Why are there so few records of the Yuan Dynasty in Chinese history books?

Updated on history 2024-02-25
12 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The time of the Yuan Dynasty is short - 97 years, there are few historical facts recorded, and it is the regime of ethnic minorities, and the implementation of ethnic discrimination policies is a nightmare era for the Han people, so the ancient literati are estimated not to mention it, and the political mechanism of the Mongols is too simple, and the provincial system is relatively novel, and the Yuan Dynasty can talk about this provincial system and the local provincial system, plus the Yuan Qu. To be honest, it has not contributed much to the trajectory of the development of ancient Chinese feudal history, as for what you said about Japan, I personally think it has little impact, because historians have never been dismissive of Japan except for modern times, do you know that the Ming Dynasty resisted the Japanese? Now it seems that it is a big thing, but in fact, there are few records in the history of the Ming Dynasty, because the pride of China does not regard this kind of thing as a big thing.

    The second point can be an important reason from a personal point of view, because China is influenced by Confucianism and has always been civilized and self-respecting. And the barbaric practices of Mongolia are not recognized by the literati, who probably think the same as you, it is really disgusting to think about, let alone write, so there are few records. Above.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Personally, I think that the short time is a reason; In addition, in the past feudal period, the orthodoxy of the Han Dynasty was serious, and he was reluctant to mention the matter of being ruled by foreign people.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Hehe, you've done a lot of research.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    The Yuan Dynasty was a dark period in Chinese history. During the Yuan Dynasty, there were a large number of wars, famines, social unrest, and other events that undermined social stability and prosperity. People in history prefer to look back at those times of civilization, prosperity, and peace, so it is understandable that the Yuan Dynasty was neglected in history education.

    Although the Yuan Dynasty is said to be one of the most important dynasties in Chinese history, it is rarely mentioned in terms of historical education and cultural inheritance, mainly for the following reasons:

    The deepest impression I felt was watching the TV series "Heaven and Dragon Slayer", in which the officers and soldiers of the Yuan Dynasty bullied the common people everywhere, making the people's livelihood miserable. There is also the TV series Zhu Liquid Socks Crack Yuanzhang Why did the old Zhu family oppose him, it was not because of poor management, so that the people had no food, there was a memory monologue of Zhu Yuanzhang in the TV series: "At that time, there was food to eat, and we would not oppose him."

    > we all know that the Ming Dynasty was ruled by our Han people, and the Han people themselves did not welcome them, so it is understandable that there are not many records. In addition, the tomb of the emperor of the Yuan Dynasty is also very mysterious, and it has not been discovered until now, which makes people feel the existence of the Yuan Dynasty, which is also one of the reasons why the Yuan Dynasty is rarely mentioned in history.

    The history of the Yuan Dynasty began with the establishment of the Yuan Dynasty by Kublai Khan, the ancestor of the Mongolian Yuan dynasty, in the eighth year of the Yuan Dynasty (1271), and ended with the Northern Expedition of Zhu Yuanzhang, the Taizu of the Autumn Ming Dynasty in the first year of Hongwu (1368), and the reign of the Yuan Dynasty in the whole country ended.

    A total of 98 years before and after.

    First of all, the Yuan Dynasty was a dynasty that relied entirely on military conquest and construction.

    The Huns fought and killed on horseback, which can be said to be the extreme, and almost all problems will be solved with their fearless force! It is precisely because of this that the obedience of the people is only a fear of the ruler's force, not a kind of obedience from the heart.

    Secondly, after the formal establishment of the Yuan Dynasty, it was still used to focus on force and ignore the practice of literature and strategy to govern all the affairs of the country.

    At the beginning of the founding of the People's Republic of China, there were almost more than ten years of fighting, killing and killing, and in the more than ten years when the dynasty was about to fall, the whole country was still fighting and killing.

    To sum up, such an experience naturally leaves few valuable historical materials. Unlike the Qin Dynasty, although it was not a long time, it built the Great Wall to block the Huns, the cars were on the same track, and the books were the same, which had a great impact on later generations, so it was natural to despise him in the Yuan Dynasty.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    The Yuan Dynasty (1271-1368) was an important period in Chinese history, but it is true that there are some problems with the lack of historical records about this period. Here are some of the reasons that may explain this phenomenon:

    Cultural differences and political systems: The Yuan Dynasty was founded by the Mongols, who had different cultural backgrounds and traditions from the Han Chinese. The rulers of the Yuan Dynasty took a number of measures to consolidate their rule, such as the establishment of an administrative body for the Mongol Pai and the preferential use of the Mongolian language.

    This led to cultural isolation between the Mongols and the Han Chinese, and may have affected the historical record of the preservation and transmission of the Zen Prayer.

    Cultural Destruction and War: The Yuan dynasty reigned during a series of wars and upheavals, including the fall of the Southern Song Dynasty, the conquest of the Western Xia and Jin dynasties in the northwest, and the two invasions of Japan. These conflicts have led to extensive cultural destruction and the loss of Ho Hui's historical documents.

    In addition, there were a series of uprisings and civil strife in the later part of the Yuan Dynasty, which may also have had an impact on the preservation of historical records.

    Attitudes and Policies of Rulers: The rulers of the Yuan Dynasty had certain attitudes and policies towards historical records. They paid more attention to the history and traditions of the Mongol Empire, and may not have paid enough attention to the recording and inheritance of Chinese history.

    In addition, the rulers of the Yuan Dynasty also took some measures to suppress the culture and knowledge of the Han Chinese, which may have further affected the preservation and transmission of historical records.

    It should be noted that although there are relatively few historical records of the Yuan Dynasty, there are still some reliable historical books, documents, and other historical materials. Modern historians have strived to reconstruct and understand the history of the Yuan dynasty through the study and analysis of these sources, as well as comparisons with other relevant periods. Historical research is a field that is constantly evolving and evolving, and new discoveries and interpretations are likely to emerge all the time, providing us with more knowledge about the Yuan dynasty.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    A: The Yuan Dynasty (1271-1368) was a dynasty in Chinese history founded by Kublai Khan, the grandson of Genghis Khan of the Mongols. The Yuan dynasty had a relatively short history, having been replaced by the Ming dynasty around 1368.

    Regarding the position and influence of the Yuan Dynasty in history, here are some possible reasons:

    1.Non-Han rule: The Yuan dynasty was ruled by ethnic Mongols, unlike Han rule, which was used for most of Chinese history. Under the influence of nationalist ideas, the non-Han ruled Yuan dynasty was often seen as a short-lived alien regime and was therefore downplayed in the historical record.

    2.Suppression of Confucian culture: The suppression of Confucian culture by the rulers of the Yuan Dynasty limited the status of Confucian scholars. This made the historical status of the Yuan Dynasty relatively low in the history of Confucianism-dominated China.

    3.Influence of cultural development: During the Yuan Dynasty, although Mongolian culture had a certain influence on Chinese culture, its development in the fields of art and literature was relatively weak, which limited the status and influence of the Yuan Dynasty in history.

    4.Shorter time: The Yuan Dynasty has a shorter history, about 129 years.

    In contrast, the Tang dynasty (618–907) and the Song dynasty (960–1279) existed for about 289 and 319 years, respectively, which gave the Yuan dynasty a relatively low place in history.

    5.Propaganda of later regimes: After the Ming Dynasty replaced the Yuan Dynasty, the history of the Yuan Dynasty was often downplayed in order to emphasize the legitimacy of its rule. This political propaganda led to the lower status of the Yuan dynasty in the historical record.

    Statue of Kublai Khan.

    Despite this, the Yuan Dynasty still has a certain status and influence in Chinese history. During the Yuan Dynasty, the territory expanded to Europe and the Middle East, laying the foundation for the development of Chinese history. At the same time, the Yuan Dynasty also provided valuable experience and lessons for the later Ming and Qing dynasties.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The Yuan Dynasty was an important dynasty in Chinese history, and it was a unified empire founded by the descendants of Genghis Khan of the Mongol ethnic group. However, there are several reasons why the Yuan Dynasty is relatively little mentioned in historical education and historical research:

    1.Political factors: The Yuan Dynasty was a foreign regime with different rulers and modes of rule from the traditional Chinese Central Plains Dynasty.

    In the traditional Chinese conception of history, the Central Plains dynasty was regarded as the legitimate ruler, while the Yuan dynasty was considered the ruler of a foreign race. As a result, the Yuan Dynasty may have been somewhat neglected or despised in China's historical records.

    2.Cultural factors: The rulers of the Yuan Dynasty implemented a series of political and cultural reforms, introducing Mongolian culture and national traditions, which had a certain impact and changes on China's traditional culture.

    This also led to the neglect or exclusion of the Yuan Dynasty by some traditional cultural maintainers, and in turn the Yuan Dynasty was rarely mentioned in history education and research.

    3.Preservation and research of historical materials: There are relatively few historical materials preserved during the Yuan Dynasty, and some historical documents were damaged or lost during the Yuan Dynasty.

    This has caused certain difficulties for scholars to study and organize the history of the Yuan Dynasty, and has also limited the in-depth study and discussion of the Yuan Dynasty.

    However, in recent years, there has been an increase in research and scholarship on the Yuan Dynasty, and scholars have paid more attention and delved into the history and culture of the Yuan Dynasty. Therefore, the gradual addition of introductions to the Yuan dynasty in history education and research contributes to a more comprehensive understanding of the diversity and complexity of Chinese history.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    The Yuan Dynasty was an important dynasty in Chinese history, and its existence had a profound impact on China's history and cultural development. However, there was indeed a period of time in history when the history of the Yuan Dynasty was neglected or rarely mentioned, mainly for the following reasons:

    1.The Yuan Dynasty was a foreign regime. The Yuan Dynasty was a regime established by the Mongols, who were not native to China. In Chinese history, foreign regimes were often ostracized and discriminated against, so the Yuan Dynasty's position in Chinese history was once questioned.

    2.The destruction of traditional culture by the Yuan Dynasty. During the reign of the Yuan Dynasty in China, there was a certain destruction of traditional culture, such as burning many ancient documents and books, which had a certain impact on the development of Chinese culture.

    3.The rise of the Ming Dynasty. Although the reign of the Yuan Dynasty lasted for nearly 100 years, after the establishment of the Ming Dynasty, the historical position of the Yuan Dynasty was gradually replaced by the Ming Dynasty.

    The Ming Dynasty's position in Chinese history was more important than that of the Yuan Dynasty, so the Ming Dynasty's position was also more prominent in historical records.

    In general, the position and role of the Yuan Dynasty in Chinese history cannot be ignored, but due to various historical reasons, its status has indeed been ignored or diluted for a period of time.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The Yuan Dynasty is a dynasty in Chinese history that was established in 1271 AD and ended in 1368 and was established after the Mongol Empire conquered China. Although the Yuan Dynasty existed for nearly 100 years in Chinese history, it had relatively little political and cultural influence, mainly for the following reasons:

    1.Ethnic relations: The Yuan Dynasty was established by the Mongols, and the status of the Han people was not high, and the Yuan Dynasty's policy of deserting the south and the north also made the relationship between the Mongol rulers and the Han scholars relatively alienated.

    2.Political Turmoil: The Yuan Dynasty's political corruption, internal and external difficulties, economic stagnation, and ethnic conflicts in the northern steppes made the Yuan Dynasty's reign relatively chaotic and did not leave much political and cultural legacy.

    3.Historical records: There are relatively few historical materials and documents during the Yuan Dynasty, and many historical books and cultural heritage have been lost, which also causes the relative lack of history of the Yuan Dynasty.

    To sum up, although the Yuan Dynasty was established for a long time, its political, cultural and economic influence in Chinese history was relatively small, so there were relatively few records and accounts of it in history books, so the status of the Yuan Dynasty in our history education and tradition is relatively low.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because the reign of the Yuan Dynasty was short, a total of 98 years, and the policies in it were lackluster, it is rarely mentioned.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    First, although the Yuan Dynasty was a unified dynasty, it existed for a short time.

    Second, the Yuan Dynasty implemented a crowd hierarchy system, dividing the crowd into four classes. With the original Southern Song Dynasty as the last class, coupled with the corruption of the social atmosphere at the end of the Yuan Dynasty, the literati were unwilling to be loyal (seclusion was the main tone of the literati of the Yuan Dynasty), and only the Mongolian tribes obeyed their orders in terms of force.

    Third, since the founding of the Yuan Dynasty, there have been many peasant uprisings.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    The Yuan Dynasty was the most shallowest in terms of culture, and although the Yuan Dynasty unified the land of the Han people, it used Mongolian and Mongolian languages. National policies and so on are done in accordance with Mongolian traditions, which is difficult to be accepted by the later Han people, so naturally there are not many descriptions.

    Although the Yuan Dynasty occupied the land of China, it was less like a ruler and more like a marauder. This is not essentially different from other invading foreign races, as the official history of the Han nationality, it is natural to demote the Yuan Dynasty from the heart, and classify it as a first-class status below the unified dynasty.

    Historical background: The Yuan Dynasty was the only ethnic minority dynasty in Chinese history that did not engage in ethnic integration with the Han Chinese. Unlike the Qing Dynasty (Kangxi had half Han Chinese ancestry), after the Mongols unified the world, they divided the people of the world into four classes.

    They are the Mongols, the Semu people (people from the Western Regions), the Han people (the Han people in the former Jin ruling area), and the Nanren (the Han people in the Southern Song Dynasty). It is not surprising that ethnic hatred was quickly stirred up and then perished, and in that respect it is rarely mentioned.

Related questions
20 answers2024-02-25

He thinks that if the gate is closed and there are strict guards, other villains will take the opportunity to frame the Guo family, and if the gate is open, anyone can enter, then no one will be caught, and the Guo family will be safe.

1 answers2024-02-25

1. Joining the World Organization can provide new growth opportunities for China's national economic development. >>>More

7 answers2024-02-25

China currently has nearly $2 trillion in foreign exchange reserves, 80 percent of which are in dollars, 60 percent of which are U.S. Treasury bonds. China's holdings of U.S. Treasury bonds account for about 10% of its issuance, and if China makes a move, the world will be watching. It doesn't matter if you buy it, if you sell it, it will cause panic selling, and if the bonds in China's hands are not taken off, it will be substantial, and the US Treasury bonds in China's foreign exchange reserves will suffer painful losses, which is equivalent to not getting along with yourself. >>>More

35 answers2024-02-25

5,000 years of traditional Chinese virtues.

13 answers2024-02-25

It is said that the Northern Song Dynasty could not unify China because later people forcibly counted the sixteen states of Yanyun as Chinese, but in fact, the sixteen states of Yanyun were the territory of the Liao State at that time, and the current Beijing was the Nanjing of the Liao State at that time, and it was also one of the largest cities of the Liao State. >>>More