-
Anonymous users2024-02-11As one of the four famous novels in my country, there are naturally a lot of people who love "Water Margin", and the 108 heroes in "Water Margin" also make people very admired, because they can stick a knife in their brothers' ribs and take care of each other. But the final ending of "Water Margin" is not very good, 108 heroes die and escape, and few have a good ending. Therefore, many people blamed this mistake on Song Jiang, thinking that it was because of the Zhao'an he supported that the heroes of Liangshan ended miserably.
Therefore, some people have some assumptions, if Liangshan neither recruits nor attacks the imperial court, then it is obviously impossible for them to exist in peace.
The first reason is that Liangshan heroes are not good. Because of the righteousness and enthusiasm of the heroes of Liangshan, many people have forgotten what they did before, and what their identities are now? Some of the 108 heroes in Liangshan are indeed pure white families, but some are bandits, scoundrels, and even those who sell human meat buns, and their form and style are not good, and they gather together, and many things are also done in the style of bandits.
And it must have been a lot of expense for so many people to gather together, so they often went down the mountain to rob the rich and give to the poor. Robbing the rich is naturally the mansion of the rich or ** in the Song Dynasty, and helping the poor is used to treat themselves, so how can Liangshan not anger Cao Ting, thus causing trouble.
The second reason is that the Song Dynasty could not allow the existence of a state-owned China. You must know that Liangshan is not only 108 heroes, but also has tens of thousands of soldiers and horses in the heyday of Liangshan, plus the wives and children of these people, Liangshan is already a force to be reckoned with. If the Song Dynasty did not recruit or eradicate it, then it would undoubtedly recognize the existence of Liangshan as a state of China, which the Song Dynasty would certainly not tolerate.
At this time, there were undoubtedly only two paths in front of Liangshan, the first accepted Zhao'an, and the second rebelled against the Song Dynasty, but Song Jiang chose the first path.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-10It's hard to survive in peace. Song Jiang and others are non-agricultural and non-businessmen, and mainly rely on robbing the rich and helping the poor to survive, which will definitely cause dissatisfaction among many people, and sooner or later they will be suppressed.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-09No, first of all, most of the heroes of Liangshan have a bad relationship with the imperial court, and it is difficult to maintain balance. The second is that the imperial court will not let Song Jiang and others be kings.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-08No. The imperial court will not watch Liangshan gradually grow, the imperial court will come to encircle and suppress Liangshan, and it is impossible to live in peace.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-07If they don't recruit An, Song Jiang and Liang Shan still have no way to survive safely.
1. Liangshan's personnel are constantly expanding, and the food and financial resources needed are increasing day by day, and such an expenditure is unbearable for Liangshan.
Second, the Song Dynasty absolutely did not allow the existence of such a force as Liangshan. Liangshan has always been a thorn in the side of the Great Song Dynasty, so even if Liangshan is in a safe corner, the imperial court will never allow such a thing to exist.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-06History is a different story.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-05May start a gang on their own. Occupancy is king.
-
Anonymous users2024-02-04The result of Song Jiang's heart still wanting to be recruited is: in the next few days, against the imperial court troops or local civil servants, they will shrink their hands and feet, and throw rats and bogeys, causing the internal personnel to no longer be of one heart and one mind, and the contradiction between the word "loyalty" and the dog meat of the "civil servant" will become more and more prominent, so as to fall apart from the inside, Lin Chong's departure is inevitable, Li Kui will still follow Song Jiang stupidly, Lu Junyi will reluctantly stay because he wants to repay the grace of saving his life, and Gongsun Sheng will definitely run away. Wu Yong can't say it well, maybe after a long time, he will prepare two kinds of red hearts. In short, those who were originally "civil servants" or who had no brains and life goals would still stay in Liangshan with Song Jiang and have a dream of being recruited, and other non-"civil servants" might set up another mountain with Lin Chong.
From the current point of view, he should not be recruited, if he does not recruit An, he will be an emperor, his power at that time was greater than that of the court at that time, but Song Jiang's loyalty to the monarch is very heavy, as if only Zhao'an is the right way.
For the environment in which it was at the time. He should be recruited. But! >>>More
Song Jiang is a disciple of an official eunuch, and it is impossible not to recruit peace. If you don't recruit An, the end is actually almost the same, because Song Jiang actually has no ambition to build the country, that is, he has no ambition to annex the world, which is very tangled, if there is no ambition, there can be no development, looking at the war in Liangshan, it can be seen that the heroes are fighting purely to grab food, grab money, or just to fight against the imperial court, and leave after the fight, and do not occupy the city to develop the cause, and one thing is very important, Liangshan's territory is actually very small, and the water park sounds very good for 800 miles, but it is not more than a ear compared to the whole country. Let's talk about the heroes of Liangshan, all of them are forced to go up the mountain in order to resist the imperial court, the reason why Liangshan can rise rapidly is because there are so many talents, but the heroes are not as united as they seem, Liangshan was originally the land of Wang Lun, and later Lin Chong and Chao Gaihuo and Wang Lun had the land of Liangshan, it can be seen that the establishment of Liangshan was not united at the beginning, and the internal power struggle was more serious after Song Jiang went up the mountain. But unfortunately died in battle, which is a bit ridiculous. >>>More
Yes, because Song Jiang's decision directly led to the death of many heroes in Liangshan, it was wrong.
I think if Song Jiang lives or dies, he won't recruit peace. Then it is very likely that the heroes of Liangshan will finally win the world. The main reason for this is because there were many peasant uprisings at that time, so ruthless people may have turmoil in the world, and Liangshan itself is very strong, so there is a chance to unify the world.