If Chao Gai is alive and Song Jiang is not the eldest brother, will the ending be different?

If the development of Liangshan can continue according to Chao Gai's ideas, then the final outcome of Liangshan must be different from the present, at least so many Liangshan heroes will not be used as cannon fodder by the imperial court, and they will not die so aggrieved. Song Jiang wants to protect the entire Liangshan through compromise, "sealing the wife and the shadow" seems to be very beautiful, but this is all sugar-coated shells of the imperial court, the first thing the imperial court did after Zhao'an was not to incorporate and transform, but to send Liangshan to attack Fang La, and the purpose of the imperial court to do this is very obvious.

If you want to understand the final direction of Liangshan, you must first understand Chao Gai's inner thoughts, and understand what the true nature of Liangshan is for Chao Gai. For Chao Gai, the first point is "anti-court", which is a completely different idea from Song JiangAlthough Song Jiang is also the owner of Liangshan, he always has a "compromise" for the imperial court in his bones, which is also the reason for Song Jiang's final failure. But for Chao Gai, it is relatively "tough", and he would rather be annihilated than choose to surrender to the imperial court.

For Chao Gai, the second point is "rule by inaction", in Chao Gai's heart has always wanted to go with the flow, although he rebelled against the imperial court, but he played the banner of "doing the right thing for heaven"., which shows that their primary enemy for Chao Gai is not the imperial court. Under Chao Gai's rule, Liangshan did not look like a complete "anti-court" organization, but more like a gang, and freedom, happiness, and unfettered were the ultimate life that Chao Gai wanted, after all, Chao Gai's favorite phrase was "eat meat and drink".

If it can really develop according to Chao Gai's ideas, Liangshan's power will not expand rapidly, but it has been very "long-lasting". Such an organization is not a big threat to the imperial court, and the imperial court will not send a large number of troops to exterminate a "gang". It's just a pity that all this can't be realized, from the moment the Song River went to Liangshan, Liangshan has begun to change its nature, and the change from Juyitang to Zhongyitang is the best proof.

If Chao Gai is still alive, and Song Jiang is not Liangshan's eldest brother. Then the ending will change, so the heroes of Liangshan will definitely not accept Zhao'an, it may be entrenched in Liangshan, and it may even be one day in the future. will win the world.

Of course, the ending will be different, Song Jiang led Liangshan to the road of Zhao'an, which led to Liangshan's heavy casualties in the end, and if Chao Gai continued to serve as the eldest brother, Liangshan would not go to the road of Zhao'an, so he continued to stay on Liangshan.

Compared with Song Jiang, Chao Gai should have lost in the hearts of the people, and at the same time, Chao Gai also lost in his own short life.

To sum up, Chao Gai is a quick-tempered person, while Song Jiang tends to be gentle and humble when getting along with people, which may also be the reason why Song Jiang is more cultured than Chao Gai.

There is no such deep scheming as Song Jiang. Although Song Jiang is known as timely rain and righteousness, he has a strong purpose and planning for doing things, and is very good at winning people's hearts.

Chao Gai has no ambitions, no talent, strong on the outside and dry in the middle, the embroidered pillow is the truest portrayal of him, compared with Song Jiang, his lack of experience in the rivers and lakes is really not a star.

He loses in indecision. He is not as ruthless as Song Jiang, nor is he sinister and cunning. Compared with Song Jiang, he is not as scheming as Song Jiang.

Chao Gai should be a carefree robber with everyone. <> Chaogai is an important character in "Water Margin". He led the LinkedIn heroes to take Liangshan from Wang Lun.

He had strong leadership skills, but he died too early. After his death, under the leadership of Song Jiang, Liangshan came to an end step by step. <>

Chao Gai is the Baozheng of Dongxi Village, Yuncheng City, Shandong Province. His family is very rich. On weekdays, he likes to make friends with heroes in the world.

He likes to dance with guns and sticks. He doesn't even care about getting married and having children. At that time, the villagers in the village said that the next village was haunted, so the villagers dug a bluestone pagoda and put it by the stream, so that the ghost was driven to Dongxi Village.

Chao Gai was very angry when he found out, so he moved the stone pagoda to his village alone, so he was given the title of "King of Tota". How did Chao Gai and Song Jiang meet? At that time, Chao Gai and several brothers robbed the Shengchengang given to Cai Jing, and sent someone to capture him.

At this time, Song Jiang informed him that they had defeated the officers and soldiers and went to Liangshan. It can be said that Song Jiang is his savior. <>

Later, when Song Jiang committed the crime, Chao Gai and his brothers tried to help each other. In the end, Song Jiang went to Liangshan (in fact, he had always hoped to be pardoned by the imperial court, preferring to go into exile rather than go to Liangshan). After Song Jiang arrived at Liangshan, he also took the initiative to attack Zhujiazhuang, Gaotang Prefecture, Sanshan, Huazhou and other places.

The second Chaogai didn't mind. So the credit is his, and the later heroes also recognize Song Jiang. Later, Chao Gai took the initiative to attack Zengtou City.

In the end, he was shot by an arrow and was finally killed by an arrow. After Chao Gai's death, Song Jiang became the true master of Liangshan. During this period, his yearning for the imperial court was vividly expressed.

He aspires to be a serious **, but when everyone believes that he accepted the invitation, most people face the fate of death, even himself. In fact, if Chao Gai was still alive, he wouldn't hurt anyone for his own selfishness like Song Jiang did. Of course, Chao Gai is open-minded and loyal.

He is still willing to be a carefree robber with everyone. It's a pity that the sky can't let him live long.

The ending should be different, at least the heroes of Liangshan can't surrender so soon.

The ending will not be different, and in the end, Liangshan will still be disbanded, completely unable to fight against the imperial army.

I think the ending should be different, because Chao Gai is kinder, no one is righteous, and he won't cheat his brother.

So if Chao Gai hadn't died, Song Jiang might not have been poisoned by poisoned wine like in the original book, and he might have followed Chao Gai to fight on the battlefield together. The big deal is that there are two endings: either win and Song Jiang becomes a role like the prime minister, or fail, and Song Jiang will die with Chao Gai.

Song Jiang should be the second leader, but he will win over Wu Yong, and then overhead Chao Gai.

Chao Gai is immortal Song Jiang will never be able to sit in the first position of Liang Shanbo, although it is said that Song Jiang will win people's hearts, but the ancient people are very loyal, and no one can be the leader when Chao Gai himself does not want to abdicate.

Song Jiang is likely to leave Liangshan. Song Jiang went to Liangshan in order to strengthen his momentum, attract the attention of the imperial court, and let the imperial court recruit peace, if he couldn't do it, he would definitely leave.

Chao Gai is because his strength is not enough, he is not as assertive and leadership as Song Jiang, and he will win people's hearts, so soon many people will throw themselves to Song Jiang and no longer have the same heart with him.

There are both, Song Jiang's status in the rivers and lakes cannot be shaken, the people in the rivers and lakes are called timely rain, and Chao Gai is relatively not so famous.

Because Song Jiang's strength was not enough at that time, if he became the boss, then he would be asking for his own death. Song Jiang is just a minor official in Yuncheng, unable to compare with Lin Chong and Wu Song in terms of martial arts, Xiao Rang and Wu Yong in terms of knowledge, and Chao Gai and Chai Rong and others in terms of wealth. In the case of insufficient strength in all aspects, if Song Jiang directly ascends to the position and becomes the boss of Liangshan, then many people will not be convinced.

However, Song Jiang still gained the trust and respect of many people on Liangshan when he was not outstanding in anything, and Chao Gai at that time still wanted to take the initiative to give way. And Song Jiang himself has a great characteristic, that is, he is very good at winning people's hearts, and in terms of using people's hearts, Song Jiang is relatively outstanding in Liangshan. Therefore, many heroes in Liangshan voluntarily called Song Jiang the eldest brother.

Although Song Jiang was just a small official at that time, he was also a member of the government. It's just that Yan Poxi discovered the secret of his dealings with bandits, and after Yan Poxi was killed by Song Jiang, Song Jiang would only go to Liangshan when he was desperate. Even if Song Jiang was unwilling to be a bandit at that time, in order to save his life, he had to be a bandit.

Song Jiang later took a large group of brothers to Chao Gai, and Chao Gai saw that Song Jiang had brought so many brothers, so he wanted to give up his position to Song Jiang. Although Song Jiang also wanted to be the boss at that time, Liangshan was beaten down by Chao Gai and his brother. If Song Jiang sat directly in this position at this time, it would cause many people to be dissatisfied, and Song Jiang decided to resign in order to give a better impression to the people on Liangshan.

Even if Song Jiang sat in this position, because he had just arrived in Liangshan, he was not familiar with the geographical location and all aspects of Liangshan. If you take it rashly, then it is easy to cause contradictions between the two sides in the case of disobedience to the public. At the same time, it is also very unfavorable for Song Jiang.

And Song Jiang only captured the hearts of the people, so if he took the throne in the future, no one would object.

Because his strength does not allow it, Song Jiang is self-aware, and if he is willing to be the boss now, it is self-seeking. Song Jiang was originally a small official in Yuncheng, and his martial arts were not as powerful as Lin Chong, Wu Song and others, and his wealth was not as good as Chao Gai, Chai Rong and others.

The main reason for this was because Song Jiang's strength did not allow it at that time. Because most of the people and horses in Liangshan are under Chao Gai's control. Song Jiang has too few henchmen, so even if he becomes the lord of Liangshan, he will exist in name only.

Because Song Jiang didn't have the strength at that time, Song Jiang was self-aware, and he didn't have any credit when he first came to Liangshan, so rashly becoming the boss would cause others to be dissatisfied.

Because Song Jiang is well-known for his chivalry and is very prestigious in Liangshan, most of his brothers are obedient to him and have great leadership skills, so this is the case.

Because at that time, Song Jiang was called timely rain. He likes to help others very much, so he is loved by many heroes of Liangshan.

Chao Gai doesn't have any brains at all, and Song Jiang has a more flexible mind, so he can beat Chao Gai.