In the Battle of Yiling, Liu Bei only lost 50,000 people at most, why did Shu Han collapse because o

Updated on history 2024-03-11
17 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    This is because Liu Bei wasted a lot of manpower, material and financial resources of Shu in order to launch the Battle of Yiling, and after this war, Liu Bei also died, so Shu gradually began to decline.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Although the number of people lost was not too many, the army's morale was unstable and they lost their fighting spirit, which was the reason why Shu Han was sluggish.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because this battle has broken the line of defense in their hearts, and in this war epidemic, Liu Bei almost lost his life, so this situation will occur.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because these 50,000 people were deceived from Cao Cao, they are all the elites of the entire Shu Han, and the strength of Shu itself cannot be built.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    50,000 people are superficial losses.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    The damage is immeasurable.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    After the Battle of Yiling, Shu Han collapsed for two reasons. The battle with Liang Qiyi destroyed the morale of the Shu Han army and caused Liu Bei to die of illness. Second, in the battle of Yiling, the elite of Shu Han suffered serious losses, which made the army extremely scarce of outstanding talents, and there was a talent fault phenomenon.

    This is a war that should never have happened, as the saying goes, "the most ruthless emperor is the family". At this time, Liu Bei has become an emperor, and he should not fight this uncertain war for his righteous brother. It was also this battle that cost Shu Han too much military and financial resources, leaving Zhuge Liang with a mess.

    As a newly established state, Shu Han was already the weakest among the three kingdoms of Wei, Shu and Wu. At this moment, the Shu Kingdom needs to recuperate, then consolidate its power, and then try to develop and grow. It's a pity that Liu Bei was so arrogant that he led to the fiasco of the Battle of Jianling, which led to the decline and destruction of Shu Han.

    For an army, the most important thing is morale, from generals to soldiers, with morale can win battles. Liu Bei is a good ruler of the army, and he is also a person who can fight well; The army he led, when the Shu Han and the Wu army fought, could be said to be invincible. The fight made Wu Jun unable to parry.

    Later, Lu Xun burned the company camp, causing his army to suffer heavy losses. Although the number of losses in this battle is not large, it has a great impact on the morale of soldiers. Many of these influences come from Liu Bei, who became decadent after this battle, and this emotion will naturally infect his soldiers.

    As the saying goes, "one soldier bears, one nest of bears", if you want to lead troops to win the war, you need excellent generals the most. Liu Bei has been fighting in the north and south for many years, so that many generals under his command can be appointed. In addition to the five tiger generals, there are also many young capable generals.

    They were originally the successors of the Five Tiger Generals, and they were also the brave generals of the new generation of Shu Han. But in the battle of Yiling, most of the losses were lost. Such a situation directly led to the late Shu Han period, and there were no generals to appoint.

    If Liu Bei can endure and wait for the opportunity to avenge Guan Yu, I think the ending may be reversed. Even if it can't defeat Soochow, it won't end in a fiasco.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because Wei Wei did not make a good prediction for Shu Han, and at the same time did not let it and did not have a good pattern, he lost a lot of time and energy, but he did not get good results, so he collapsed.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Hehe! Shu Han established a population of 900,000! But until the destruction of 940,000 people!

    It only took 42 years to rise by 40,000 Cha people! 50,000 people were wiped out in the Battle of Keyiling! Shu Han didn't make up for the 50,000 vacancies in 42 years!

    What else can you vibrate? Directly lay down Lusun!

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because 50,000 people was already quite a lot, Liu Bei did not have many soldiers and horses at that time, compared to Cao Cao and Sun Quan, Liu Bei's strength was indeed relatively weak.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Only 50,000 people were lost? Only? Then how many people do you think there are in Shuhan? Another person who has been brainwashed by **, thinking that Liu Bei has an army of 700,000?

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Shu Han's army itself was small in number, and in the Battle of Yiling, most of Liu Bei's losses were elite.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It's because Liu Bei can't withstand the blow. And he once boasted that he would definitely return triumphantly, but he didn't expect to lose so many soldiers.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    After this battle, everyone's morale has become a lot, and it has also affected the judgment of some people, so it has collapsed.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because there were too many failures at that time, in fact, it was also because morale was sluggish and there was a lot of brain drain, so this situation occurred.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Because Shu Han had lost a lot of opportunities at that time, and secondly, because Liu Bei's subordinates had lost a lot of talents, and their morale had also decreased a lot.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because this battle directly destroyed the self-confidence of the Shuhan Group. Liu Chan took the position and took over a mess.

Related questions
20 answers2024-03-11

I think Shu Han has a very good chance of unifying the Three Kingdoms, because in the Battle of Yiling that year, they lost a lot of warriors, which had a great impact on their strength.

14 answers2024-03-11

OneIt should be that Zhuge Liang was sick at that time, and he was seriously ill, so they didn't have anyone to give advice, so their morale would be greatly reduced。Therefore, after losing 50,000 soldiers and horses, it will be a slump, because if there is no morale, then it is really a particularly important loss for a team. So if Zhuge Liang hadn't been sick at that time, there might not have been such a problem, so Zhuge Liang was particularly important to Shu Han at that time. >>>More

16 answers2024-03-11

I think so, because Liu Bei was proud and complacent, so he insisted on avenging Guan Yu when his army was tired and the logistics were not enough, if there was more time to repair the army, he should not lose so badly.

16 answers2024-03-11

No. This is not necessarily. The battle of Yiling destroyed the Eastern Wu, and Shu Han was also greatly injured, so he could only let Cao Wei sit and reap the benefits of the fisherman! >>>More

5 answers2024-03-11

Campaign Introduction: Battle Name: Battle of Yiling, also known as the Battle of Yiling and the Battle of Yiting. >>>More