Who is powerful Zhuge Liang or Shi Ma Yi?

Updated on history 2024-03-28
10 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Like Hannibal and Fabian, the former has strange tactics and makes flexible use of political and diplomatic tactics; The latter may be more like an orthodox soldier, who recognizes a strategy and resolutely implements it to the end. It turned out that the more talented Hannibal lost to Fabian, who could only make one move.

    In the romance, Zhuge Liang should be praised and Sima Yi belittled, but Shu Han was only six unsuccessful out of Qishan. It is said that Zhuge Liang's choice of timing to send troops should be good, but it seems that he is not good at selecting generals and direct command.

    So Zhuge Liang may not be able to fight a war.

    Zhuge Liang's strength is the internal affairs or logistics, which is the icing on the cake for the Wei State.

    The Sima family is the family that finally ended Cao Wei, and if it is put in Shu Han, Liu Bei may not be able to accommodate them when he is alive; Or even if it can last until the period when Zhuge Liang is in power, eighty percent will be the monarch himself, and will not be like Zhuge Liang who is at most monopolistic in power. Therefore, Zhuge Liang can mobilize Shu Han to exert his strength in one place, while Sima Yi is probably good at using ready-made national resources.

    However, with the national strength of Shu Han, it is far away to engage in unification, and the Sima family to Shu Han is at most a local warlord who has existed for a long time; And Zhuge Liang to Wei, as long as the internal affairs are in order or icing on the cake, the war is seized, and there are a few diplomatic strategies during the Battle of Chibi, or a few legendary escapes of the northern nomads, and there is no shortage of generals who are in charge of the army, and the unification of China should also be certain.

    Therefore, I personally feel that the two have their own abilities, and Sima Yi's final support for Zhuge Liang is mostly a factor of national strength.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Sima Yi was ashamed to say that he was not as good as Zhuge Liang after the empty city plan, and said, "Zhuge Liang is a true god, I am not as good as him", Zhuge Liang is generally strategizing behind the scenes, not going out of the mountain to know everything in the world, and Zhuge Liang is more upright and friendly, Sima Yi is relatively deceitful and ruthless. I think that whether it is in terms of bearing or intelligence, Sima Yi is inferior to Sima Yi.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Personally, I think it is Sima Yi 41, because Zhuge 6 went out of Qishan to attack Wei and failed for various reasons, but 41 was passive defense and economic development, and then his grandson killed Shu at one time, and Zhuge was portrayed as the embodiment of wisdom in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and Zhuge Liang in history was engaged in politics and did not understand military ......

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Sima Yi. The book "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" respects Liu and Cao. Even when Zhuge Liang was defeated and retreated, the author had to ask Sima Yi to say "Zhuge Liang is a true god, I am not as good as him" so that Zhuge Liang was defeated as if he had won, in the book "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Zhuge Zhong and Sima Traitor were deeply stationed in people's hearts.

    So people always stand up to Zhuge Liang all the time. Again, don't read the history book ("Three Kingdoms") with any prejudice

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Zhuge Liang is more powerful.

    Zhuge Liang (181 - October 8, 234), the name Kongming, the name Wolong, Xuzhou Langya Yangdu (now Yinan County, Shandong Province), the prime minister of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period, an outstanding politician, military strategist, inventor and writer in ancient China.

    Zhuge Liang is good at governing the army, and Chen Shou mentioned in "Three Kingdoms, Shu Zhi, Zhuge Liang Biography" that Zhuge Liang "governs Rong for the long". Zhuge Liang also said in the article "On Recommending Liu Ba": "Strategizing is in the middle of the battle, I am not as good as the beginning of the child!"

    If the drum is raised, it will meet the army gate, and the people will be brave and brave, and they should be the ears of the people. It can be seen that Zhuge Liang governs the army well.

    Zhuge Liang has also been highly recognized as a military strategist in the past dynasties. After Zhuge Liang's death, Sima Yi saw Zhuge Liang's camp and praised him as "the genius of the world".

    Economy: Zhuge Liang in Hanzhong Hushi persuasion of agriculture, the use of Hanzhong's economic conditions, according to local conditions to take a series of effective measures to develop production, so that the Northern Expedition military funds were basically solved on the spot, after Zhuge Liang's death, the Shu Han army retreated, the Wei army also in the Shu camp "get its books, grain and grain".

    This just shows the effect of Zhuge Liang's persuasion of farmers and the implementation of military cultivation warfare. If the local people live well, they will be able to attract more people, so that Hanzhong, which is vast and sparsely populated, will be able to develop again, and gradually reach a virtuous circle of more people and more food, so that the people can "live in peace and enjoy their work."

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    I think Sima Yi is more powerful, although Sima Yi's reputation is not as strong as Zhuge Liang's now, but Sima Yi's military strength is indeed very good.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Zhuge Liang was more powerful, Zhuge Liang was more talented at that time, and Sima Yi was not his opponent, so he was more powerful.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Zhuge Liang is more powerful, Zhuge Liang's strength should not be underestimated, Zhuge Liang is also very talented, and he is a very good military strategist.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Zhuge Liang is a little more powerful, when Zhuge Liang was alive, Sima Yi did not dare to confront Zhuge Liang head-on.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Zhuge Liang is a little more powerful, Zhuge Liang is very famous in history, he has won many wars.

Related questions
15 answers2024-03-28

There is no comparison, if you want to talk about the image of later generations, of course, it is still Shang Ying.

13 answers2024-03-28

It should be Jiang Ziya.

Because Jiang Ziya's deeds are very old, people at that time did not develop the habit of recording history truthfully and in detail, so no one doubts that his deeds are true or false, and there is no basis for doubt. >>>More

8 answers2024-03-28

Zhuge Liang should be Sima Yi's lifelong enemy, but in fact they are also real confidants, and they are all excellent. They are also very similar in many ways. Sima Yi has been in a weak position in the years of confrontation, because Sima Yi cannot compete with Zhuge Liang in terms of military ability. >>>More

21 answers2024-03-28

Because Sima Yi was very good at cultivating children, he was suspicious of Cao Cao, so he focused on cultivating his son. Zhuge Liang is too busy, he can't finish the affairs of Shu, and he doesn't have the energy to teach his talents to his children, so he is weak.

36 answers2024-03-28

Kong Ming's sadness lies in the fact that although he has the ability, he has not met a good lord. >>>More