In history, Zhuge Liang or Sima Yi is better

Kong Ming's sadness lies in the fact that although he has the ability, he has not met a good lord.

Liu Bei was too fake, so Jingzhou was not taken early, which affected the process of unifying China; Later, he fought with Wu on his own, and was defeated, and he lost the merits he had painstakingly accumulated before. That's why I said"Hatred swallows Wu"

Later, Liu Chan was incompetent and squandered Kong Ming's ability in vain.

Cao Cao is eloquent, with excellent overall planning ability and writing ability, but the only pity is that he is a little suspicious, so he has not met a person with great wisdom like Zhuge Liang. Although there is a Sima Yi, he is loyal to the Cao family in his heart, so he did not tell his descendants to guard against the Sima family.

In this way, they did not meet the object of real domination of the world, orthodoxy harmed Zhuge Liang, Cao Cao was suspicious, and destroyed the orthodoxy of traditional Confucianism, so the two did not go together. What a pity @

Moreover, their goals themselves are different. Cao Cao took the unification of the world as his responsibility, and Zhuge Liang took the task of assisting Ming Jun as his responsibility, with different categories and different aspirations.

This depends on what angle you look at, just from the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Luo Guanzhong's Zhuge Liang is a character who rebellious against the sky, burning Chibi, the Three Kingdoms, and finally the territory of Shu, at that time, the situation of three points in the world can be said to be if it were not for Zhuge Liang to come out of the mountain, these are impossible. Sima Yi is nothing compared to him. Moreover, Sima Yi himself was afraid of Zhuge Liang, and he didn't dare to attack the city if he had a plan to empty the city.

If you want to say that history is true, it is more troublesome to research now, and if you really want to be better than anyone, you may have to look for all kinds of history books and see their respective achievements.

If you want to say what I think, their abilities are always about the same, the battle of Chibi, Shu can dominate one side, although maybe Zhuge Liang's role is not as big as that of the old man Luo Guanzhong, but since he can be favored by him, he has participated in it, and after so much time, he can still be us, think about the role that is always powerful. And Sima Yi, not to mention, as the general of the Wei State, which was the strongest at that time, was able to serve as the leader of such a big country, and was valued by Cao Cao, he was always strong. It's really hard to say in comparison.

I'm sorry for giving such an ambiguous answer, saying the same answer as not saying ha).

Sima Yi not only 'consumed' Zhuge Liang, but his own strength (strategy, courage) was also a few points stronger than Zhuge Liang.

In real history, the intelligence of two people is comparable, and they win and lose each other's battles, and they are not so mysterious as in **.

The winner is the king and the defeat is the villain, and naturally the final winner Sima Yi is more powerful. Don't believe in the prejudice of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms against Shu, if it is really so strong, why is it still defeated?

My personal feeling is Sima Yi, when Sima Yi first started by Cao Cao's side, he was very aware of the current affairs of the retreat, and then seized power and established the Western Jin Dynasty, it can be said that he is the winner of the battle of the Three Kingdoms.

In terms of ability, in fact, both of them are very good, but their fates are different, and I personally think that Zhuge Liang is good, at least he is loyal.

No one is more powerful, everyone is nothing more than for fame and fortune, in terms of profit, the Sima family unified the Three Kingdoms, and naturally Sima is powerful, and Zhuge has been deified in name, so naturally Zhuge is powerful.

Of course, it was Sima Yi, who died first out of Qishan, and Sima unified the Three Kingdoms.

Personally, I think that in military terms, they are equal. Sima Yi has a heavy army, but compared to Zhuge Liang, its strategy is slightly inferior. As the saying goes, the ruler is short, the inch is long, and they are just as powerful.

But if there is a real war, I am afraid that Zhuge Liang will not have many soldiers, and he will be defeated by Sima Yi.

Sima Yi is powerful, and Zhuge Liang was blown up by Luo Guanzhong.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms", as one of the four famous novels in my country, has been sought after by many people, and many people have made it into a TV series. However, with the advent of TV series, many people regard "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" as history, and the funniest thing is that some people compare TV series with ** to see who is really powerful. To be honest, in the real history, Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi did not have a real confrontation, but from their respective lives and strategies, they can know who is powerful.

1. Politically, Zhuge Liang is powerfulZhuge Liang, who is now portrayed in **, is a talent in both politics and military, but in fact this is not the case. Many of the schemes and plots were modified by the author with other characters'. For example, "Empty City Strategy", "Burning Rattan Armor Soldiers", etc., have little to do with Zhuge Liang.

After reading the analysis, many people think that Zhuge Liang is an incompetent person, which is a bit taken out of context. Zhuge Liang's real ability is mainly to suppress the scholars of Bashu after Tuogu, and then he cultivated talents like Jiang Wei. From the perspective of political ability, Zhuge Liang is still more powerful, and the person who can write "The Teacher's Table" is not a mediocre talent.

2, Sima Yisheng is ambitiousCompared with Zhuge Liang, Sima Yi was the last to laugh, after all, the Sima family stole the Cao family's fruit in the end. Sima Yi is a more tolerant person, and when Jiang Wei was crusading, he maintained the psychology of "not seeking merit but seeking no fault". Coupled with the weakness of the Cao clan at that time, the Sima clan gradually gained power and successfully stole the fruits of the Cao clan.

If you look at it from the perspective of ambition, Sima Yi is indeed relatively strong, but from the political point of view, he is not as good as Zhuge Liang. can hold on to Jiang Wei for many years in the military, and he is also a relatively powerful character.

3. Not history

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" mythologizes Zhuge Liang and adds a lot of magic to Zhuge Liang, making Sima Yi look like a clown, but what is the truth in history?

It must be that Zhuge Liang is more powerful, and in some wars that have occurred in the past, Zhuge Liang has always been slightly better.

In real history, Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi are on par, Zhuge Liang is more powerful in the military field, and Sima Yi is more powerful in employing people.

Wei is strong and in the Central Plains, the people are fierce, even if Sima Yi is worse than Zhuge Liang, but Wei is like an elephant that can only hurt its fur, Xishu is defeated in a slightly lower stature but united to enviable, Dongwu wins in the people are rich and the country is strong, and there are many talents.

In real history, the strength of the two is still about the same, but Zhuge Liang is better

Zhuge is a king, in addition to fighting with Cao Zhen, Zhang He, and Sima Yi on the frontal battlefield, he also has to balance the forces in Shuzhong.

Sima Yi is purely to the end, using a lifetime of experience to bully the minor and Cao Shuang, the bronze.

Chen Shou's evaluation: Zhirong is the director, and his strategy is short. is a real evaluation, and there is nothing to gain from Qishan in the six exits.

This should be said in the big picture. It must be Sima Yi who is powerful. Wei, Shu and Wu were all unified by the Sima family. And the person who laid the foundation for Sima Yan was Sima Yi.

Of course it's Zhuge Liang, let me tell you this, Sima Yi took two or three exams with more than ninety points, Zhuge Liang with more than ninety points, what astrology, six dings and six jia, Qimen Dunjia, fighting soldiers and fighting generals fighting and fighting in the heart, which time did not make Sima Yi suffer. It's just that the national strength is not as good as that of Wei, and the land of Wei and Kyushu fought in the land of Shu and one state is still desperately resisting, and every battle of Zhuge Northern Expedition will be rewarded. Defeated the migrants, defeated and retreated.

Sima Yi killed Zhuge Liang in Wuzhang Plain. Zhuge Liang's various methods were ineffective.

Zhuge Liang died of heaven's will, not because of a heavy rain, Sima Yi was burned to death in the battle of the upper valley, Zhuge Liang's life was short Sima Yi's life was long, Zhuge Liang's luck was bad, Sima Yi's luck was good, both sides won and lost, Zhuge Liang was good at attacking, Sima Yi was good at defending, Zhuge Liang had a three-inch tongue, Sima Yi was stoic and spicy! Zhuge Liang is good at governing the country and using soldiers, and Sima Yi is good at using people.

Of course, Zhuge Liang is amazing, how to compare a hard difficulty and an easy difficulty.

Zhuge Liang is omnipotent, and Sima Yi is biased.

Nothing to do! Nonsense! The Jin Dynasty belonged to the Sima family! Is that right?

Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang fought several times in their lives, Sima Yi was frightened back by the empty city plan, and was almost burned to death in Shanggu but finally escaped, and there should be no winner in the long-term confrontation. Sima Yi was defeated repeatedly, exchanging defeat for time and space, and finally dragged Zhuge Liang down. Purely in terms of who is more powerful, Zhuge Liang is undoubtedly higher than Sima Yi.

Zhuge Liang is even more powerful, he helped Liu Bei divide the world when Liu Bei had nothing, such an ability is not something that Sima Yi can do.

Sima Yi is powerful, because Sima Yi finally won the world, while Zhuge Liang not only did not win the world, but also exhausted himself to death.

If you look at the results, Sima Yi is more powerful, after all, Zhuge Liang's four Northern Expeditions were all prevented by Sima Yi and did not take advantage. But Zhuge Liang also has his own strengths, such as his invention of the repeating crossbow, Kong Ming lantern and wooden ox flowing horse, which Sima Yi cannot compare.

I think Zhuge Liang is more powerful, because Zhuge Liang is a well-known god operator, he is resourceful, brave and strategic, Zhuge Liang is the embodiment of wisdom, he used a straw boat to borrow arrows when he was standing in Cao Cao.

Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang are not equal, they are not up or down, they both have their own good things, and they are very powerful in military affairs.

I think Sima Yi is better. Because Sima Yi was more forbearing, and in the end, the three kingdoms were all returned to Sima Yi, and Sima Yi's merits were greater than Zhuge Liang's.

I think it's Zhuge Liang, because Zhuge Liang has repeatedly gained the upper hand in the confrontation with Sima Yi, and once almost killed Sima Yi, it's a pity that God didn't make a beauty and let Sima Yi escape.

In terms of personal ability, I think Zhuge Liang is better. The reason is that Zhuge Liang helped Liu Bei, who was the weakest in the Three Kingdoms, to establish the Shu State, and in the battle between the Three Kingdoms, the battle led by Zhuge Liang won more and lost less.

From the perspective of the country and the world, I think Sima Yi is better. The reason is that Sima Yi helped the Cao family stabilize the political situation in the Central Plains, and during the Three Kingdoms period, Sima Yi helped Wei establish the strongest economic and military regime among the three kingdoms. At the same time, as far as the family is concerned, Sima Yi is also successful, after all, Sima Zhao is his son.

Campaign commanded by Sima Yi.

In the first month of 228, Sima Yi traveled thousands of miles to capture Meng Da, passed on the first Beijing division, and captured more than 10,000 people.

In 230, Sima Yi served as a general, increased the governor, and fake Huang Yue, and participated in the destruction of Shu.

In 231, Sima Yiyi supervised the military forces of Yong and Liang and began to preside over the war against Shu.

Regarding the Fourth Qishan War with Zhuge Liang in 231, the Book of Jin records that Sima Yi defeated Zhuge Liang, beheaded 10,000 prisoners, and sent Zhang He to chase him, but Zhang He was shot in the knee and died. "The Spring and Autumn Period of the Han and Jin Dynasties" records that Zhuge Liang defeated Sima Yi, the first three thousand, and ambushed Zhang He.

In the spring of 234, Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of Shu, led an army of 100,000 out of the valley to attack Wei, and Sima Yi led the army to cross the Weishui River and build a fortress against the water. The two armies confronted each other. Sima Yi in order to avoid a two-front battle! Soochow is also going all out on the Northern Expedition!

In May 234, the Wu army attacked Wei with 100,000 troops in three ways to cooperate with the Shu army. In July, the Wu army was defeated and retreated, and then in August, Zhuge Liang died of illness in the Wuzhang original army.

In the first month of 238, Sima Yi led Niu Jin, Hu Zun and others to ride 40,000 horses to conquer Gongsun Yuan, break Xiangping, and slaughter more than 7,000 people.

In April 241, Sun Quan attacked Wei, Sima Yi led his army south, and Wu's army was defeated. Sima Yi immediately planned to create a military camp in Huainan and Huaibei.

In April 251, Sima Yi led an army against Wang Ling. Wang Ling's whole family is dead!

The campaign commanded by Zhuge Liang.

In the spring of the sixth year of Shu Jianxing 228, Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition, lost the street pavilion, beheaded the horse, and degraded himself to the right general.

In the winter of the same year, in 228, Zhuge Liang went out of the pass and surrounded Chencang. The grain ran out and retreated to Hanzhong.

In the seventh year of Shu Jianxing in 229, Zhuge Liang went on another northern expedition and captured Wudu and Yinping, which were close to the two counties of Hanzhong, and the Wei army withdrew immediately after arriving!

In the ninth year of Shu Jianxing 231 Zhuge Liang's fourth northern expedition attacked Qishan and ambushed Zhang He in Mumendao. The Book of Jin records that Sima Yi won a great victory, cut down thousands of plans, and sent Zhang He to chase him and was shot in the knee and killed. "The Spring and Autumn Period of the Han and Jin Dynasties" records that Zhuge Liang won a great victory, with three thousand firsts, and ambushed Zhang He.

In March 234 AD, Zhuge Liang led the whole country and led an army of 100,000 to carry out the fifth northern expedition.

The Wei general Sima Yi led a large army to the south bank of the Weishui River and confronted Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of the Han Dynasty, across the martial arts water.

In July 234 of the same year, the main force of the Wu army that cooperated with the Northern Expedition on the other side was defeated and retreated, and then in August, Zhuge Liang died of illness after hearing about it. It should be said that Zhuge Liang died in the expectation of the Northern Expedition of Wu, when Wu was strong and Shu was weak!