If Guan Yu breaks through Fancheng, what will happen to the end?

If Guan Yu breaks through Fancheng, what will happen to the end?

There is a matter of time for this, the best time to take Fancheng, including the entire Xiangfan Campaign, should be more than half a year in advance, that is, at the beginning of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219). However, at that time, Liu Bei was in Hanzhong, and the fight was also in full swing, although there was already Lao Huang Zhongli to kill Xiahou Yuan, and Cao Jun had no commander in Hanzhong, but Cao Cao had personally led the army and entered Hanzhong, and it was not yet known who would kill the deer. According to the description in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", when Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, Xiangyang had been taken, and the time should be in July and August, when the attack on Fancheng was the most intense, it was also when Yu Ban was captured, Pang De was killed, and the Seventh Army was annihilated.

The following is an analysis of the pros and cons of the 24th (219) beginning of Jian'an, the attack on Fancheng, and the pros and cons are as follows:

If Guan Yu broke through Fancheng at the beginning of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219), although there would be no flooding of the Seventh Army, capture the ban, and behead Pang De, "Megatron Huaxia" would not be just on paper, and it is likely to become real. Because, according to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Emperor Wu Ji records:

In the winter of October, Wan Shou will Hou Yin and other opponents, hold Nanyang Taishou, rob the people, and protect Wan. At the beginning, Cao Ren begged Guan Yu, Tunfan City, and it was the moon envoy Ren Wai Wan. In the first month of the spring of the twenty-fourth year, Ren Tu Wan, chopped the sound.

In October of the twenty-third year of Jian'an (218), Hou Yin, the general of Wancheng, led his troops to rebel, captured Nanyang Taishou alive, and also gathered the local people to occupy Wancheng. By the first month of the twenty-fourth year (219), Cao Ren broke through Wancheng and slaughtered it, beheading Hou Yin.

Think about it, what is the concept of slaughtering a city? That's indiscriminate, go into the city and kill people! If Guan Yu Jian'an broke through Fancheng at the beginning of the twenty-fourth year (219) and liberated the people of Wancheng in Nanyang, Cao Ren would not talk about Tu Wancheng and Hou Yin, I am afraid that he would be too busy to take care of himself, and even Nanyang would be lost.

Then, combined with "Three Kingdoms. In Guan Yu's Biography, [ Liang, Jia, Lu Hun and the group of thieves or the number of the feather seal were sent to support the party, and the feather shocked China. Cao Gong discussed moving Xu to avoid his sharp ......], and then break through Xudu and rescue Emperor Xian of the Han Dynasty, there is a great possibility of success.

Moreover, if properly organized and handled, the large number of Liang, Jia, and Lu Hun bandits will soon "turn the guerrillas into regular troops", supplement Guan Yu's lack of troops, and form a powerful Jingzhou corps. It should be explained that this batch of soldiers is completely different from the captured soldiers of Yu Ban, and the political quality is leveraged, and there is also an old leader who escaped from Cao Ren's knife - Hou Yin, so as long as it is slightly reorganized, the leadership is strengthened, and the training is strengthened, and they can be fought at that time, and the combat effectiveness should be very good.

After Guan Yu captured Fancheng, Jingzhou, which was so under his control, colluded with Cao Wei, and there would be a situation in which Wei and Wu jointly resisted Shu.

In the end, Wu lost a city, but Shu and Wu were at enmity and could no longer unite to resist Cao Cao, so in the end the two countries would still be annexed by Cao Cao.

I think the worst outcome is to lose the state of Wu, and since then I have been at odds with the state of Shu, and there is no help from anyone.

I think that if Guan Yu breaks through Fancheng, then Shu can carry out some blows to Wu according to this important city, which will help to attack Wu, and finally there is a great possibility of unifying the Three Kingdoms in troubled times.

If it is broken, this will undoubtedly increase the overall strength of Shu by a great boost. In this way, Shu is stronger and has more opportunities to unify.

When he was eager to make meritorious contributions and had the power of the false jieyue, Guan Yu immediately decided to attack Fancheng and start the Northern Expedition.

Because Guan Yu was very arrogant at that time, he thought that he could attack Xiachengchi, so he said that he would fight, so he carelessly lost Jingzhou.

In order to echo with Liu Bei in the north and south of Hanzhong, in order to jointly flank Cao Cao, he attacked Fancheng.

No, because the overall strength of Shu Han at that time was still not comparable to that of Eastern Wu and Cao Wei, and he did not have this strength to dominate the world.

I think it's also difficult, after all, the strength of Cao Cao's side is very strong, even if Guan Yu captures Fancheng and unifies the world, it will still be Cao Cao's side.

No. Even if Guan Yu really captured Fancheng, there was still Cao Cao's army in the north, and Sun Wu's regime in the south of the Yangtze River, their strength was very strong, and if they wanted to unify the world, they had to be defeated.

Satisfactory answer Good man Level 42012-10-02Whether it is Romance or Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu is the head of all generals, but Zhang Fei, Huang Zhong, and Ma Chao's merits are greater than him (Zhao Yun's status merits in the Three Kingdoms are not high), and he thinks that he should have some more merits to make himself worthy of his real name. Moreover, Guan Yu's territory at that time was not stable, because Dongwu wanted to return to the three counties, Cao Cao based on Xiangyang Fancheng, Guan Yu's place of existence was compressed into a straight line, of which only Nanjun could see, and other places were in remote places, and Biyang meant a poor township. Eastern Wu is eyeing the tiger, Cao Cao is strong, and Jingzhou at this time is not a long-term place.

Liu Bei won a big victory in Hanzhong, the army was in full swing, Eastern Wu could not fight, the Northern Expedition was imperative, and the defenders of Fancheng were Cao Cao's favorite generals Cao Ren, and they were Cao Cao's descendants. Full of combat power. If you want to take Xiangyang, you must cut off the road of mutual aid to Fancheng and Xiangyang, and put pressure on Fancheng.

And Fancheng was followed by Xuchang, and Fancheng was laid, and the Central Plains was shaken. Whether for the sake of the overall situation or the small situation, Fancheng must be defeated Follow-up question: Isn't it possible to attack Xiangyang first and rely on the Han River to defend?

When Liu Bei heard that Cao Cao wanted to marry Sun Quan to take Jingzhou, Zhuge came up with an idea and said, I have long known that Cao Cao wants Cao Ren to send troops to Fancheng to join forces with Eastern Wu to make contributions to Jingzhou, so it is better to let General Guan send troops to Fancheng to thwart Cao Cao's conspiracy. From this, it is known that Fancheng is the real goal, so that the conspiracy of Eastern Wu and Northern Wei can fail. Jingzhou can be safe.

In addition, Fancheng is the northern barrier, and the Central Plains shook when Fancheng was lost. Liu Bei can take advantage of the situation to capture Guanzhong. Completed the Longzhong pair.

Eastern Wu would change its strategy to attack Wei, and Northern Wei would be greatly damaged if it did not die. At that time, Shu was the most powerful, which made Shu get out of the situation of self-defense. Therefore, Guan Yu could not only fight Xiangyang, but also fought on two fronts with Liu Bei, and only in Fancheng could he drag most of Cao Cao's troops.

But in the end, the-stirring stick of Soochow appeared. Providence so.

No need for Liu Bei's order. Guan Yu's official position is a former general, fake Jieyue. This "fake festival" means that Liu Bei has given him the power to wage war alone, and he does not need to ask for instructions. And it can kill anyone except Liu Bei.

Liu Bei, killing two birds with one stone! Let Guan Yu attack Sun Wu's Fancheng, one to intimidate Eastern Wu and occupy the territory south of the Wu River! The second is to use Sun Quan's hand to get rid of Guan Yu, who is highly meritorious, and then to conquer Soochow in the name of avenging Guan Yu!

The characters of the Three Kingdoms are not simple! Take a look at "Three Kingdoms", analyze it yourself, Romance TV is all fake....

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it was not said that Zhuge Liang asked him to fight, so he took a good look at it.

It is recorded in the official history that he himself is going to fight ......And Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang are estimated to have acquiesced to ......

Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan for the following reasons: First, Guan Yu was canonized as a former general, and his status in the army was higher than that of Zhang Fei, Ma Chao and Huang Zhong. As a military general, Guan Yu attaches great importance to his reputation, and since he has been given a very high status in the army, he naturally wants to create corresponding military achievements.

In addition, at this time, it happened to be the most prosperous period of Shu, and in the face of countless talents in the army, Guan Yu himself also had a certain amount of pressure, hoping to stabilize his position in the army.

Third, after Cao Cao's defeat in Hanzhong, this was the best opportunity to attack Xiangyang and Fancheng. With Guan Yu's strength, there was absolutely no problem in winning the two cities, but he didn't expect Dongwu to sneak attack from behind. After this battle, Shu Han's strength was severely hit and became the weakest of the Three Kingdoms.

The reason why Guan Yu attacked Fancheng:

If you want to pull out the nails of Jingzhou's march to the north and take Fancheng, you can look at Xuchang and Luoyang with a rough eye, and directly threaten Cao Cao's hinterland of the Central Plains; echoing Liu Feng's stationed Shangyong, they can respond to each other at critical moments; forced Cao Cao to pay more attention to Fancheng, so that he could not divide his troops in Hanzhong, and reduce the pressure on Hanzhong, which had not gained a firm foothold; Guan Yu faked the festival, and once he had the opportunity to recover the entire territory of Jingzhou; As a local military response to the battle for Hanzhong, it contained Xin and distracted Cao Wei's attention on the Western Front, and divided pressure on Liu Bei.