Assuming that Song Jiang didn t recruit An, what would the ending be?

Song Jiang is a disciple of an official eunuch, and it is impossible not to recruit peace. If you don't recruit An, the end is actually almost the same, because Song Jiang actually has no ambition to build the country, that is, he has no ambition to annex the world, which is very tangled, if there is no ambition, there can be no development, looking at the war in Liangshan, it can be seen that the heroes are fighting purely to grab food, grab money, or just to fight against the imperial court, and leave after the fight, and do not occupy the city to develop the cause, and one thing is very important, Liangshan's territory is actually very small, and the water park sounds very good for 800 miles, but it is not more than a ear compared to the whole country. Let's talk about the heroes of Liangshan, all of them are forced to go up the mountain in order to resist the imperial court, the reason why Liangshan can rise rapidly is because there are so many talents, but the heroes are not as united as they seem, Liangshan was originally the land of Wang Lun, and later Lin Chong and Chao Gaihuo and Wang Lun had the land of Liangshan, it can be seen that the establishment of Liangshan was not united at the beginning, and the internal power struggle was more serious after Song Jiang went up the mountain. But unfortunately died in battle, which is a bit ridiculous.

So let's talk about the heroes of Liangshan, one hundred singles and eight generals, who is the boss? Song Jiang, and then Lu Junyi, who was calculated by Song Jiang to go up the mountain, has no real power, no power, only a little Yi brother. Who is the boss of the Five Tiger Generals in Liangshan?

Lin Chong, who did not create Liangshan and made great contributions in Liangshan, was actually a big knife Guan Sheng who fell into the grass halfway! It's ridiculous and ridiculous, and we even made a heavenly stone to prove that we who were born under the red flag can naturally easily see this plan, which shows that the contradictions between the Liangshan forces are sharp, and it is impossible for them to exist and develop for a long time. All in all, if Liangshan does not surrender, it will inevitably break down in a few years, rather than being defeated by the imperial court at that time, it is better to surrender now to beg for a wife and a cute son, Song Jiang is quite smart.

Even if you haven't been recruited. Shuibo Liangshan is also destined to be short-lived. After shining its brilliance, it fades away like a shooting star.

Maybe the court will be in turmoil, maybe there will be new characters to start a new dynasty, but it is definitely not Liangshan to open up the country, because they are just forced, yearning for a free and easy life, and do not have the elements to govern the country, if you want to give them a good ending, it is like the Wagangzhai of the Sui and Tang Dynasties. met a master like Li Shiming. Otherwise, it's grass at most.

Live a life of drinking wine in a big bowl and eating meat in a big bowl.

was destroyed by Song Huizong, Song Jiang really rebelled, most of the main forces of Liangshan were generals of the Song Dynasty, and they would definitely not rebel, and it was a matter of time before Song Jiang was destroyed.

Personally, I think they will always lose, and then they will already have infighting. And "Song Jiang" is "sending the river".

Water MarginIn the end, if the Song River is not recruited, it may also be exterminatedAt that time, Song Jiang not only had to deal with the Northern Song Dynasty.

The imperial court, at the same time, also has to face a potential opponent, the Jin State, there are too many opponents, even if it can achieve a certain stage of victory, but there is no guarantee that it will be able to seize the supreme power in the end.

The Song River uprising in the Water Margin.

The background is the late Northern Song Dynasty Song Huizong.

Period, in the background of the Water Margin, there were four major Kou, which were the four major rebel armies in the late Northern Song Dynasty, which posed a very serious threat to the rule of the Northern Song Dynasty.

recruited Song Jiang and his gang, and then used their strength to attack the rest of their own forces, and in the end Song Jiang and others were killed and wounded, and this uprising was no longer threatening. And if Song Jiang is not recruited, then he will face the full encirclement and suppression of the imperial court. Song Jiang and his gang may be able to succeed in the uprising through years of hard work, but it is more likely to be solved by a certain force.

Although Liangshan repelled many attacks by the Northern Song Dynasty, the gap in strength between the two sides is still very large, in terms of the most needed armor for war, the gap between the imperial court and the rebel army in these places is huge, the equipment used by the regular army and the ** of the rebel army is not a level at all, and the bow and arrow of the rebel army may not be able to penetrate the leather armor of the regular army. And judging from the uprisings in the last years of the Northern Song Dynasty in history, He Meng of the Northern Song Dynasty has not yet reached the point where his strength has been exhausted, and his demise is due to external factors. The historical Songjiang Uprising was not on the scale of **, and it didn't take long to be exterminated.

The rest of the larger ones in history are Fang La.

However, it did not last long, and was defeated by a large number of troops mobilized by the imperial court in just one year. If Song Jiang is not recruited in the end, it is very likely that he will be exterminated by the imperial army first, of course, Song Jiang may also survive the encirclement and suppression, but he still has to face a strong opponent.

If Song Jiang had not been recruited, then in a few years, he would have to face the rising Jin State, after the rise of the Jin State, Shou Lucha first defeated the northern overlord Liao State, and then went directly south to destroy the Song State.

Even Song Huizong was taken prisoner. Since then, the area occupied by the Jin State includes the Shandong region to which the Song Jiang Uprising belonged, and whether Song Jiang wanted to compete in the world or serve the imperial court, he had to confront this Chan Hao Bridge opponent, but with the national strength of the Jin State at that time, Song Jiang's army did not necessarily have a chance of winning.

It's just the needs of the times, just like now people write through the small chop paragraph and say that it is often how Taizu sports and warfare, how the military body boxing, and not using force against Taiwan, do we love peace? Is it the ruler who is sympathetic to the people? One will be a success, and ten thousand bones will wither,。。

I thought it was just a hemp rod to beat the wolf, ** that's it, can Liang Chunqing really overthrow the Song Dynasty? Zhengfang is really Fangla, how much effort the gang in Liangshan has made, everyone knows it... No matter how you write it, you can't detach yourself from history.

I think it's stupid to be in the Water Margin, if Song Jiang doesn't recruit An, they will live a very good life in the end, and they can be a good overlord far away from the imperial court, because the heroes of the Water Margin seem to be advocating freedom, and they don't want to be controlled by the imperial court at all.

Like ordinary people, they may be displaced and eventually die in a foreign land after experiencing the decay of the country.

I don't think there will be a lot of people going to do this uprising. They're all going to make compromises. will even end up as a traitor.

Song Jiang in "Water Margin" is a very charismatic image, if he doesn't accept Zhao'an, what will happen? In fact, the outcome of Song Jiang's failure to recruit an may be the following four situations.

Situation 1: Die out with friends.

Legend has it that there are one hundred and eight heroes under Song Jiang, and they are all heroes with heroic personalities and bloody nature. If Song Jiang does not recruit peace, then these heroes will probably continue to wander in the rivers and lakes and become entangled with other forces. It is highly likely that they will die unexpectedly, never return to their normal lives, and perish with Song Jiang.

Situation 2: Reduced to a rogue and annoyed the court.

If Song Jiang did not accept Zhao'an, then he would become a thorn in the side of the imperial court. In addition to the banquets that are all over the world, he will cause dissatisfaction in the imperial court, and even cause resistance from forces more powerful than Song Jiang at that time, bringing more unfortunate consequences to the small people.

Situation 3: Continue to struggle in the rivers and lakes.

If Song Jiang chooses not to recruit dust and destroy peace, then he and his subordinates will continue to struggle in the rivers and lakes. They will have more opportunities to accomplish more missions. Although there will be greater dangers, the more dangerous the time, the more you need a hero to help.

Situation 4: Support the new generation that is still the same.

Song Jiang attaches great importance to Brother Baoqing's filial piety to his old friend. But if he doesn't recruit An, then he will quietly support some new generation of savior heroes, such as revolutionary pioneers like Lu Zhishen. He no longer stands at the front of the people, but plans behind the scenes, adheres to his beliefs, and silently dedicates himself to the sake of the country.

1.These generals led their troops to rebel.

What's going on? Because those generals are different from other Bai Koren in Liangshan, most of them have been officials in the court for many years, and they already have a certain loyalty to the court in their hearts, such as Hu Yanzhuo, Guan Sheng, and Xiao Ming. The reason why they stood here in Liangshan was actually a last resort, and if they didn't surrender, they would die, so the heroes didn't suffer immediate losses.

Speaking of Song Jiang before he wooed them, he persuaded him with the concept of Zhao'an, and during the period of Song Huizong, when wars broke out on the border line and he wanted to be an official to kill people and sell more goods to recruit An, they would definitely be able to use this Zhao'an to make other officials do higher. Therefore, if Song Jiang did not cooperate with Zhao'an to resist the imperial court unremittingly, then once his expectations were destroyed, he would have no value in Liangshan, and he would eventually lead his troops to rebel.

2.It will only push the fallen country of Liangshan earlier.

Among the one hundred and eight generals in Liangshan, some of the imperial court generals were removed, and the rest were not known as Lin Chong, Wu Song, and Lu Junyi? The others are typical Bai Koren who can only act brutally and dominate one side. The reason why Liang Shan was able to defeat Tong Guansheng and capture Gao Yu was nothing more than relying on this kind of force, if that part of the generals was removed, Liang Shan would not be able to set off any big storms at all.

When Tong Guan and Gao Yu came to attack Liangshan, the logistics management was very abundant.

Part of the battle is the "money for fighting", what are the Liangshan? The vast majority rely on dominating a stove type to maintain operation. Emaciated camels are bigger than horses, let alone a country.

Although the imperial court at that time was corrupt, the powerful Liao State could not win for so many years, and the Song Dynasty still had a certain foundation. In the final analysis, Liangshan Lujiao and the imperial court resisted by hitting an egg with a huge stone, and there was no contrast at all.

3.The reputation of the heroes of Liangshan and Liangshan can be completely destroyed.

If Liangshan often resists with the imperial court, it will definitely make the surrounding people miserable. Although the second half of the Song Dynasty was corrupt and weak, the common people would inevitably still stand on the side of the imperial court. Since Liangshan is too insignificant, it will definitely be wiped out by the imperial court shouting the banner of exterminating the bandits.

At that time, he would never be written out of books and his name would be immortalized, but he would only be a sinner for the ages in the name of a gang of thieves and thieves who disturbed the court.

If Song Jiang refused to accept Zhao'an, it would only have a bad impact, and at that time, Fang La's power was so deep that it was still destroyed by the imperial court. Therefore, Zhao'an can only be accepted, and Liangshan's overall strength is too small to make any waves at all.

Rich family background and upright work: Song Jiang was originally a person with a rich family background and a strong heart in his work, and because he was burly and well-versed, he often tried to be influenced by the local people, so he was amazed by the neighbors next door in his hometown. And in addition to hugging and fighting, Song Jiang also likes to meet good friends in the martial arts, often in order to help them help the poor, so he also won the titles of "advantageous" and "Hu Baoyi".

Personally, I think that if Song Jiang doesn't recruit An, it will be tantamount to the end of the three collapses. The first is to be exterminated by the imperial court, the second is to overthrow the imperial court and other peasant rebel armies because of the war on the throne or to be wiped out by the Jin State in one fell swoop, and the third is the infighting among the brothers under his command that leads to the disbandment of the gang.

Song Jiang Tuandou is a person with a very contradictory personality, he wants to talk about both righteousness and loyalty, but he doesn't know that there is no way to protect these two, and between righteousness and loyalty, he finally chose loyalty.

If he hadn't been recruited, Liangshan would probably have been destroyed by the imperial court like Fang La's ending. Song Jiang is a person who is benevolent and righteous on the surface, but is actually very black-bellied.

You can be a king of the mountain, but you can never be famous.

As far as ** is concerned, it will be exterminated, Liangshan is a corner of the land after all, and there is factional struggle inside, the fish and dragons are mixed, 100,000 people are 100,000 hearts, and it is easy to have civil strife.

According to the Water Margin, it is impossible to encircle and suppress Liangshan by means of the imperial court's refueling tactics (only part of the troops are transferred each time), and it is impossible to destroy Liangshan at once. However, Liangshan's strength was limited after all - the territory was limited, the source of troops was limited, if the imperial court adopted the fortress policy, besieged Liangshan heavily, fought positional warfare and used local landlord forces (such as Zhujiazhuang, Zengtou City, etc.), Liangshan could only jump out of the encirclement through guerrilla warfare, but there would be no base area. Song Jiang is politically more clever than ordinary Liangshan figures, and naturally knows this truth, after all, fighting a war is a fight for attrition, and there are several ways out for "bandits":

Unified the country, established himself as the king, accepted Zhao'an, returned to the rivers and lakes, was defeated and died, and treason to the enemy.

For Liangshan, the better way out is to accept Zhao'an and return to the rivers and lakes.

The way out for treason and defection to the enemy In the process of fighting with Liao, Wu Yong once advised Song Jiang to consider it, which can be regarded as another kind of "recruitment".

In the Water Margin, Song Jiang and Lu Junyi attacked Fang La in two ways, bringing 30,000 horses with each battle (after each battle, they could get the supply of troops), and broke the various state capitals occupied by Fang La one by one. It shows that there is still a certain gap between Fang La's strength and the imperial court. The advantage of Fang La is that there are more talents.

It is impossible for Song Jiang to refuse not to be edicted, even if he is not edicted, he is still a group of rabble, unorganized and undisciplined