In the Battle of Yiling, why did Liu Bei lose to Lu Xun? What mistakes did he make?

Updated on history 2024-03-24
10 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because Liu Bei despised Lu Xun excessively, Liu Bei made the most basic mistake and set up camp next to the mountains and forests.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    1.Liu Bei didn't notice that the morale of the Shu army was already low to the limit.

    2.Liu Bei as the attacker and Eastern Wu had about the same strength, and Eastern Wu occupied the geography, so Liu Bei was in a weak position.

    3.Liu Bei began to move forward, feeling that Dongwu was nothing more than that, but later he was blocked by Dongwu and couldn't take a step forward, so he began to be anxious. Moreover, the national strength of Shu Han was also weak and could not be delayed, so Liu Bei was anxious for a decisive battle, and then was defeated by Eastern Wu.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    The reasons are as follows: first, the morale of Shu was already very low at that time, and Liu Bei's military talent was not as high as Lu Xun; The second is that from a rational point of view, Liu Bei's heart was very unwilling, which led to the failure to retreat in time and suffered defeat; The third is because the war dragged on for too long, and the already weak Shu Han had no food and grass to support, and the soldiers endured hunger.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    In the Battle of Yiling, Liu Bei was defeated by Lu Xun, a 39-year-old junior.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because Liu Bei was proud of his achievements at that time, he thought he was very powerful, and Zhuge Liang was not by his side, which led to the defeat of this war.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Liu Bei is the regime of the development of the forces of the Three Kingdoms, at the latest to the Battle of Chibi, Liu Bei is not one of the main forces, just a strange Jingzhou guest general, taking advantage of the Battle of Chibi, Liu Bei began to fight, first the four southern counties got Jingzhou, and then borrowed the southern county from Sun Quan, and then entered the Li to fight Milan, won Quanli, and fought out of the siege in the battle of Hanzhong, defeated Cao Cao, and entered the peak of the regime. Xuzhou is Liu Bei's first territory, and it really belongs to Liu Bei himself. However, Liu Bei made a big mistake, that is, he did not guard against Lu Bu.

    Liu Bei was well aware of Lu Bu's character, and when he led his army to resist Yuan Shu on the front line, he did not arrange the rear.

    In 211, Liu Bei, at the invitation of Liu Zhang, marched into Sichuan and attacked Zhang Lu. When Pang Tong met with Liu Zhang, he suggested that Liu Bei put Liu Zhang in prison, so that Yizhou would be left ownerless and Yizhou could be easily captured. However, Liu Bei did not listen, thinking that he could not do this, because he had been a righteous person all his life.

    Judging from what happened later, Liu Bei was undefended, and Zhang Fei thought that there was no problem with the defense burden of Phijia City, but the problem was that Liu Bei was not defended, and Lu Bu should arrange personnel to keep an eye on Lu Bu, and while preparing for Phijia City next to him, Lu Bu Phijia City was attacked, not only Zhang Fei was not defended, but even the secret communication with Lu Bu was in Liu Bei's hands, which was Liu Bei's first mistake.

    In 208 AD, Cao Cao went south to attack Jingzhou, Liu Bei died, Zhang Fei ascended the throne, and then surrendered to Cao Cao, when Cao Cao's army arrived in Nanyang City, Liu Bei learned that Cao Cao was going south, so he hurriedly went down the mountain to escape. When Liu Bei came to Xiangyang through the Han River, Liu Bei wanted to see Brittany, but he did not dare to see Liu Bei's appearance of Brittany being closed, and there were many people there who gave up Brittany's hand and Jingzhou to follow Liu Bei, at this time, Zhuge Liang persuaded Liu Bei to capture Xiangyang. Soon after ascending the throne, Boulez happened to surrender Cao Cao at this time, and his heart was not steady, many people were willing to follow Liu Bei, as long as Liu Bei made an abacus, it was okay to capture Xiangyang, and then re-use the army to block the Han River.

    At that time, Cao's army was very weak, or no, Liu Bei could completely prevent Guan Yu from crossing the river, and the south of the Han River would belong to Liu Bei in advance, in this way, there would be no problem with the ownership of Jingzhou, and Liu Bei would develop faster.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    He didn't take into account the problem of morale, which had already dropped greatly at that time, and at this time he should retreat bravely and should not continue to fight. The result will not change, because the defeat in this war was not caused by one person.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    They did not advance steadily, marched too quickly, and did not occupy the territory in a timely manner. In the second time Sun Quan sued for peace, Jingzhou should be recovered first and occupy the dangerous pass. After a few years of rest, digest the occupied areas, stabilize the rear, select generals, and then attack Soochow.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    The mistake was to choose to rest in some dense woods, if it weren't for Lu Xun, their sneak attack might have been successful, and the war would have been won quickly.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The general was not arranged, he was too hasty when he set out for the expedition, he did not prepare his troops and prepare for everything. It won't be so bad.

Related questions
16 answers2024-03-24

No. This is not necessarily. The battle of Yiling destroyed the Eastern Wu, and Shu Han was also greatly injured, so he could only let Cao Wei sit and reap the benefits of the fisherman! >>>More

20 answers2024-03-24

I think Shu Han has a very good chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, because in the Battle of Yiling that year, they lost a lot of warriors, which had a great impact on their strength.

16 answers2024-03-24

I think so, because Liu Bei was proud and complacent, so he insisted on avenging Guan Yu when his army was tired and the logistics were not enough, if there was more time to repair the army, he should not lose so badly.

14 answers2024-03-24

OneIt should be that Zhuge Liang was sick at that time, and he was seriously ill, so they didn't have anyone to give advice, so their morale would be greatly reduced。Therefore, after losing 50,000 soldiers and horses, it will be a slump, because if there is no morale, then it is really a particularly important loss for a team. So if Zhuge Liang hadn't been sick at that time, there might not have been such a problem, so Zhuge Liang was particularly important to Shu Han at that time. >>>More

17 answers2024-03-24

This is because Liu Bei wasted a lot of manpower, material and financial resources of Shu in order to launch the Battle of Yiling, and after this war, Liu Bei also died, so Shu gradually began to decline.