Why is Mandarin the broken Chinese of the Manchurians?

Updated on culture 2024-02-25
35 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Manchu is a relatively primitive language, and its pronunciation, vocabulary and grammar are very primitive and immature. Even in Beijing, it is difficult for the Manchu language to meet the needs of daily life, and many things such as animals and plants, buildings, and daily necessities in Beijing are unseen and unheard of by the Manchu people, and these things are difficult to describe and communicate in the Manchu language.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Now Chinese is not Mandarin, it is the official Chinese of Manchuria, Mandarin is like Peking Opera, Street, pronunciation da4gai1, you just pronounce it like this, Beijing dialect play, Chinese end, this is Mandarin, we are talking about the Northern Palace dialect now!

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    In fact, it is mainly based on some factual bases that are controversial in the academic community and distorted by the author, intentionally or unintentionally, and through the logical and non-mainstream linguistic value positions that cannot withstand scrutiny, and finally come to a conclusion contrary to the mainstream academic understanding.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    There is a difference in language, and it is impossible to be proficient.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    In fact, this is just a folk saying.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because each ethnic group has its own specific language.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Other people's language, we also think is a very lame language.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Two communities emerged in the city of Beijing: the Manchu community and the Han community, and two languages appeared in the city: the official dialect of the Ming Dynasty and the Manchu language.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    I think Mandarin is the easiest thing to learn.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Manchu Chinese is an alternative Chinese that is said by Manchu people with their tongues curled and changed the pronunciation of Chinese characters, understand? A large number of Chinese characters are pronounced differently, which is a crime.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    This is because Mandarin is inherently special.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    This is because they don't speak Chinese.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It doesn't matter. Mandarin did not evolve from Manchu, Mandarin evolved from the dialect of the ancient capital Beijing.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Mandarin was developed on the basis of the northern dialect represented by Beijing dialect, which was the popular language in Beijing after the Manchus entered the customs, and was a mixed language produced by the communication between the Manchus and the Han people.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    It is possible that Bai is related, because Manchurian Qing Du and Mongolian Russo, Korean and Japanese

    Yudu and English versions.

    The same is two tones and two voices up, four tones down, pay attention to the tone and frustration, and the Chinese language has added one and three tones, otherwise the Chinese language is Jinzhou Huludao tune! Mandarin is influenced by Manchu in this tone, and if you go to Manchuria, Chinese will remove the second and fourth tones to be pure Chinese!!

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Mandarin itself is made up of a mixture of many languages, so there must be some elements of Manchu, just as Japanese must have some elements of Mandarin.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Mandarin is the language of the Han people, while Manchu is the language of the Manchu people, and after a period of interaction between the two ethnic groups, the two languages eventually evolved into each other.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Mao has no relationship, according to.

    It is proved that the Beijing dialect was basically formed in the middle and late Ming Dynasty, and there were only hundreds of thousands of people after the Manchus entered the customs, how could it have a large impact on the Chinese accent, at most it had an impact on some vocabulary, and Chinese belonged to the Sino-Tibetan language family, and theoretically Chinese and the minority languages in southern China are related, Manchu belongs to the Tungusic language family of the Altaic language family, and there is no blood relationship with Chinese, not to mention that Mandarin is a Manchu change, nonsense, This can be verified from the fact that there are only a few hundred old people who can speak Manchu now, and the pronunciation of Mandarin has little to do with Manchu, it is just a naturally formed common language.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Ordinary copy dialect is just a kind of accent in the official dialect of Chinese. Du Manchu is a large linguistic category.

    Mandarin: Isolation: Zhi class dao - Sino-Tibetan language family - Chinese family - Chinese - Chinese Mandarin ——— Youyan Blockbuster (or Beijing Mandarin) - Jingshi Xiaopian - Jingshi Beicheng dialect.

    Shengjing Manchu: Adhesive language class - Altaic language family - Manchu language family - Manchu - Kanto Manchu - Fengtian blockbuster - Shengjing small piece - Manchu Shengjing dialect.

    Jingshi Manchu: Adhesive language class - Altaic language family - Manchurian language family - Manchu - Kansai Manchu - Jingshi blockbuster - Jingshi small piece - Jingshi inner city banner dialect.

    Mandarin: Hello.

    Shengjing Manchu: si saiyvn.

    Two completely different words.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Because the last dynasty in China's feudal society was the Qing Dynasty, and the Qing Dynasty was established with satisfaction, it had the deepest influence on Mandarin, and now Mandarin has a lot of Manchu vocabulary.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Because Mandarin is a local language in Beijing, the language of this place was influenced by the Qing Dynasty, so such words appeared.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Because of the history of China's development, and there are many kinds of Chinese characters and meanings, and many local languages have the same meaning.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    There is a traditional cross talk called "Manchurian dialect", and Manchurian dialect is Manchu.

    Manchu and Mandarin are two different things, Mandarin is based on the northern dialect of Mandarin, and Beijing pronunciation is the standard tone.

    Now the Manchus who can speak Manchu are almost gone, and everyone can speak Mandarin.

    Manchu has had an impact on Mandarin, and the "Saqima" and "cat's waist" in modern Mandarin are both Manchu words, but they are essentially two different things.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Mandarin translates to mandarin in English, which means Manchurian, because the standard pronunciation it uses is indeed the language used by the Manchus in Beijing after their sinicization, (abolishing the intonation sound, adding the Manchu prenasal and post-nasal sounds, and the warped tongue sound) In other words, today's Beijing dialect is mainly the popular pronunciation in Beijing after the Manchus entered the customs.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    No, Mandarin is much simpler.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    After the Manchus entered the customs, they spoke Chinese with an accent, and this accent is today's Mandarin, and then the Manchus forced the Han people to speak this kind of Chinese with a Manchu accent, of course, to this day, Mandarin is Chinese, and Mandarin is definitely not ancient Chinese.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    In ancient times, it was not only our country that used Chinese characters, but also Japan, Korea, Vietnam, etc., take a Chinese character article, people from all over the world read it differently, in fact, different parts of China, the pronunciation is also different, for example, Shanghainese people read the same article, they can't understand each other, the Manchus also use Chinese characters, and the pronunciation of Chinese characters they read is today's Mandarin, because the Manchus ruled for nearly 300 years, and the Han people who want to be officials, they have to speak Manchu (Mandarin), so it has been gradually promoted, and most people can understand it.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Mandarin is not Manchu.

    Today's Mandarin is based on the pronunciation of Beijing Mandarin (different from Beijing Hutong) and has been modified, with Luanping as the general standard, Northern dialect as the basic dialect, and exemplary modern vernacular writings as the grammatical norm.

    Although Mandarin is based on the northern dialect, there is a historical reason for this, after all, Beijing was the ancient capital of the Three Dynasties, and many other regional dialects were also referenced in the standardization.

    Many people mistakenly classify Mandarin or Beijing dialect as Manchu, probably because the Qing Dynasty made the capital in Beijing and designated Beijing dialect as the official language, but the language itself will be affected by historical development, such as the Beijing dialect has absorbed some Manchu.

    However, neither Mandarin nor the Beijing dialect is Manchu. First of all, the Manchus had their own language, that is, Manchu. Secondly, Mandarin is based on the northern dialect and the grammatical norms of typical modern vernacular writings, while Beijing dialect is not equal to Mandarin.

    Generally, the change of dynasties is to use the national capital Yayan (dialect) as the official language, such as Luoyang dialect, Chang'an dialect, etc., with the passage of history, or under the influence of other ethnic cultures, the language will also have corresponding development. This is very normal, as long as our culture is not replaced or eliminated, it can be regarded as cultural exchange and collision.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    Yes, Mandarin is the pronunciation of Chinese characters learned by the Manchus, for example, suppose that the English spoken by Zhejiang people is better than American and British English, and the English pronunciation of Zhejiang people is learned all over the world, and it is popularized to everyone in the world, but English is still English, and it cannot be said that English is Zhejiang.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    Today when we read Tang poems in Mandarin, we sometimes find that they do not rhyme, and this is obvious.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    No, it used to be in classical Chinese, and New China only began to speak vernacular.

  32. Anonymous users2024-01-06

    No. Mandarin is modern standard Chinese, also known as Chinese and Mandarin. Its titles vary from place to place, but they all use Beijing pronunciation as the standard sound, northern dialect as the basic dialect, and exemplary modern vernacular works as the grammatical norms, which are the common languages spoken in Chinese mainland, Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan and overseas Chinese, and as the standard language of official, teaching, **.

    Mandarin is the official language of the People's Republic of China, one of the four official languages of Singapore, and one of the six official working languages of the United Nations. Article 19 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of China stipulates that "the State shall promote the use of Putonghua throughout the country".

    The Law of the People's Republic of China on the Standard Spoken and Written Language of the People's Republic of China establishes the legal status of Putonghua as the "national standard language".

  33. Anonymous users2024-01-05

    How is it possible, where are a bunch of fools making up, you also believe it.

  34. Anonymous users2024-01-04

    Nowadays, the Manchus basically speak Chinese.

    There was a process of the Manchu loss of their mother tongue, and some sources confirm that until the end of the Qing Dynasty, some of the lower Manchus in Beijing were still using Manchu. After Xinhai, the Manchu language of the Manchu people in Guannai must have quickly disappeared. Because of the serious ethnic discrimination at that time, almost all the Mongolian banner people, Han army banner people, and most of the Manchurian banner people in the urban "banner clan" were forced to hide their previous "flag clan" identity, and naturally no one dared to speak Manchu again.

    In the mid-to-late 20th century, only a few Manchus in villages far away in the Heilongjiang and Nenjiang valleys still had some daily Manchu conversations.

  35. Anonymous users2024-01-03

    At the end of the Qing Dynasty, only Manchus in remote areas still spoke Manchu, and after the Xinhai Revolution, it was gradually replaced by Chinese, and the number of people who could speak Manchu was very small.

Related questions
6 answers2024-02-25

Han'er dialect, the Northeast dialect, originated in the Northern Wei Dynasty, initially formed in the Liao Dynasty, matured in the Yuan Dynasty, the Yuan Dynasty accent is close to the modern era, the Ming and Qing dynasties inherited the Yuan Dynasty accent, (these are the Zhengshuo Ye Emperor at that time, the strength of the south is slightly inferior to the emperor). >>>More

4 answers2024-02-25

1. My aspirations (or ideals).

Each of us has our own aspirations and ideals, which are our goals and sources of motivation for our progress on the road of life. When we were very young, our parents and teachers would often ask us: What is your ideal and what kind of person do you want to be when you grow up? >>>More

15 answers2024-02-25

In Mandarin, n and l are two very different sounds. The two sounds have different ways of overcoming the obstacle in the way of pronunciation, n is nasal, l is marginal, so the words "female and brigade", "mud and pear", "male and blue" are never confused. However, in some dialects, most people do not distinguish between n and l, and read it as l, and read "traveler" as "female guest" and "helpless" as "scoundrel". >>>More

29 answers2024-02-25

Mandarin is used for communication, and whether it is standard or not will not affect communication. As long as both sides can understand each other's meaning, what if it is not standard? Another point is that the essence of Mandarin is Manchu Chinese. >>>More

10 answers2024-02-25

Summary: Speaking Mandarin often will allow you to improve your language level, give you more opportunities when applying for jobs, and make your leaders feel that you are a civilized person and trustworthy. There are many benefits to speaking Mandarin that will benefit you a lot. >>>More