What are the faults of Zhao Kuangyin and Zhu Yuanzhang?

It is the relationship between cousins and grandchildren, Zhao Kuangyin and Zhao Guangyi are brothers, and Zhao Zhen is Zhao Guangyi's grandson.

1. Comparison:

1. Zhao Kuangyin's greatest contribution and achievement in his life was to restore the unification of the Chinese region and put an end to the nearly 70-year-long situation of separating and fighting between feudal towns and towns since the end of the Tang Dynasty and the Fifth Dynasty. The people who have suffered so much from the war finally have a peaceful and tranquil production and living environment, which has created good conditions for social progress, economic development, and cultural prosperity.

Zhao Kuangyin, as the end of the chaos of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms in the late Tang Dynasty and the pioneer of the Song Dynasty, is an important figure in Chinese history. He has a perfect personality charm: upright-hearted, jealous and hateful, generous, open-minded, tireless in learning, diligent and loving the people, strict with himself, not close to the public, advocating frugality, leading by example, etc., not only has a great exemplary effect on changing the extravagant atmosphere of the past five generations, but also has been deeply talked about by later historians.

2. Zhu Yuanzhang is one of the most outstanding monarchs in Chinese history. He has been diligent in political affairs all his life and has made a lot of achievements, especially the creation of a large number of systems and regulations, which not only laid the foundation of the Ming Dynasty for nearly 300 years, but also influenced the Qing Dynasty. From the Ming Dynasty to the Qing Dynasty, the administrative management system of centralized political rule and unified multi-ethnic state gradually became complete.

2. Introduction: 1. Song Taizu Zhao Kuangyin (March 21, 927, November 14, 976), the word Yuen Long, nicknamed Xiang Child, Zhao Jiuzhong, a native of Zhuo County (now Zhuozhou City, Hebei Province), was born in Jiamaying, Luoyang (now Dongguan, Luoyang Qianhe District, Henan). From the Five Dynasties to the early years of the Northern Song Dynasty, he was a military strategist and martial artist, and the founding emperor of the Song Dynasty. The son of Zhao Hongyin (Song Xuanzu), the commander of the Protector Capital, and his mother was Du (Empress Dowager Zhaoxian).

Zhao Kuangyin defected to Guo Wei during the reign of Emperor Yin of the Later Han Dynasty. After the establishment of the Later Zhou Dynasty, Zhao Kuangyin began to enter the eunuch journey, and was valued by Chai Rong (Later Zhou Shizong), and repeatedly made military exploits during the conquest of the Southern Tang Dynasty. After that, Emperor Gong was forced to take the throne, Zhao Kuangyin ascended the throne, changed to Yuan Jianlong, and the country name was "Song", known as "Song Dynasty" and "Northern Song Dynasty" in history.

2. Emperor Zhu Yuanzhang (1328 - June 24, 1398), the word Guorui, formerly known as Chongba, was later named Xingzong, Haozhou Zhongliren (now Fengyang, Anhui), the founding emperor of the Ming Dynasty.

Zhu Yuanzhang was poor when he was a child and used to herd cattle for landlords. In 1368, Zhu Yuanzhang was proclaimed emperor in Yingtianfu, with the country name Daming and the year name Hongwu. After that, he first pacified the southwest, northwest, northeast and other places, and finally unified China.

In 1398 (the thirty-first year of Hongwu), Zhu Yuanzhang died of illness at the age of 71, the temple name Taizu, the name of Emperor Gao, and the burial of Ming Xiaoling.

1. National interests, Zhu Yuanzhang is the real expulsion of the Tartars and the restoration of the Han people, the Northern Song Dynasty is even inferior to the Later Tang Dynasty of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms, and is basically in a state of being bullied by the Khitan Jin. 2 The country is complete, and it is a unified country in the Ming Dynasty, but not in the Northern Song Dynasty, let alone in the Southern Song Dynasty. 3 From the perspective of achievement, Zhao Da was blown up by Lao Zhu, and took Li Shimin to fight Zhu Bi, and the cattle baby beggar counterattacked at the bottom of the society, which was extremely inspirational and tough.

Even the chosen son of Li Shimin also relies on the gate valve in Guanzhong, and he himself is a child of the aristocratic family. 4 The ability to fight the world, one relies on usurping the throne and enjoys its success, and the other dies to lay down the country and make a judgment.

Do you need to ask this question? Zhu Yuanzhang dumped Zhao Kuangyin for more than ten streets?

Of course, I am Emperor Gao, the Taizu of the Ming Dynasty, the emperor is eloquent, the world returns to the heart, drives out the Tartars, restores China, and creates immortal achievements. And Song Yizu released his military power with a cup of wine, coupled with his ordinary talents, he did not unify the world until his death, and the Song Dynasty was trampled on by Yidi from beginning to end.

Zhu Yuanzhang must be more powerful Zhao Kuangyin is just a founding emperor who does not usurp the throne.

There is no doubt that Zhu Yuanzhang has a higher status and won the position by driving out the Tartars. There is no better way to win the country than to be clear, and there is no easier way to win the country than to be clear.

Yuan Fang: Who wrote the monument of Zhilong Tang and Song dynasties in front of Zhu Yuanzhang's filial piety mausoleum? What does it mean?

Zhu Yuanzhang, Song Taizu, Zhao Kuangyin, the founder of the Northern Song Dynasty in China, the temple name Taizu.

Zhu Yuanzhang, the founding emperor of the Ming Dynasty. A unified feudal regime was established.

Zhu Yuanzhang established a unified feudal regime throughout the country.

Zhu Yuanzhang's high status is not mainly his status, we generally say that his influence on history Zhu's influence on history is definitely more far-reaching than Zhao Kuangyin's.

Whether it is the good side, the expulsion of the Tartars, the opening up of the territory, the unification of the whole country, the new system, or the bad side, the "four major cases in the early Ming Dynasty" (Hu Weiyong's case, the empty seal case, the Guo Huan case, the Lanyu case) wrongly killed countless innocents, abolished the power of the prime minister (led to the later establishment of the cabinet by Zhu Di, ** centralization of power is more unstable), wrong Tuo Gu (when the Emperor Jianwen was passed on to Qi Tai and Qi Tai, Huang Zicheng, Fang Xiaoru three, these three are all nerds,,, especially Huang Zicheng, he is so arrogant, fuck, I really want to fan him, but look at this person is really loyal, Forget it), all of them have a very far-reaching impact on the development of history.

However, the highest achievement in the Ming Dynasty is still classmate Zhu Di Hehe, it's not easy to fight so much by yourself Dude, let's look at it, hehe.

Joke, how can a butcher compare with my Zhao Dabi?

It should be Zhu Yuanzhang, the emperor of the Ming Dynasty, I usually think that in ancient Chinese history, the Song Dynasty was also a very well-founded dynasty, and it was bullied by a few famous ethnic groups such as the Khitan and the Jurchen.

It must be Zhu Yuanzhang, Zhu Yuanzhang basically completed the unification of China, and the Song Dynasty never unified the original territory.

Zhu Yuanzhang, he successfully resisted the Yuan Dynasty and stood out among many rebel armies, and his territory was larger than Zhao Kuangyin.

Just look at the surname, Zhao is lying on his stomach, Zhu is standing, who do you say is tall!

Gong is not a person's work, and it is not a person's work.

What is the comparison, one is a bowl at the beginning, and the other is a group to bully orphans and widows, do you need to say it?

It's all pretty much the same!

Zhu Yuanzhang drove out the Mongols, and the status of this history is beyond doubt.

And if Zhao Kuangyin had not unified the traditional areas of influence of the Han people, and our civil war continued, Kenneng would have allowed the Liao State, which had become the overlord of Liaodong at that time, to dominate the Central Plains, and let us be ruled by foreign races by 300 years earlier.

So I feel the same. Both have similar credits.

It should be said that Zhao Kuangyin is older, because even if there is no Zhu Yuanzhang, there is Li Yuanzhang; And at that time of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms, Zhao Kuangyin could be said to be the only person who had the ability to unify the whole country.

If you look at it this way, Zhao Kuangyin's historical status should be a little higher.

Personal understanding.

It should be Zhu Yuanzhang, how to say that it also drove the rulers of the Yuan Dynasty out of the customs, which is good, but the history of the Ming Dynasty shows that Zhu Yuanzhang and his fourth son Zhu Di can still be said, and the others are very ordinary.

Zhu Yuanzhang because he recovered the sixteen states of Yanyun.

And Zhao Kuangyin was not able to do it.

It's incomparable. If I had to say it, it should be Zhao.

Zhu Yuanzhang was actually a tyrant who killed all the founding fathers. And Zhao Kuangyin is just "releasing military power with a glass of wine", so the two have different personalities, and Zhao's status will be higher than Zhu.

Zhu Yuanzhang: He unified the whole country.

And Zhao Kuangyin, except for the Northern Han Dynasty, the ten kingdoms were basically unified, and he was a mutiny to seize power.

And Zhu Yuanzhang was a peasant uprising.

According to the words of the first chairman, Qin Yuanchun does not seem to have Zhu Yuanzhang.

This can't be compared, and it's not in the same era, Guan Gong and Qin Qiong go.

I think it's Zhu Yuanzhang for the following reasons:

1。Zhu Yuanzhang recovered the Central Plains after the ethnic minorities (i.e., the Mongols) and brought the Central Plains back into the hands of the Han Chinese.

2。Zhu Yuanzhang's historical representation is also higher than that of Zhao Kuangyin, which can be seen from the historical legends of later generations and the quotations of literati and writers.

But in a sense, their historical status should be comparable, for a simple reason:

They were all the founding emperors of a dynasty in history.

It is indeed said in the wild history that Zhao Kuangyin died at the hands of Zhao Guangyi, but the official history of Zhao Kuangyin's death is all brushed aside, only saying that Song Taizu died after Zhao Guangyi entered, and no one can make an accurate conclusion about the specific cause of Song Taizu's death, so there is an unsolved case of candle shadow axe sound in history.

At that time, Song Taizu was seriously ill, he let the eunuch around him pass the queen and Zhao Defang to meet, but this eunuch has been bought by Zhao Guangyi, so Zhao Guangyi came to Song Taizu's bedroom first, and after entering, the shadow moved inside, and after it quieted down, Song Taizu died, Zhao Guangyi took the first step to ascend the throne, called Song Taizong, and cleaned the Taizu lineage after ascending the throne, and there were many people who died unjustly in the Taizu lineage, and from this move, Zhao Guangyi was very likely to kill Taizu.

Although the wild history is mostly conjecture, but the wild history is not groundless, it is adapted and processed from certain social facts, Zhao Kuangyin was indeed only Zhao Guangyi when he was seriously ill, and he himself was the most suspicious, but with the Jinkui Alliance as an agreement, Zhao Guangyi did not need to be charged with killing his brother.

The main reason for the murder is from the Jinkui Alliance, after Song Taizu won the world, the Queen Mother said to Taizu that you can get the country because Chai Rong only left a pair of orphans and widows, this is the reason for the demise of the Hou Zhou, your brother has helped you a lot along the way, for our Zhao Song Jiangshan long-term consideration, I hope you can pass the throne to your younger brother, and then pass the throne back after a hundred years for your younger brother, Song Taizu agreed, so there is the Jinkui Alliance.

However, when Song Taizu died, Zhao Defang was already an adult, and he was fully capable of taking on national affairs, and there was no need to pass the throne to Zhao Guangyi.

Judging from Zhao Guangyi's later performance, Zhao Kuangyin should have been murdered by him, otherwise Zhao Kuangyin was very healthy and could not have died suddenly.

This is already a major mystery in history, and Zhao Kuangyin's sudden death cannot be determined whether it was caused by Zhao Guangyi's drugs.

No, there is no evidence in the history books to prove that Zhao Kuangyin died of **, and according to the records, the relationship between Zhao Kuangyin and Zhao Guangyi is very harmonious, and it is impossible for Zhao Guangyi to rebel.

I feel that Zhao Guangyi has no need to kill his brother, because when he supported Zhao Kuangyin as emperor, he was the most active, if he wanted to be the emperor, he could be the emperor at the very beginning, there was no need to wait until after the success of his brother to seize the throne.

No, Zhao Kuangyin should have died of a sudden illness, not murder. And Zhao Kuangyin trusted his younger brother Zhao Guangyi very much to let him take charge of the army, so Zhao Guangyi had no reason to murder Zhao Kuangyin.

It should be **, Zhao Guangyi has long had the intention of rebelling, and after Zhao Kuangyin's death, his children also died mysteriously.

Zhao Kuangyin should have died of illness, not his younger brother Zhao Guangyi, because there are no historical facts to prove that he was murdered.

This is not exact, and the answer to it is not actually recorded as such, and there is such a statement in the history of the wilderness, but there is no relevant evidence.

According to the wild history, yes, but there is no conclusive evidence in the official history to prove this, so let's wait until time wants to tell us the truth.

It's not easy to say, judging from the historical records, it shouldn't be, but history is also written by people, who knows what the truth of the facts is?