-
Ma Tan lost the street pavilion Chinese translation.
Zhuge Liang: Smart one, confused for a while, committed the taboo of "suspects don't use".
But the tears of the horse show that he is strict in governing the army; Applying for a demotion on his own shows that he has the courage to take his mistakes. Sima Yi: Good at using soldiers, old and calculating.
According to the terrain, he trapped Ma Tan in the mountains, cut off his water supply, and made him defeat himself. Ma Yan: I have the heart to serve the country, but I have a low eye, I can only talk on paper, and I am self-righteous and do not listen to Wang Ping's advice, so I have this big defeat.
Wang Ping: As a deputy general, he argued for Ma Tan's military deployment according to Kong Ming's requirements, which shows his courage and loyalty. At the critical juncture, he reported Kong Ming's situation and tried to make up for the loss, which shows his sophistication and composure.
When Zhuge Liang arrived at Qishan, he decided to send a detachment of men and horses to occupy Jieting (southeast of present-day Zhuanglang, Gansu) as a stronghold. Who's going to lead this team?
Ma Tan Lost Street Pavilion".
The crime of losing the street pavilion is not light, and it can be talked about in vain.
Yuanmen beheaded the strict military law, wiped away tears and thought about the first emperor.
Translation: During the Three Kingdoms, Ma Tan and Sima Yi fought in the street pavilion, and Ma Jian stationed his soldiers and horses on the dead ground, applying the rigid theory of "putting the place of death and then rejuvenating" said in the ancient book, causing the street pavilion to be seriously lost and committing a capital crime.
It's a pity that Ma Jian can only talk about the art of war in vain, and like Zhao Kuo, he is a person who talks about war on paper (Sima Yi said that Ma Jian is a vain name and a mediocre talent).
Ma Jian and Kong Ming have a deep friendship, but Kong Ming still endured his tears and beheaded Ma Jian outside the door, and it was natural to have strict military law.
After Ma Tan was beheaded, when Kong Ming wiped away his tears, he was still thinking about Liu Bei's brilliant opinion, (Liu Bei gave Kong Ming a will when he was dying, saying that Ma Tan was an exaggerated person and could not be used), only to know that the first emperor was the person who knew Ma Tan best.
-
In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Zhuge Liang is a person with superior wisdom'He is always a victorious hero, but he is not a god, and he also suffers setbacks, and the "Lost Answer to the Street Pavilion" (the 95th chapter of the Tomb) is the worst defeat he has encountered in his life.
-
In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Zhuge Liang is a victorious hero with superior wisdom, but he is not a god, and he also suffers setbacks, and "Lost Street Pavilion" (Chapter 95) is the worst defeat he has encountered in his life.
1.High school Chinese "On the Passage of Qin" ppt (compulsory 4).
2.High school Chinese "Discipline and Thrift" ppt
3.High school Chinese "Ji's Will Fall Away" ppt (compulsory four) 4Senior one language "Blessing" ppt
5.Senior one language "Chess King" ppt (next volume).
6.High school Chinese "Metamorphosis" ppt
7.High school Chinese "Su Wu Biography" ppt
8.High school Chinese "Love Life" PPT (compulsory 4).
9.High school Chinese "Slow Voice (Li Qingzhao)" ppt
10.High school Chinese "Love between Parents and Children" ppt11High school Chinese "Slow Voice" ppt
12.High school Chinese "Jingkou Beiguting Nostalgia" ppt
13.High school Chinese "Dragon Boat Day" ppt
14.High school Chinese "Honor and Love, Honor" ppt
15.High School Chinese Compulsory 4 "Thunderstorm" PPT
-
Recently, many people have attributed the sin of losing the street pavilion to Zhuge Liang and accused him of improper employment, and I have different opinions:
1. As the commander of the three armies, Zhuge Liang judged the situation and made the correct decision to guard the street pavilion, and at that time, Ma Jian repeatedly made military exploits and took the initiative to ask for help, so he should be sent to guard the street pavilion. As for Ma Jian not listening to Kong's fierce general's order and changing the formation without authorization, can this be said to be Zhuge Liang's fault?
2. Some people think that since Zhuge Liang has placed a lot of reinforcements, it shows that he himself is not worried about Ma Yan, so why do he insist on using him. I think that Zhuge Liang's arrangement of Gao Xiang, Wei Yan, Zhao Yun, Deng Zhi and others to make a strategy is not because he is not worried about Ma Yan, but for the sake of prudence. Sima's army was 150,000, and Ma Tan's army was only 25,000, and Zhuge Liang was afraid that Sima Yi would attack and lose the street pavilion, so he arranged reinforcements.
This shows that it is cautious in the use of troops.
The reason why many readers will seize the loss of the street pavilion to accuse Zhuge Liang of improper use of people is because "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" almost deifies Zhuge Liang, and readers habitually think that Zhuge Liang should be like a god and should not have anything to think of. Don't you know that Zhuge Liang is also a mortal with the naked eye, he is just better at observing and knowing how to use soldiers than ordinary people, and he can be an unpredictable prophet? The battlefield is changing rapidly, how can anyone calculate everything?
In addition, I have another question: Should Zhuge Liang kill the horse? As Ma Jian himself who made a big mistake, he himself is full of remorse, if he is given the opportunity to make meritorious contributions, he will definitely spare no effort and fight bravely to kill the enemy, and he will definitely not be arrogant anymore.
Wouldn't it be nice to exchange a loss for a good general?! Although Ma Tan made a military order, if the capital crime was changed to a living crime, it would not only punish him, but also show leniency, and make him grateful. Isn't Shu pretending to be suspicious of the country, and Sen Queqiao has always advertised that he rules the world with "benevolence"?
-
Zhuge Liang, obviously there are so many suitable generals under the account, but Jian still sent Ma Jian to guard the street pavilion!Hidden suspicions.
A good strategist may not be a good general?Ma Jian is very suitable as a staff officer, but not as a commander of the army!
I think it was Ma Tan's responsibility to lose the street pavilion, because Ma Tan was very arrogant at that time and did not abide by Zhuge Liang's plan.
The street pavilion is in Longcheng Town, Qin'an County, Tianshui City, Gansu Province. In ancient times, it was a very important military location.
I think Jiang Wei should be able to defend the street pavilion, because Jiang Wei's strength is very strong. He's very good at playing defensively.
The Three Kingdoms are still the Three Kingdoms, and there will not be much change. >>>More
Because the basket that Ma Tan stabbed this time was too big, Zhuge Liang couldn't protect him. Zhuge Liang went out of Qishan six times, and the closest thing to victory was this time, the location of the street pavilion was very important, it was the only way on the supply line of Shu, and it was the only grain route in Shu. Zhuge Liang's many failed conquests of Wei were due to the problem of grain and grass, and the road of Shu was not easy to walk, and it was very difficult for Shu to smoothly transport grain and grass. >>>More