Can Tai Chi be learned with discs alone?

No. Tai Chi is a very mysterious martial art. Many of its theories and applications, without the guidance of a teacher, you can't be Mion White at all, unless you are extremely talented.

Watching a CD or practicing with someone else may be able to practice the superficial posture, but you will never understand the truth. Then your Tai Chi will be practiced in vain, and Tai Chi is not only about exercising the body, but also about improving the connotation. Looking at the disc, you are barely learning the moves, and yours is not standard, but it will harm yourself, let alone hit people.

Ordinary Tai Chi masters will rarely tell you the application of each move, and if they do, they will not tell you all of them. Martial arts masters are very secretive, so Chinese martial arts will be more and more difficult to go like this.

Your idea is too simple. There is a saying that Tai Chi does not go out for ten years, and you only watch CDs, I'm afraid it won't work. **It's just a rough idea, if you want to learn, you need someone to teach you by hand. There's a lot of stuff in this that you can only understand. It is recommended to find a reliable gym or teacher.

Taijiquan is just a routine, the real essence lies in the pusher, and the pusher is practiced, and it is impossible to practice "listening to the strength" and want to become a master without practice. "Practice is the only criterion for testing truth."

No, CDs and books are for people with foundations.

Hello, if you really want to practice Taijiquan and really know the mystery of Taijiquan, then you have to find a teacher to learn, because you will never enter the Taijiquan circle just by reading books and **, and you must have the guidance of a teacher to practice Taijiquan well.

That's just fitness, don't take it too seriously.

You have to have the Master's guidance to learn quickly.

You can learn the movements first, and then find someone to correct the instructions for you.

If you have a certain foundation in dance or martial arts, you can do it! If you don't have a certain foundation, it will be very slow to learn!!

If you don't learn well, the action is not standardized, and the effect is not good.

If you are learning for the purpose of strengthening your body or participating in competitions, as long as you are serious, books and CDs can teach you how to learn Tai Chi. If you're learning for the sake of playing, it's best to have a really knowledgeable Master in addition to books and CDs.

Yes, there are a lot of teaching CDs now, but don't watch too much.

Absolutely, when I was in college, I studied with a Ph.D. in our school, and I learned a Ph.D. in basic movements, and then it became that we watched CDs together to study, and the main thing was persistence.

OK. It is best to learn from teachers, make rapid progress, and do not take detours.

It is also difficult for beginners to learn well just by watching CDs, and it is best to have a teacher know that after understanding and mastering a certain foundation of Taijiquan, it is easier to watch CDs by yourself

Tai Chi can be taught on your own, but only if you have some basics.

At least you can learn on your own after you get started.

Otherwise, practice is also blind practice.

What kind of foundation are you talking about, and then look at the CD?

I'm practicing Tai Chi, practicing every day, and my body is getting better. In addition, in addition to the master, there are many brothers and sisters, making progress together, laughing and laughing together, which is very good. You have to go out and find a master by yourself, there are many people in the park who teach Tai Chi, you go to investigate for a few days by yourself, and then according to the results of the investigation, find a good master.

It doesn't matter where the address is? Then you go to Chenjiagou, there seems to be a training school there. Another disc can only be used as a reference, and it is best to have a master to guide it, otherwise you can only draw a scoop with the disc according to the gourd, and you can't practice anything at all.

Hi, tranquility and far-reaching. I think you can learn anytime and anywhere, all you need is a kind of quiet, and I hope you can practice to the point of calming your mind anytime and anywhere.

No. Because in the process of self-study, the movements will be practiced irregularly and the wrong movements will be practiced, once the wrong and irregular movements are formed into a habit, it will be difficult to correct, and even if they are corrected, it will take several times longer than practicing boxing to correct. Also, self-taught martial arts basically can't learn the core of martial arts, because boxers who write books and record ** will not completely record the core things; If you are self-taught, because you don't have the teacher's guidance, you won't understand the truth at all, and if you learn according to your own understanding, you will often go astray.

So, don't go to self-study, it's better to find a Master to learn Tai Chi if possible. This is a suggestion from someone who has studied martial arts.

I don't want to hurt my self-confidence, but the chances of learning on my own are very small......You can't really see the movements in those ** and *** Martial arts is very easy to stereotype in the beginner stage Once you make a mistake, it is difficult to correct it in the later learning stage Because you have repeated a wrong action many times at the beginning Even if you do it correctly many times in the future, the mistake will still be the most primitive setting in your mind, and it cannot be easily corrected without deliberate It is not what matters in martial arts is not strength or skill But spirit This sounds a bit like a god stick now, but really, a martial artist who doesn't have the spirit of martial arts can only be called a thug, and without a teacher, it's difficult for you to enter the world of that spirit, so I still recommend that you follow the teacher and learn Wait until a certain stage, the foundation has been laid, the master has been led in, and you are practicing in the individual, I wish you success, come on

It should be said that I can't learn. At most, I learned to be like a bluff to the layman. You can't learn the real taste of Tai Chi. I used to watch discs to learn, but later I learned from my teacher that it was all just appearance, and there was no Tai Chi flavor at all.

No, because I don't know that the movements of ** are not standardized, or the wrong movements, if you practice these irregular (or wrong) movements, it will not be beneficial, but will be harmful! ~

As long as you have faith, of course you can.

It's best to follow the teacher, so that the movements can be more in place.

Learn according to your own understanding.

It's good to learn from others.

No matter which school of Tai Chi you learn, the core of the practice is the same, but the moves are different from the practice.

It's okay to practice that one, and the good or bad of kung fu lies in the practitioner itself, not in kung fu.

It's up to you to see what style you like. In addition to the old road, the Chen family mostly exerts strength for the position, which is very powerful. Yang's pine is quiet and generous, and the momentum is strong. It depends on what kind of individual likes.

Chen's longest time in China has the deepest insight into Tai Chi.

Of course, it is Zhang's good pull, (Zhang Sanfeng).

It first started with Chan.

There are too many later.