Compared with Zhuge Liang and Sima Qian, who is more skilled?

Personally, I think Zhuge Liang is a step ahead, he has won the trust of Liu Bei and Liu Chan with his talents, Zhuge Liang, he is tactful, and he can quickly gain a firm foothold in the officialdom, and Sima Qian does not know how to be flexible, so he was finally sentenced to palace punishment.

Zhuge Liang and Sima Qian have their own strengths, and it is difficult for the two of them to distinguish between them in the Three Kingdoms. So I think it's hard to tell who they want to say is more skilled.

Historically, I think Sima Yi should be more skilled, because it was the Sima family that won in the end.

Personally, I think Zhuge Liang is more skilled, because Zhuge Liang is more meticulous and strategic in the military.

Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, not only depending on their skills, but also on how to let the king give them a chance to perform.

Personally, I like Zhuge Liang more, because he is loyal, can anticipate what happens after him, and my king glory Zhuge Liang plays well.

Zhuge Liang is a step ahead, he has won the trust of Liu Bei and Liu Chan by virtue of his talents, but Sima Qian was tragically tortured by the palace and endured humiliation and stole his life.

Personally, I think Sima Yi is smarter, although the two are not equal in military affairs, but in terms of power and forbearance, Sima Yi is better, and on the whole, Sima Yi is smarter.

As one of the four ancient Chinese classics, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was widely circulated among the people, especially in the later period of the Battle of Shu Wei and the Battle of Wolong and Tiger. It's even more thrilling。However, with the development of the times, people have come up with **.

Questioning, constantly learning lessons from official history, thinking that Zhuge Liang is not as divine as in the kingdom, and also feels that Zhuge Liang's military ability is not as strong as in the kingdom. Regardless of borders, who can beat Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi? Although the official history has a tendency to respect Liu and belittle Cao, but aside from the romance, Zhuge Liang is better than Sima Yi in terms of military strength in the official history.

According to historical records, Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi fought many times, and Sima Yi was basically in a passive defensive state. In fact, Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi only had two face-to-face encounters.

The Battle of Lucheng. You may not be familiar with the Battle of Deer City, but you must be familiar with the Battle of the Upper Valley. In the battle of Shangfang Valley, Sima Yi fell for Zhuge Liang's strategy and was burned in the upper valley

Sima Yi and his son almost died. This battle was the prototype of the Battle of Upper Valley. In the battle of Lucheng, Zhuge Liang led the enemy into a deep trap, Sima Yi was ambushed by Zhuge Liang, and was killed by the Shu army of 3,000, and the defeated general Zhang Yun.

However, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" only records Zhang Xu's death, and does not contain the defeat of Sima Yi. The Book of Jin directly records that Sima Yi defeated Zhuge Liang. The elements that beautify Sima Yi, but Sima Yi's defeat is clearly recorded in historical books such as "Spring and Autumn of the Han Jin Dynasty" and "Tongjian of Knowledge".

In the summer of May, Xin Si and Yi Nai made Zhang Gongwu a prisoner, and He Ping Yu Nanwei and Xiang Liang were from the road. Liang led Wei Yan, Gao Xiang, and Wu Ban to fight, and the Wei soldiers were defeated。Since the Battle of Lucheng, Sima Yi has not been able to avoid this battle, because he knows that his talent is not as good as Zhuge Liang.

This is also a mockery of Cao Weijun's "fear of Shu like a tiger". Sima Yi pursued the Shu army for the second time.

After Zhuge Liang's death, Yang Yi was ordered by Zhuge Liang to slowly withdraw his troops. Sima Yi led the army to pursue at this time, but was frightened back by the wooden statue left by Zhuge Liang with a false trick, although the "empty city map" was fabricated, but Sima Yi was indeed frightened away。Zhuge Liang's final plan.

Since then, there have been rumors of "Dead Zhuge scaring away Living Zhongda". Sima Yi himself couldn't help but praise Zhuge Liang: a wizard in the real world!

All in all, although Zhuge Liang's military talent is not as mythical as written in **, his military talent is not boastful. Sima Yi was inferior to Zhuge Liang militarily.

For example, the "Empty City Plan" was fictionalized to reflect Zhuge Liang's clever calculations, and there is no record of this incident in history. and Sima Yi is an excellent strategist. And the person who can give Zhuge Liang a headache in terms of strategy is only Sima Yi, and many people think that Sima Yi's talent is above Zhuge Liang.

In real history, Sima Yi's wisdom was a little higher, but Wu Chengen wrote Zhuge Liang very mythically when he wrote **.

For example, Zhuge Liang has not set up an empty city plan, but ** does.

Zhuge Liang is good at governing government affairs, such as managing the size of the ** national household registration, how much taxes are paid, the severity of the criminal law, economic development, population reproduction, material reserves, and he also invented the crossbow and the wooden ox and the flowing horse.

It's not bad to lead the troops, march and set up camp, and there is nothing wrong with it, but there is a lack of change, and it is suitable for steady and steady fighting.

Sima Yi is good at power skills, such as political struggles such as intrigue with others, which can be seen in his struggle with the Cao family. As for the military strategy, I personally feel that it is slightly higher than Zhuge Liang.

It's hard to say, but strictly speaking, Zhuge Liang's political talent is relatively powerful, and fighting a war is not so good

Inferior to Sima Yi militarily.

Although the talents of the two of them are similar, but Sima Yi followed the wrong lord, when he defected to Cao Cao, the other party's warriors were like clouds and strategists were like rain, and there was no shortage of Sima Yi at all. But Liu Bei is different, he was in a very difficult stage when he got Zhuge Liang, so he will use Zhuge Liang very much, and Zhuge Liang's talent can be brought into play.

Although Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi's talents are similar, in the early days of the Three Kingdoms, Sima Yi's sense of existence was not high, and Zhuge Liang had always helped Liu Bei fight, so everyone in the world knew Zhuge Liang, but not Sima Yi. It was not until the death of Cao Cao and Liu Bei in the late Three Kingdoms period that Sima Yi gradually stepped onto the political stage and became well-known to everyone. The main reason for this phenomenon is that the two of them follow different lords.

Zhuge Liang wanted to make a name for himself in history, so he did put a lot of thought into choosing the lord.

Before Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain, Liu Bei could be regarded as a poor and white man, he did not have many soldiers and horses, nor did he have any excellent generals, just a Han clan who had not yet made a career. Zhuge Liang did not choose Liu Biao, Cao Cao and Sun Quan, or Yuan Shao, but chose Liu Bei. His purpose is very obvious, that is, he hopes that he can be reused by the other party after following Liu Bei.

Although Sima Yi has been an official in the Cao Wei regime since following Cao Cao, Sima Yi's presence under Cao Cao is not high at all.

Cao Cao has a lot of generals under him, and there are many strategists under him, Guo Jia in the front and Jia Xu in the back, so Cao Cao does not particularly trust Sima Yi. If it weren't for Cao Cao's death, Cao Wei couldn't find other more suitable people to resist Zhuge Liang, maybe Sima Yi's talent would have been buried in the court. It is precisely because Sima Yi has not been reused during the Cao Wei regime that his fame in history is not as great as Zhuge Liang's.

Because Zhuge Liang is a very scheming person, and his loyalty to the emperor is praised by history. is not careful, but Sima Yi is very careful.

This is because Liu Beisan invited Zhuge Liang to make Zhuge Liang's fame already very big, and Zhuge Liang provided Liu Bei with a lot of help after entering Liu Bei's camp, so he was able to make Zhuge Liang so famous.

This is because Zhuge Liang has participated in many wars, and he has helped the war to win, and his strategy can turn the war into victory every time, so he can be so famous.