Why did Shu fail to unify the world, and what would happen if Shu unified the world during the Three

Economy, the Sichuan Plain is so big, how can it be compared with the whole country, the population is small, there are no soldiers, and the economy is not good. Outland. As for talents, Zhuge Liang was mythologized, not so strong. So failure is inevitable hunger.

The monarch of the late Shu Kingdom was incompetent, and there was also a plan in the sky.

My point of view is that if Shu Han.

If you unify the world, it is better to unify the world than Jin.

There are several main reasons:

First, there are internal defects in the country of Shuhan, that is, Jingzhou Group, Dongzhou Group, and Yizhou.

The groups are tilting against each other, and there are many internal contradictions, Zhuge Liang.

When he was alive, he could barely hold it down (it can only be said that it was reluctantly, Li Yan.

The noisy and cranky week.

has never stopped). After Zhuge Liang died, the three groups were about to fight, imagine that a Yizhou is not well governed, what about the thirteen states in the world?

Second, the Shu Han was nominally the Eastern Han Dynasty.

The continuation, that is, the inheritance of the Eastern Han Dynasty. At that time, the Eastern Han Dynasty, whether it was official management or military management, had been corrupted, especially the inspection system.

The system of electing officials under the conscription system has deteriorated, and it should be Cao Wei who is popular.

The "Nine Products in the Positive System, the Shiren Group to grasp the power of the state is the trend of the times, Shu Han against the sky, disaster is not long in coming.

Third, the ruling order of Shu Han was basically Zhuge Liang's monopoly during Zhuge Liang's lifetime, while Cao Wei was Sima Yi.

Chen Qun, Cao Zhen.

Cao Xiu and other civil and military forces, if Shu Han unified the world, assuming that Zhuge Liang was still alive, a person with a strong desire for power like Zhuge Liang would be able to get busy with everything and be determined by Liang? After Zhuge Liang died, Shu Han was in a mess, Jiang Wan, Dong Yun, and Fei Yi.

Jiang Wei doesn't have the same great talent as Zhuge Liang, so he can only look forward to the emergence of new talents, is this a bet?

Fourth, as mentioned above, Shu Han has already lost talent, and no successor is the deadliest place for Shu Han, and it is already very difficult to defend itself.

Having said so much, even if Shu Han is unified, the general trend of Chinese history will not change much, the scholar group will still rise, and the ** selection system of the Jiupin Zhongzheng system will also develop, and the phenomenon of famous families controlling the dynasty will still appear, if Shu Han rebels against these historical trends, it will perish, and if it conforms to the historical trend, it will become the new Jin Dynasty. Of course, it may be a little longer than the Western Jin Dynasty, after all, the royal family (prince) of Shu Han has no actual power, unlike the Jin Dynasty, so there may not be the "Eight Kings Rebellion" of the Western Jin Dynasty.

If Shu unifies the world, Liu Bei is likely to restore the Han dynasty and continue the rule of the Han Dynasty.

Then there will be no Qin Shi Huang, and there will be no modern ancient buildings in our country, which will be a very big loss.

With the manpower and material resources of Liangyi and Erzhou, it is even more difficult to take the Shu Road and cross the Qinling Mountains to fight against Cao Wei, which includes Yong, Henan, and, Hebei, You, Qing, Yan and Xu, and lives in the heart of China. Liu Beizhi is not as good as Liu Bang, just as Xiang Yu can't match Cao Cao. Cao Cao's talent is slightly higher than Liu Bei, the Central Plains is full of talents in Shu Han, and Liu Bei relies on a Zhuge Liang alone, and it is difficult to support it alone.

The population, materials, and talents needed to compete in the world are not comparable to Cao Wei, so it is naturally difficult for the power of Shu to dominate the world.

It was impossible, because there was a gap in manpower and material resources at that time, and there was no ability to develop the south after years of war.

It will definitely unify the world, after all, the strength of Shu is very strong, and there are a lot of capable soldiers, if he develops the south, he will definitely unify the world.

I think in the end they didn't unify the world, because they had exhausted all their efforts and all their obsessions to create all this, but in the end, they couldn't unify the world.

In the end, it was not possible to unify the world, because the Jiangnan region was occupied by Sun Ce, and it was basically difficult to conquer it.

OK. Because they still have a lot of strength to attack the south, and if they occupy the south, they are likely to unify the world.

You can't unify the world, because it's very difficult to unify the world. This requires a strong force and an absolute strategic strategy.

No, because the proportion of his army at that time was all northerners, and it was difficult for him to adapt to the climatic conditions and geography of the south.

By the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, there were four counties in the southern and central areas: Yueshan, Qiqi, Yizhou, and Yongchang. After Liu Bei entered Shu, he controlled Nanzhong by forceful means (the governor of Shu Han was the earliest of the four governors, which was specially used to control Nanzhong), and the benefits were also considerable, so whether politically or economically, the Northern Expedition was the only way out for Shu Han.

If Wei is not defeated, the factional contradictions in Shu Han will intensify, and the relationship with Eastern Wu will also deteriorate, which is extremely unfavorable for Shu Han.

The terrain of Shu is easy to defend and difficult to attack. But there are many mountains around, and in the south there are a lot of mountains and plateaus. In such an area, it is inherently easy to breed local separatist forces.

In fact, after Liu Bei's death, there were many rebellions in various parts of the south. Shu was able to maintain its rule in the south, Liu Bei only surnamed Liu wanted to call himself orthodox in a proper name, the question is who cares about you, Cao Cao, Sun Jian, Sun Ce, Sun Quan, Liu Biao at that time was okay, Liu Bei was not sweet.

The political system of the Shu Han Dynasty inherited the form of "virtual monarch reality" in the early years of the Western Han Dynasty, with Emperor Liu Chan in charge of "palace" affairs, Prime Minister Zhuge Liang in charge of "palace" affairs, clear boundaries between the inner court and the outer court, and state decrees from the prime minister's office. First of all, Dongwu may not really cooperate, and it is likely to make a stumbling block behind it, and secondly, under the premise of the lack of a horse army, it is difficult to win against the Wei army near Chang'an, and if you win, you will win a small victory, and if you lose, you will lose miserably.

It is not something that can be developed in a short period of time. Even a civilized tribal patriarch like Meng Shu had spent a lot of money and grain in Shu, so it was appropriate for Zhuge Liang to take measures of both grace and power. It was impossible to develop and build the south with the power of Shu Han at that time.

Strengthen Shu first. Turn Shu into a small power. After all, Shu is only a small country.

The advantage of Shu is that there are natural dangers, and it is difficult for Shu to go to the sky. Many Yamaguchi Kazuo should be closed. Just send troops to guard it.

It was not so easy for Wei to sneak attack.

This assumption simply does not hold true, because every period of history has a meaning to exist. And there is no scientific basis for such an assumption.

In the end, it was not possible to unify the world, although the strength of Shu was very strong, but if it was fully developed in the south, the north would be relatively weak.

Yes. Because if Shu makes every effort to develop the south, the national strength will become stronger and stronger, so it should be able to unify the world in the end.

No. If Zhuge Liang's troops were to guide the party, it would be possible to seize Bengal and some of the shy territories in the south and drink the Bay of Bengal, so as to get some jewelry and seafood for Liu Chan and them. However, even if Shu's military resources increased, Zhuge Liang still did not have the ability to lead troops to defeat Lu Xun, and the Northern Expedition still had no hope of victory.

No, because if you want to unify the whole country, you must carry out the Northern Expedition, and if the Northern Expedition is not successful, it is only a luxury to unify the world.

At that time, the strength of Shu Han to develop and build the south was insufficient. The powerful Shu Kingdom is the first. Turn Shu into a small force.

After all, Shu is only a small country. The advantage of Shu is that there is natural danger, and it is difficult for Shu to go to heaven. Many mountain passes are guarded by one person, and 10,000 people cannot force them.

and sent troops to guard it. Wei's sneak attack wasn't that easy.