Is the other party responsible for having a heart attack caused by a quarrel?

1. In the event of a quarrel, if you know it, you may have some responsibility;

2. Whether the other party had a heart attack during the quarrel, if he did not fall ill at the time of the quarrel, but fell ill after the quarrel left, then the relationship with the parties is not very large, and if the other party claims compensation, evidence is required. Article 234 of the Criminal Law stipulates that anyone who intentionally injures the body of another person shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years, short-term detention or controlled release. Whoever commits the crime in the preceding paragraph, causing serious injury, is to be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years but not more than ten years; Whoever causes death or seriously injures a person by especially cruel means, causing serious disability, is to be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than 10 years, life imprisonment, or death.

Where this Law provides otherwise, follow those provisions.

If you quarrel without knowing that the elderly person has heart disease or high blood pressure, and there is no physical conflict during the quarrel, you are not responsible for the outcome of the death of the elderly person without direct evidence to prove that the death of the elderly person is directly related to you.

If he knows that he has heart disease or high blood pressure, there may be subjective intentional injury, which constitutes the crime of intentional injury. If the death of a person is caused, the perpetrator subjectively has the intention to harm others, and the death of the victim is negligent. In the course of judicial practice, the death penalty is generally not imposed if a person is killed as a result of some excesses.

According to the provisions of China's criminal law, the minimum sentence for intentional injury causing death is 10 years, and the death penalty is applicable.

Legal analysis: If one party has a heart attack due to quarreling with others, the other party needs to bear the corresponding responsibility according to the specific circumstances. If the other party does not know that the other party has a heart attack at the time of the quarrel, or if the other party does not intentionally cause the other party to become ill despite knowing that the other party has a heart attack, the other party shall bear the corresponding liability for compensation according to the size of its own responsibility.

Legal basis: Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Personal Injury Compensation Cases

Article 1: Where life, body, or health are violated, and the person with the right to compensation sues to request compensation for material or moral harms, the people's court shall accept it.

"Compensation obligor" as used in this article refers to natural persons, legal persons, or unincorporated organizations that shall bear civil liability in accordance with law for their own or others' tortious acts or other causes of harm.

Article 2: Where the compensation rights holder sues some of the joint infringers, the people's court shall add the other joint infringers as co-defendants. Where the person entitled to compensation waives its claims against some of the joint infringers in the litigation, the other joint infringers shall not be jointly and severally liable for the share of compensation that the defendant whose claims have been abandoned. Where the scope of liability is difficult to determine, it is presumed that the joint tortfeasors bear equal liability.

The people's court shall inform the person entitled to compensation of the legal consequences of the waiver of the litigation claim, and explain the circumstances of the waiver of the litigation claim in the legal documents.

Legal analysis: 1. When quarrelling, do you know that the other party has heart disease, and if so, you may be held responsible;

2. Whether the other party had a heart attack during the quarrel, if he did not fall ill at the time of the quarrel, but fell ill after the other party left, if the other party asked you to compensate, you need to provide evidence;

3. Whether there is a causal relationship between quarreling and heart disease, if there is, you need to bear some responsibility, if not, then you should not be held responsible;

4. After he had a heart attack, did you, as a related person, take the necessary treatment measures?

Legal basis: Civil Code of the People's Republic of China

Article 1165:Where the perpetrator infringes upon the civil rights and interests of others due to fault and causes harm, they shall bear tort liability.

Article 1186:Where neither the victim nor the perpetrator is at fault for the occurrence of the harm, both parties are to share the losses in accordance with the provisions of law.

Legal Analysis: Specifically: 1. When quarreling, if you know about it, you will have a certain responsibility; 2. Whether the other party had a heart attack during the quarrel, if he did not fall ill at the time of the quarrel, but fell ill after the quarrel left, then the relationship with the parties is not very large, and if the other party claims compensation, evidence is required.

Legal basis: Civil Code of the People's Republic of China

Article 120:Where civil rights and interests are infringed upon, the infringed party has the right to request that the infringer bear tort liability.

Article 183:Where oneself is harmed by protecting the civil rights and interests of others, the infringer bears civil liability, and the beneficiary may give appropriate compensation. Where there is no infringer, the infringer has escaped, or is unable to bear civil liability, and the victim requests compensation, the beneficiary shall give appropriate compensation.

Article 1167:Where the tortious conduct endangers the safety of others' persons or property, the infringed party has the right to request that the infringer bear tortious liability such as stopping the infringement, removing obstructions, or eliminating dangers.

Article 1168:Where two or more persons jointly commit tortious acts, causing harm to others, they shall bear joint and several liability.

1. When quarrelling, do you know that the other party has heart disease, if so, you may have some responsibility;

2. Whether the other party committed a heart attack during the quarrel, if he did not fall ill at the time of the quarrel, but fell ill after the quarrel left, if the other party asked you to compensate, you need to provide evidence;

3. Whether there is a causal relationship between quarreling and heart disease, if there is, you need to bear some responsibility, if not, then you should not be held responsible;

4. After he had a heart attack, did you take the necessary treatment measures as a related person?

Civil Code of the People's Republic of China

Article 1165:Where the perpetrator infringes upon the civil rights and interests of others due to fault and causes harm, they shall bear tort liability.

Article 1186:Where neither the victim nor the perpetrator is at fault for the occurrence of the harm, both parties are to share the losses in accordance with the provisions of law.