Whether Kangxi intends to give the throne to the fourth son or the fourteenth son

The fourth son Yinzhen Yong was passed on by Kangxi, and what was said on TV was that the fourth elder brother Yinzhen was the general in the posthumous edict"Ten"Instead"In. The emperor of the Qing Dynasty was a Manchu, and when he wrote the more formal documents in this one, he wrote in Manchu, so he would be a general"Ten"Instead"So the impossible. Kangxi intended to be located in the fourteenth elder brother, but the fourteenth elder brother at that time was not in the capital when Kangxi was critically ill, and it was the fourth elder brother who commanded the forbidden army in the palace at that time.

Kangxi is not confused, if the throne is passed to the fourteenth elder brother, there will be a battle for the throne. However, Yinzhen's ability is not bad, and he is also excellent among the princes. At the time of Kangxi's death, the princes were also older, and the fourth elder brother was already 45 years old at the time.

Yinzhen's fourth son, Hongli Kangxi, likes it very much, and it cannot be said that Kangxi at that time had seen the comparison of the next generation and looked at the long term. Yinzhen's accession to the throne was also created by current events at that time. But it is true that it is in place normally.

It's Yongzheng who has offended too many people. In fact, it is Yongzheng who inherits the throne. That is, the four princes.

The Qing Dynasty fucking wrote the word "Yu" like that? How can he not write English, he can write simplified characters, and time flies.

Saying that the fourth elder brother usurped the throne may be a rumor Anyway, the book I read said a lot of reasons, but I just remembered one thing, because the edict of the first emperor should not only be written in Chinese, but also written in Manchu on the side, you say, Even if you change the Chinese "ten" to "Yu", how should the Manchu text be changed? There is also a saying that it is because the son of the fourth elder brother, Hongli, is deeply loved by Kangxi Indeed, it was passed on to Emperor Yongzheng Because when Kangxi was terminally ill, he actually sent the fourteenth elder brother to the border to fight Do you think If you really want to pass on to him, what to do if you transfer him so far Also, Yongzheng married Nian, that is, Nian Qianyao's sister, It seems that it is still a marriage If the emperor wants to give the fourteenth elder brother the throne, why should he let the fourth elder brother marry the powerful people at that time?

First, the word "Yu" in "Chuan is located in the four sons" should be written as "Yu" according to the way it was written at that time; The whole sentence is "to pass on the throne to the four sons", or "to pass the throne to the fourteenth son", so there is no possibility of changing "ten" to "yu". Clause.

2. The emperor's title to the prince is generally preceded by the word "emperor", and the official document such as the edict of succession will not be an exception, so the edict should be "the fourth son of the emperor" or "the fourteenth son of the emperor". Clause.

3. The official statement of the emperor's succession should be that after the emperor's death, the prince succeeds to the throne, whether it is the early establishment of the prince or the establishment of the prince before his death, the emperor is still alive when the edict is written, so it is impossible to write the throne to whom, but should be written who is the crown prince. So if Kangxi wrote "The fourteenth son of the emperor is the crown prince", it will not be changed to the "fourth son" anyway. Clause.

Fourth, in the Qing Dynasty, the official documents issued by the emperor were all stationed in Hebi, that is, in both Chinese and Manchu scripts. The Chinese character "fourteen" can be changed to "Yu four", how to change the Manchu text? It should be said that the above four theories are reasonable, and if any of them are true, then Yongzheng's theory of tampering with the edict is untenable.

A few years ago, the edict has been found, and what is written directly on it is passed to Yinzhen, even if it can be changed to the name, it is impossible to write it wrong, so the legend is fake.

The fourth son of the emperor. There are Manchu edicts.

Emperor Kangxi died, and the throne passed to the fourth prince Yunzhen, with the year name Yongzheng.

Judging from the record of "Kangxi Record", Kangxi summoned the princes and Long Keduo and others before his death, and issued a testament to the fourth son of the emperor, Yinzhen (Yongzheng), which should be true. But is Yongzheng succeeding or usurping the throne? The intricacies of the court struggle are still a matter of debate in historiography.

Many people believe that Yongzheng is not a succession but a usurpation. There are three theories:

1, Yinzhen (Yongzheng) used the opportunity of donating medicine to poison his father;

2, Kangxi originally planned that the fourteenth prince would succeed to the throne, but Long Keduo falsely passed the decree to Yinzhen;

3. Dolgon favored Yinzhen and changed the edict "Passing on the Fourteenth Prince" to "Passing on the Four Princes".

Kangxi's edict is one of the points of contention between the two schools of scholars. Scholars who hold the normal succession to the throne believe that Yongzheng's ascension process engaged in a conspiracy, but they cannot produce strong and convincing evidence, and the existing Kangxi edict is very clear that it is to pass on the throne to Yongzheng.

There are two parts of Kangxi's edict, one part talks about Kangxi's achievements in the past 60 years, which has been written in the 56th year of Kangxi, and the other part, which is also the most critical, is to pass the throne to his fourth son.

If it is inferred that the edict is fake just because it was not written by Kangxi himself, but by someone else, then some problems will be difficult to explain. Because the edicts of the emperors of previous dynasties were generally written by others or written according to the last wishes of the old emperor after his death.

It should be the fourth son, I don't think there is so much room for others to modify the posthumous photo, after all, he is only a prince, not a prince, and another one, isn't Yongzheng doing a good job, called the general of the emperor's 14th son, and he is also a martial artist.

Why do you care about him so much, you don't want to be an emperor.

There are three main reasons for this:

One. In the last years of Kangxi, he abolished the crown prince twice, which provided a good opportunity for other princes to compete for the crown. Because of his personal friendship, Kangxi demoted the eldest brother and the eighth elder brother to civilians, and imprisoned Mingzhu and Suo Etu for life.

As a lesson from the past, Yongzheng expressed his disinterest in the throne on the surface and won Kangxi's trust, but secretly made a big splash.

Two. Yongzheng has a son, Hongli (Qianlong), who is deeply liked by Kangxi.

Three. During Kangxi's serious illness, only Yongzheng went to visit.

There are many kinds of legends, one of the more widely circulated is this, Kangxi originally liked the fourteenth son, and the edict was prepared and hidden behind the Zhengda Guangming plaque, after Kangxi's death, Yinzhen tampered with the edict and changed the fourteenth prince to the fourth prince. But this is just a folk rumor, it should not be true, and the issue is still inconclusive.

According to the history of Juye, in fact, Uncle Kang actually wanted to pass it on to his fourteenth son, but Yongzheng changed a word, and as a result, he passed the throne to him.