shang Dynasty, the human emperor was chosen by heaven Since King Wu of Zhou fell, the human emperor was artificially chosen The gods fell into the god platform Even the gods began to fight Later, even the gods were sealed by people Where did the myths come from Are people making up their own gods?

The Human Emperor and the Emperor of Heaven can lead a group of people to become gods, and only one of the Sons of Heaven behind is the son of the Emperor of Heaven, and the others are on the sidelines!

Di Xin is Wei Yi who has not been mythologized, what if the three kingdoms are all fought with immortals, and what will happen if the Sui and Tang wars are also fought with immortals?

The problem of cultural popularization! In the Shang Dynasty, most of their use of writing was used on the gold Dading! And these things are all sacrificial items for the gods!

Cultural rulers feel that they have supernatural powers, so they like to use divine expressions to record when they use words! Therefore, it is normal for them to become a situation of coexistence between gods and men in words and inheritance! This is also why the Jin Wen Society was the mainstream recording method of the Shang Dynasty!

The main reason is that after the gods, the god-man class has solidified, and no matter how hard people try, they can't become gods